4 ms·
In the corresponding criminal case, as this is clearly in breach of 18 USC 1030 (eg a(2)(C), https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1030#a https://www.law.c
by pbhjpbhj 12y ago
In the corresponding criminal case, as this is clearly in breach of 18 USC 1030 (eg a(2)(C), https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1030#a https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1030#a) couldn't the court require reparations be made?
Presumably anyone with a computer with spyware can get their money back under consumer protection laws as a bare minimum?
USA law really can't consider that there should be no compensation if a company secretly MitM people's bank transactions as long as there is no provable financial damages, can it?
Cost of replacing the computer is an actual damage as is administration of that. Lenovo should also be liable for costs of having a financial audit (to make sure no breeches have followed the MitM of banking transactions) and cost of a full security audit of any computer equipment connected that might also be affected. Plus the cost of changing all passwords used on the computer. The need to get these done is actual damage, the payout should be predicated on costs that reasonably are incurred to recover from the tortuous actions (that also means poor people don't get stiffed).
IMO punishment for this sort of contemptuous action by corporations should be of the order that threatens to shut down the company. Like the average of all profits from the past 5 years is taken and a fine is levied to that amount and paid in to the public purse. Each customer's purchases should be refunded in full and paid damages as above and paid compensation.
The FBI should be at Lenovo headquarters now taking copies of hard-drives so they can put the directors responsible in court to answer for this crime. AFAIK Superfish can be charged too under supply clauses of 18 USC 1030.
This wasn't an accident. It didn't require someone else to commit a crime to become a problem, LinkedIn were negligent but this action by Lenovo's directors was a wilful criminal act; it's nothing like the LinkedIn breach.
LinkedIn did the equivalent of leaving your details open in a file on their desk, but only using a Yale on the door so that someone was able to break in and get your details. Lenovo have done the equivalent of breaking in to your home, finding your files marked "private", copying them and then posting them in public so that everyone can get them. Sure criminals may not have read the details about your bank accounts or whatever but that making them available was OK.