4 ms·
" Participants were randomly assigned to groups given either 4.375 g/day gluten or rice starch (placebo) for 1 week, each via gastro-soluble capsules."" One th
by raverbashing 12y ago
" Participants were randomly assigned to groups given either 4.375 g/day gluten or rice starch (placebo) for 1 week, each via gastro-soluble capsules.""
One thing that's not clear is what was communicated to the patients: "You'll be given gluten", "You'll be given something unspecified" or "You'll be given a gluten-free food" (and then groups split in gluten/placebo given)
- zemo 12y agosubjects don't know whether they do or do not have placebo. That's inherent in the definition of placebo.
- hatsix 12y agoPlease re-read the parent comment. The question is "What did they think they have?"
- jimjimjim 12y ago"... a Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled, ..." The important part of the title is the words Double-Blind. The patients don't know and the people running it don't know.
- bcherry 12y agoThe patients know they're eating a pill - the administrators have to tell them something about this pill, even in a double blind study. Did they tell them "this pill contains gluten" (even though the placebo group did not receive gluten) or did they tell them "this pill contains no gluten" or did they tell them "this pill may or may not contain gluten"? Maybe they told them "this pill contains an experimental drug for combatting gluten intolerance". it does matter what they used.
- inyourtenement 12y agoI have some small experience as a study subject. We were given detailed information ahead of time which included what was under study, and whether there would be a placebo group. I guess the assumption is that since both groups receive the same information any placebo effect would be equalized.
- marcosdumay 12y agoIt's a double blind experiment. That means that the person giving them the pill has no idea if it has gluten or not either.
- raverbashing 12y agoI know that I'm asking what they are told, of course in a double-blind study they are never told if they're given the drug or the placebo, but they tell the people "this is an experimental drug for X" But they might have told them "This is a treatment for gluten intolerance" or "this is purified gluten" or nothing
- JshWright 12y agoAs it was a crossover study (1 week with gluten or placebo, 1 week gluten free, then 1 week with whichever they didn't have the first time), it is likely they were aware that they would be receiving either gluten or a placebo (and that they would be receiving the other alternative in the next phase of the study).