22 ms·
Google now automatically converts Flash ads to HTML5
- serve_yay 12y agoUhh, hooray.
- vitno 12y agowhy swiffy? Why not use Shumway? Is this just a case of "Not invented here" syndrome?
- melling 12y agoLooks like Swiffy was started first. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Swiffy http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Swiffy http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shumway_(software) http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shumway_(software)
- evincarofautumn 12y agoAnd I think Spaceport (now defunct) was started even earlier than that. Shame Google didn’t acquire it.
- cpeterso 12y agoSwiffy is an offline publishing tool to convert SWFs to SVG. Shumway is a client-side SWF interpreter.
- itsjareds 12y agoOn a related note: can someone explain the advantages of Swiffy over Shumway? Upon first glance, it looks like Shumway has the ability to translate Actionscript to Javascript and the Flash visual elements to HTML5 elements. Whereas with Swiffy, the SWF is just converted to what's basically an animated SVG. What would make Swiffy more attractive for Google to use over Shumway if Shumway seems to be a more complete solution?
- bshimmin 12y agoMost Flash ads don't really have a great deal of ActionScript in them beyond the odd call to stop and play in the timeline.
- TD-Linux 12y agoShumway is a very heavyweight dynamic recompiler and includes a complex canvas/webGL rendering engine. Shipping it just for an ad is a bit much. Naturally, Swiffy's method is quite limited in what Flash features it can support, but that's OK for its purpose.
- akersten 12y agoShame that I automatically convert all ads to nonexistance. It's too little, too late for rich media/content-heavy ads. Especially in the mobile sector: * Ads are a performance burden on low-power devices * They consume extra battery; power is wasted on superfluous cruft * Bandwidth wasted; especially a concern given draconian data caps * Tracking and privacy concerns Not to mention the fact that ads are a primary attack vector (think of all the advertising CDNs that have been compromised and used to deliver malware). The real improvement here is moving away from a proprietary plugin. Pointing out the problems of rich media ads isn't very useful here though, since most of us are probably aware already. My proposal would be simple, inline text, along the lines of "this page load sponsored by _". Doubt that will gain traction, though.
- drzaiusapelord 12y ago>They consume extra battery; I find it fascinating that Google is always hurting their own mobile experience. Between all the issues android has with wake locks and memory leaks and the massive infrastructure of location and 'lifestyle' tracking for ad delivery, its a miracle Android devices get any battery life at all. Even without this html5 conversion, Android battery life often pales compared to iOS or Windows Phone. The more I think about it, an OS from whats essentially an ad delivery company is probably a liability. Monetization will trump user experience. Get ready for some pretty invasive html5 ads.
- higherpurpose 12y agoAren't most iOS apps ad-based, too?
- Zirro 12y agoNot most of them, in my experience. Most seem to rely on the initial purchase price only, and many of those that used to have ads have switched to in-app purchases. While I could not tell you for sure why this is, several statistics indicate that iOS users have more money to spend and piracy is much less frequent. Ads also have a tendency to disrupt the "experience" of using an app which may be more discouraged on Apple platforms. With that said, there are also many apps which make no attempts at monetization at all.
- marquis 12y agoI run the flash blocker extension in Chrome. So I expect, the next extension I'll be running is a <video> tag blocker with an option to enable on demand. (edit: known as "click to play" mode)
- Igglyboo 12y agoOr just use an adblocker and you don't have to worry what format the ads are in.
- marquis 12y agoAdblockers don't catch everything, and also on some sites I am happy to support via Ads but I cannot stand being interrupted with auto-play video. I've really enjoyed the complete silence from ads in Flash format and am not looking forward to a repeat of the early 2000s.
- wutbrodo 12y ago+1, I starting using click-to-play _years_ ago as a quick way to make sure that YouTube didn't autoplay when I opened it in a new tab. I don't use ad blockers for ethical reasons, so a pleasant side effect turned out to be neutralizing the most egregious behavior that ads would display (by and large autoplay etc tend to be Flash ads).
- whyever 12y agoRunning an adblocker when using Chrome on Android is non-trivial.
- codesuela 12y agofyi you dont need an extension, Chrome has native click to play support
- cpeterso 12y agoThis looks like an optional conversion step for advertisers that want to target mobile devices that don't have Flash. So not wholesale replacement of Flash ads.
- thebouv 12y agoOn the plus side: death to Flash ads! On the negative side: life to more ads!
- simonsarris 12y agoSo when are they gonna convert Google Finance to HTML5 instead of Flash?
- azakai 12y agoThere's no financial benefit there. But, for ads...
- bane 12y agoAlmost 1500 days ago I made this prediction https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2300123 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2300123 "(I can't wait for my quad core computer to grind to a halt with dozens of unblockable canvas advertisements wallpapering every website I go to from now on...sigh, the end is near" The death of Flash doesn't necessarily mean a better world.
- misterbwong 12y agoHere. Have a cookie...?
- eludwig 12y agoQuestion: not knowing anything about browser plugins, will it be possible to build a "Click to Canvas" plugin, similar to the Click to Flash plugins avialable? It seems like anything that can access the DOM can insert stuff into (override) or outright block elements, right?
- bane 12y agoI'm sure we'll see such a thing. The problem is that it'll just shift to somewhere else in the browser, and killing off all the codepaths that might be doing something to the non-working canvas might be subtly hard. It'll stay a game of cat-and-mouse for a long time I'm afraid.
- eludwig 12y agoGood points. Thanks. I guess it's inevitable given the free (as in, subscription free) nature of web content. Heck, even paying a subscription to the NYT doesn't opt you out of seeing their ads, unless you take matters into your own hands with something like AdBlock.
- quoiquoi 12y agohttps://github.com/kkapsner/CanvasBlocker https://github.com/kkapsner/CanvasBlocker
- 12y ago
- bostik 12y agoI'm torn. On one hand, this means that there will be less flash overall polluting the net. A good thing. On the other hand, it also means that the polluters have less incentive to actually remove their flash-crap. Someone else will transform their guano into form that is more widely deliverable. A bad thing. Flash will persist even longer. And of course, flash blocker will now kill less ads than before. Damn.
- towelguy 12y ago> And of course, flash blocker will now kill less ads than before. Damn. That was my concern too, but I guess the only difference will be you'll have to block a bunch of scripts and images instead of blocking just one flash file. Why does it matter that Flash persist if it's being converted to html5 on the fly anyway? By the way, the swiffy service Google offers has a extension to Flash (the authoring tool) so it can output html5 directly.
- woodchuck64 12y agoSpeaking of ads, what can block that obnoxious "THE BEST OF VB, DELIVERED" that pops up like a visual air horn just as you're starting to grasp the content of the first paragraph?
- clarry 12y agoSince I didn't see such a thing, I'm betting it's NoScript. HTML5 and Javascript are cancer..
- eyeareque 12y agoWhat are these "ads" you speak of?
- Zei33 12y agoThis is really good as somebody who uses google ads from time to time, albeit rarely. It's time for flash to take a walk.
- thisjustinm 12y agoWe dove into this at work (where we make a lot of flash and HTML ads) and it took a 40k flash ad and made it into a 100k HTML add that also required the nearly 500k swiffly.js file to run. So it's a start but it's not magic nor replacement for a competent human just yet.
- chanux 12y agoAlso relevant: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/01/new-drm-boss-same-old-boss https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/01/new-drm-boss-same-old-... HN thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9013211 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9013211
- Lverano 12y agoThis is cool!
- Lverano 12y agoThis is cool!
- z3t4 12y agoI've turned off JavaScript in the browser. And only allow it for sites where I really need it. I though this day would never come.
- 72deluxe 12y agoHopefully they will finally fix the bug in Chrome where sites that require Flash pop up a "this site requires flash! - would you like to install it?" bar at the top of the screen, even though it isn't bundled with the app. It is particularly annoying considering their own efforts to remove Flash from usage on YouTube, that is, with supporting HTML5 video.