3 ms·
DNA studies topple the ladder of complexity
- fchollet 12y agoThere seems to be some confusion between complexity, quantity of DNA, and intelligence as a measure of organism complexity. A larger quantity of DNA does not translate into a more "complex" organism, as amoebas prove. In fact, I would think it likely that organisms with a very large codebase have to be very simple ones, since the simpler an organism is the "safer" it is to add useless DNA code to it without breaking anything essential. And consider intelligence: it is generally thought that the human brain is largely self-similar (the same structures can be observed throughout the cortex, repeated in layers and columns) and therefore very simple from an information-theoretic point of view. You could express what it does using very little information, or code. The closest we have to an artificial visual cortex, deep convolutional neural networks (shown to have a representational power equivalent to the primate visual cortex [1]), can be implemented in just a couple hundred lines of CUDA code. Just because a system is hard to understand does not mean it has to be complicated, or that it requires a lot of code (DNA or otherwise) to implement. [1] http://arxiv.org/abs/1406.3284 http://arxiv.org/abs/1406.3284
- jostmey 12y agoWhen I first looked at the genetic code, my first question was where is the code? The letter sequences and arrangement of genes looked random. Gradually I started to realize that the genetic code is random, and that the design of an organism is irrational. After having this personal realization, biology finally started to make sense.
- henrikschroder 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protein_biosynthesis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protein_biosynthesis The order of amino acids that make up specific proteins are neither random nor irrational, and that's just one example of things that our DNA explicitly encodes.
- fasteo 12y agoAnd then, you need to add another dimension: 5% to 8% of our DNA in from viruses that once infected us [1] [1] http://phenomena.nationalgeographic.com/2015/02/01/our-inner-viruses-forty-million-years-in-the-making/ http://phenomena.nationalgeographic.com/2015/02/01/our-inner...
- otakucode 12y agoAnd do you qualify those viruses as alive? Why do we have more claim to the tangle of DNA in our cells than they do? Why do we not simply qualify as vehicles evolved by the virus to accomplish its travel through the centuries of reproduction? Obviously, we very well might. Perspective is, at best, meaningless, and, more often, misleading. The view that the evolution of oxygen-bearing organisms was a boon which unfurled the history of organisms which resulted in us is exactly equivalent to the view that the evolution of oxygen-bearing organisms caused the most calamitous tragedy in the history of the planet, wiping out nearly a whole planet of life and dooming the future to a lack of complex anaerobic organisms. Objectivity and a dispassionate approach to knowledge isn't just a personality affect of scientists. It's a vital tool.
- henrikschroder 12y ago> Furthermore, the idea that complex parts like a brain and nervous system—including nerve cells, synapses, and neurotransmitter molecules—could evolve separately multiple times perplexes evolutionary biologists This makes absolutely no sense. Why would this be perplexing? If evolutionary pressure causes a feature to evolve once in one part of the tree of life, why couldn't it happen multiple times independently? It would be a lot more surprising if it didn't!
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago>If evolutionary pressure causes a feature to evolve once in one part of the tree of life, why couldn't it happen multiple times independently? // Isn't it rather that the features work in the same way. Bats and dolphins [1] using echolocation that - I've heard - works the same way but the pressures on them are different, the environments different. Given the random occurrence of mutations it seems striking (to me) that these similar paths should be followed. A corollary would appear to be also that if parallel evolution can converge on identical structures that reliance on morphological features to indicate common ancestry is flawed. If evolution tends to converge then a geological sample with a simple form of fossil can't be assumed to be contemporaneous with another sample, the fossils could be the result of parallel evolution. I've never understood why mainstream paleo-biology seems to reject that life could have started in more than one place. Convergent evolution suggests that the same types of complex structures can develop independently too. Perhaps Star Trek's universe of four-limbed, bipedal, binocular aliens isn't so far-fetched after all!?! --- [1] http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v502/n7470/full/nature12511.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v502/n7470/full/nature1...
- andrewflnr 12y agoWe could expect some sort of electro-chemical processing network to evolve multiple times. It's crazy to suggest they would all have the same structures and use the same neurotransmitters, to have all the details be the same. I'm not really familiar with the nervous systems of comb jellies, but I'm guessing the latter case is what they're looking at.
- crimsonalucard 12y agoJust because you have a simple UI doesn't mean the code underneath isn't complex. Technically, you can have source code that's mind boggling bloated and complex for something as simple as doing addition. In the end, the selection mechanism that evolution uses for natural selection is just survivability. Bloated, ugly code doesn't affect survivability if it all ends up working correctly.
- snowwrestler 12y agoThe assumption behind this story doesn't make sense to me. If you look at amoeba today and a human today, they are at the same "depth" on the evolutionary tree, just on different branches. Mammals have been evolving for tens of millions of years...but amoebas have also been evolving during that time. If we could go back a couple hundred million years and compare an amoeba from then, to a human from now, I think we would see that the older organism is less complex. But we can't do that, and I don't see how looking at a modern amoeba is any kind of reliable proxy for that.