12 ms·
Privacy is at a crossroads. Choose wisely
- justcommenting 12y agoI've also noticed the quality of DuckDuckGo search results has been steadily improving, especially over the past year. I would encourage anyone who tried it and went back to another search engine to consider giving DuckDuckGo another shot--you may be pleasantly surprised!
- bsbechtel 12y agoAgreed. By using them more often, you're only going to help them improve.
- antr 12y agoI just read Gabriel's post, and I pretty much agree (and do) with what he says. Due to these shared believes I've been using DDG quite a bit, I even deleted the Google search app from my phone, and instead been using DDG's iOS app as my default mobile search engine. However, every time I use DDG it hurts a bit. The quality of the results are very far behind from that of Google's. I many times end up doing a Google search in incognito mode because DDG just doesn't cut it. I hope DDG improves, because I haven't seen that improvement during the past year.
- yegg 12y agoSpecific examples you're willing to share really help us improve. Feel free to send them to us at inbound at duckduckgo.
- schoen 12y agoI found DDG commonly does worse than Google on long natural-language questions, especially ones that are mainly made up of common words, and also seems to have more trouble than Google with automatically splitting queries into relevant noun phrases (like if a query included "vegetarian restaurant new york", I expect Google more reliably to decompose that into (vegetarian restaurant) (new york) than DDG). But I'll keep an eye out and actually write down particular queries where I see these phenomena, and send them along.
- jaryd 12y agoWe've actually been working on improving relevancy for queries like your example ("vegetarian restaurant new york") -- check it out! https://duckduckgo.com/?q=vegetarian+restaurant+new+york https://duckduckgo.com/?q=vegetarian+restaurant+new+york
- schoen 12y agoHuh, it sure got that one right! Way to go. I'll keep an eye out for cases where this does or doesn't work in the future.
- logn 12y agoOr something like "movie with andre the giant". Google gets Princess Bride as result #2. DDG doesn't have a direct link to that in the first batch. I think Google handles ambiguity better (what users are searching for when they don't know how to express it). Of course, Google tends to overdo this too such that simple keyword searches ain't what they used to be.
- schoen 12y agoGoogle also apparently entirely eliminated the verbatim search mode (some time after making double quotes no longer perform a verbatim search). People now complain that there is no documented way to perform verbatim searches with Google.
- shabbyrobe 12y agoAt least from Australia, you can still perform a verbatim search by clicking "search tools", "all results", then changing the option to "verbatim". I still sometimes forget I can do this and wonder why Google is ignoring several of my qualifying terms. The deprecation of the plus symbol and double quotes for coercion is the single biggest piece of vandalism I've seen Google commit on their interface in over fifteen largely restrained years.
- 12y ago
- rom16384 12y agoI find the auto-correct to be over-zealous. If DDG decides that what I've entered is a typo, It will only show me results for the "corrected" word, so I'll have to quote uncommonly searched words. This usually happens when the search is similar to another one that is much more common.
- saraid216 12y agoThat isn't really different from Google, though, is it?
- TaylorAlexander 12y agoSo... two poorly designed sites?
- burkaman 12y agoIt is, because sometimes DDG is so sure you made a typo, they don't bother to mention it and just search the correction. Try searching "president ovama". The first one or two pages of results are almost exactly the same as the results for "president obama", with no mention of the correction. I know this is sort of a contrived example, but you get the point. As far as I can tell, Google will always tell you when it thinks you made a mistake, and provide a link to search for your exact query.
- sroerick 12y agoI agree with this criticism. Making auto-correct optional would help usability a lot.
- yellowapple 12y agoAs a workaround, you can prefix the word in question with a +, and DDG will recognize that you really did mean to search for that specific word.
- mike-cardwell 12y agoMy biggest pain point with DuckDuckGo, is locality. I search for "hdmi cable" on DuckDuckGo and it gives me links to products that are sold in BestBuy and Walmart... They don't exist here in the UK. It also gives me links to Amazon.COM and Ebay.COM... I do the same search on Google and it gives me links to Currys, Tesco, Argos and Maplin (all UK shops/sites). And it links me to Amazon.CO.UK and Ebay.CO.UK. I don't use DuckDuckGo for searching for products which I want to buy, because this is always what happens. I suspect DuckDuckGo is a much better search experience for people inside the US than outside. EDIT: Ooh. I've just noticed that if I set my region to "UK" in DuckDuckGo the results suddenly become far more relevant. Why isn't this set by default? Not only am I coming from a UK IP address, but my browser is sending "Accept-Language: en-gb"
- tempestn 12y agoI expect if they did use these signals to automatically set geography, some of their user base would assume that their location is being "tracked".
- valente 12y agoHuge fan of DDG, but overseas speed is a problem for me. I find DDG amazing in the States, but when I'm in Australia the extra tiny bit of latency can be frustrating (in the most First World Problem kind of way, of course).
- dredmorbius 12y agoI'll frequently run the searches from within DDG as !g or !scholar searches (my most frequent variants). Lack of date-bounded search is a frequent reason to resort to Google. Special collections (Scholar, Books, News) others. I'm actually relying far more on DDG image search than even a few months ago -- the results are getting good. Also the instant answers, which are getting good. There have been a few times in recent past where DDG searches have turned up empty (or unsatisfactory results) while Google's nailed it. Actually went hunting for an example and got lost which is why this comment is so late. Couldn't find the example though I'll try to remember to submit it when I do.
- hackuser 12y ago> many times end up doing a Google search in incognito mode because DDG just doesn't cut it The sample is only searches where DDG fails; inevitably, every other search engine will provide better results. (That doesn't mean DDG is better or worse than Google; it only means that this methodology doesn't provide infromation on that topic.)
- cbr 12y agoThe sample is only searches where DDG fails; inevitably, every other search engine will provide better results. That's not guaranteed. You could try the search on Google in an incognito tab and decide you think the results are actually worse. (But yes, it is a skewed sample.)
- waffl 12y agoI'm just curious if when you say incognito mode that you are using Chrome? I am assuming that changing the default search engine from Google avoids sending partially typed searches to Google, and the privacy policy seems to state that limited personally identifying data is still transmitted but I'm still somehow a bit wary of chrome. Is it fairly substantiated that other than having a different search engine and not signing in, that chrome behaves in a trustworthy fashion? There is still the odd translation suggestion and double click definition that I suppose would also have to be turned off. (From their privacy policy they claim no identifying data is sent along with these requests but the IP alone is an obvious identifier)
- sroerick 12y agoI find the "!g" to perform an anonymous Google search works great, and has very little added effort.
- shit_parade 12y agoI also recommend people try startpage.com
- Sami_Lehtinen 12y ago+1, Starpage uses Google's search index and DDG uses Bing's. Yet it seems that Google is delivering clearly weakened search results for them?
- smhenderson 12y agoWhile also not as good as google from a result standpoint I have been using ixquick.com for several years now and have seen a steady improvement in it's results as well. They claim to be "the world's most private search engine: https://ixquick.com/eng/protect-privacy.html https://ixquick.com/eng/protect-privacy.html?
- Aoyagi 12y agoActually, I've noticed that DGG is way overdoing guessing. More often than not I get results that are only similar to the search query in some way instead of actually what I'm looking for. This has been getting worse over time for me.
- username223 12y agoBoth DDG and Google hatefully over-guess. I understand their motivation -- people typing natural-language queries with smartphone-level typos and expecting to get answers -- but as someone long used to simple keyword queries, I wish I could have the old system back. Programmers trying to make computers "smart" seem not to understand that unless they're almost flawless, users will just have more trouble trying to work around the "smartness" to tell the computers what they actually want.
- amelius 12y agoOf course, because DDG can't build a profile of you, it would have to resort to some guessing. For example, if you search for "python", it would have to guess whether you are a programmer, or a biologist, in order to present the most relevant results. And of course, Google already has all this information...
- Aoyagi 12y ago...not that kind of guessing. Obviously. That's not "similar to the search query", that's just different meanings of words/phrases. I didn't say anything about that, but it looks like you didn't read past the first sentence anyway. Example of what I meant: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=BMW+723i https://duckduckgo.com/?q=BMW+723i
- nl 12y agohttps://duckduckgo.com/?q=%22BMW+723i%22 https://duckduckgo.com/?q=%22BMW+723i%22 Seriously, quoting that is a reasonable solution. Given the comparative popularity of the two, it seems statistically likely that most people actually wanted a 323i. Having said that, I note that Google doesn't show 323i results for 723i, so... hm. I do think explaining the substitution that was done and linking to the exact search (ie, how Google does it) would be a good feature though.
- fpgaminer 12y agoI've had this question for awhile ... What is the advantage to using DuckDuckGo, with respect to privacy? All I've found is that they say privacy is important and that they don't track users. But I see no way for them to prove that. So you still have to trust them not to spy on you. Perhaps on the whole that is better than alternatives. "Google is definitely spying on me" versus "DuckDuckGo might be spying on me". Is that the only difference, or am I missing something? If that's the only difference, isn't Google-over-Tor a better option? Known privacy with world-class search results?
- duaneb 12y agoWell, it's very unusual in this day for a company to proactively protect your privacy. Whether they actually do is unknowable without encryption.
- warfangle 12y agoJust did a surface audit. They set and read no cookies. You can test this yourself. They set etags on static assets, and those theoretically could be used to track you as an identifiable visitor. How else would they track you? By IP address? That would make any kind of tracking useless -- how would you deal with trying to track 100,000 connections from behind NAT, individually, other than cookies or etags? There's browser fingerprinting, but I don't see any evidence of that either.
- stavrianos 12y agoWhat evidence of browser fingerprinting would you expect to see?
- droopyEyelids 12y agoa bulky or obfuscated javascript file probing the standard fingerprinting areas of your browser
- warfangle 12y ago
- sparaker 12y agoI hope i don't see very irrelevant results again cause i might not return again if it fails again.
- Too 12y agoI've been using it for a while too now and my verdict is that i can't remove google from the second row in my search bar but i find the results of ddg to be good enough to use as my first choice. 80% searches work flawlessly on ddg, and for the remaining part you learn which kind of searches that will work and which ones doesn't. Many times i know in advance that this particular query will probably not work here but on google it will and i'll just append !g to the search to go straight to google. What i find mostly interesting is that I have re-learned to use multiple different search engines, you know like we all did back before in the days, and that it actually helps me find more relevant information. Not only because the quality of Google has dropped significantly the past 5 years but even when google delivers a pretty solid result i check DDG after and i might find an even more relevant result, or an opposing story in a political topic etc. We all learn to check your information sources, this includes your search engine!
- tripzilch 12y agoI just put DDG as my default address bar search, and taught myself a bunch of !bang commands, since for much of the stuff I'm looking for I already know what site I want to end up any way (!w, !wnl, !yt, !gi, !wayback, etc). In the mean time for general searches, I either use DDG's results or slap on a pre-emptive !g on a hunch, randomly or just-in-case. My idea behind this is that, as DDG's results become better, I'll habitually start using !g less and less. And indeed, DDG's results have become better, and indeed I have been using the !g command less and less. Google Search with !g is slowly becoming "just another one among the predefined !bang commands", a command I will append after my searches when I specifically desire to find out what Google has to say about a certain query. Though in comparison I hardly ever use !y and !b (Yahoo and Bing, respectively), mostly because I have no clue in what vague sense those results would be better (with DDG vs Google, I sort of have a feeling when asking for something really mundane and stupid, Google always hits the spot exactly, DDG sometimes misinterprets--though less so lately). For image searching I really use !yi, !bi and !gi pretty much randomly. They all give quite different results, but as far as I've been able to determine, none of them are of particularly better quality than the others. Yahoo Image Search has a nice integration with Flickr though, so I tend to use it more when my target may be found between high-ish resolution photography. I already named !wayback, anyone got any other cool !bang commands they use often? For instance, any good documentation searches for JS/DOM/HTML/CSS etc? I tried !mdn but I don't like their search result pages. Same for !python, if I do "!python itertools", I want to be taken straight to the itertools module documentation, not a results page of all python docs that contains the term "itertools".
- runn1ng 12y agoJust look at Europe's cookie law and law about removal of "personal information" from Google search, how well regulations work.
- goodmornings 12y agoI don't want to sound too pessimistic and I agree with the sentiment of the article, but I think people need to come to terms with that there isn't really a choice to be made here. Just like you suddenly isn't going to change the at least decade old path of the NSA, you aren't suddenly going to change the fundamentals of the Internet. The choices that affects us now has to a large extent already been made and we are living with the consequences.
- shit_parade 12y agoI'm also surprised that people are not more skeptical of anything coming out of the white house with Obama's name on it. Obama has proven himself to be a warmonger with loose ethics unwilling to prosecute torture and also fully interested in continuing the surveillance state, killing Americans without due process, prosecuting whistle-blowers, and protecting the status quo above the constitution and civil rights.
- mgreg 12y agoI'm curious if data privacy & protection will ever emerge from its little corner where a few passionate folks worry about it while the masses blithely ignore how their personal data is used and abused. Couple of other related items just from today indicate this _may_ be taking on steam but we've seen this kind of blip before just to see it fade. 1. Helping Prove Mr. Weinberg's going (CEO of DuckDuckGo) is an article on how heath web sites share your search queries with 3rd parties found at http://motherboard.vice.com/read/looking-up-symptoms-online-these-companies-are-collecting-your-data http://motherboard.vice.com/read/looking-up-symptoms-online-... Nice to know that WebMD et al are sharing your _assumed_ private searched for whatever itch you might have with others. 2. Symantec published results of their European survey on the topic of Data Privacy found at http://www.symantec.com/content/en/us/about/presskits/b-state-of-privacy-report-2015.pdf http://www.symantec.com/content/en/us/about/presskits/b-stat... Not sure I believe a survey where the respondents claim to read the terms of service 25% of the time.... My guess would have been .25% of the time.
- chestnut-tree 12y ago"...health web sites share your search queries with 3rd parties..." For anyone looking for health information (in English), I recommend the NHS website. (Start your search from there rather than Google if you're worried about being tracked). It may not be the best-looking website, but the info is written by medical professionals and there are no commercial interests since the NHS is funded by the UK taxpayer. They have an A-Z of conditions, a symptom checker, videos and much more. (I presume this is all available to anyone outside the UK) http://www.nhs.uk http://www.nhs.uk
- unprepare 12y agoUnfortunately This falls into the same trap as the US CDC site in the parents linked article. The NHS site you linked makes requests to google analytics, webtrends and cloudfront. The point in the parents article applies here equally, since what i'm searching will still be analyzed by Google at the very least. I'm not sure how identifiable this information is though, but definitely important to be aware of
- fixermark 12y agoPeople are willing to trade personally-identifiable information for a Snickers bar.* Until and unless that changes, privacy doesn't have sufficient value to change the status quo very much. *Really, they'll even trade it for intangible gold. http://candycrushgametactics.com/get-free-gold-bars-in-candy-crush-saga-surveys/ http://candycrushgametactics.com/get-free-gold-bars-in-candy...
- ashark 12y agoIt won't change. There's no way the average person is going to spend the kind of time and effort it would take to fight the pervasive privacy violations we're seeing now. Even if they all say they want better privacy, there's only so much stuff a person can keep up with / so many hours in a day. The market doesn't cater to what we want, it caters to what we have time to understand and the willpower to act on and, outside that very slim set of things, what is most profitable (e.g. selling our data). Coordination problems. Coordination problems as far as the eye can see.
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoTrading for a snickers bar is the default. How can I stop the default and who gets to decide what my punishment is if I do? Let's say google offers some kind of privacy plan, which is 100% outside of their interests. Do you think they'll give me honest pricing if I opted out of all their tracking? Lets say they actually make $15 off me annually via tracking. What would they charge me to not be spied on? It sure as hell won't be $15. The problem is we're not being offered a fair value in the beginning when we get into a relationship with these companies. Cloud providers are throwing snickers bars at me and not offering to stop. When I do say I don't want them, I'm hit with punitive pricing. Look at AT&T's gigapower charge to not be spied on. Its like $40 a month. Sorry, but I doubt anyone is making $40 a month from someone like me who almost never clicks on ads and whose information can't be that valuable. If advertisers are paying AT&T $40 a month to see how long I'm on reddit, then the whole system is well... fucked. It seems to me that cloud providers and ISPs want their cake and to eat it to. They're double-dipping. I'm still paying somehow, even if its indirectly. I bought $100 worth of apps and movie rentals last quarter via my android device. They sure as hell weren't free. Not only am I subject to market pricing on these items, not to mention my hefty phone bill, I also am being spied on? Where exactly is the 'free' where the products monetize themselves via app store purchases and rentals? VUDU and On Demand charge the exact same amount for these rentals. This narrative that customers won't pay for things is asinine. We're constantly paying for things.
- j2kun 12y agoThere is a possibility to share statistical analysis of data privately. This is the subfield of computer science known as differential privacy, and I bet companies just looking for trend data (not specific targeting) would be able to benefit from user data without compromising user privacy. In other words, there are good and bad ways to use user data, some of the good ones are provably private, and we shouldn't rule out all data sharing as inherently evil.
- rqebmm 12y ago>we shouldn't rule out all data sharing as inherently evil. I agree. However, that's going to be the knee-jerk reaction for a while precisely because huge entities like Google, NSA, AT&T, Verizon, etc have been doing that data sharing while doing an abysmal job of notifying users about what was happening. Eventually I think we'll settle into a happy medium, but we're in the pushback phase at the moment.
- cheatsheet 12y ago> provably private citation?
- j2kun 12y agohttp://research.microsoft.com/pubs/74339/dwork_tamc.pdf http://research.microsoft.com/pubs/74339/dwork_tamc.pdf They define the mathematical guarantees on privacy, which are computational guarantees against a polynomial-time adversary trying to distinguish between the analyses of two databases that differ in a single record. I.e., nobody can reasonably tell whether your information is included in the analysis.
- cheatsheet 12y agoI am not particularly looking for a debate today; but this seems to be a disagreement of terms when using the word "provable". Just because a polynomial time algorithm can not be constructed to distinguish a single record does not mean private information can not be derived. I still would prefer a choice in the matter - a required small check box that says "record my data" or "do not record my data" XOR "erase my data". The term 'reasonably' has a very different meaning to me (assuming many unknowns in the future) over the long term. It is either that, or people should literally stop making such a hard line distinguishing person A from person B. If the data is going to be used to make an inference from the collective to the individual, and it doesn't matter whether my data is included or not, well, shrug and thumbs up. It really depends on the context of the application. Does it determine whether my imaginary future children get to go to college or not? The problem with data and private organizations is that we do not know what the data analysis is being used for, and as private citizens we do not have any control over how that data is mathematically reasoned about and qualitatively assessed aside from forging the data itself it (garbage in, garbage out).
- dmschulman 12y agoThe myth of "partially anonymize" data is infuriating. As an academic exercise I've begun to pore over Privacy Policies for web new services I find, specifically how my account info will be used with third parties. No new consumer oriented web product in their right mind would advertise "we monetize your data with third parties", but they all include language in their Privacy Policies about sharing "partially anonymize" data. It might make you feel safe and sound when it comes to Company X protecting your identity, but marketers and other organizations don't look at data points in a vacuum, everything is in aggregate, and your aggregate profile represents you to the highest degree of certainty.
- dasboth 12y ago"As an academic exercise I've begun to pour over Privacy Policies for web new services" This is something I've been thinking of doing. I don't suppose you've shared these anywhere online by any chance? I always thought that would make a good site - somewhere where you can look up certain services' privacy policies in layman's terms. I suspect a good one already exists.
- drdaeman 12y agohttps://tosdr.org/ https://tosdr.org/
- tnhh 12y agohttp://www.docracy.com/tos/changes http://www.docracy.com/tos/changes is also good for tracking changes. And today I saw a talk about http://commonterms.org/ http://commonterms.org/ which could be useful if widely implemented.
- dasboth 12y agoCommon Terms looks like an interesting idea, I'd like to think I actually would read a summary of terms like what they're suggesting
- 12y ago
- angersock 12y agoThe annoying thing is that, even if we prevent them from harvesting data on us, there's nothing to prevent them from convincing our friends/parents/coworkers from sharing that information on our behalves.
- drdaeman 12y agoExcept for the lack of data. Don't share things you consider private (and that are indeed private and not just things you don't want to expose but can't really do so, like your own face) with those who you don't trust. This is the most secure approach among all possibilities.
- angersock 12y agoSo, consider "Hey, tomorrow is angersock's 34th birthday! We're organizing a surprise party in his hometown of jonestown!". Now, they've given away my age, birthdate, and where I was born. That's the sort of information that, while private and something I don't give away, they know and give away without thinking.
- diminoten 12y agoWho is it you don't want to have that information? The government already knows (it's part of your SSN information), and any private company that cares will just make you give that info to them as part of the cost of service. You'll do it too, because you don't want to be unable to drive or have a mortgage.
- angersock 12y agoI know about those entities, though--and I know that, in the case of private companies, they're probably going to share it (and we can make laws to that effect). My original point is that those protections won't apply when just crawling through friends and acquaintances mentioning things. EDIT: For another example, consider "Thank God, my friend angersock had a car accident today but only scratched the bumper". That's something I don't want as public knowledge, and that my insurance provider could (theoretically) use to raise my rates.
- AdmiralAsshat 12y agoAnd there are indeed a few solutions that actually grant you partial relief from the pains of online tracking. First, switch your search engine, email and other major services where your personal information is heavily tracked to good private alternatives. Second, add EFF’s HTTPS Everywhere plugin to your browser, which will encrypt web site connections where possible. Third, add EFF’s Privacy Badger plugin to your browser, which blocks third-party trackers. These three simple changes will pretty seamlessly and significantly reduce your digital footprint. Since this is a quote from the article, I feel this is an appropriate space to ask: does anyone have a page explaining how these various privacy extensions interact/overlap with each other? I tend to install (or at least try out) pretty much every popular one at some point or another, and I'm hoping to reduce redundancies. Alot of these tools show up on recommended "Get These If You're Serious About Privacy" lists without indicating what exactly each extension does or how it might interact with another extension. These include: - Adblock Plus - Ghostery - Disconnect - HTTPS Everywhere - EFF Privacy Badger - uBlock - NoScript At this point, I've "slimmed" down to just HTTPS Everywhere and uBlock, although I'm debating adding Privacy Badger. However, their own page mentions that it's "based on ABP code" [0], so my thought is that uBlock is probably also taking care of it. Is that sufficient? Is there any danger in installing Privacy Badger and uBlock, for instance, if they serve the same function? Will they step on each other's toes? Some kind of comparison chart would be useful. [0] - https://www.eff.org/privacybadger#how_is_it_different https://www.eff.org/privacybadger#how_is_it_different
- joosters 12y agoThere is a chance that some extensions will interfere with each other. For instance, Ghostery mentions this on their options page: Warning! When combined with other cookie monitoring addons such as Beef Taco, Cookie Monster, and Google Opt-Out, this feature can cause unresponsive script errors. If you experience this error, please try disabling this feature or conflicting addons.
- schoen 12y agoThat kind of problem used to happen with DOS TSRs (the equivalent of multitasking extensions or daemon processes). It's funny to think that the reason for browser extension incompatibilities is kind of analogous to the reason for TSR incompatibilities: both of them will hook function calls in the system whose functionality they're extending, and make assumptions about how they can alter, act on, or cancel the function call without breaking things, and whether or how it needs to be passed along afterwards. If only one extension is loaded, these assumptions aren't stressed very much, but when several are loaded the assumptions can conflict. (That analogy isn't perfect because the TSRs also had an issue about patching the interrupt descriptor table, which is where the system looks up the location of an interrupt handler; one common problem was that if TSRs weren't unloaded in the same order in which they were loaded, the table could be "restored" with values that were not actually current, which I don't think is a problem that has an equivalent for browser extensions!)
- lnanek2 12y agoHonestly, I kind of prefer the new AT&T solution where they charge you ~$30 more to do nothing with your data. If paranoid people want this, then by all means, let them pay for it.
- TruthWillFree 12y agoYou trust them? How do you know this just makes you more suspicious and gives them more of an illogical basis for placing you under increased surveillance.
- fixermark 12y agoSure I trust them. The moment it's discovered that they've failed to hold up their end of the bargain, they're out $30 x some significant percentage of the users of that service per month. That's not chump change (to say nothing of the potential class action lawsuit for utterly failing to hold up a contract while continuing to charge customers for the services stipulated in said contract).
- TruthWillFree 12y agoWe assume that we are entitled to some sort of protection because we've paid for a service, but that didn't stop these companies from unlawfully participating or turning a blind eye to unwarranted and unrestrained violations of privacy. If you believe some court centered process will protect you from abuse you are sadly mistaken. Of course it is no issue until the fascists come after you....
- Retra 12y agoYou are assuming there is a meaningful contract to uphold. So I ask you this: what exactly do you think you are buying from them?
- hackuser 12y ago* Should privacy only be available to people who can afford $360/yr? * What good is confidentiality on AT&T, when everyone else still is tracking you (websites, cellular provider, electric utility, car manufacturer, CCTV operators, etc.). * Should privacy require you to pay every one of those businesses $360/year? Also, AT&T easily could buy the the information they are forgoing from a third party, and for much less than $360/year/customer.
- TruthWillFree 12y agoThe fight for privacy has to start at universities. At Georgia Tech, the faculty are routinely involved in unwarranted surveillance and testing out their fundamentally flawed ideas to sell off to the national security apparatus. Such tests I would classify as being human experimentation with a critical need for more transparency with the public. Without a broad education that contains humanities, arts, and ethics we won't get the technical solutions we need that address core societal issues. Instead we have an cancerous culture in engineering that threatens our position among other first world countries. Not all engineers have the same commitment to ethics and unfortunately the most unethical don't have the proper economic incentives for respecting human rights, liberty, and dignity. It's time to take a stand for privacy, against the exploitation of technology, and against unethical human experimentation. Georgia Tech's campus is a good place to start...
- linkregister 12y agoWhat kind of surveillance is going on there? What kind of experiments are happening there?
- TruthWillFree 12y agoThey psychologically torture and harass people to produce false confessions or force people to do things against their will. Think what happened to Aaron Swartz, but on crack... Chicago, I'm sure is no different... http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/feb/24/chicago-police-detain-americans-black-site http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/feb/24/chicago-polic...
- jff 12y agoSo you couldn't provide any real source, instead linking to something about the Chicago police. What's the Georgia Tech connection?
- TruthWillFree 12y agoEndgame Systems
- anon012012 12y agoSometimes I think privacy is bound to die because of nuclear bombs. What stops a country sneaking bombs into another? We need total knowledge of what's in the city. But maybe I'm wrong, I haven't thought it through.
- recondite 12y agoI really want to recommend (upvote) his post, but Medium requires me to sign in with Twitter or Facebook to do so. Great.
- owly 12y agoFunny how that works. :(
- happyscrappy 12y agoChoose what? To live like Stallman? Even his data leaks all over the place. Absolute privacy, like all absolutes, is a sandcastle in the path of an incoming tide. I am all for encrypted comm but metadata is almost as bad and virtually unavoidable. Why was no one creeped out that Starfleet always knows where every crew member is at all times?
- whyever 12y agoI thought they don't if people do not carry their communicator. So basically the same as today?
- code_duck 12y agoStarfleet personal are in some sort of military organization and are constantly exposed to some sort of danger. Not to mention, on a space ship managed by some kind of artificial intelligence. It makes sense the Federation would keep tabs on them.
- TheMagicHorsey 12y agoI'm curious how DuckDuckGo makes money. They don't charge us for search results, and they don't use our information to target ads. How do they make money to run their operations?
- dmschulman 12y agoDonations (https://flattr.com/thing/38589/DuckDuckGo https://flattr.com/thing/38589/DuckDuckGo) Referral programs (Amazon) and VC funding AFAIK
- rocky1138 12y agoI've seen ads on their site related to keywords in my search query.
- bonn1 12y agoClever Marketing gig from DDG's CEO Weinberg (as recommended in his book 'Traction'). The post makes sense, DDG makes sense, good timing, ok no news to most of us but a good way to get people again talking about DDG. Considering that DDG is 'just' a Yandex whitelabel (before Bing) with some extra features, especially the no tracking, it's surprising how big it got with Weinberg's Marketing hacks. Congrats!
- mikerichards 12y agoObama's natural inclination is to never to "regulate" the power of government, but to regulate industry. Government's intrusion of our privacy is the much bigger problem, but Obama just says "look over there at those big internet companies, forget about the NSA, CIA, IRS and other numerous government agencies and unaccountable bureaucrats that want to snoop into and control your private lives. Forget that the government has the guns that can force you. I'll throw the boogey-strawman of "big internet" to appease you"
- Retra 12y agoObama is not a member of congress. He doesn't write laws or regulations.
- mikerichards 12y agoThe first sentence of the post. Any day now President Obama is going to propose a new privacy bill of rights that will give you much more control over your personal information. http://www.politico.com/story/2015/01/online-privacy-bill-white-house-114696.html http://www.politico.com/story/2015/01/online-privacy-bill-wh...
- mirimir 12y agoI believe that prudent compartmentalization is the best way to control tracking and reclaim privacy. Each compartment comprises interests, relationships and activities that you want observers to track and interrelate. For compartments where privacy is essential, it's best to use pseudonyms, and to avoid cross-linking with public compartments. Compartments are isolated in VMs, with separate network connectivity using nested chains of VPNs, JonDonym and Tor. Particularly sensitive compartments are isolated in separate computers. It's prudent to avoid cross-compartment sharing of USB drives.
- tacoman 12y agoThis is incredibly hard to do well and takes a great deal of discipline. Unless you're a Belgacom or Gemalto sysadmin, the consequences of cross-contamination aren't grave. It's easy enough to burn an identity and create a new one.
- stcredzero 12y agoEach compartment comprises interests, relationships and activities that you want observers to track and interrelate. Excellent! There are a lot of historical precedents for technology enabling intermediation! Such intermediation comes with power, which does need to be tempered with some regulation. (The minimum possible, due to regulatory capture, of course.)
- stcredzero 12y agoPretty much all technologies have facets where markets break down and require some form of corrective regulation to make things work the way we want them to. No! Nooooooo! Say it isn't so! The market is a magical infallible oracle of laissez-faire goodness! (That snidely said, the market is absolutely a marvellous thing in precisely the contexts where situations are so complex that centralized control is hopeless and only massively distributed decision making can hope to keep up. Again, context is everything.)
- murbard2 12y agoIn which category do you think the question of how privacy should be managed between websites and their customers, across all kind of business models, all types of customers, and all sorts of data fit? A complex situation that needs context aware distributed decision, or a problem simple enough that regulation can unambiguously help?
- stcredzero 12y agoOf course, there are actually a great number of questions, not just one. One of the biggest problems is that there is not enough knowledge in general society yet for markets to work well enough wrt privacy. One thing that lawmakers should be keenly aware of, is that broadly written regulations can be helpful at first, but then become burdensome in a mature market or in the face of technological change.
- Nanzikambe 12y agoFascinating, wake me up when this ethereal bill appears and offers protections for the privacy of all humans regardless of nationality, and not just some humans.
- owly 12y agoThank you. DDG should be the default in Firefox and iOS.
- jwatte 12y agoPrivacy is not achievable. It's much better to build a world where we can all live happy /without/ privacy. This requires an attitude adjustment and significant tolerance because everything is public. Want to know if your bank treats customers good or bad? Look it up. Want to know if the issuer bets against a mortgage backed security? Audit the numbers. Want to cheat on your taxes? Tough luck! The thing is, we only have two options: 1. Only spooks and marketers and those who pay, know. 2. We all know.
- 0x5f3759df-i 12y agoYou are presenting a false dichotomy and your conclusion that "privacy is not achievable" is a claim without any justification. http://mind.ucsd.edu/syllabi/98-99/logic/falsedichotomy.html http://mind.ucsd.edu/syllabi/98-99/logic/falsedichotomy.html
- jqm 12y agoI don't think we are at a privacy crossroad. I think the fork was taken some time ago and now it's just a matter of how fast and reckless we go, and just who is going to be doing the driving.