3 ms·
For the good of future mathematics we need generalists and strategians who can see the big picture. Older mathematicians probably already see the big picture -
by amichail 17y ago
For the good of future mathematics we need generalists and strategians who can see the big picture.
Older mathematicians probably already see the big picture -- well enough anyway.
Younger mathematicians need to worry about tenure and can't waste their time on big picture things that are not likely to pay off.
- carterschonwald 17y agobut what about when these junior faculty etc become senior faculty? as time goes on, if you're not habitually trying to be broadly knowledgeable, how will you ever be? I think the point of the article is to point out this issue and provoke thought, because it certainly doesn't provide a solution.
- nrr 17y agoI would go as far as to say that we need generalists who will take the time to chronicle and revive works from the past to make them relevant again. Better still, we need the mathematics community at large to become more accustomed to seeing papers published in journals that do this so that a larger contingent can be made aware that these papers/ideas/theorems/corollaries/lemmata/definitions/people/pictures/etc. exist. Note also that this doesn't necessarily preclude anyone in mathematics from adopting a specialization. In my eyes, the younger mathematician is in the same place as the startup founder: in the position to take a big risk and do something that sounds like a stupid idea (e.g., avoid publishing results anywhere but freely and openly on the WWW; see also: Daniel Bernstein) in order to have it pay off (e.g., earn tenure).
- joe_the_user 17y agoYounger mathematicians need to worry about tenure and can't waste their time on big picture things that are not likely to pay off Uh, mathematics departments decide what the criteria for tenure are. As the article suggests, perhaps mathematics departments could make knowledge of the field in general a criterion.