10 ms·
Why the practical applications of Bitcoin will be limited
- moe 12y agoCongrats. That may be the dumbest bitcoin-related headline ever created (and the competition wasn't weak to begin with).
- theandrewbailey 12y agoReason 4: Bitcoin doesn't transmit ideas effectively, thus ruling it out as any internet "replacement" or successor. Wait, that's the only reason it won't.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- drthsrth 12y agoTl;rd
- efnx 12y agoEach point is a prediction, not a reason. Given that, I didn't read more than those.
- kordless 12y agoTotally agree with you here. It smacks of "I think it's this way, so therefore here's why I'm right thinking these things."
- Mahn 12y agoDespite the click-bait title, the article makes valid points which are very often overlooked or downright ignored by hardcore bitcoiners. As someone who's been watching bitcoin for the past few years, this is in my opinion the plain reality.
- sida 12y agoAnd in Bitcoinland, objections against Bitcoin are also often flagged as trolling, and dismissed immediately
- etchalon 12y agoThere is definitely a pervasive culture within cryptos of people either "getting it" or "not". It's a bit disturbing.
- valarauca1 12y agoThis is true for the cultures surrounding most things I'd postulate. A large majority who support it, largely blindly but dismiss valid arguments against with suspicion, and a smaller minority who actually understand counter arguments, but believe, or hold a complex opinion.
- philh 12y agoOften it goes both ways. Of the people who oppose it, most do so blindly and dismiss valid arguments in favor, while a minority understand the arguments well enough to reply to them. Ninety percent of opinions are crap.
- lsadam0 12y agoI believe both sides of the aisle hold some responsibility for this disconnect. Detractors of cryptocurrency often like to cite the shady world of BitCoin securities, just like this article does. However, that's not a valid criticism. BTC functioned only as the method of payment. You can't criticize the future utility of a technology based upon how someone has misused it. If that were the case, we should ban the Internet.
- etchalon 12y agoGenerally though, the issue is mentioned in a broader context than just "someone did a bad thing with the internet", and more that the community behind Bitcoin, and the libertarian philosophies which guide it, give rise to the scams and dark market uses of the currency. When evaluating and discussing any technology, you're absolutely right: it is unfair to criticize it based on a few bad examples. However, it is fair to look at a technology and consider whether the "legal" outweigh the "illegal" ones, and if not, why. The author makes this point succinctly.
- jerguismi 12y agoBitcoin won't be the new internet, true. Its impact will be far greater than that. Trolololo.
- hartator 12y ago"Per transaction cost is currently low because mining revenue comes from inflation." It's actually the reverse. Mining speculates on deflation not inflation.
- tveita 12y agoI think the point is that mining is subsidized by "printing" new bitcoins, which currently make up most of the block reward. Speculation is in theory not a factor, since spending $ on buying a bitcoin == spending $ on mining a bitcoin, so the price would be the same, if a rational market existed.
- yebyen 12y agoYou say this like it's not a thing... "if a rational market existed." Maybe we're experiencing a breakdown of understanding because your intent isn't clear, so forgive me if I've misinterpreted your sentiment. Isn't the market mostly rational? Where is your evidence that it does not exist/that the price is not rational? To me it has the appearance that the price of bitcoin hovers around the cost of mining bitcoin, ever since the big rising bubble first popped. I am not an expert but I have been following for quite some time as mining hardware gets more efficient and the difficulty waggles mostly trending up over time. There is no universal "electricity cost to mine a bitcoin" since mining hardware varies in efficiency, and it's true that any rational miner would stop mining if his hardware could no longer make a marginal profit on the cost of the electricity. You would get more bitcoin by just spending that part of your utility budget at an exchange. I have obsolete ASIC hardware from BFL that I only run because I have a source of free electricity and for the novelty / because it's cold. They made money for a time, and then the market corrected. With the advances in hardware that are constantly coming from many different players in the mining hardware market, I would not be surprised to hear that many latest-gen ASIC miners are still hovering around "break-even" electricity cost to mine, and as the difficulty continues to rise, anyone waiting for delivery of their equipment goes on biting their nails, waiting to see if they will make a profit or if all their effort will have been wasted.
- GlickWick 12y agoThe title is very click-baity, I think we can all agree on that. However, a lot of the points made within are completely legit. The Bitcoin world is rife with scams and one of the primary uses of Bitcoin is to engage in illegal transactions. The benefits of de-regulation are obvious, but the downsides are killing it right now. A lot of people are stuck on the "regulation is evil!" rehtoric due to the current issues with the NSA and the government in general, but I think everyone needs to take a step back and realize that a radical shift in the opposite direction is not the answer. The technology is interesting, and I definitely think we'll see the ideas behind some of these new cryptocurrencies working to change the future of currency in general, but Bitcoin itself is not that future. I also see that the /r/bitcoin defense force is in full swing here, unsurprisingly.
- lsadam0 12y agoI won't disagree that CryptoCurrencies have by and large been used for illegal transactions. Though, my response would be: So? Any technology can be applied to do something illegal. Do you think this fact played 0 part in the Internet itself thriving? I don't see us scrambling to throw away steak knives just because some people have been stabbed.
- GlickWick 12y agoThe problem is that the majority of money changing hands appears to be for illegal uses. When the internet was in its infancy, this was absolutely not the case. I'm sure there was something going on, but it wasn't the primary use.
- shawnhermans 12y agoThe author makes a lot of statements but doesn't really back them up with solid facts or analysis. Consider the second reason of "Bitcoin will not end the need for trusted central parties" and claims that intermediaries do more than just payment processing. As an example, he talks about YouTube and revenue splitting. I don't understand the connection between YouTube revenue splitting and Bitcoin replacing traditional currencies. I guess this is supposed to be an example of intermediaries providing value added, but can we at least provide an example in the payment processing space? What does a credit card company provide that is not provided by Bitcoin? Overall, I am on the fence on Bitcoin. I get the feeling cryptocurrencies will drastically change the world economy in the future, but I don't think anyone really knows how and to what extent.
- sida 12y agoTo build a bit more context, there are a lot of talks about how Bitcoin will: - Replace youtube in the form of a decentralized video platform - Decentralized Spotify - Decentralized Uber A google search of DAO (Decentralized Autonomous Organization) and you will find many many people talking about that. The thesis is that, no Bitcoin won't decentralize all these intermediaries, instead what is more feasible is that maybe future blockchain technologies could lower barriers to entry. As for comparison payment processing space, this is more in point 1. Bitcoin is not cheaper. Bitcoin is extremely expensive to use and intended to be expensive.
- aminok 12y ago>As for comparison payment processing space, this is more in point 1. Bitcoin is not cheaper. Bitcoin is extremely expensive to use and intended to be expensive. Bitcoin is currently overly secure, due to the block subsidy, so therefore total mining costs relative to number of transactions is very high. As the block subsidy diminishes, this ratio will decline Total security can be maintained, without transaction fees increasing, if transaction volumes increase, which is entirely possible, and is what has historically happened.
- LukeHoersten 12y agoThe first point is the only real argument IMHO and as others here have said, it's prediction, not reasons. Here's the crux of the first argument: 1. At the same number of daily transactions, fees must increase 250 folds. Or, 2. At the same fee level, transaction count must increase 250 folds. Or, 3. Price increases 250 folds to $65000/BTC. Or, 4. A combination of all 3 #4 seemed like the question answered itself. Instead the author doesn't acknowledge #4 at all: "However, neither one of these scenarios is likely to occur. Scenario 1 represents a per transaction fee of $10. Scenario 2 represents 290 transactions per second and close to 25 million transactions per day" The second part of the first argument is comparing Bitcoin costs to credit card costs. What the author is trying to say is that Fiat->XBT, buy something, then XBT->Fiat is more expensive than credit card fees of 3%. But on Coinbase, for example, that would be ~2% in transaction fees and that will only go down as XBT inventory is held and pooled so not every purchase transaction results in a fiat conversion. That's only being done now as a bootstrapping strategy (and it seems to be working). I think the author has some good points here but didn't seriously address them, only thinly speculated on them. I'm giving it an up-vote to hopefully have some deeper discussion especially around the first argument of Bitcoin's inherent costs. A quick side note: I'd like to see an analysis of electricity costs of mining vs. mining fees. Mining fees eventually need to surpass electricity costs for mining to be sustainable after inflation-payments are gone. The difference between costs and fees is the margin the miners will make. To me, that would really answer the first argument.
- nickik 12y agoI do belive that bitcoin has huge drawbacks, but there are allready system that are way better in most of these. Delegated prove of stack allows for extreamly low cost, high speed transactions. The notion of a DAC is extreamly intresting, insead of destroying money be wasting it on energy companys we use this money to improve the infrastructure. This will allow development and even services. The problem of the transaction and the lack of annonymity can be solved rather well. The goal is identity if you want it, annonymity otherwise. Bitcoin has a clear first mover advantage but with the development of smart wallets and things like that, altcoins will be more easly integrated with the market. This technology is in its early days but it does have lits of promis. > People forget quickly that regulations were enacted in response to fraud and to protect people. If you really belive that, you have not studied the history of banking reglation. Bitcoin suffers from the same problem that all trade on the international internet suffers from, the lack of contract enforcment. There is a huge diffrece between finacial regulation and contract enforcment. Contracts can be self enforcing by simular mechanisms as it is on ebay. We just need a opt identity system.
- clavalle 12y agoI think this essay is top heavy: the conclusions can't hold given the assumptions. Take the first argument: for transactions to remain cheap one of three things has to happen, then those three things are painted as almost impossible. But the second one; "At the same fee level, transaction count must increase 250 folds." Seems completely possible. If transactions remain relatively cheap then bitcoin can be very useful for microtransactions. And if they are useful for microtransactions then, by there nature, there will be many more transactions. Then the author is all over the map in the second section. At one point saying decentralized entities are useless, then that they don't provide value compared to traditional centralized entities, then than they /are/ real competition for those traditional services but the only real beneficiaries of trustless decentralized transactions are people engaged in illegal activity. They close out by saying since cyberpunks, drug dealers, and gamblers use bitcoin now, it will never find a place in the public sphere. But the blockchain idea is a good one and will find some sort of use. TL:DR The first point was interesting but flawed. The rest was garbage.
- StavrosK 12y agoI think he means transactions per block, which is hard to increase 250x.
- DennisP 12y agoThe Bitcoin devs are working right now on something that could increase the block size more than that. The main thing that limits the size is latency in propagating large blocks. But most miners already have most of the transactions in each block. All you really need to send is a small data structure that lets the miner reconstruct the full block, from the transactions he already has. An invertible bloom lookup table makes that pretty easy: http://www.i-programmer.info/programming/theory/4641-the-invertible-bloom-filter.html?start http://www.i-programmer.info/programming/theory/4641-the-inv... Using this, a home bandwidth connection could handle about 45,000 tx/sec, which is more than Visa at peak: https://gist.github.com/gavinandresen/e20c3b5a1d4b97f79ac2 https://gist.github.com/gavinandresen/e20c3b5a1d4b97f79ac2 The other problem is blockchain storage. They're planning to prune old empty addresses, which should help a lot. A more radical solution is to store the full blocks only for the last couple months, and only a linked set of hashes back to the beginning. That might be a bigger change than Bitcoin can handle, but another currency could do it.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y ago> At the same fee level, transaction count must increase 250 folds. Or, How is this not plausible, given how few transactions must occur there?
- sharpneli 12y agoThe transaction count can only increase if they allow the block size to increase. Right now it's 1MB at maximum. The community is torn about the issue so it's an open question if it will ever happen.
- aminok 12y agoAlmost everyone agrees with the 1 MB block size limit being removed, and replaced with something else. The only question is what it will be replaced with.
- smokeyj 12y agoWe've moved past the "Bitcoin will die" phase to the "Bitcoin may not be the largest technical innovation since the internet" phase. I'm okay with that.
- vectorpush 12y agoThat's not a "phase", that's just a rebuttal to a hyperbolic claim often made by bitcoin fanatics.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mrb 12y agoThe author's post is full of misguided opinions, and inaccuracies. "Reason 1: Bitcoin will not replace retail payment systems" Bitcoin is more of an enabler than a replacer. There are many financial transactions that do not take place because current financial platforms do not let them happen. For example with Bitcoin I could in theory pay an artist in Namibia who makes little sculptures and ships them to worldwide. This economic activity does not exist today because there is no safe/efficient way to pay some random guy in Namibia who does not have a bank account. "Scenario 2 [transaction count must increase 250 folds] and 3 [Price increases 250 folds to $65000/BTC] are not likely to occur" So the author hand-waves that and says it cannot continue to happen with zero reasons? To see a combined 250 fold increase all we need to see is a number of transactions increasing by 25x (which will happen with the upcoming block size increase) and a price increasing by 10x. Consider that: - the number of transactions has already increased 1,000 fold (and more) in the past few years, and there is no sign of it slowing down: https://blockchain.info/charts/n-transactions?showDataPoints=false&show_header=true&daysAverageString=7×pan=all&scale=0&address= https://blockchain.info/charts/n-transactions?showDataPoints... - the price has already increased 1,000 fold (and more) in the past few years: https://blockchain.info/charts/market-price?showDataPoints=false&show_header=true&daysAverageString=7×pan=all&scale=1&address= https://blockchain.info/charts/market-price?showDataPoints=f... So the author ought to explain to us why he thinks such increases would suddenly stop. "Fiat conversion makes Bitcoin transactions even more expensive" The author completely ignores the economic incentive of transactions within the Bitcoin economy itself. When I give 1 BTC to my father, he can spend 1 BTC on Dell.com. No fiat conversion takes place. "Reason 2: Bitcoin will not end the need for trusted central parties" I agree with this, but I do not see at all why the author listed this as a reason why Bitcoin will not succeed. In some cases having a central trusted party does make sense, in others it does not. "When is censorship resistance so important that it is worthwhile to make those trade offs? The answer is: illegal use cases" Or: oppressive governments who seize the bank accounts of dissidents, Paypal when they decide to shut down the accounts of donation receivers (because their fraud system incorrectly interprets such sudden flows of money as fraud), etc. You see, the world is bigger than you. There are many instances where censorship resistance is important and is needed for legal use cases. "Whereas most Bitcoin users are primarily using Bitcoin as a speculative asset and illegal transactions" The author provides no source for the "illegal transactions", because he has no data to back this up, because this claim is false. In fact the biggest illegal shops have been shut down (SR 1.0, SR 2.0). And the number of legit merchants continues to increase (now surpassing 100,000 merchants accepting Bitcoin worldwide). "Internet did not make design trade-offs to primarily focus on censorship resistance at the expense of other qualities (such as speed)" Yes it did make trade-offs. Internet was designed to be decentralized to make it resilient (which is similar to censorship resistance), at the expense of complexity (it took decades to develop a stack that works well: BGP / IP / TCP / UDP / DNS / HTTP). "If online gambling were to become legal and widely accepted by banks, Bitcoin would not be used to gamble online" Another flawed argument. Let me try this: "if online reselling were to become legal and widely accepted by banks, Bitcoin would not be used by online merchants". Yet 100,000 merchants are using Bitcoin... "However, Bitcoin has shown us the promise of blockchain technologies" The author does not understand that Bitcoin's block chain technology simply cannot exist without Bitcoin (the currency): why would miners mine if they received no bitcoins rewards? For the block chain technology to succeed, Bitcoin needs to succeed, and vice versa.
- Lord_Zero 12y ago"internet" I dont think that word means what you think it means.
- Lord_Zero 12y ago"internet" I dont think that word means what you think it means.
- csentropy 12y agoBad arguments. 1. Reason one is wrong as both increase in transaction volume and BTC price are both not only possible but can actually be positive externalities that reinforce each other. The increase in transactions could lead to an increase in price as more people adopt BTC. This has already proven to be the case in the early history of BTC. 2. See above. Once adoption increases, the incentive to convert to Fiat decreases thus making this problem gradually irrelevant once the market tips (the big if). 3. The need for regulations: Obviously total garbage. No need to refute. 4. Decentralization is better than monopoly central control. Legislators and Regulators are the only true monopolies. Market actors are not, so market based intermediaries will still have reasons to exist. This is not a necessary condition for widespread BTC adoption. 5. Full decentralization and "censorship resistance(aka freedom)" are important when there is a threat of property confiscation, which will become increasingly relevant when states become desperate for more revenue (already happening). 6. People don't find daily utility in fast decentralized transactions? That is ludicrous. 7. Trust. That's the whole point of btc protocol. Achieving trust between unknown parties (refer to Byzantine Generals Problem) 8. The section on blockchain is good and valid.
- simas 12y agoPeople are hyped about Bitcoins being trustless? That sounds wrong.
- tuna-piano 12y agoFor his first point "You cannot be cheap and secured by proof-of-work at the same time". The US dollar used to be part of a much more expensive "proof-of-work", the gold standard. In order to create dollars, someone had to buy expensive mining equipment and spend a ton of time and money physically digging gold out of the ground, melting it, and keeping it safe. Seemed to work out well for a pretty long time.
- ianferrel 12y agoBeing pegged to gold and being secured by gold aren't the same thing. The gold that backed the dollar had already been dug up. It was already in the hands of the government. Whatever the costs were to get it, they were sunk costs based on the value of the gold, not the currency system layered on top of it. The dollar was secured via tricky-to-duplicate printing techniques and police powers.
- CyberDildonics 12y agoThis whole thing rests on the fundamental assumption that the current level of mining must be constant. If mining is less profitable, there will be less miners. This is the most likely scenario and not some crazy price increase or fee price increase. Miners can't profit? Miners drop out and leave more breathing room for the other miners.
- frozenport 12y agoIs anybody worried about the terrible consequences if Bitcoin does succeed? It will be a like putting the world back on the gold standard, except with even less inflation! Is anger at online transaction fees worth destroying the world economy?
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoI'm worried as you are. That silicon valley snobs will ignore a thousand years of learning, just to spite 'the man'. We've seen abominable cheating, lying and abuses in virtual currency systems - that surpass anything physical currency systems have experienced, in that they happen at the speed of the internet if nothing else.
- aminok 12y agoI don't believe people should be banned from doing a whole host of things to ostensibly prevent cheating and fraud. The faith you have in centralised authority is extremely dangerous and leads to things like the multi-trillion dollar LIBOR scandal. Unlike with a market system, industries centralised through thousands of regulatory bans cannot evolve because they are typically dominated by a small number of super-giants, and are monocultures. Super large organisms and monocultures are rare in nature for that reason. If anything is snobbish, it's your willingness to impose your will on others through forceful bans that dictate their personal financial activity. As for the hacks and thefts that have occurred thus far, it's worth nothing that Bitcoin is a young and immature sector, that is going through its growing pains. There were similar concerns about crime and fraud in the internet's early years too. I can link you to news stories from the 1990s that demonstrate this. It's not reasonable to generalize Bitcoin's first six years to the inherent qualities of p2p electronic cash.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoNo faith; just experience. Virtual currencies are unregulated, and behave like it. That sort of system got us the great depression and numerous recessions. I appreciate some supporters are there for good reasons; 'snob' may be too strong a word. But it's naïve to believe a pure unregulated market is a good idea, especially one that responds at the speed of light. And where did that comment about banning bitcoin come from?
- placeybordeaux 12y agoThe real practical application for bitcoin that I see will be machine to machine transactions, not human to human transactions. Pre-bitcoin if you want to set up a static website that accepts donations to keep on serving it's content you absolutely have to have a human in the loop to faciliate those transactions. If your webserver is overloaded and you need to charge browsers 0.0001 cents per connection to filter out the legitimate browsers there is a clear path to do that with bitcoin, not so with any other payment scheme. The path to do that involves everyone loading bitcoin into the browser and doing some sort of side chain, trust channel, trusted third party to enable such a cheap transaction, but the point being that there is no one stopping people from developing and pushing these technologies with bitcoin. If you wanted to do this with paypal or cash or credit cards or any other known payment system there are very real road blocks and people that can simply pull the plug. Bitcoin enables people to try out new ways of paying without asking anyone's permission. The quickest to market is illegal trades, because there is no one to say no and no one to pull the plug. It is really fairly similar to bittorrent in that way. Everyone will first say the technology should die because it lets people do things illegally.
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoDid you read the article? If you accept his conclusions, then long term even using bitcoin for $1 transactions much less for $0.000001 isn't economically feasible since he proposes that the true cost of a bitcoin transaction is ~$10.
- placeybordeaux 12y agoThats for transactions on the main block chain. For true micro transactions there are a multitude of options for increasing throughput or decreasing latency.
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoBut that wouldn't be bitcoin anymore. It would be a different crypto-currency.