9 ms·
If you're not thinking of watching the video, think again. Even if you watch just the last two minutes. There's a good twist in the tail in the way the most suc
by petercooper 17y ago
If you're not thinking of watching the video, think again. Even if you watch just the last two minutes. There's a good twist in the tail in the way the most successful team made the most money :-)
- igorgue 17y agoyes it was awesome!, I bet the students felt used by the winning team :), but in a very good way. It was a great idea.
- mustpax 17y agoThe peculiar thing about these brilliant hacks is that they challenge our assumptions about what's allowed to such an extent that they feel dishonest. That isn't because there is anything amoral about them. Social interactions are a kind of delicate dance, they thrive on a certain basic level of predictability. So people are unnerved when that is taken away from them.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoIt was a bit dishonest - they sold other peoples time without any guarantee they could deliver it. The students could all have got up and left saying they weren't going to be exploited, or have done a non-violent protest, etc.. Very clever though.
- ggrot 17y agoIn theory, but they could be pretty confident about the risk of this being low since it was only a 3-minute presentation.
- idm 17y agoThe more I think about the video, the more disappointed I become. You're right: these "genius entrepreneurs" were selling the time of their classmates. The 3-minute slot had no value if their classmates didn't tolerate the fact that their time became a commercial - one which they certainly didn't opt into. On the one hand, it's probably true that the timeslot they sold was the most valuable thing they had, for the purposes of the demonstration - and on that basis, they get a "gold star" for making the identification. On the other hand, their actions were questionable at best, and unethical at worst. Imagine, for example, if professors routinely sold part of their lecture time to any startup that wanted a few interns. It's a strategy that doesn't scale, because it erodes trust and reduces the chances that it will work in the future. Therefore, it's a bad strategy and a bad "moral of the story." Recap: good exercise in identifying valuable things, bad exercise for determining sustainable growth.
- wvenable 17y ago> You're right: these "genius entrepreneurs" were selling the time of their classmates. Exactly. But you miss the fact that they already had the time of their classmates to sell. No matter what happened, the classmates would have to sit through 3 minutes from this group.
- idm 17y agoonce. not twice.
- wvenable 17y agoWho said anything about twice, though? They had 3 minutes and they sold it -- I don't think that means they got another 3 minutes. Now both the students and the instructor might have given them another 3 minutes, but that's not something they could have assumed nor is it somehow wrong.
- gcheong 17y agoMy experience with these in-class group presentations is that most groups tend to shut out the presentations of the other groups because they're focused on waiting for their turn to present and last-minute prep. So unless it's a really good presentation most of them probably fall on deaf ears. Now these students will present a company pitch for a company that wants to actively recruit students from the class. I'd probably listen to that.
- magnuschr 17y agoHow is that different from the current $100B+ advertisement business? TV, press, Google all sell "our time".
- mechanical_fish 17y agoImagine, for example, if professors routinely sold part of their lecture time to any startup that wanted a few interns. I don't need to imagine. Most of the conferences I've been to work this way. There are many ways to look at this. One is to note that, if I needed a job, I would probably pay cash money to attend a series of 3-minute commercials by companies that were looking to hire interns. Indeed, this is a lot of what Stanford students are paying tuition for. In the building next door to your college classroom is a job placement office that specializes in exactly this. So I'm kind of dubious about the assertion that this is some kind of terrible disservice to the students. Another way to look at it: "sustainable growth" is highly overrated. It's not merely that it wasn't a criteria of the original problem -- which it wasn't -- but also that judging what is and isn't "sustainable" is an exercise in predicting the future. And, like all exercises in predicting the future, it tends to miss a lot of the good stuff. You find yourself saying things like "This business plan won't scale past the first 5000 customers!" or "If Netflix catches on, Blockbuster will get into the business and crush Netflix like a bug!" or "How could I ever make a million dollars doing something this trivial?" or "How can Twitter succeed after the open-source open-protocol Twitter Substitute comes along, as it surely will, any minute now?" [1] But the most obvious conclusion is: Just because you can't do it twice doesn't mean it isn't worth doing once. If I were a student in that class, I would surely have been happy to sit through a three-minute presentation, though I'm not sure I would have heard much of it, because I would have been too busy rolling on the floor with laughter at the scope of the other students' awesome hack. But, yeah, it won't work a second time. Everybody knows the punch line now. --- [1] Hey, if people didn't believe stuff like this I wouldn't see it pop up on HN every three months, like clockwork.
- MikeCapone 17y agoThanks. You convinced me to watch it, and it was worth the time.
- zackattack 17y agoCan someone just spoil it please? I hate having to waste my time in order to glean insights. Pareto.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- wvenable 17y agoI normally hate watching videos to get information, but to the credit of the presenter this video is very concise and quick. The whole thing is insightful.
- rjett 17y agoIt's only 6 minutes, but if you want the 10 second version, the winning team sold their 3 minute presentation time in class to a company called Frog Design that wanted to recruit Stanford design students. Frog Design paid $650 for this 3 minutes. Lessons learned in this experiment: Successful teams did not frame the problem in terms of the $5 limitation. Instead, they thought of the problem in terms of services they could easily provide where salesmanship and timeliness were valued. The most successful team forgot about the $5 limitation and the 2 hour time limit altogether.
- nkurz 17y agoShe teaches a class at Stanford and offers each team $5 of 'funding' in an envelope. She tells them that once they open the envelope, they have 2 hours to make as much money as they can. She cites three teams' approaches: 1) First team opens a free stand that offers to check peoples bike tire pressure for free, then charges $1 to inflate if necessary. This team changes midstream to accepting donations instead of charging, and makes more money. Lauded for rapid iteration. 2) Second team makes lots of reservations at local restaurants, and then sells them to people waiting in line for same restaurant. Didn't use the $5 at all. Lauded for realizing that the $5 constraint was artificial, and that using it constrained their thinking. 3) Third team skipped the exercise, and sold their 3 minute class presentation time as a advertisement to a local company. Made the most money. Instead of presenting, they recruited. Lauded for realizing that the 2 hours was also artificially hampering their thinking. Personally, I found the presentation glib and condescending, and the solutions immoral and dishonest. I'm hoping for good discussion about the issues here, but I would not recommend the video.