41 ms·
> Why does it matter what you do with the corpse? If you have to kill something, or destroy something, at least have a good reason for doing so. Cutting down
by grecy 12y ago
> Why does it matter what you do with the corpse?
If you have to kill something, or destroy something, at least have a good reason for doing so.
Cutting down a whole forest for no reason is not a good way to behave.
- Dylan16807 12y agoCutting down a forest is only a problem if I'm not growing suitable new forest to replace it. If I'm buying meat in the store I'm definitely paying for it to be replaced. I don't see why a good reason is necessary when it comes to a renewable resource. I support demanding good reasons for non-renewable resources.
- grecy 12y agoBecause you're actively killing a living thing. In the same way I think it's not productive to call an animal that will killed "cold cuts", I don't think it's productive to refer to a living animal as a "renewable resource". Also implying that you can kill and waste as many of them as you like simply because you paid for it is not productive either. In all honesty, it's disappointing to see people refer to living creatures this way.
- Dylan16807 12y agoI feel like the distinction between active killing and passive killing is overblown. A lot of things die simply because I exist. If it was a top priority to minimize it I wouldn't eat meat at all. I'm not trying to be insulting by calling things resources. Even the most important things like time are renewable in some important contexts. Waste is not productive by definition, not sure where you're going with that. It's bad economically but not morally. To get to the important part, I want animals to live without suffering. But cold cuts can't suffer. And I'm not calling living animals cold cuts.
- grecy 12y agoThanks for the conversation, I appreciate it. > I feel like the distinction between active killing and passive killing is overblown. I used to feel the same way. A genuine question - have you ever done any active killing yourself? I feel like it was a massive perspective changing experience for me to kill and butcher a ~1000lb wild creature.
- Dylan16807 12y agoI haven't. Maybe I'll try it some time. Though there's a lot of difference in the wild vs. farmed part of the equation, not just in the details of killing.