14 ms·
How crazy am I to think I actually know where that Malaysia Airlines plane is?
- Gustomaximus 12y agoThis articles first paragraph says: "There had been no bad weather, no distress call, no wreckage, no eyewitness accounts of a fireball in the sky" Someone did claim to see a fireball. http://www.thewire.com/global/2014/03/oil-rig-worker-says-he-saw-malaysia-air-flight-370-go-down/359093/ http://www.thewire.com/global/2014/03/oil-rig-worker-says-he...
- damian2000 12y agoAlso the british woman on a yacht ... http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/mh370-search-british-sailor-may-be-last-to-see-lost-jet-after-reporting-burning-plane-with-trail-of-black-smoke-over-indian-ocean-9477827.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/mh370-search-br... Incidentally, the kiwi oil rig worker who claimed he saw MH370 come down in a fireball was sacked for saying that, and hasn't worked since. http://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/news/article.cfm?c_id=2&objectid=11404392 http://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/news/article.cfm?c_id=2&obje...
- pyrophane 12y agoI hadn't heard about that oil rig worker, but unless there are details missing from this article, it seems a terrible shame he was fired. Given what he describes, I would have likely done the same thing, used whatever means I had at my disposal to try to notify some relevant official. His only mistake might have been making too clear a declaration in his email that what he'd seen was a plane, when his later description makes that appear less certain. Still, it is also easy to understand how, in the moment, I might have again done the same thing. The best explanation I could find of why he was fired was that his email caused computer problems related to the resulting traffic, which was in no way his fault.
- junto 12y agoMy gut feeling is that the plane was accidentally shot down as part of the continuing tensions in the South China Sea. This article and the included map illustrate the problems quite well: http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-pacific-13748349 http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-pacific-13748349 There were a large number of different nations involved in various "war games", "search and rescue practices", and general provocative actions at the time. http://tass.ru/en/world/725908 http://tass.ru/en/world/725908
- orbifold 12y agoWhy would you shoot with live ammunition during a war game?
- melling 12y agoOne of CNN's most embarrassing moments: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZpVd7k1Uw6A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZpVd7k1Uw6A Can anyone fix American news?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Dylan16807 12y agoYou're going to mock her? She's put on the spot with a ridiculous question and shoots it down with a minor misspeak. She is not the problem in this scenario.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Dylan16807 12y agoHere's something totally crazy. You have five seconds to formulate a response to it and two other crazy things. A black hole that would suck in a plane would suck in the entire planet. Close enough to what she said. Yeah 'universe' was a simple error not worth taking the time to correct.
- aklemm 12y agoExactly. There's no reason to expect her to understand a lot about black holes, but even so she demonstrates her general competence by knowing that black holes are a ridiculous suggestion for the disappearance of the flight. Compare that to the questioners and to Don Lemon.
- jmadsen 12y agoHer answer was essentially, "I'm a public official and so I know better than to call you a dumbshit in front of everyone on national TV" It's the news "editors" that need to be taken to task.
- peteretep 12y agoHe wrote his whole theory up as a book: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00TP07B0I/ http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00TP07B0I/
- jasonm23 12y agoThis is all you ever need to remember when considering the validity of the majority of news sources: > I soon realized the germ of every TV-news segment is: “Officials say X.” The validity of the story derives from the authority of the source. The expert, such as myself, is on hand to add dimension or clarity. Truth flowed one way: from the official source, through the anchor, past the expert, and onward into the great sea of viewerdom.
- arh68 12y agoYeah. What I got from the article was: 1) As an expert, I appear on TV to repeat the Official News Updates 2) I'm there all week, so I'm a regular 3) The experts don't agree at all 4) The experts don't like conspiracy theorists (lightning?) 5) The experts can be conspiracy theorists, too! (Putin!?) Even his book summary lays out the same trope: CNN Aviation Analyst Jeff Wise sweeps aside the conspiracy theories and misconceptions, then just down below, once they've made the appeal to authority, a radical new hypothesis ought to be considered. Bizarre. A very entertaining read.
- ausjke 12y agowow an eye-opener, maybe there is 5% chance it makes sense? Is Australia still actively looking for it? who is paying for all these efforts?
- damian2000 12y agoYes - http://www.atsb.gov.au/mh370.aspx http://www.atsb.gov.au/mh370.aspx Its being shared between Malaysia, Australia & China, but what % each I don't know. I think Australia has spent the most so far.
- TillE 12y agoThe search costs are in the tens of millions of dollars, which is peanuts to most countries.
- johnloeber 12y agoThe difficult thing with this sort of article is that while it generally sounds plausible, the layperson reader doesn't know about the specifics. I don't know anything about BFO spoofing or handshake rings. This means that all I can really judge this article on is its presentation and logical reasoning, and while both seem okay, there's no way for me to evaluate the premises and finer points that the piece critically hinges upon. Reading this article sort of left me feeling the same way I imagine a child might feel when reading Erich von Daniken or a book about Roswell or something like that: a set of allegations that are (1) surprising, (2) seem to make sense, and (3) that are totally beyond the reader's capacity for counterargument. I will deliver one counter-argument: I think the focus on Yubileyniy might be unwarranted. The extrapolation of the flight-path is mere speculation, and don't forget that there are lots of places to land a plane, even a very large one. Out of all the larger airfields on the eastern hemisphere of our planet, I'm not surprised to see one that's large enough for this plane and that had some apparently-unusual things going on within the last few months. Statistically, I just regard such an event as probable to occur, independently of any missing planes. Anyway, it was an interesting read.
- alaskamiller 12y agoThis illustrates that feel: http://imgur.com/r/IASIP/YQi3ZFz http://imgur.com/r/IASIP/YQi3ZFz
- bhouston 12y agoI started reading this and then I thought of Occam's Razor. This theory is appears way too complex to be true, something much simpler likely happened.
- xnull6guest 12y agoLack of debris and communication aside, the sheer frequency of Asian airliner disasters and disappearances this past year has been especially provocative and unusual. The Ex-Prime Minister of Malaysia has resisted implications that the plane had crashed, insisting that MH370 was a CIA operation. The loss of the plane over the Ukraine, too, stirred up rumors of a hacked plane being used as a missile and also rumors that it was taken down by US Air Force to as a reputation tarnishing campaign and pretense for military action (plus countless others). There's just not enough real information to gain certainty, and the number of plausible sounding theories create a cacaphony. But one thing seems certain. The series of unusual, '(in)convenient' (a plane full of AIDs reseachers!) and mysterious circumstances have triggered enough minds to where is not controversial to conclude that something unusual and extraordinary is going on. I wonder if we'll ever know.
- jpatokal 12y ago> the sheer frequency of Asian airliner disasters and disappearances this past year has been especially provocative and unusual No, not really. 2014 actually had less crashes of large planes (6) than any previous year on record, it's just that three of them were particularly large -- and the death toll was still less than 2005 (or 2002 or 2001 or 2000). http://www.planecrashinfo.com/cause.htm http://www.planecrashinfo.com/cause.htm
- xnull6guest 12y agoOh that's really interesting. Am I alone in the impression there were an unusual number of Asian (specifically) airliners that disappeared or crashed under unusual circumstances? I've recieved some other numbers (12; aviation-safety.com for 2014) but the consensus is that 2014 is the safest year on record.
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoProbably not. Considering that airline crashes are exceedingly rare on a per flight or per distance basis, what, exactly, are the usual circumstances of airline crashes?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rdtsc 12y agoI think the main point of the story is not to convince us that he has a good proof. But rather to document how we convince ourselves, and how we latch on to small things and head down a path. Once we are on a path we become commited to it and it becomes hard to turn back. Notice how he talks about the "crazies" on the forum. How they would use aliases, log back in and mention their stupid "lightning" theory, and he had to kick them out. However, he then carefully proceeds to discribe how he did pretty much the same. Spent his own money and time building this complicated theory of super smart and efficient russian spies hacking into a satcom of a flying aircraft, also somehow, incapacitation everyone else on board, etc. In the meantime he is dropping clues how his own wife doesn't even believe him. I think many people here, judging by the comments, misunderstood the goal of the article and took it too literaly. But, there is a good lesson here. This stuff happens if you program and design software. There are lot of moving parts and lot of imperfect knowledge -- market needs, tools, langauges, platforms, APIs, architectures desicions, etc etc. Sometimes if you start to "just write code" too early. You end up committed to a bad path and it becomes hard mentally to throw it away and restart. Or, alternatively, you spend so much time picking the right combination of tools or redesigning the system that it becomes too later to do anything (someone else already built the system or there is no need for it anymore somehow).
- viraptor 12y agoSounds similar to how the extended rocket car story from cDc was written (http://www.cultdeadcow.com/cDc_files/cDc-0363.php http://www.cultdeadcow.com/cDc_files/cDc-0363.php) - it's a long story with a lot of background, including friends, past friend/family reactions, current as-author-writes-it friend/family reactions, technical details, diagrams, step-by-step ideas as they were developed and worked/failed in testing. There's also a lot of "this is a story of how I acted as a silly teenager, it was not a great idea" kind of self-mocking. It shows how much a good story-telling can go with convincing others that you know the truth.
- crimsonalucard 12y agoThere is another side to this lesson. I cannot count the amount of times I've read about scientists in the past getting ridiculed for some "crackpot" theory only to be vindicated later. A perfect example is Ohm's law: "Ohm's initial publication was met with ridicule and dismissal; called "a tissue of naked fantasy." Approx. twenty years passed before scientists began to recognize its great importance." The site here has a whole list of these "maverick scientists": http://amasci.com/weird/vindac.html#j9 http://amasci.com/weird/vindac.html#j9 I think the other lesson we need to consider is, just because an idea appears to be crazy, doesn't mean it is... The Author, by presenting his theory in a way that also illustrates his awareness of the possibility that he himself is also crazy, was able to get it published by the New Yorker as a symbolic piece on the dangers of getting sucked into a conspiracy theory. If this was his plan, I think it's a good one as there's too many technical summaries, pictures and diagrams for this not be an article that is in part promoting a conspiracy theory.
- 8ig8 12y agoIf anything, it was a good read. It was one of those rare stories where I was looking at my scroll position hoping I wasn't near the end. Usually it is the other way around.
- defen 12y agoI don't understand why an entity with "state level resources" would need to go through this elaborate procedure to acquire a jet (which they presumably want to use for nefarious purposes). 1) What nefarious purpose could they possibly use it for? e.g. let's say they want to turn it into a flying bomb - do they really think the rest of the world won't figure out where it came from / who did it, simply because they're using a stolen plane? 2) Why go through all this trouble with a mission that could go catastrophically wrong, when you could just buy it through your regular black-budget process?
- damian2000 12y agoThe theory has a lot of holes, but in the absence of the plane and much other hard evidence, it becomes really attractive to believe in it. What were the Russians doing in Malaysia? In fact Russians make up an increasing number of tourists in south east asia. I ran into many when I was in Phuket a couple of years back.
- jonah 12y agoMaybe it was some passengers/cargo they were interested in. </tinfoil>
- Throwaway90283 12y agoSurely it would be easier to kidnap a passenger at their hotel, or to hijack their taxi, then to steal an entire airplane, take control of hundreds of passengers, make it disappear from radar, spoof the location, fly it across national borders, land it in Kazakhstan, and hide it underground. It's completely absurd. If the president of the United States was on that flight, I'd give it more credibility. However, which passenger on that flight was so valuable, and surrounded by so much security, that hijacking the flight made sense? The same goes for cargo, it must be easier to make friends in the right places, or pay people off to have that cargo "misplaced".
- jonah 12y ago
- bobmoretti 12y agoThe scenario described in the article could only have gone down with the support of a state level actor. In foreign affairs, states are mostly rational and risk-averse. The risk involved in such an operation would have been astronomical: - It stretches the imagination that in the Post-9/11 world, hijackers could access a panel in the cabin without raising passenger and crew suspicion. So the hijackers would have required some way to control the passengers. Smuggling this past airport security is already a huge risk to the operation. - The northern route may be the optimal route for someone looking to avoid detection, but there is still a massive risk that one of these countries might notice the plane on military or other radar. This would be an unqualified disaster to the sponsors of the operation. - The most probable final ping locations are so far out that the aircraft was almost certainly at or on the verge of fuel exhaustion. How would the hijackers have known the precise amount of fuel on board? How would they deal with unexpectedly high head winds, or some other in-flight issue? Any crash landing would be difficult to conceal. The sophistication, danger, and lack of motivation for such an operation makes this sound more like a movie plot than a credible theory.
- jonah 12y agoAnd if it's that sophisticated of an operation, planned far in advance, they surely wouldn't need to auto-land the plane.
- raverbashing 12y ago" but there is still a massive risk that one of these countries might notice the plane on military or other radar" And radar coverage is much bigger in the northern arc. China/Russia/India/Pakistan, etc
- bobmoretti 12y agoYep, and as someone else mentioned, flying right over one of the more heavily militarized areas of the planet (Kashmir). Also, why would Russia choose to hijack a plane full of Chinese citizens for this? The last thing they want right now is to compromise their relationship with China. It just doesn't make any sense.
- ouiya 12y agoLook something's wrong. Let's blame it on Putin. Let's not blame it on the weapons manufacturer's who wield powers to influence decisions on who should join NATO. Why do we need to spook Russia by starting the process of adding Ukraine to NATO? Why do we need 3% of GDP as defense budget in peace times? Why does everybody think about this but not ask?
- cyanbane 12y agoI think the first few paragraphs about the inner workings of being knighted and paid as "experts" is surreal and as interesting as his theory on the flight.
- Steko 12y agordtsc's point above is taken but this guy's idea in particular is really bonkers. He tries to pass off the idea that you can avoid radar by flying along borders with nothing more than the word of an anonymous military navigator. Maybe he should rent a plane in Kashmir and try flying along the Chinese-India border for a few hours and see if that actually works.
- nandemo 12y agoAgreed. Also, am I the only one disturbed by OP's implicating the 3 Russian passengers? It's not backed by any investigation, just speculation. And more likely than not those 3 Russians were simply victims.
- ars 12y agoIf anything the border would be the worst place to fly - if I were a country I'd put the majority of my radar right at the border.
- yongjik 12y agoOn top of everything others said, what kind of nation hijacks a plane with 152 Chinese nationals, unless they want a war with China? (And if they do want a war with China, why bother with such a complicated plot?) If Russia did it, and if China finds out, does anybody think China will say, "Well, it's Russia, we'll protest at UN and demand economic sanction"? Moscow and Beijing will be in rubbles when the dusts clear.
- signa11 12y ago> Moscow and Beijing will be in rubbles when the dusts clear. reminds me of sting's "russian" song, specifically, "i hope the russians love their children too..."
- jfoster 12y agoUnlikely. Despite the negative perception, China is quite pragmatic. They wouldn't immediately resort to physical conflict.
- prawn 12y agoRussia took down another Malaysian Airlines plane and virtually nothing has come of that.
- jpatokal 12y agoFull of Dutch nationals, not Chinese. Also, it's unlikely that "Russia" took it down, they merely supplied the weaponry to a bunch of incompetent hotheads who accidentally shot it down.
- jakub- 12y agoAccording to a report by the Berlin-based Correctiv & Der Spiegel [0], it was Russia's 53rd Air Defence Brigade that was directly operating the missile launcher. [0] https://mh17.correctiv.org/english/ https://mh17.correctiv.org/english/
- 12y ago
- platz 12y agoThe old man the boat.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoThe answer to the headline question is: "very". Speculation on the location of MH370 is evidence of innumeracy, at best. Insanity, at worst: http://www.tjradcliffe.com/?p=1364 http://www.tjradcliffe.com/?p=1364 tl;dr: because air disasters are incredibly improbable, the range for speculation is almost completely unbounded, and therefore the probability that any particular speculation is correct is vanishingly small.
- benhov 12y agog
- slantedview 12y agoI can't say how much merit the Russian theory is, but history has shown it is certainly plausible. The Russian apartment bombing (and failed bombing attempt) come to mind...
- brfox 12y agoAustralian journalist does not agree with this story: http://blogs.crikey.com.au/planetalking/2015/02/24/was-mh370s-flight-south-spoofed-as-it-really-flew-north/ http://blogs.crikey.com.au/planetalking/2015/02/24/was-mh370...
- baddox 12y ago> The MH370 obsessives continued attacking the problem. Since I was the proprietor of the major web forum, it fell on me to protect the fragile cocoon of civility that nurtured the conversation. A single troll could easily derail everything. The worst offenders were the ones who seemed intelligent but soon revealed themselves as Believers. They’d seized on a few pieces of faulty data and convinced themselves that they’d discovered the truth. One was sure the plane had been hit by lightning and then floated in the South China Sea, transmitting to the satellite on battery power. When I kicked him out, he came back under aliases. I wound up banning anyone who used the word “lightning.” I have no experience moderating a large online community, but this feels like a particularly bad way to do so.
- DavidPlumpton 12y agoSo if any of this was true it would all just be an amazing coincidence that the pilot was in a courtroom seeing a political figure he strongly supported for years getting a hefty sentence on trumped up charges for challenging the national leader. And then after being observed to be highly upset and emotional have a night to consider it all and then go fly the plane the next day.
- n1c 12y agoCould you elaborate on this? Did that really happen?
- DavidPlumpton 12y agoIt's widely reported. For example http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/foreigners/2014/03/pilot_zaharie_ahmad_shah_supported_anwar_ibrahim_was_he_a_terrorist.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/foreigners/2...
- lovemenot 12y agoWhatever the merits of the argument about the actual location of MH370, it was entirely inappropriate to dox those two Ukrainians with such circumstantial evidence as to their involvement. At one point he is saying just look at their physique and imagine these guys taking over your aircraft. Right. Theorising on the internet is one thing, but real people don't deserve terrorism accusations, except through due process of law. Boston bomb media lynching is a case in point.
- adaml_623 12y agoI would agree with you if it weren't for the fact that those people are dead. Obviously accusations such as these are not very nice for the families of those gentlemen but not really the same as doxing.
- ck2 12y agoIt's amazing how some people think governments can be so precise. This is like "9/11 inside job" level of thinking. We can't even get special forces to do their jobs without publishing books about it, what makes you think more than a handful of people can keep a secret about anything?
- trhway 12y ago>It's amazing how some people think governments can be so precise. >This is like "9/11 inside job" level of thinking. precise may be not. Opportunistic - definitely. While i have no doubts about WTC, when i first time saw the released security cam video with Pentagon hit i was surprised how it looks like a hit by a cruise missile not by a huge plane - speed, approach angle and height, explosion style, etc... That immediately prompted me to really look at the damage photos and i just wasn't able to make myself to see a huge plane hit damage, instead i see a damage from a cruise missile.
- cshimmin 12y agoSay what you will about the article or his theory, but I thought this passage was really well written and concisely summed up an important observation: “‘That’s right’ is a feeling you get so that you can move on,” Burton told me. It’s a kind of subconscious laziness. Just as it’s harder to go for a run than to plop onto the sofa, it’s harder to reexamine one’s assumptions than it is to embrace certainty. At one end of the spectrum of skeptics are scientists, who by disposition or training resist the easy path; at the other end are conspiracy theorists, who’ll leap effortlessly into the sweet bosom of certainty.
- Kiro 12y ago> One was sure the plane had been hit by lightning and then floated in the South China Sea, transmitting to the satellite on battery power. When I kicked him out, he came back under aliases. I wound up banning anyone who used the word “lightning.” That's some seriously messed up moderation. Who is this guy and what forum is he talking about?
- slouch 12y agohis personal blog...
- k4renio 12y agoThis theory would have had way more impact without quoting any names or making any direct accusations. It would also have had the benefit to spare his reputation.
- jkot 12y agoWell that story with lightning sounds more likely.
- slaction 12y agoThe real lesson learned here is that people stopped talking about what made this guy famous, and in an attempt to kick the fires and get the flames going again, he's doing whatever it takes to bring the story back into the public eye so that we will once again call on him for his expertise.
- smegel 12y agoFar fetched, but I would sure like to know what was going on at Baikonur.
- znowi 12y agotl;dr Russia hijacked the plain, spoofed the satellite data, landed it in Baikonur and then buried under the ground.
- tiler 12y ago"The world divides into facts. Each fact can be the case or not the case, while everything else remains the same." -Ludwig Wittgenstein
- codecamper 12y agowho has time for these articles??
- S_A_P 12y agoI just don't understand why if this was a hijacking that there was no media outlet alerted stating demands or claiming responsibility, etc. If that were the case I can only imagine that something went wrong and they were unable to announce the takeover or there is some sort of cover up that is being implemented to prevent any groups from getting credit for hijacking a plane. Nothing really seems to make a lot of sense to me. I do think it's interesting that the author doesn't really seem to sure himself and thinks that he may be crazy to think he has the answer. It seems that a lot of events when thrown into a strange context can seem to both explain something yet sound/be completely crazy(the work to hide the airplane in Kazakhstan in the middle of winter) It could have just been some government project that just so happened to wrap up around that time. I wonder if this plane will be found...
- kawa 12y agoI would dismiss it as some crude conspiration-theory, but the fact that only 4 month later a plane of the same company has been shoot down under unclear circumstances over the Ukraine is really quite odd.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- AnonJ 12y agoIt certainly is crazy. I appreciate that the author left hints and certain introspection about how it could be a self-irony. However the author seems mostly still believes in it being true. Looking at the "evidences" he put together they're mostly frail and nonsensical, especially the motive part. Rational people would certainly avoid failing prey to such obviously irrational rut. Good for being sane enough at times to remind readers about that, though.