8 ms·
I've never been a user, but I do support legalisation. The reason I support it even though I myself wouldn't benefit is: - It is at least as safe as tobacco a
by Someone1234 12y ago
I've never been a user, but I do support legalisation.
The reason I support it even though I myself wouldn't benefit is:
- It is at least as safe as tobacco and alcohol. So even if we leave the question of what is safer on the table, I think most people would agree based on available evidence that it isn't LESS safe than those two, and they're legal.
- The "war on drugs" has been a disaster. It has actually hurt economic growth, you have too many people in jail for trivial things, you leave a black mark on their file almost indefinitely making them unable to get a [good] job, you isolate them from society, you further push people into criminality, and the benefits of it are not clear if you ignore moralist arguments.
- We gain tax money from it being legal AND drug users aren't funding pretty horrifying criminality in countries like Mexico and Columbia.
- It has been shown to help with certain medical conditions (e.g. chronic pain, PTSD, etc). And while much more research needs to be conducted, it might be easier after legalisation as the permits needed are much easier to get.
However I will say my support for legalisation dropped quite a lot after reading how lightly "weed" users take smoking and driving. A lot of them seem to do it now and don't consider it a big deal, which I take a pretty dim view of. Unfortunately there isn't a very reliable test to see if someone is under the influence of anything other than alcohol.
People who drive under the influence of any mind altering substance (be it alcohol or weed) should have their driving privileges taken away or for repeat offenders they should literally go to jail for a period. It endangers their lives and the lives of other people on or near the road.
- madaxe_again 12y agoAgreed on the whole driving bit - but commensurately, whenever I'm in the US, I am astonished by how casually people drink and drive. Don't think it's a stoner problem, more an inconsiderate dickhead/cultural problem.
- misiti3780 12y agopeople smoke and drive here too though
- Someone1234 12y agoI agree. People are far too blasé about drinking and driving in the US. It also seems like the punishment is often fairly light for the first few offenses (e.g. a small ticket, no penalty points, or similar). People from the US I've spoken to often claim this is because in some areas not having a car is pretty unworkable due to a lack of public transport or alternatives. So if driving was revoked then people could get "stranded" at home (e.g. the nearer store is a 10 minute drive away on roads with no sidewalk). I think if they're unwilling to revoke people's driving, then waste a bunch of their time. People car much more about their time than their money, just force people to take a full day weekend class even on the first offense and make it three weeks worth or more on the second attempt (you can fine them also).
- madaxe_again 12y agoI think car-centric town and transport planning actually has a hell of a lot to answer for. Most drink driving accidents in the UK are rural. Not so many in human-scale/public transport provisioned cities - and the UK has a much bigger drinking problem than the U.S. Also, in the US, buses equate to poverty in the minds of many, and that attitude is going to be hard to shift, so... roll on driverless cars? I don't think punishment will put people off to any great degree. I mean - how many people do you know who have not once lamented the shit they got up to while drink? Rather the problem with impaired judgment...
- digi_owl 12y agoGiven that one silicon valley bus route pretty much act as a homeless shelter, not surprising.
- ssharp 12y agoIf you get a DUI, even for the first time, you're going to spend at least a night in jail and rack up several thousand dollars in fines and attorney fees. I don't think first time DUI's are a felony in most of the U.S., but you're going to get points on your license and it's going to cost you long-term with insurance as well. The penalties aren't damning, but I'm not sure I'd call them "light" either. Many states also having shaming laws in place where you have to get a different colored license plate on your car if you've gotten a DUI. You're right in that in that for most of the US, not having a vehicle is crippling. Many first-time DUI offenders have their licenses suspended but are allowed work privileges to avoid them losing their job. Also, in my state, first-time offenders are often sentenced to either spend three days in jail or take a weekend class, so at least in Ohio, they're doing exactly what you're mentioning. The only serious issue I see with making DUI laws somewhat more strict is knowing whether or not you're too impaired to drive. Groups like Mothers Against Drunk Driving have successfully lobbied to effectively force States to reduce the blood/alcohol threshold that's often used to distinguish impairment. I really have no idea how many drinks I can have within a given time frame and still know I'm legally not considered drunk. I've heard enough instances where people test right at, or slightly below, the threshold and get arrested and they say they felt their driving wasn't impaired at all. So I am left with no choice other than to arrange other transportation, or drink what I feel is a limited enough to make me not impaired.
- thejosh 12y agoSame as in Australia. People go out of their way to report booze buses, and complain about police pulling them over when they are speeding / drunk.
- cylinder 12y agoAt least you have DUI road checkpoints (even in daytime) and stricter licensing regimes.
- Zelphyr 12y agoWe're just bad drivers in general, regardless of our level of intoxication. Texting. Dancing (I see this frequently). The number of elderly people who drive who shouldn't be is mind boggling. I'm of a mind that its actually way too easy to obtain a drivers license in this country. For example; my mother took my uncle to get his drivers license renewed. Why she did is beyond me because he has early stage dementia. He couldn't understand the written test so the lady at the DMV just had my mom fill it out for him! Not even our own government cares whether we're qualified to drive!
- DanBC 12y ago> The number of elderly people who drive who shouldn't be is mind boggling. Is this supported by any research? Road traffic accident statistics show too many young people. So, older people might be safer drivers. Of course, there are a few people with dementia or visual impairment who shouldn't be driving but it's interesting that it's ok to suggest that older people are risky drivers when that doesn't appear to be true.
- Retric 12y agoOlder drivers (85+) are generally extremely risky per mile. "On the per-mile basis, the death rate of target drivers aged 85 and older is nearly triple that of drivers aged 16 to 17" https://aaafoundation.org/sites/default/files/OlderDriverRisk.pdf https://aaafoundation.org/sites/default/files/OlderDriverRis... They drive fewer miles, but even still their far more risky than teenagers. "The per-driver death rate of target drivers aged 85 and older is nearly double that of target drivers aged 16 to 17 (Rate Ratio [RR] 1.93, 95% Confidence Interval [CI] 1.66–2.24) and is over six times that of drivers aged 50 to 59 (RR 6.25, CI 5.48–7.14)." Also of note, new drivers of any age are generally more risky than experienced ones of that same age. So, a large chunk of the teenage hit would happen even if you banned people <20 from driving.
- digikata 12y agoI'm not sure about your takeaway from that link. In the Summary: "For example, the results of this study suggest that if a randomly-selected driver in his or thirties and a randomly-selected driver aged 85 or older were to drive equal numbers of miles, the older driver would be over 1500% more likely than the younger driver to be responsible for and die as a result of a crash, and about 220% more likely than the younger driver to kill an occupant of another vehicle or a non-motorist. However, drivers in their thirties drive approximately 217% more miles on average than drivers aged 85 and older do. Without statistical adjustment for what occurs naturally, a randomly-selected driver aged 85 or older is about 720% more likely than a randomly selected driver aged 30 to 39 to die in a crash, but only about 0.8% more likely to kill an occupant of another vehicle or a non-motorist, over the course of a year." I haven't gone back to review what the author means exactly by "statistical adjustment for what occurs naturally"
- fossuser 12y agoI think there are a couple of things with this. The legal limit in most of the US (0.08 BAC) is actually pretty high, so you can legally drink and drive. For example at that level a 220lb man can have four (American 1.5oz) shots and hit the road immediately at ~0.7. So most drinking and driving you might have seen probably isn't (at least legally). The second main reason is probably because there is no good mass transit. Most other countries either have the local pub you can walk to or some subway you can take - there's no 20min drive to meet somewhere.
- slouch 12y ago> For example at that level a 220lb man can have four (American 1.5oz) shots and hit the road immediately at ~0.7. If you were to test his blood. Breathalyzers work differently and this guy would not pass one.
- exprL 12y agoCan you get hit with a DUI without a blood test result in the U.S.? Breathalysers pretty much only give largely inaccurate results when you still have alcohol residue in your throat or mouth. If you rinse out or wait a moment, they'll probably fall in line with blood tests.
- mod 12y agoI believe you get taken to the station and then given a blood test. Where I live, refusing either results in a guilty verdict.
- TylerE 12y agoThe legal limit is only when arresting the driver is mandatory. If, in the judgement of the officer, you are impared, he can arrest you at 0.00.
- mariodiana 12y agoA BAC of 0.08 is not high at all. "Consider the 2000 federal law that pressured states to lower their BAC standards to 0.08 from 0.10. At the time, the average BAC in alcohol-related fatal accidents was 0.17, and two-thirds of such accidents involved drivers with BACs of 0.14 or higher." http://reason.com/archives/2010/10/11/abolish-drunk-driving-laws http://reason.com/archives/2010/10/11/abolish-drunk-driving-...
- ufmace 12y agoI'm American, and I think it's neither. It's more that in almost all of the country, the alternatives to drinking and driving work so badly that it's a better option, even with the risks. I think we're positively pathological about it in a way - we're all about punishment and stricter penalties, but nobody cares about making the alternatives suck less. I drink pretty frequently, and I go to a lot of effort to never drive drunk. I don't think I've ever met a designated driver in person, but I've met a lot of people who talk about how they drink and drive home drunk anyways. Public transit is mostly nonexistent and unreliable, and most of what there is doesn't run at night. Taxi service is also either nonexistent or may take the better part of an hour outside of major city centers. Walking is also a practical impossibility outside of major city centers. Meanwhile, there are so many people driving a little drunk that you're probably safe enough as long as you aren't the one obviously swerving all over the road. If we actually care about the issue, why don't we make better alternatives instead of creating a situation where it's painful to not drive drunk, and then act all outraged when people do it.
- mod 12y agoAs an American, I don't drive drunk, and I don't find it painful. Drink somewhere close to home, call a cab. If I can get drunk at a bar, which will costs me $50+, I can certainly afford a $5-10 cab ride. That said, I've heard that in Japan, it's the bar's responsibility to get you home safely. They take it very seriously, but you pay extra at the club to account for it.
- forgotpasswd3x 12y agoMost of America doesn't have cab service available though, however things like Uber and Lyft are changing that.
- mod 12y agoI've never lived anywhere without cab service. I'm currently in a town with 35k residents and we have a few cab companies, though we do have a big tourist draw. That said, I hadn't considered that possibility. In that case I'd be making plans to be picked up, or I'd be staying in.
- mariodiana 12y agoCan I just ask what you mean by "drink and drive": specifically, drink how much?
- CalRobert 12y agoOne of the interesting thing about moving from the US to Ireland was that it went from being acceptable to have a couple of beers and then drive, to people maybe having one mid-strength Guinness, if that (some reasonable exception for parties where you were hanging out for several hours). I find I prefer it here. Also, it's worth noting the limit for your first two years of having a licence is 0.02%, and they require 12 hours of behind the wheel training (when I got my Californian licence there was no requirement, as I was 18). Ireland has some of the more dangerous roads in Europe, and yet it's still about half as dangerous as the US, depending on your preferred metric.
- CalRobert 12y agoCaveat - I live in Dublin. I understand people are a little more accepting of a couple drinks in the country.
- tormeh 12y agoLet's not stop at that. Texting while driving and masturbating while driving are both completely insane. And roadhead, are you fucking kidding me?!
- VLM 12y ago"People who drive under the influence of any mind altering substance (be it alcohol or weed)" How bout coffee, energy drinks, cold medicine, most prescribed prescription medicines have some blurb about possible mental effects, tea, kava, nodoz caffeine pills, numerous herbal products ... We only complain about certain psychoactive drugs, and not others. Theres no logic behind it aside from residual cultural Puritanism, so looking for non cavalier logical behavior is likely to be fruitless. Also it varies by state, and there are quite effective tests for THC, and we've got megatons of state laws on the books WRT inattentive and distracted and negligent driving that cover it quite well. Finally we have endless nuisance laws such that all of us are always criminals all the time that can be selectively enforce by cops on pot smokers, much as "driving while black" has been criminalized in certain areas. Like yourself, I don't smoke (gives me an awful headache) but given the total net effect of prohibition, my kids are more likely to be killed as innocent bystanders in a shootout than killed by a stoned driver, so I'd prefer the lower risk. On the assumption that use patterns would change significantly with legalization (I'm still not going to smoke, my grannie still isn't going to smoke, its based on the "logic" that if abortion is legal nobody would ever have children, ever, which is pretty laughable). This logic is often seen in hyper-authoritarian areas. I live in a free area where cops won't drag me out of my house and shoot me if I paint polka dots on my house, of course nobody acts like that, but people who live in hyper authoritarian areas always under some HOA jackboots assume all humans would uncontrollably paint their houses purple polkadots unless the stormtroopers keep order under violent force.
- nitrogen 12y agoThere is definitely logic behind it: anything that impairs one's driving can result in a DUI. Commercially available egogenics (caffeine) do not impair one's driving under typical doses.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dnissley 12y agoMost of the studies I've seen on caffeine and driving have only focused on drivers who were already sleep deprived. Are there any that focus on it's effects on otherwise well-rested subjects?
- dethstar 12y ago>We gain tax money from it being legal AND drug users aren't funding pretty horrifying criminality in countries like Mexico and Columbia. As a note, I remember an article somewhere about how it was meth the drug that gave more profit to drug mafias. So it'd still be a problem. The question is, bigger or smaller? I'm pretty sure there's data of the translation from marijuana users->hard drugs users.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> I'm pretty sure there's data of the translation from marijuana users->hard drugs users. Even assuming that data is good, its an open question how much of that is causal, how much if it is "people who would use hard drugs anyway tend to stop by marijuana on the way because its more accessible", and how much of it is "people who develop relationships with illegal drug dealers through marijuana are likely to be pushed by them to other drugs at some point". The first is exacerbated by legalization, the second indifferent to it, and the third mitigated by it, so simple correlation data doesn't really provide useful information for policy without some clear indication of why the correlation exists.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoI'm pretty sure there's data of the translation from marijuana users->hard drugs users. The data for oxygen is far more alarming. 100% of hard drug users users first started out on oxygen. Furthermore, if nobody was allowed oxygen, all illegal drug addiction would stop. Oxygen is the ultimate gateway drug.
- mark-r 12y agoDHMO is pretty bad too: http://www.dhmo.org/ http://www.dhmo.org/
- lotsofmangos 12y agoWithout oxygen it would just float away harmlessly.
- 12y ago
- lotsofmangos 12y ago"There have been numerous studies in which the effects of marijuana have been assesed on performance in driving simulators and even a few studies conducted in city traffic. Much to everyone's surprise, the results of many of these studies revealed only relatively small impairments in driving skills, even after quite large doses of the drug. Several of the early studies showed no impairment at all, but as driving simulators grew more sophisticated and the tasks became more complex and demanding, impairments were observed, for example in peripheral vision and lane control. Marijuana users, however seem to be aware that their driving skills may be impaired and they tend to compensate by driving more slowly, keeping some distance from the vehicle ahead and in general take fewer risks (Smiley, 1986). This is in marked contrast to the effects of alcohol, which produces clear impairments in many aspects of driving skill as assesed in driving simulators. Alcohol also tends to encourage people to take greater risks and drive more aggresively" (Iversen, 2008, p.95) http://www.amazon.co.uk/Science-Marijuana-Leslie-L-Iversen/dp/0195328248/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1321650884&sr=1-1 http://www.amazon.co.uk/Science-Marijuana-Leslie-L-Iversen/d... Now personally I do not think it is at all a good idea to drive when stoned, but I do not consider it anywhere near as dangerous as driving when drunk. Same goes for a lot of other drugs. I'd rather get in a car with someone driving on LSD than on alcohol. They might think the other cars are penguins, but their reaction time if the penguins get too close is still going to be reasonable. People who drive under the influence of any mind altering substance (be it alcohol or weed) should have their driving privileges taken away Caffine and most painkillers fall into this definition. I'd rather just replace the ignition system with a short driving game that you have to complete to start the car.
- josefresco 12y agoOr replace the need for an active driver at all. Seems like we're already flirting with this scenario with the lane-assist, adaptive cruise control etc. The question then becomes, if an active/traditional "driver" is not needed, can the occupants be intoxicated?
- anigbrowl 12y agoYeah, the inherent advantages of self-driving cars look set to moot these debates within the next decade.
- hnov 12y agoEmpirically, driving under the influence of marijuana makes one safer by dialing back their willingness to take risk. Empirically, I'd rather be a passenger to stoner a than someone past their 60s, in their teens or recently emigrated from a non driving country. More research needs to be done before we can make any conclusions but research to date hasn't shown it to be a problem [0]. I actually dread legalization because it's only a matter of time before some legislator decides to "crack down" on the menace that is stoned drivers. http://norml.org/library/item/marijuana-and-driving-a-review-of-the-scientific-evidence http://norml.org/library/item/marijuana-and-driving-a-review...
- TranceMan 12y agoTotally ancedotal - I have a friend who who gives me a lift and I feel more comfortable as a passenger when they are stoned. Their attention span is low.
- cryptophreak 12y agoRevoking the license of everyone who drives while impaired seems unworkable given its prevalence and the necessity of driving in the States: 1. Since so many people do it and will continue to do it, you essentially create a lottery situation; just as now, very few are caught, whereas the vast majority will evade punishment, and they know it, therefore the problem persists. 2. People who have their licenses revoked still have to get places, therefore they continue to drive and accept the fact of additional penalties. In summary, creating harsh penalties for everyday behavior creates new problems while solving no existing ones.
- integraton 12y ago> drive under the influence The research about Marijuana's impact on driving is inconclusive, but there are indications that it might have no negative impact (for the most recent example: https://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1667972/nhtsa-marijuana.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1667...) and even that it might reduce risks of crashes. As a result, it's unfortunate that it's apparently socially acceptable to assume without question that marijuana has a negative impact on driving. New research could still demonstrate that it does not, just as new research has been strongly suggesting that our other assumptions are likely flawed. If marijuana is found to not be dangerous for drivers, then it will very unfortunate that we've promoted yet another misconception about it due to unchecked assumptions.
- tsomctl 12y agoNo. Just, no. Speaking from my own experience, and that of my friends, marijuana can make you a shittier driver. I very much doubt the current scientific consensus is that marijuana in general makes you a better driver. It is possible that there are some strains with a certain cannabinoid ratio that has a minimal impact (like low in THC), but there are other strains that have a major impact.
- autoreleasepool 12y agoYou are responding to a post with a link to research by countering with anecdotal evidence. The parent also never said that "the current scientific consensus is that marijuana in general makes you a better driver". That's a total distortion of the comment was saying. I, for one, think we should be open to actually studying the topic instead of baselessly and unscientifically concluding that driving under the influence of marijuana is equally as dangerous as driving under the influence of alcohol.
- techpeace 12y agoThe plural of anecdote isn't data.
- 12y ago
- jksmith 12y agoObligatory cynicism: The point of the "War on Drugs" is to perpetuate the "War on Drugs." It's a jobs program, a funding program, and serves government's natural desire to grow and control. From this point of view the program has probably been pretty successful.
- tw04 12y agoI would agree with you they shouldn't be doing it, but I would disagree that's it's anywhere near the equivalent to drinking and driving. People who drink and drive (assuming not to the point of being blackout drunk) tend to drive more aggressively. People who get high and drive, if nothing else, are a danger to others for driving too slow and being too cautious. I don't think it's a good idea to drive around a 2,000+ lbs pile of metal while in any kind of altered state, but I'd take someone high over someone drunk or extremely tired any day of the week.
- igorgue 12y agoPeople drive under conditions that they shouldn't, I know kids that wont wear a seatbealt and never follow rules in general. What I'm trying to say is that, same as with alcohol, people are still going to do it. Legalization won't change how people feel the effects of pot affect their driving.
- njharman 12y ago> any mind altering substance (be it alcohol or weed) should have their driving privileges taken away Such a blanket statement without any science backing is without merit. Even phrase "mind altering" is suspect as substances that increase mental focus, reaction time, and clarity all (probably) benefit driving ability. Many substances are "mind altering". Nicotine, Caffeine, Endorphin (from exercise e.g.), even just sugar. Also, mental states; sleep-deprived, agitated, depressed.
- gnaritas 12y agoStoners driver safer than most sober people, your opinion is ill informed and based on alcohol, which is a vastly different drug.
- mackwic 12y agoDo you have source to backup this claim ? I found it quite doubtful.
- gnaritas 12y agoRead this thread, plenty are posting exactly those sources. Yes, I exaggerate when I say most sober people, my point was that they're safer than many normal drivers like old people or teenagers or tired people or texters, etc. More to the point, it's not alcohol, so those wanting to treat it as such and calling it DUI need to show evidence that it impairs driving. You can't simply assume it does. Pot is not alcohol, it does not impair your decision making in that way. The idea that people should be given DUI's for driving while having THC in their system is quite simply baseless idiocy from those who simply want to treat it like alcohol which it is not. People drive around daily on prescription drugs far more dangerous to their driving abilities than a little pot and you don't hear anyone up in arms about them. The demonetization of marijuana is simple idiocy from the uneducated fools who want to continue the failed drug war or who swallowed the propaganda without demanding evidence of the bogus claims continually made.
- filoeleven 12y ago> Unfortunately there isn't a very reliable test to see if someone is under the influence of anything other than alcohol. I heard a lot of noise almost a decade ago about impairment testing. The idea is not to test for a specific drug, or a specific amount of a drug, but rather to test the ability of the person to react to situations. There isn't a lot of material out there about it, but it was highly praised at the time (in the info I came across) because it gets closer to the question that we really want to be answered: does this person currently have the ability to safely perform the task at hand? It removes the stigma of particular substances from the equation and also gives you the ability to test someone who is "drug-free" but also stayed up all night and may not be as able a driver (or machinist, or nurse) as usual. That was all a while ago, and I have yet to hear more or read any in-depth studies about the practice. Does anyone know if new research has been done?
- mod 12y agoIt also would presumably discriminate against entire swaths of people (think old folks, potentially disabled drivers, etc). Not that I think anyone incapable of driving should be, but any impairment test would flunk certain groups of 100% sober people working at their best ability (not sleep-drunk, either).
- camhenlin 12y agoIf they're unable to pass the impairment test they shouldn't be driving. If grandpa is too old to drive and can't maintain his lane in traffic anymore, a police officer giving him an impairment test and failing him is not discrimination.
- mod 12y agoI didn't mean to use discriminate in the PC sense of the word. Simply meant that those groups of people will fail. I agree with your conclusion. I think taking away the driving privilege of tons of old people is going to cause a stir, that's all. And more importantly, we don't have "old age checkpoints," and you don't go to jail if you're old and fail some kind of ability test while sober.
- nedwin 12y agoIn Australia we have rolled out widespread "booze busses" which block off major roads and breathalize everyone who comes through. This + major advertising campaigns have had a significant impact on drunk driving. I am surprised at the lack of these kinds of measures in the US - and how casually most people treat drink driving. These booze busses have now extended to testing for marijuana and methamphetamine, though neither drug is likely to be legalized in Australia anytime soon.
- mod 12y agoThere's plenty of roadblocks in the US. It's often argued they violate the constitution--that police are stopping every car for no reason. Police get around that by calling it a "safety check." There's plenty of videos about how to "beat" them: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kLmKl60VrWM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kLmKl60VrWM You can see from this video that the cops are clearly violating rights, and someone who knows what their rights are can stand up for themselves, so to speak. There's another one I can't find where someone hangs a note out the window and gets waved through.
- nedwin 12y agoI've done a fair bit of driving (mostly in California) and never been through a roadblock. I've also never seen any booze busses or similar. I've seen those videos too - are you saying it's unconstitutional to stop drivers to do a breathalyser?
- mod 12y agoI'm not saying it is or isn't, I'm saying it's argued that it is. It's my personal belief that it's a rights violation to stop anyone without a reason if you intend to arrest them if they meet some criteria. In particular, I believe it would be a major rights violation to force everyone to do a breathalyzer at a dui checkpoint. Fortunately, they're not that extreme yet--the have to smell alcohol or suspect impairment afaik. I've been stopped in approximately 8 DUI checkpoints in my ~15 years of driving. I drive significantly less miles per year than the national average here in America, if that counts for anything.
- mod 12y agoIt's my estimate, as a non-user, that someone would drive much better under the influence of marijuana than alcohol, especially at the extremes. It's also my estimate that many drivers at .08 BAC or under the influence of marijuana are far superior drivers than some other drivers who are 100% sober. So why isn't the line drawn based on driving ability or driving performance rather than mental state? I can see some obvious reasons: you can measure BAC and it's pretty hard to objectively measure driving ability. But the point stands--BAC is not a measure of actual driving ability, rather a measure of personal impairment. Edit: for dumbness.
- ecdavis 12y agoDriving under the influence is dangerous because it affects your judgement and your reaction times - much like driving while tired. The danger is not as present in familiar, safe conditions, but when something unexpected happens that puts you in a potentially dangerous situation. If you are driving under the influence your decision-making is impaired and you are more likely to make the wrong decision and be involved in an accident. So perhaps there are some people who drive better under the influence than others who are sober, but that says nothing about their ability to react to dangerous situations. > So why isn't the line drawn based on driving ability or driving performance rather than mental state? Reckless/careless driving is a traffic violation that can result in loss of license.
- mod 12y agoOkay, so rephrase my post to this: I'm sure there's some segment of the population (A) that is so bad at reacting to dangerous situations that the people who are best at it (B) still outperform (A), despite (B) being under the influence. You just shifted "driving" to "reacting to dangerous situations." The point holds. Reckless / careless driving is a seldom-issued traffic violation, probably often in conjunction with DUI. It does not cover "the old man who can't pass a sobriety test when sober."
- curiously 12y agostudies have shown that people driving under the influence of marijuana are extremely careful. alcohol is complete opposite.