2 ms·
> The pre-key is needed when you have never talked to someone (I guess it's also needed when the last conversation is really old, I haven't dug throuh the code)
by e12e 12y ago
> The pre-key is needed when you have never talked to someone (I guess it's also needed when the last conversation is really old, I haven't dug throuh the code); it's a necessary bootstrap step. After that all you need is inside your client.
Well, no. It's needed when you client has never talked to someone. If you have a pad, a phone and a laptop, they all need a pre-key to talk to the same person. If the person's server is down, the system breaks down (you can't have just anyone mirror the pre-keys).
> From a user pov, there is no difference between:
>
> - I type the message and hit send, the message is encrypted now and sent when I have connectivity
>
> - I type the message and hit send, the message is encrypted and sent when I have connectivity
Perhaps not. But there's a difference between being alerted that you can't reach the recipient securely before you type the message, and getting that message (no pre-key available) after you've taken the time to write the message.
Not to mention that hopefully the device has FDE, so there aren't any plain-text messages around for when you go through customs, or when someone steals your phone etc. But I'll concede that device security is probably outside the realm of what a message system should deal with.
Don't get me wrong, I welcome improvements like this -- I just don't think it's comparable to pgp (which is both good and bad).