4 ms·
Fundamental theories of nature aren’t allowed to hide information
- ars 12y ago> For if every event was predetermined, the outcomes of all experiments should be independent of the information possessed by any agent. I don't see how this follows from what was said before. I also don't see how he can say that Quantum Mechanics is the only theory that can be pure. You don't know that everything is not predetermined, they might be. We don't know. Quantum randomness might not actually be random.
- lisper 12y agoIf quantum randomness isn't random then QM is wrong. For quantum randomness to not be random, that would mean that the outcome of quantum experiments must be correlated with some other observable somewhere in the universe. QM specifically denies this, so a demonstration that quantum randomness isn't random would be a falsification of QM. That would be the biggest breakthrough in physics in 100 years.
- amelius 12y agoBut what if an underlying "random number generator" was actually built into the rules of physics? In other words, that quantum randomness appears to be random, but is a byproduct of a (probably much more complicated) underlying scheme that is totally deterministic. (This random number generator would not be external to the universe, but implicitly built into the rules of this universe.)
- lisper 12y agoDoesn't matter. If the Kolmogorov complexity of quantum randomness can be shown to be finite that falsifies QM. (The output of any physically realizable computing machine is an observable.)
- saraid216 12y agoDo you mean a random number generator, or do you mean a pseudo-random number generator using an algorithm that generates apparent randomness based on an unpredictable seed? The point GP is making (to my understanding) is that QM claims that there isn't such a seed or algorithm.
- dTal 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hidden_variable_theory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hidden_variable_theory "Assuming the validity of Bell's theorem, any deterministic hidden-variable theory which is consistent with quantum mechanics would have to be non-local, maintaining the existence of instantaneous or faster-than-light relations (correlations) between physically separated entities." Basically, you have three choices: 1) The universe is genuinely random 2) The universe is "nonlocal" (i.e. "spooky action at a distance") 3) Bell's theorem is invalid for some reason.
- AnimalMuppet 12y agoFor every claim in the article, you must remember to prefix it with "If this asserted principle is true, then..." But as far as I can see, no proof of the principle is given (that's why it's called a principle, not a theorem).
- Sniffnoy 12y agoHere's a link to the referenced paper on arXiv: http://arxiv.org/abs/1011.6451 http://arxiv.org/abs/1011.6451
- Strilanc 12y agoThis was a poorly written article, in my opinion. It failed to communicate the intent of the paper. I think it's trying to say something like... In quantum information theory there's pure states, like "[Off]", "[On]", "([Off] + [On])/sqrt(2)", "([Off] - [On])/sqrt(2)", and "3/5 [Off] + 4i/5 [On]". There's also mixed states, which are probability distributions of pure states, like "35% [On] + 65% [Off]" or "10% [On] + 90% ([Off] + [On])/sqrt(2)". Pure states behave differently from mixed states (sometimes), which is why the distinction is worth having. Pure states collapse into mixed states when measured. There's a process to convert any mixed state into a pure state, called purification [1], that works by grafting on a secondary system with the appropriate entanglements. For example, "10% [On] + 90% ([Off] + [On])/sqrt(2)" can be purified into "sqrt(1/10) [On and Extra=0] + sqrt(9/20) [Off and Extra=1] + sqrt(9/20) [On and Extra=1]". This isn't just a theoretical trick to ignore mixed-ness, it's something you can do in practice. You can even verify that it works, statistically, because pure states interfere and correlate in ways that some mixed states can't. The article appears to be saying that any theory that allows for purification (however they define it) must secretly be isomorphic to quantum mechanics (i.e. the state space is tensor products of complex vectors, the operations are unitary matrices, and measurement outcomes are related to the eigenvalues/vectors of Hermitian matrices). 1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purification_of_quantum_state http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purification_of_quantum_state