9 ms·
My life in London's houseboat slums (2014)
- Doctor_Fegg 12y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7288085 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7288085
- swah 12y agohn could start grouping stories by "hot topics" (i wish hn would provide competition for custom frontpage algorithms)
- tomelders 12y agoI'm giving some light consideration to running for Mayor of London with all my policies focused on one aim: Hyper-Aggressive Rent Control. Quite simply, the current situation for renters and first time buyers in London is unfair and needs to be addressed in a way that restores the balance between those that live and work in London, and those that just own property here. Although it costs £10k to run, because that's the type of democracy we have here in the UK apparently. UPDATE: I've not outlined a single policy - and I'm already being told I'm wrong.
- Numberwang 12y agoKickstart your campaign. You will get my vote.
- tomelders 12y agoI don't think you can kickstart political stuff. But there must be something out there... or I suppose I have the requisite skills to build something. Maybe I will give it a shot. At the very least it force the candidates to address rent control as an issue.
- anu_gupta 12y ago> Maybe I will give it a shot. At the very least it force the candidates to address rent control as an issue. I doubt it will force anyone to do anything, least of all the candidates.
- jeffbr13 12y agoThere are a handful of more generic crowd-funding platforms out there, so no need to build your own. A good candidate website would be more than enough to build. As a bonus, crowd-funding your candidacy would give you early validation. And, as a comment below says, you should be able to convince enough people to scrape together £10k, if you expect to run. Fail fast, and all that. You certainly have my donation, and my vote if I can still afford to live in London by election-time! [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9100275 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9100275
- esja 12y agoAnd mine.
- colechristensen 12y ago>Although it costs £10k to run, because that's the type of democracy we have here in the UK apparently. This is a good thing, despite how it seems on the surface. If it were free you'd probably have 10,000 candidates. If it were £50, you'd probably have 500. Nobody benefits. The city has to spend lots of money and resources handling large volumes of useless candidates and voters do have any idea of who to pay attention to besides one or two huge names and a mass of idiots. If you can't get 1000 people to give you £10, you don't have any business running anyway. A large entry fee does a great job weeding out wonks, crazies, and jokers. Real candidates will spend a lot more than 10k through the process anyway. In the US I voted during the last election to increase the filing fee from $20 to $500 for mayor of Minneapolis. Obviously a much smaller city but the idea is the same.
- Joeboy 12y agoIf anybody's interested, here's a petition against evictions of boat dwellers: https://you.38degrees.org.uk/petitions/boats-are-homes-prevent-the-eviction-of-boat-dwellers https://you.38degrees.org.uk/petitions/boats-are-homes-preve...
- Doctor_Fegg 12y agoI used to live on a boat; I still own one; and I don't support that petition. The Canal & River Trust is an underfunded charity whose aims are to preserve and maintain Britain's historic waterway network. They are not funded to provide affordable housing for people. That is, and should be, the role of local and central Government. When you buy a boat in the UK (on CRT waterways), there are clear rules, in force since 1992, that you must either have a permanent mooring for it or undertake to move on to a different place every 14 days ("continuously cruising"). Numerous people have tried to avoid the expense of a permanent mooring by declaring themselves to be "continuously cruising" but actually staying in the same place. That is what this petition is seeking to legalise. If it were accepted, CRT would lose out two-fold: it would have greater costs in providing facilities and maintaining the waterways as more people bought boats simply to use as cheap houses, and it would have significantly lower income as people learned that they can get away without paying for a permanent mooring. Yet even now, CRT doesn't have enough money to maintain its 2,500 miles of waterways to a safe, reliable standard - just look at the recent breach on the Trent & Mersey Canal as an example. I feel for the people who can't afford to live in London and have alighted on boats as a cheap way to do so. I believe the city would be better as a vibrant, varied community rather than a rich ghetto. But expecting an underfunded heritage charity to fix London's housing problem is unfair and unrealistic. Target Whitehall and City Hall, not CRT.
- fab13n 12y agoI'm on a French canal, and I wish we had a continuous cruising status. It would keep canals alive, force boats to be maintained in working condition, and drive off most people who see liveaboard boats as an alternative to a flat. Unfortunately, I'm sure French civil services would fail to enforce it, and we'd end up with the kind of floating shacks described in the article. Actually, we already have many of them, and they're already powerless to get rid of them.
- jhallenworld 12y agoI know someone who lived on his boat in Boston Harbor because he did not want give up collecting rent from his apartments... basically if you have a boat, this is one way to maximize its value. Even so I think winter living was not fun.
- omegaham 12y agoMy girlfriend grew up on a boat in San Diego. Better weather makes it a viable option.
- colechristensen 12y agoHere's a solution: a city- or nation-wide graduated tax on per-square-foot rent applied to the profit above property tax with a fixed allowance for maintenance. Add in a limited deduction for physical property improvements. Graduate the tax and put it on owners for several effects: * Diminishing or negative returns on increasing rent price * Reduced ROI for top priced real estate lowering demand for investment ownership and price * Increased relative ROI for improving lower quality properties & cheap places to live unaffected
- easytiger 12y ago> As more and more areas of London become unaffordable to anyone but wealthy professionals, Is this a joke? I know some people who live on Barges in London and they are no where near as shit as those in the article.
- jbb555 12y agoArticle summary : "I can't afford to live in london so I'll live somewhere terrible instead of living somewhere I can afford and whine about it on the internet instead"
- vincentkriek 12y agoThe point is that London is driving it's lower income citizen's to accommodations like this. And London needs this citizen's just as hard as the higher paid individuals.
- gadders 12y agoLondon has a pretty decent infrastructure for commuting. Buses/tubes/trains/light railways etc. Perhaps they just don't want to get up an hour earlier?
- littletimmy 12y agoYes people don't want to sacrifice their time to account for the failed policies that led to a housing shortage. What a shocker.
- gadders 12y agoWell, they're trading their time for living in unpleasant accommodation. If their time is more important to them than where they live then fair enough. But they should admit it is a conscious trade-off.
- joshuaheard 12y agoIf only there was a way they could be productive while riding the train into town...
- esja 12y agoYou may have noticed that everywhere commutable became 20% more expensive last year. There is only so far people can move.
- Lazare 12y agoPoint 1: A lot of people want to live in London. More, in point of fact, than there's really room for. Point 2: We, as a society, really dislike the idea of telling people where they can and cannot live. "Your papers, please" is a punchline, not a blueprint. Point 3: Britain, in specific, is very leary about development. Not without reason, but even though it would be absurdly profitable to build a fuckton of cheap, efficient, high rise apartments, it is and will remain illegal. (Which is fine; build the apartments and then you have traffic issues, etc. My point is that you can't do this, not that you should.) Combine these three points, and you'll get high rents and frustrated people. But unless you have a suggestion on how to change one of those points, it's not going to change, is it? (Well, I guess you could say the high cost of housing is changing point 1 by making London less desirable, but clearly, it's not happening quickly.) Seriously though, it feels like the article is missing a conclusion. "Here's a thing that sucks, but let's not think about why it exists or how it might be fixed." (But maybe I'm just being grumpy, I dunno.)
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoThe population of London has been declining for many years, so point #1 is out.
- Lazare 12y agoThat's actually untrue. Going off census data (which is taken every decade, roughly), it increased until 1939, then declined until 1981, then has been increasing since then—slowly at first, but lately more rapidly. If it hasn't hit an all-time high already, it will very soon. ...which makes sense, given that housing prices have been rising. Source: http://www.londonspovertyprofile.org.uk/indicators/1_3.gif http://www.londonspovertyprofile.org.uk/indicators/1_3.gif
- m-i-l 12y agoAccording to many sources (e.g. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-31082941 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-31082941 ) the population of London has recently reached a record high and predicted to rise by 25-30% over the next 35 years.
- littletimmy 12y agoA good partial solution to London's housing problem is to tax the thousands of empty houses being used as investments. For example, there's a road in London called Bishops Avenue. The Saudi royal family owns about 1/3 of the houses on that road. ONE THIRD. Those houses are completely empty, they are just being used as investment by the Saudi elite (who can apparently amass as much money as they can because the US protects their kingdom against any democratic struggle). You can tax these houses (the Saudis have no objection paying property taxes in the US and they won't have an objection paying it in the UK) and use the tax money to build cheaper houses for people who need them. Get these Arabs, Indians, Russians who are hoarding London property to pay a tidy sum for being allowed in London. What you've got left is enough of London that Londoners can share. It is about time society realizes that the right to life and shelter is more important than property rights for foreigners.
- gadders 12y agoYes, because if this woman in the article wasn't living on a barge she'd have spent £20m on a 10 bedroom mansion on Bishops Avenue.
- littletimmy 12y agoI am not saying start building projects on Bishops Avenue. I'm saying tax the people who hoard properties so that the money can be used to provide cheaper housing for people who need it.
- kjs3 12y agoThen the next day there's be someone in the employ of the owner living in the house to avoid the tax, and that would undoubtedly not be someone who "needs it", for whatever measure of need.
- esja 12y agoThere is an obvious ripple effect here which your comment ignores. Oligarchs buy in Knightsbridge, pushing aristocrats to Notting Hill. That pushes the international managerial types to places like Chiswick, which pushes the mere professionals to Ealing. And so on. If the oligarchs disappear, everyone moves in one slot, and this woman gets to live in a decent but modest home instead of a slum.
- bonn1 12y agoI never understood people complaining about raising rents. If demand is bigger than supply prices will regulate the market, here: prices will increase. This is market economy and is there any reason real-estate shouldn't follow this model in a market economy?
- tomjen3 12y agoInstead of fighting over different ways to tax property, why not try new methods of housing? Like why not make the housing smaller, with one common kitchen for an entire appartment where you pick your meals every day (and save the time to cook, clean and maintain a kitchen?), why not have the old alcove system where your bed is essentially in a closet so that you can get by with just one room per family? Would a common shower room (separated by gender, obviously) really be so bad? Hacker news is place of thinking new, can we please try that? Admittably not all ideas are going to be good, but can we please do something new?
- Lazare 12y agoI think you may have misunderstood the problem. It's not that we don't know how to build dense modern cities (just look at China). It's that London has made a very concerted effort not to be dense or modern. There are (finally) skyscrapers being built in London, but even now they are limited to a few specific areas. Views of St Paul's and Westminster are especially protected. Which is fine, and understandable! But you're asking, I think, "why doesn't London become a bit more like Beijing or Tokyo", and the answer is "because London really doesn't want to become like them". Building a bunch of small apartments would absolutely solve the issue (and cause others; a lot of London infrastructure is close to capacity), but it's a solution which is politically impossible. Interesting article on the subject here: http://www.economist.com/news/britain/21596539-capitals-skyline-growing-mess-let-boris-sort-it-out-ascent-city http://www.economist.com/news/britain/21596539-capitals-skyl...
- gambiting 12y agoBecause the last thing I want in my life right now is to go back to living at a university campus, with shared kitchen and shower. There will be a lot of people who are alright with this - and there is such housing available to those people. But generally, people who are done with education and are "working professionals" would rather not live in a frat house anymore.
- tomjen3 12y agoI was just trying to come up with some suggestions for alternatives, I do not necessarily support any of them. Also I didn't intent for that to be a shared kitchen but a kitchen you ordered from and had others cook your food - it simply makes little sense for me to have every household spend time every single day to make food for themselves.
- piratebroadcast 12y agoI'm a Rails developer in the US and my dream is to live in London and work. I should forget it, eh?