8 ms·
A different cluetrain
- HarryHirsch 12y agoThe extreme short-termism of capitalism that stifles innovation is missing from the analysis. Right now we are seeing an overinvestment in Sillicon Valley and an underinvestment in Biotech. The money is flowing to ad-selling services like Google and Facebook, and to intermediaries like Uber and friends, but biotech startups are funded below replacement rates. The development pipeline is drying up, it's not that the IP wasn't there, it's just not getting funded. Locust investors like Valeant don't help either. (Their business model is to buy up companies and then immediately divest of R&D.) Any money in biotech goes to cancer instead of antibacterials, because the price points of cancer medicines are highest. The future was in the news last week: superbugs spread through colonoscopy procedures in LA. We'll see more of that in the coming years, but there is no alternative funding model within sight.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoInvestment in biotech is low because the returns are low, not because of a high discount rate. It's getting harder to discover new drugs and get them through the FDA gauntlet. Most of the low hanging fruit has been found, and additional fruit won't necessarily pass comparative effectiveness without huge (and expensive) trials. After it makes it to market you are subject to political risks - price controls, lawsuits over side effects too small to find in clinical trials, etc. It's hardly clear that the valley is even a good short term investment. Most tech companies focus heavily on growth, not profits. Why do you believe that biotech has higher long term returns than the valley?
- HarryHirsch 12y agoWhy do you believe that biotech has higher long term returns than the valley? That's precisely the problem. Within my lifetime the current antibiotics will become useless, we will be where we were before 1937 (discovery of sulfanilamide), physicians will be as good as they always were at prognosis, but helpless in the face of bacterial infections. The apocalypse is coming, and capitalism is no tool against it.
- CamperBob2 12y agoWithin my lifetime the current antibiotics will become useless Also, bananas will be extinct by 2008, and there won't be enough oil or food.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoThe issue of fewer drug targets than in the past is not something that any economic system can solve. That's just chemistry. As for the rest of it, it's true that capitalism can't fix the FDA or foreign price controls. Lets hope Charlie Stross is right and the capitalists can take over the government and fix this.
- angersock 12y agoSo, that's being too nice--recall that market forces are what have led to the overprescription of these medications and also the creation of the environments (hospitals) in which they flourish and mutate.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoYes, we would likely be better off with a Pigouvian tax on antibiotics - that's the economist solution. Unfortunately, neither the capitalistic system nor the democratic process has any real way to get us there.
- HarryHirsch 12y agoPigouvian tax on antibiotics - that's the economist solution The Swedes and British manage extremely well with national guidelines that physicians actually adhere too. In some disciplines there is no alternatives to the technocrats.
- craigyk 12y agoHeh, the takeaway I've gotten from some of Stross's novels is that AI makes "capitalism" indistinguishable, at least from the point of human beings, from a centrally-planned managed economy. So there could be a future in which AI's become sufficiently advanced at serving human needs that we all live as komrades in a utopian communist society.
- hga 12y ago"additional fruit won't necessarily pass comparative effectiveness without huge (and expensive) trials" Ah, that may explain the statistic I recently saw that Phase III trials are taking up 90% of the budget necessary to bring a new drug to market.
- protomyth 12y agoThink of a study that needs 3 lab test per day for each of the participants. These tests aren't cheap and a multi-year study with a couple of hundred participants with shipping costs (overnight) for the samples. It does ring up quite a bill.
- hga 12y agoPlus, oh, finding and keeping enough people in the study willing to get 1-3 blood draws a day??? Yow. I thought that by Phase III safety was pretty well established and you'd be looking for efficacy endpoints, surrogate or real. Emphasis on endpoint ... but I guess not. But ... if vague memory serves, from the overview of some Phase III trials, maybe not the first one, I remember more like hundreds of participants. Maybe not quite a thousand, but a lot.
- protomyth 12y agoThey don't have to be blood samples. I remember one which was blood, urine, and stool each day. Also, each sample might have multiple tests performed. Its a pretty interesting logistical problem.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Investment in biotech is low because the returns are low As I understand, investment in biotech is low because the time to realize returns is long, not because the returns are low (even after adjusting for time). The time it takes to bring a product from concept to market in biotech is virtually an eternity by Silicon Valley standards.
- protomyth 12y agoAlso, the long term cash outlay for a drug that might have side effects discovered long after the patents run out. It is a very chancy business with a lot of failures per success. There are much better things to investment in.
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y ago> The extreme short-termism of capitalism that stifles innovation is missing from the analysis What would that add? Civilisations don't have to innovate. In fact, the people on top may be perfectly happy with stagnation and the status quo.
- itg 12y ago"underinvestment in Biotech" have you looked at biotech IPO's as of late. I would say the complete opposite.
- Kiro 12y agoStifles innovation compared to what? I don't think there's any system that stimulates innovation more than capitalism.
- TheOtherHobbes 12y agoOf course there isn't. Capitalism guarantees no such system is allowed to exist. But capitalism is based on jam today and famine tomorrow. This works just fine for people - as long as they're not thinking straight. Intelligent resource allocation understands that famine ten years from now is a bad thing and should be avoided, even if it means lower short-term profits. Any system that thinks ahead like that would be much more innovative than capitalism, because it would be able to make long term plans and invest in long term projects with pay-off times measured in decades or even centuries - something capitalism is manifestly unable to do. It would also be better at avoiding the usual capitalist kooky idiocies like poisoned water tables, avoidable drought, accidental anti-terraforming, and the rest.
- xioxox 12y agoPublic funding of science and universities stimulates more innovation. The stuff you see from companies took years of research in universities before they pushed it the last few yards.
- murbard2 12y agoThe market's horizon depends on the world's population time preference and risk aversion as a whole, not on the whims of venture capitalist. Why? Because arbitrage. If the world as a whole has a low rate of time preference and risk aversion, investments will flow towards high potential long term projects rather than short term ones. But what if you're a greedy, myopic VC with high time preference who wants to make money now? That doesn't affect too much how you will value deals. What you care about is how much money you will make at the exit, which will depend on the equity valuation at that point. And that valuation, depends on the global investment's community risk aversion and risk preference. Facebook trades at a P/E ratio of 71, meaning the equity is worth 71 years of current earnings. Netflix has a P/E of 116. Think that's shorts-sighted? Ultimately, investments come from two sources, money saved and invested by individuals, and banks. If it were only the first, you could say that the type of investments you see reflect the society you have. As a whole, society picks taxi cabs now rather than maybe some pharmaceutical product later. It's not capitalism, it's human nature. Banks complicate the picture, since they turn their deposits into loans of various maturity. The rates on these loans are ultimately tied to central bank policies. However, these policies generally attempt to keep rates low, so as to stimulate "productive" investments. In addition, various bail-out guarantees tend to artificially increase the amount of risk taking. So there you have it. Capitalism by itself merely represents the time preference and risk preference of the population as a whole, and central banks tend to make it more risk taking and longer terms than investors would actually prefer.
- username223 12y ago> And that valuation, depends on the global investment's community risk aversion and risk preference. > > Facebook trades at a P/E ratio of 71, meaning the equity is worth 71 years of current earnings. Netflix has a P/E of 116. Think that's shorts-sighted? Most humans aren't trading on earnings, but on market psychology, believing they can sell to a greater fool in the future. And most trades aren't even made by humans, but by HFT algorithms trying to win massively-leveraged short-term bets for a fraction of a percent. The Facebook and Netflix P/E ratios have very little to do with long-term earnings.
- 12y ago
- nosuchthing 12y agoIt seems detrimental that large scale organizations are short sighted to 4 month (quarterly), annual, and 2-4 year (election) cycles. Asphalt is cheap yet requires high maintenance and degrades quickly - rather than a larger initial investment in concrete which lasts 4 times as long.
- grandpa 12y agoThe "cluetrain" in the title refers to the Cluetrain Manifesto from 1999: http://www.cluetrain.com/book/95-theses.html http://www.cluetrain.com/book/95-theses.html
- bonn1 12y agoWhile I find the post a bit odd I value the 3rd bullet legitimate for debate: Since the collapse of the USSR and the rise of post-Tiananmen China it has become glaringly obvious that capitalism does not require democracy. Or even benefit from it. Capitalism as a system may well work best in the absence of democracy. I am also quite impressed and wonder how China got there where it is today in the absence of democracy. But I am not sure if I would agree with the OP since there many examples where states economically failed/are failing and assumingly because of the absence of democracy.
- cstross 12y agoSee also Singapore, arguably a democracy in name only. Or its neighbour Malaysia, ditto (and rather less successful). I could cherry-pick examples until the cows come home, but I suspect other factors are at work -- and not just the obvious cultural stereotypes (look at how the two Koreas diverged after 1973, for example).
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoAn example of an undemocratic failing capitalistic state does not repudiate the statement "capitalism does not require democracy", but an example of an undemocratic succeeding capitalistic state proves the statement. And we have several examples of such states. Logic is like that.
- nothrabannosir 12y agoWhile technically true, this is not pure logic, and his statement is more nuanced. To note: > Capitalism as a system may well work best in the absence of democracy. That's written in English, and it is reasonably interpreted to mean more than \not(capitalism-works-well \implies democracy). The author suggests capitalism-works-well \implies \not democracy.
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoFair enough, though plainly, capitalism can work well in some kinds of democracy. The statement that is there to provoke thought is actually about where capitalism works best, i.e. what are the optimal conditions for capitalism or if "capitalism-works-best \implies \not democracy" Which is now making me think of ways in which money distorts government, i.e in which capitalism and democracy are in tension. For a prime example, "Citizens United" is clearly pro-capitalistic, and anti-democratic. http://www.newsweek.com/five-years-after-citizens-united-signs-backlash-303336 http://www.newsweek.com/five-years-after-citizens-united-sig...
- kordless 12y agoI'll just remind everyone this is the same Charles Stross that wants Bitcoin to 'die in a fire': http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2013/12/why-i-want-bitcoin-to-die-in-a.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2013/12/why-i-wa.... Beware taking advice from individuals in the throes of massive cognitive dissonance.
- wavefunction 12y agoSo? I don't see anything wrong with someone being anti-bitcoin and all his points seem salient. His points in this piece are well-considered and argued as well. I would downvote you but I'm just going to register my disapproval of your sort of criticism, which seems empty and baseless.
- kordless 12y agoOh, don't worry. There are plenty of anti-Bitcoin people around here who will do it for you.
- knowaveragejoe 12y agoNot only does this sound like Ad Hominem, but I also think you are taking that statement too literally... the very sentence it's contained in should give a clue as to where his sentiment lies on alternative currencies(emphasis mine): > I want Bitcoin to die in a fire: this is a start, but it's not sufficient.
- sp332 12y agoI think the part you have in italics was referring to BTC losing half its value.
- kordless 12y agoIt may sound like ad hominem, but that would mean I was "responding to arguments by attacking a person's character". That said, I'm definitely making blaming statements, so it's fair you made the observation. I'm pretty sure cognitive dissonance isn't a character trait so much as it is a current state of thinking surrounding a given topic, which in this case is global finance. I've read Stross, and like his works, but I am attacking what he is saying (currently) about a given topic. I think it's also fair to point out he makes his own ad hominem arguments: "Bitcoin (is bad b/c) mining software is now being distributed as malware". I also think it's fair to say, when observing illogical remarks from an individual, that they may still be conflicted on the topic.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoI agree with the other commenter that "capitalism does not require democracy" is interesting enough to kick around. The rest of it seems more and more tenuous the further you get down the list (and the more things that are combined in some sort of quasi-logic to reach a conclusion). I'm not saying the guy is wrong, just that there's a lot to digest there -- too much for a forum like this. From what I've read, there are clear things that separate various civilizations. A quick list that I pulled out of the air might look like this: - Private property - Rule of law (contracts) - Freedom of political speech - Consent of the governed - Ability to freely associate into commercial units (corporations) - Peaceful transfer of authority Societies that have these things, on average, are able to solve more problems for more people over a longer period of time than those who do not. These problems are usually solved from the bottom-up; whether through innovation or grassroots political efforts, distributed, self-optimizing systems beat centralized ones. The various forms of democracies that we see instantiated usually have more of these things than the other types of governments we've tried as a planet. Capitalism refers to a very specific type of financial arrangement. It seems to map man's desire to trade with the above values -- at least as good as anything else. To say "captialism does not require democracy", then, is true -- but it's woefully incomplete. The Chinese are getting away with rapid growth because they've met many but not all of the criteria, and that's only for the last decade or two. The problem with the statement is that it wants to form a broad conclusion about complex topics using simple language. If you do that, you miss out on the important parts. This is also the problem with the rest of the list. Do enough of this and string a thread through it, you can prove pretty much any dang thing you'd like.
- sp332 12y agoSo to stop this from becoming violent, we need a peaceful means of transfer of power that can keep up with "internet speed". Or the bureaucracy of government needs to absorb everyone who has political legitimacy and use them to continue expanding, which I think has been happening lately. Or we could find a way to "financialize" labor.
- PakG1 12y agoWould you prefer public policy that changes at the speed of high-frequency traders on the stock market, or at the speed of long-term investors that analyze at the level of Warren Buffett (true value-oriented investments) and storied venture capitalists (big-play game-changing startups)?
- sp332 12y agoIt's not that policy should change constantly, but that people who make policy tend to lose legitimacy in a very abrupt way. Transfer of power has to be very rapid, or people will rebel and stop following the leader.
- guelo 12y agoI think student loans are the financialization of labor.
- murbard2 12y agoI mostly agree with the axioms as stated, but there's an obvious subtext that is more questionable and that carries a few unstated assumptions - Democracy, or more generally giving political power to the people is a good thing, maybe an end in itself. - Increases in inequalities between capital and labor are intrinsically a bad thing. If your focus is on people being able to live happy, fulfilling lives, the whole Maslow hierarchy of need thing, it's not clear at all that these assumptions are warranted.
- istjohn 12y agoThose aren't assumptions. Axiom 18, the final conclusion, states, "we're on the receiving end of a war fought for control of our societies by opposing forces that are increasingly more powerful than we are." The reader is left to decide whether that is a good or bad thing. Edit: And if you are labor, if you are the people of the democracy, of course these things are bad. It is self-evident. It is not a hidden assumption, but rather falls out of the conclusion. No one wants to be under the finger of another's control. These things are only good for capital.
- murbard2 12y agoYou're right of course, these aren't stated assumptions which is why I mentioned the subtext. I could of course be reading Stross's intentions wrong, but given what he's written before, and given how widespread those assumptions are, I tend to think they're taken as a given.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoUpvoted because you made a good point. Good point, but wrong, in my opinion. - “Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all the others.” -- Churchill. - technological progress is making everything cheaper except for land, labour and political influence. Having only the rich able to afford those three things is very dangerous in my opinion. Sure, the poor can afford bread and televised circuses, but I'm not sure I think that makes a good society.
- VLM 12y agoDemocracy is the opiate of the masses. No need to rebel, here, just select one of two hand picked identical candidates with no substantial policy differences outside unimportant hot button social issues, no need for mob violence to change leadership when you can vote (just remember not to "waste" your vote on a 3rd party non-hand picked candidate, because they're not under our thumb!) The inequality problem sets in when you expel most of the labor force from the economy. The economy no longer has space for them, no longer needs them, no longer will let them in to participate. I'm sure the teeming masses of bored angry resentful aspirational young men will never respond violently like they always have in the past. Nope no demagogues will become leaders, LOL. Assuming there's no revolution, what happens to the economic refugees when the population is 99% refugee? They'll need some way to get the requirements of living, which seems to involve currency and an economy, or they'll die. But they have the perma-economic-death-penalty so they can't participate, and we'd like to think the 1% won't kill them, so immovable object meet irresistible force. Being in the UK Charlie has absolutely weird ideas about gun ownership and rebellion. True a 18th century napoleonic war with civilian gun owners on one side and the conventional army on the other would be just a bit one sided. The actual result would look a lot more like Afghanistan or Iraq or Vietnam or Somalia, you know, the places where the army lost the war? When an angry well-enough armed population dramatically outnumbers the army, the army loses. Maybe a couple million civilians will die, but the army is still going to lose in the end. Then out come the guillotines for the 1% leaders for their war crimes or revenge or whatever. Sure would be nice to avoid this outcome, but we're not even trying, not in the least, if anything we're not steering away from the brick wall we're stomping on the accelerator. Talking about 18th century strategy being all thats possible is almost intentional disinfo, which is weird coming from Charlie. Gonna be a fun century!
- lukev 12y agoThis is very insightful. I wonder however if his partitioning of the economy into "labor" and "capital" isn't a bit too black and white, though. In particular, it leaves out knowledge workers who are capable of implementing automation, inventing new products, performing new research. These activities can be fueled by capital but they are gated by a not-entirely-fungible resource; namely, skilled individuals, that I'm not sure it makes sense just to classify as "labor". Such individuals could wield considerable influence, aside from capital. I can't help but wonder what kind of an effect (if any) this observation has on his analysis.
- JackFr 12y ago>Since the collapse of the USSR and the rise of post-Tiananmen China it has become glaringly obvious that capitalism does not require democracy. Or even benefit from it. Capitalism as a system may well work best in the absence of democracy. It's tough to respond to statements like this as written. 'Capitalism', 'democracy' and 'work well' are not precise terms, and the statement can be either true or false depending on the shade of meaning.
- craigyk 12y agoIt always struck me that socialism is the economic system that in theory appears to be closest/compatible with democracy. Then again, I think what has actually become obvious is that mixed economies are what seem to work, to which I'd add not just having rules, but changing them often enough to prevent gaming of the system. So maybe in a sense messy is good not just because the real-world requires messy solutions, but because you got to keep people on their toes. Let's face it, laissez-faire or pure socialism, the weak point in either case is people subverting the system.
- metaphorm 12y agoI think you're searching for reasons to disagree based on semantics and technicalities and evading the very cogent points made by the author. While there is room for disagreement about some of the nuances of what is meant by "Capitalism" or "democracy", do you think that there is really any comprehension problem w.r.t Stross' use of those terms? It seemed perfectly clear to me. His usage is quite conventional. What about the quoted passage do you actually think is ambiguous?
- mikeash 12y agoYou've neatly summed up why computer people have so much trouble talking about the real world. Some things are inherently imprecise. We can talk about them anyway.
- api 12y agoWilliam Gibson got the essence and the aesthetic of it in Neuromancer in 1984.
- thornygreb 12y ago> I have a CS degree from 1990. It's about as much use as an aerospace engineering degree from 1927 I'm not sure there was such a thing as an aerospace engineering degree in 1927, but if you think a CS degree from 1990 is worthless than you didn't learn much. That theory is still applicable today. Just because the shiny bits on the outside look all new and fancy does not change the underlying theory one bit.
- mcguire 12y agoI don't know about the existence of a degree in 1927, but graduating in that year would put you among the designers just before and during WW-II---i.e. the fastest period of aircraft development. So, yeah.
- dceddia 12y agoThe theory sure is applicable, but employers don't pay for theory. If you got a CS degree in 1990 and stopped learning the day you graduated, you'd surely have a hard to finding a job in 2014. The CS field moves at an especially breakneck pace, though. The half-life of the knowledge learned in school is very short. There are probably some other degrees out there where the knowledge stays relevant a bit longer. But I think it really comes down to the fact that you need at least some degree of continual learning to stay employable after graduation.
- thornygreb 12y agoYou are confusing computer science with software engineering/programming. They are not the same. The CS field does not move at breakneck pace. The core classes taught in CS are the same now as they were then.
- tonyedgecombe 12y agoThe author is a full time writer so it's quite possible he no longer uses the knowledge from his studies.
- mcguire 12y agoThat's funny, I also have a CS degree from 1990 and I use it every day. Further, I've found it puts me rather significantly ahead of many of my programming coworkers. But I'm not a novelist. On the other hand, I suspect that I'm in the "eye-wateringly rich" category (as is everyone reading this on HN).
- pdkl95 12y ago> ...most of their activity will be devoted to the perpetuation of the organization, not to the pursuit of its ostensible objective. aka, the tyranny of the bureaucratic overhead equation Δw = p ln (st / sg) w := "useful work towards the objective" g := "the group of people doing w" p := "effective productivity of g" sg := "total size of the g" st := "total size of the organization (sg + bureaucracy)"