15 ms·
Show HN: A histogram of salaries given to H1B workers in the software industry
- ensmotko 12y agoIt'd be interesting to see how H1B salaries compare to normal salaries, but that data probably isn't publicly available, right?
- Swizec 12y agoExactly, I was kind of surprised that the H1B data was public in the first place. But private companies usually don't release their salary info. I don't even think public companies do.
- wooyi 12y agopayscale and glassdoor has some data but not publicly available. ie http://www.glassdoor.com/Salaries/san-francisco-software-engineer-salary-SRCH_IL.0,13_IM759_KO14,31.htm http://www.glassdoor.com/Salaries/san-francisco-software-eng...
- nabucodonosor 12y agoor http://wageoffer.com http://wageoffer.com
- thisisit 12y agoLCA declarations filed for H1B does have salary data. It is there to stop people from exploiting immigrant workers. At least that is the official stance. I am not sure how accurate the numbers are but this site seems to have extracted info from the H1B applications: http://redbus2us.com/h1b-visa-sponsors/ http://redbus2us.com/h1b-visa-sponsors/ searchable by city. Looking up menlo park tells me, FB was the largest sponsor with median salary of 133k.
- negrit 12y agoBy law, foreigners should not have a lower salary. When a company sponsor an employee for a visa, the salary is one of the criteria to check for the immigration. They should/have to make sure it match the average salary in the office location. So, if the office is in Boulder, CO instead of San Francisco then it's ok to not pay your employee $100k+. But a least 4 of the top 10 companies sponsoring for visas in the US are playing very dirty[1][2][3][4] and pay there employee a lot less than they should. And for what it's worth, most of this companies, now in trouble, are: - Exploiting cheap labor from India. - Compromising career and future opportunity of the employee they sponsor - Affecting thousands of other visa applicants workers who want to move to the US and can't due to the illegal practice of those companies. [1] http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304527504579167490918208338 http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240527023045275045791674... [2] http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-04-04/news/31287764_1_gopi-vedachalam-tcs-tata-consultancy-services http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-04-04/news... [3] http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2011-07-20/news/29794893_1_h-1b-visa-h-1b-workers-indian-workers http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2011-07-20/news... [4] http://www.businessweek.com/bwdaily/dnflash/content/feb2009/db20090212_920784.htm http://www.businessweek.com/bwdaily/dnflash/content/feb2009/...
- JOnAgain 12y agotldr; turnover of visa holders vs. non-visa holders should be used as the metric more than wages. Significantly lower turnover of visa holders suggests they're being exploited since those who can quit and find another job do. But this doesn't work. For many people on H1B's the visa and greencard sponsoring has tremendous value. The do depress wages, but it's because of the risk around the visas. If you have an H1B, you're less likely to work at startups -- if the company goes bust and you need to find a job fast, you're at tremendous risk of needing to leave the US. You have 4-5 weeks to get a new job, but it has to start by then. Thinking about how long interview cycles can be at some companies, 4 weeks from application to start date is challenging. Also, people getting sponsored are much less likely to leave. This should be the real metric for evaluation -- turnover. If you're on a visa, especially if you're getting sponsored for a green card, you're much less likely to quit and go to another company. You can get hired at a competitive salary, but over a few years and a few promotions you can be underpaid. To completely stereotype, I used to work with a ton of these guys at Amazon -- they're all in line for Green Cards and will not consider quitting or even complaining about things until they get it. The turnover among non-visa people is much higher.
- kelukelugames 12y agoLegally it should be the same. But in reality foreign workers have way less leverage when negotiating.
- ild 12y agoMany, many Indians come in on L1/B1/tourism visa and work completely illegally.Or may be politely asked to return a bit of money on coming back to India.
- negrit 12y agoThis is not relevant: > The best city for software engineers was Menlo Park with an average salary of $130,640 The best city for software engineers should not determined on salary only. If the cost of living is 10X cheaper in Huntington Beach and the average salary is $125k then the best city by far is Huntington Beach. Then again there is a lot more than salary to consider before moving to a city...
- Swizec 12y agoYou're right. But I had to use some metric and I thought it was interesting to show some data about cities. As an interesting point, engineers in Menlo Park earn $30k more than in San Francisco. I'm not sure Menlo is that much more expensive to live in.
- CHY872 12y agoRemember that Facebook is the largest employer in Menlo Park by a factor of about 10, which will totally skew those rankings. Edit: to be more clear, I'm making two points. Firstly, Facebook is not known for the sort of Tata/Infosys style abusive H1b (and there'll be almost none of them in Menlo Park) whilst SF is much larger, and there could easily be such a company with an office in SF. Furthermore, the bar for entry to work as an engineer at Facebook is possibly higher than in SF as a whole.
- jure_z 12y agoGood point, would be interesting to see a comparison with cost of living included.
- canistr 12y agoMay further want to account for income tax laws according to state. Take-home pay is really what we're after.
- felixgallo 12y agoI would like to see the 'value' taken from the point of view of the employer; how much is an H1B visa worth in terms of cost savings over a local employee?
- Swizec 12y agoIf you can find me the data, I can make something work :D
- s73v3r 12y agoWell, it's hard to quantify, but I'm guessing most of these employers derive tremendous value from having an employee they can basically own, and not have to worry about them leaving for a better company for a number of years. Obviously companies like Google and Facebook treat their employees well, but many of these visas are going to companies which are not Google or Facebook.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- foobar2020 12y agoYou should read about H1B transfers.
- modoc 12y agoAt least in our limited experience we aren't saving any money, and that's not the driving factor. When the best person for the job needs a visa, that's what we do. It typically costs us $5k+/year in filing and legal fees on top of salary actually, so we pay MORE for H1B employees.
- pslam 12y agoIt is very expensive to hire an H1-B compared to a US resident. The only way for it to be cheaper would involve fraud: paying a worker less than prevailing wage, which would require cooking your books, lying to US Immigration, and getting into a lot of trouble. (As is the case for a few big out-sourcing companies recently) Filing fees are high ($5k+ over 6 years), as is the cost in lawyers (probably similar), auditing, and time consumption. It is impossible to keep an employee on H1-B indefinitely, so generally they will also go through the Green Card process, which is also expensive and time consuming. Generally companies will offer a relocation package, which is also very expensive when it's international, and have partnerships with banks (having zero US credit sucks) and other services to get employees settled. The idea that hiring an H1-B is a cost-saver is utterly bunk, and needs to stop spreading. (Other than fraud)
- mh- 12y agoOP: the 'administrator' button doesn't load new data, leaves previously rendered data in place.
- Swizec 12y agoThat's an unfortunate result of some brackets having zero data and my code not handling that edge case well :( Thanks for letting me know!
- Gurkenmaster 12y agoThe bars are tiny when I select architect/consultant/manager in Arizona.
- hoprocker 12y agoI am an unabashed infographic fanatic, but one thing that really throws me off here is the changing scale between graphs. I think it'd be a lot easier to flip through these tabs if a) the pay scale was the same for each graphic, and b) the pixel count on the y-axis remained the same.
- rev_bird 12y agoSeconding this. The data is thorough and fascinating, but impossible to compare between any two. Not being able to select two at the same time is fine, but it'd be really nice to at least be able to switch between two without getting stuck with apples and oranges.
- gojomo 12y agoSimilarly: placing higher values further down the page (lower) is highly unintuitive.
- djb_hackernews 12y agoThis gets to the rub of prevailing wage. You are hiring a developer, do you call her an engineer where the prevailing wage is 87k or do you call her a programmer where the prevailing wage is 61k? This type of fraud is difficult to prove and there probably isn't even anyone responsible in the government to verify or investigate issues. EDIT: forgot to mention that the prevailing wage can be determined by salary surveys provided by the employer themselves (!!) during the labor application, giving even more incentive for tech companies to suppress wages by any means possible.
- tjl 12y agoIn Canada, you wouldn't be allowed to call them an engineer if they didn't have professional certification as an engineer. It's against the law. People have been taken to court over it.
- hackerboos 12y agoPlenty of companies in Canada offering Software Engineer positions and asking for a degree in CS. Now I wouldn't class a CS degree as a 'certification in engineering'.
- tjl 12y agoIt's certainly something that could get them in trouble as it is against the law. It relies on reporting, so if no one reports the company, nothing specific will be done. For example, Microsoft lost a lawsuit regarding the MCSE designation. http://www.peo.on.ca/index.php/ci_id/21643/la_id/1.htm http://www.peo.on.ca/index.php/ci_id/21643/la_id/1.htm
- balls187 12y agoIIRC, the US believe is similar, however the title engineer can be bestowed by a company to an employee while they are working for the company.
- kevin_thibedeau 12y ago
- hatred 12y agoThis is pretty interesting especially for cities which have mainly a single software giant to know sort of how much an engineer in that company makes. Like for example Kirkland ( google ). There might be others like Menlo Park (Facebook ? ) too.
- bzz01 12y agoThere is no need to guess, data published by Dept of Labor (original source for this infographic) includes company names, specific position names and exact salaries. Glassdoor was including that info in their estimates for a while though, so no big discoveries here.
- fsk 12y agoAlternatively, you could look at what % raise a former H1-b visa holder receives when he gets his greencard. I heard it can be 2x-3x, but I've never seen a formal analysis.
- pslam 12y agoIt is illegal to pay an H1-B Visa Holder differently to the prevailing wage. Converting to a Green Card should have no effect on your pay, and if it does, the employers are committing fraud. You may have a side-effect of increased pay due to having more positions open to you. Holding an H1-B restricts you to a specific job description. For example, if you were a plain ordinary "Software Engineer" with nobody reporting to you, then you are not normally allowed to move to a role where you would have reports. This can be overcome with due-process and lawyers etc, but the basic idea is an H1-B worker is coming to the US to fill a job role not just a job. So, when you convert to holding a Green Card, you can get promoted into positions which weren't previously open to you. You get the pay increase by being a better engineer and getting the better job.
- fiatmoney 12y agoIt's illegal to hire H1-Bs in preference to citizen workers, yet that goes on all the time.
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoIt's also illegal to commit murder in the US. Yet it still happens ~14,000 times per year.
- ild 12y agoMany foreign worker are brought on L1. No minimal comp. requirements.
- npalli 12y agoPretty sure 2x-3x number is bullshit. H1-B visas are transferable between employers. If someone is paying you 1/2 or 1/3 the market rate, it pretty much a given that some other employer will easily pay you 20-30% more and hire you away. I would say 20% is probably the higher end of increase, if any.
- thoughtpalette 12y agoInteresting to note the "developer" position salary in Illinois is slowly getting lower year by year.
- pcurve 12y agoseems to be the trend in majority of other states as well. I guess H1B program is working as the design intended; wage suppression.
- benmathes 12y agoFYI: the visualization doesn't load if you're using adblock or uBlock.
- soheil 12y ago"The best city for software managers was Vancouver with an average salary of $183,500" Is it because it's in Canadian dollars?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- JeremyMorgan 12y agoI'm wondering where the data came from and how accurate it it is. "In 2012 the Oregon software industry gave jobs to 38 foreign software engineers." Ok so here I am assuming you mean 38 new H1B engineers were hired in 2012. There is no way that could be true, I nearly hired and processed that many H1Bs personally in 2012. I was working with several others with similar or higher numbers. And that's just one company in Oregon. Not trying to nitpick with anecdotal data, but it just seems wrong to me.
- kelukelugames 12y agoThis site says that got the data from the government. http://www.salar.ly/ http://www.salar.ly/
- ryen 12y agoThe link shows h1bdata.info as a source, which uses data from here: http://www.foreignlaborcert.doleta.gov/performancedata.cfm#dis http://www.foreignlaborcert.doleta.gov/performancedata.cfm#d...
- JeremyMorgan 12y agoYep, and it shows 2,830 H1B applications approved in Oregon in 2012, which sounds more accurate
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jpatokal 12y agoNot all H1Bs are for software engineers though.
- utunga 12y agoDoes anyone know if this reporting is official base salary or if its total earnings including bonuses. In NY especially that's gonna make a pretty noticeable difference to the averages I'd say.
- arenaninja 12y agoWow, that disparity between developer and engineer... I'm not an H1B worker, but does this mean I should start calling myself an Engineer?
- grecy 12y agoOnly if you're a certified Engineer. I studied Software Engineering, and I'm accredited by the Institute of Engineers in Australia.
- hyperliner 12y ago(USA) I know many people who call themselves "engineers" who studied HTML and JavaScript and develop websites or web apps. I know many "engineers" who graduated from "Software Engineering" or "Computer Science" but have no governmental certification. Unlike Civil Engineering or other engineering disciplines, in the US software work is not as regulated, though I have seen regulations when dealing with Government work, calling for "engineers" to actually be accepted by a "official body of engineers." Basically, in software in US, you can be an "engineer" and not get in trouble if you are not.
- ryanSrich 12y ago> Only if you're a certified Engineer Not really. If you've got a CS or SE degree you are certainly an engineer. If you've built systems and worked in the industry solving difficult problems you are an engineer. In the US we don't need an expensive piece of paper telling us what we're qualified to call ourselves. EDIT: To be clear I'm referring to software engineering. Not all engineering. I thought that was obvious based on the context of the post but I guess not.
- Dirlewanger 12y agoProblem with that is that, at least compared to actual engineers who need to take the FE exam to be called one, it's a complete misnomer and to be frank, a little embarrassing. Most CS/SE programs share no classes with engineering programs except maybe calc 1/2 and one or two others. It just feels wrong referring to myself as a software engineer because a. there's no formal definition of one and b. it's unfair to those who actually are engineers. I didn't slog through statics/Differential EQs/vibrations/Calc 3/Mechatronics/Embedded Systems/etc. like some of my friends, and on a nominal level it's unfair to them.
- spiralpolitik 12y agoThe data would be more meaningful if it separated out direct hires (Company X directly hires the employee) verses proxy hires (Company X contracts Company Y for employees) as generally the later relationship is a lot more exploitive than the former in terms of salaries as its much easier to hide the actually end of day take home salary. Not sure how you would do that.
- k3fernan 12y agoSuper interesting to see the pay differences between "programmer" vs "developer" vs "engineer". With the other titles there is either an inference of management/hierarchy (manager, lead) or just a different or isolated work (tester, analyst). Do people have very defined definitions of the differences between programmer vs developer vs engineer? I've just used engineer as the generic title.
- bstar77 12y agoDoes this actually represent the salary of the individual or what a consulting company is paying for them, or a combination of both?
- eggoa 12y agoIf you know the one H1Ber in Alaska, you now know their salary.
- nashashmi 12y agoTHIS IS WHERE YOU NEED ANONYMITIZATION.
- lsaferite 12y agoHow do you retain the ability to filter and anonymize a single data point result?
- nashashmi 12y agoyou remove the data entirely and lump it into "other". I guess states or entities with less than 5 occurrences should be categorized as other.
- lsaferite 12y ago5 seems fairly arbitrary. If all 5 are almost the same then you are back in the same boat, no? If all data points for a given filter are substantially the same you still run into the same issue.
- montz1 12y agoThis is pretty cool. I created a similar site http://salarytalk.org/search http://salarytalk.org/search. I has has more charts and search capabilities for the same dataset across 2010-2014. For aggregate information per company go to http://salarytalk.org/companies http://salarytalk.org/companies
- ryanSrich 12y agoI wonder how they define "software designer". I see that 17% are making north of $130k. Does this role identify as a software architect? an API designer? Or is it referring to product designers, UX designers and such? If it's the latter that seems much higher than the self reported salaries on sites like Glassdoor and Salary Fairy.
- juggernautq 12y agowould be interesting to factor in living cost and rank states by best-to-live-by-H1Bs.
- tn13 12y agoProxy hires often do not make that much money. A lot of them do not get paid leaves, employer paid insurance and many other benefits.
- lnkmails 12y agoThere is a privacy issue in government releasing the H1B salary data publicly. If you are a H1b worker working at a small startup, your privacy is pretty much violated. In the interest of long term, I think it is vital that salary information is available publicly but it should also include citizens' salary information so employees can negotiate better. I kinda feel sad for a lot of H1B people and their salaries.
- Flemlord 12y agoCoincidentally I just posted an Ask HN question asking how small companies facilitated H1B workers. I run a small company and don't have time to figure the process out. Was wondering how others did it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9096684 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9096684
- poulsbohemian 12y agoWhen I was at a small company about 4 years ago that was hiring two H1Bs (one from Romania, the other from Russia), a local lawyer experienced in the process was hired for a few thousand dollars. All we had to do was answer the questions from the lawyer, pay the fee, and magically the two guys got on airplanes and appeared.
- G650 12y agoThink about that for a second. About $130,000/year. How much are they worth to the company? About 10X more. I hope some of these guys realize their worth and just create their own software.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- simook 12y agoRan into several bugs when switching to a state & field.
- Eduard 12y agoCrass distribution for WV / West Virginia ;-) http://swizec.github.io/h1b-software-salaries/#2014-wv-engineer http://swizec.github.io/h1b-software-salaries/#2014-wv-engin...
- nickysielicki 12y agoIn Alaska, software engineers on an H1B made $72,000/year in 2014 In 2014 the Alaska software industry gave jobs to 1 foreign software engineers, 100% less than the year before. Most of them made between $NaN and $NaN per year. The best city for software engineers was Anchorage with an average salary of $72,000. Hahah.
- TwistedWeasel 12y agoSame bug for Utah... In 2014 the Utah software industry gave jobs to 1 foreign software managers, Infinity times more than the year before. Most of them made between $NaN and $NaN per year. The best city for software managers was South Jordan with an average salary of $165,000.
- pm90 12y agoHandling edge cases. One of the most important qualities of a software engineer. Actually, of any engineer.
- akgerber 12y agoThere is a bug in the histogram for Vermont.
- nsxwolf 12y agoWhat are these $200k+ software engineering jobs, and how do I get one?
- mikeklaas 12y agoLive in the bay area; be a really really good engineer. You will make 200k soon.
- IndianAstronaut 12y agoNow the question is how does one become a really good engineer.
- tsax 12y agoI'm guessing those are in the upper echelons of the finance industry such as hedge funds.
- yaur 12y agoIn nyc it's mostly fin tech stuff that will get you over 200k.
- emcrazyone 12y agoI own a company that specializes in hiring H1Bs and placing them into contract roles. The data doesn't look very accurate. For one thing, this data doesn't appear to represent what companies pay. I usually get bill rates up around $100/hr to $150/hr depending on skill and location. Like New York has higher cost of living than Michigan so I can often pull a higher bill rate. The payout to the H1B is works out to be $60K to $80K. An Oracle DBA working in New York will make about $80K which is roughly $38/hour and the company easily pays $125/hour for 6 month contract. I have some overhead but it's usually a one time fee such as transferring H1B from one company to mine, legal paper work to renew, attain, and transfer H1Bs runs me about $500/piece.
- lawnchair_larry 12y agoSo you're one of the companies giving H1-B a bad name by abusing it for cheap labor and taking money out of the foreigner's pockets then?
- gutnor 12y agoPresumably he also offers the applicant some sort of stability ? Without a middleman, the H1B holder is very tied to its employer and has a difficult time changing job or bouncing back after being laid off. A middleman could smooth that out, by keeping the employee a bit longer on the payroll until they find another contract. I know people using those kind of services in the UK. Also if you are a permanent employee with good benefits, getting a quarter of what your company sell you for is not bad. Anyway, that's a lot of "if", I agree.
- emcrazyone 12y agovery true. I offer a lot of benefits over other similar companies. Many times I am involved in moving a contract because I will give more of the bill rate. I also offer a family package. You would not believe how many H1Bs I get that want to leave their L1 status because they want to move for various reasons. Marriage being the one I get the most. When a contract ends, I will put H1Bs on internal work for as long as I can but the liquidity of this area is such that I hardly go past a month or two for any given candidate.
- peter303 12y agoI wonder if you can distinguish between direct hires and contracted hires through "body shops". The latter have reputationfor taking a big cut off the top. or hiring 'L'-class business visas, etc.
- ild 12y agoYes, confirm - worked with Indian body shop; half of their were L1.
- chavesn 12y agoNice work, love clean and simple data apps like this. (Do they have a good name? E.g., stuff like the NY Times "Upshot" interactive data apps?[1]) Two suggestions: 1. Make the bars consistently positioned and grouped across filter clicks. That would make it super easy to compare different cross-sections. 2. The use of the history API is cool; one tiny nitpick: if the click is equal to the previous history entry, navigate back instead of pushing it onto the stack. That will avoid histories filled with A-B-A-B-A-B back and forth clicks between two pages. [1]: http://www.nytimes.com/upshot/ http://www.nytimes.com/upshot/ -- try scrolling to "Best of"
- aninteger 12y agoThese H1B engineers make more than me.. How do I become an H1B engineer? I was born in the USA and have the title "Senior Software Engineer".
- nerfhammer 12y ago<glib>Move to a more expensive part of the country</glib>
- xxxyy 12y agoSalary is about negotiation and leverage, not being born in a particular country, holding H1B status or having professional titles. This might have offended you, sorry for that, but it is just true.
- serve_yay 12y agoThey make more than you, in the region of the US where you live? If so, get a new job. (If you can't just get a new job, well, there's your answer.)
- Jugurtha 12y agoIt would be better to fix the axis so that we get the info by the position of the hisogram. Example: When you're at "Engineer", and then you click "Programmer", the histogram moves to the bottom, giving the illusion they're paid more, when in fact the labels on the axis also changed. The same axis for everyone to really bring the difference home.
- varunjuice 12y agoHas anyone tried to determine if the prevalence of H1B visas results in a downward pressure on salaries in the tech sector? In theory, it shouldn't because H1B visas are supposed to be filled when you can't find a citizen or a resident, but I wonder.
- kansface 12y agoMore supply typically means lower prices.
- IndianAstronaut 12y agoIt may lower salaries down. This is not unique to software. Immigrant construction workers lower some wages, shipping steel industries abroad lowers wages and causes unemployment. The important issue is if it is a net good for the economy and society. Lower wages in one area can also mean lower prices for the rest.
- jimhefferon 12y agoNot looking good for VT.
- hyperlz 12y agoSome interesting stats here too: http://visadoor.com/h1bvisa-by-companies-2014 http://visadoor.com/h1bvisa-by-companies-2014 http://visadoor.com/h1bvisa-by-states-2014 http://visadoor.com/h1bvisa-by-states-2014 http://visadoor.com/h1bvisa-by-cities-2014 http://visadoor.com/h1bvisa-by-cities-2014 http://visadoor.com/h1bvisa-by-status-2014 http://visadoor.com/h1bvisa-by-status-2014
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pugz 12y agoI'd be interested to see how this compares to the E-3 visa, which is specific to workers from Australia. There were 33,000 E-3 visas issued in 2012.
- throwaway6496 12y agoMy salary is missing. I earn well over $300k base salary, and H-1B'd in California, 2014. My salary is on visadoor, but not here. If my high salary is missing, what other high salaries are missing, too? Does this give us a distribution that is distorted low?
- jsprogrammer 12y agoIt's probably also missing lower salaries and middle salaries.
- throwaway6496 12y agobrowsing visadoor, I now see a number of high salaries are missing. If visadoor ever read this, please add salary range filters to http://visadoor.com/h1bvisa-database http://visadoor.com/h1bvisa-database. E.g., only show offered salaries >= 300000. Thanks!
- visadoor 12y agoVisadoor builder here. Thanks for the feedback. Its on my todo list. What data are you seeing missing? AFAIK its pretty accurate, but http://visadoor.com/h1bvisa-database http://visadoor.com/h1bvisa-database is the archive database and is usually upto a quarter old. Realtime (updated daily) is at http://visadoor.com/h1b-lca-database http://visadoor.com/h1b-lca-database.
- throwaway6496 12y agoSorry, visadoor looks accurate, but I meant to say that the salaries were missing in the new distribution visualization. BTW - thanks for visadoor!
- hyperlz 12y agoThere are only 4 cases in CA in 2014 with salaries between 300K and 400K.
- facepalm 12y agoI wasn't aware that there is a difference between Software Developer and Software Engineer? What does the latter entail?
- lawnchair_larry 12y agoThe only difference is that a Software Developer works at Company X, and a Software Engineer works at Company Y.
- qdog 12y agoI'm a Software Development Engineer. Doesn't really matter what you are called, it's what salary you negotiate for the most part. Some titles are only bestowed on certain levels of people, but there are very few of those at all the companies I've worked at (Staff Engineer at one was a title only bestowed on people who had been promoted to a certain level and had certain compensation bonuses tied to it).
- scilro 12y agoCommon knowledge is that foreign workers will typically have lower wages on average because they have less freedom to switch companies, and as such have less bargaining power. On the other hand, giving greater visibility into H1-B wages like this could exert an slight upward pressure on their wages as well.
- luuio 12y ago>foreign workers will typically have lower wages >they have less freedom to switch companies Is there some data/documentation to back this up? As far as I know, an H1B VISA does not tie you to a specific company.
- jacalata 12y agoIt doesn't tie you to a specific company, but your new company has to be able to go through the H1B process for you as well which definitely increases switching friction.
- klipt 12y agoIt is tied to a company (and job description, and location). Any change in those requires amending/transferring the H1B, even just switching locations within the same company. I found this out the hard way when I accidentally gave the lawyers my company's headquarters address instead of the office where I would be working. They're like 35 miles apart but that still required an amendment. Plus while on H1B I can't sell a mobile app, or monetize a Youtube channel (things I could of course do if I were living in my home country), or even rent a room on AirBnB, as my visa restricts me to income from my sponsoring employer. Luckily I should have a green card soon.
- hibikir 12y agoAs a former H1-B, I might be able to help. You can change jobs as an H1-B: In fact, I did once, when my first employer was doing constant rounds of layoffs, and I got antsy. It's not easy, as many companies won't sponsor H1-Bs at all, but the real kicker is that most H1-Bs, me included, wanted to stay longer than the 6 year maximum. We see H1-B as the one way to stay permanently. First you get an H1-B, and maybe in the middle of it, or at the start of the second one, you get your company to sponsor you for a Green Card. If you have real qualifications, it's a very high probability process, but it's very slow. Back when I did it at least, it was VERY, VERY slow. During the process, you can keep renewing your H1-B a third, and even a fourth time, past the 6 year maximum, so barring the company going belly up, or a layoff, you'll eventually be able to stay forever, and get paid real market rates. But during the process, changing jobs is very hard, as changing jobs at the wrong time can make you have to start the process all over again. You might also have had to sign an agreement paying back the costs incurred if you leave before it's all done + 1 year, and that can be 15K, easy, so it's a big deterrent to change jobs. In my case, I had mild salary increases while I was getting the green card. Now, 3 years later, I make more than double what I made then, in the same town, because now I can actually negotiate without a sword over my head, and change jobs if there is a high enough bidder out there.
- visadoor 12y agoA few of you have mentioned http://www.visadoor.com http://www.visadoor.com below. I am the builder of the site and really did it for my own use. If you find any bugs or need any features implemented, contact me at the email on my profile.
- iagooar 12y agoWhat are the typical working conditions in the US tech sector? I mean vacation days, hours / week, flexible working hours, other perks and benefits? What would be the most typical conditions? What are the conditions an American software engineer would say: "I'm not accepting to work for less than this"?