4 ms·
This is absolutely horrible for the open web. What this means is that users who sign in to your website with this are Facebook's users, not your users. Faceboo
by stickfigure 12y ago
This is absolutely horrible for the open web.
What this means is that users who sign in to your website with this are Facebook's users, not your users. Facebook controls them and decides if and when your access to them shall be revoked. At least with an email address, you can bootstrap an independent relationship. Not here.
Mozilla Persona got this right - authentication should be decentralized and establish an independent relationship between website and user. Too bad they gave up on it.
- rkuykendall-com 12y ago> At least with an email address, you can bootstrap an independent relationship. Not here. Wait, what if I want that? I'd say 95%+ of sites I sign up for I am just trying out. I don't want an independent relationship to be bootstrapped, I just want to play with the site. Chances are, after a week I will never see it again. But instead, I get a newsletter, and have to unsubscribe. Then I get a friend notification or something, and unsubscribe from those, or try to find out how to deactivate or delete my account. > Facebook's users, not your users Yes, that's true. I am a Facebook user. I have an account there, which I use. Why should I spread my email around to sites I don't really consider myself a user of, just because I want to save my game or explore the app or something?
- astromarch 12y agoYou only see two choices. That's bad. 1) Give your info to one site and let them rule you like a king 2) Give your info to lots of sites only to be annoyed I suggest a third option, 3) Use ssh style key login. You own the key, not Facebook/Google/Apple. You can lock the key locally with a password. One password for all websites. Only you know it. The password is not shared with others. You authenticate and encrypt in a cryptographically strong way that can't be defeated easily like SSL with "trusted" CAs can. Good luck getting Google to implement THAT in chrome though. Also, up yours YC for banning account creation on my IP. You think it's not easy as pie to find another one? Jerks. Why should I trust you with my information?
- stickfigure 12y agoCongratulations, you've just handed ownership of your electronic life over to Facebook. Now your access to the internet is gated by Facebook. What? You've used a nickname or an inaccurate photo or you're a sex offender or a drug offender or you've had a DUI or enough people have flagged you? Say goodbye to your entire internet identity, time to start from scratch - assuming FB doesn't recognize your IP address and ban you. The risks of submitting an email address are overblown. Websites are terrified that you will click the 'spam' button. They don't put those little 'unsubscribe' links at the bottom because they want you to click on them. I was one of the early adopters of the Facebook platform and 'social login'. Now I think it's a menace. They aren't doing anyone, except themselves, any favors with this.
- acdha 12y ago> Facebook controls them and decides if and when your access to them shall be revoked. I share the Persona love but I don't think this is complete: yes, Facebook could zero-day you and drop support but it's really unlikely that they wouldn't announce something in advance which would allow you to pivot, leading to: > At least with an email address, you can bootstrap an independent relationship. You can also do this using a Facebook login by having a way for the user to enter an email address. The difference is that you can avoid hitting them for it up front and triggering the “Are they going to spam me?” worry which makes people question using your site in the first place. You could introduce it at some point where it has a benefit to them – “Please enter your email address if you'd like new turn notifications”, etc. – or, were Facebook to announce that they're discontinuing this service, ask them for another way to login in. Most sites already have a bunch of separate social login services linked to a single identity, this is only one more.
- stickfigure 12y agoAs someone who has built this (one of my sites, http://voo.st/ http://voo.st/, is literally the poster child for Persona+Facebook login), it's practically impossible to unify accounts unless you get an email address up front. Otherwise you end up with separate accounts and a post-facto merge process that almost always requires some level of administrator touch. Yes, you can solve any problem with a big enough customer support budget. Not helpful.
- eastbayjake 12y agoI resent the way Facebook treats third-party developers, but my early dread has turned into a little excitement over what this could do for soft-touch demos. Right now most product pitches are short videos on the landing page that walk you through the features, but that's a poor substitute for actually logging in and poking around. If you build the anonymous login experience the right way, you cut through the newsletter and transactional email noise from all the people who signup just to try it out, and you just get to communicate with people who actually want to use your product. There's room for both sides to win: users don't have to listen to things they're not interested in, and companies don't have to waste resources on people who aren't listening. It's also easier to sell a signup when you've got someone in a product they like but can restrict access until they commit. Want to upload a photo? Create an account with Facebook. Want to save your work? Create an account with Facebook. If you're just an anonymous user, you get the same dummy-data experience as logging in with a demo account until you commit and share your email.
- stickfigure 12y agoIt's been my experience from running a Persona+Facebook login system with a nontechnical audience (bicycle racers) that 50% of real customers (the ones buying stuff) prefer not to use to Facebook, and a giant percentage of those are overtly hostile - no Facebook account and refuse to create one. Period. I don't know if your audience will swing the same way, but I don't expect this is the magic lubricant you're looking for.
- nosuchthing 12y agoCouldn't verifiable identity just be a signature, or a handshake?