10 ms·
The Superfish Funder List
- finnn 12y ago>CoinBase, an similar anti-privacy company Really? How is looking at public blockchain data at all similar to installing malware?
- scintill76 12y agoSome Bitcoiners don't like Coinbase's know-your-customer measures for anti money-laundering. Reddit's /r/bitcoin has had reports of people being suprised about what documentation they have to provide; or having their accounts shut down because they withdrew their bitcoins to an address Coinbase determined was connected to something shady, or put a joking reference to drugs in their transaction memo field.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- scintill76 12y agoNot much IMO, but I said it because it's probably why this writer (an apparent cryptocurrency enthusiast) calls Coinbase an "anti-privacy company".
- fragsworth 12y agoBut that's entirely because they have to comply with federal law, not because they're "anti-privacy".
- sk_ 12y agoI suppose the author missed the letter 'd' in this statement.
- flatline 12y agoThe very notion of a service like coinbase is problematic, and coinbase's implementation is especially poor for privacy. First, they are taking an inherently trustless system and demanding a very high level of trust for AML/KYC requirements, which is unavoidable when dealing with fiat conversions. Why not just trade directly in bitcoin (of course few people want to do this which is why coinbase exists)? Specifically however, coinbase by default keeps your private keys under their control, which is where the bigger violation is IMO. They push everyone to go through their service and not use bitcoin directly, so they can track and control everything. The blockchain may or may not even be involved in some of their schemes (they offer a fiat-fiat service that supposedly involves bitcoin!). This is inevitable, as they are a company out for profit not an idealistic bunch of ancap hackers, but they are not just looking at public blockchain data. Even their name is a conflation, coinbase is a technical term for the block reward transaction.
- driverdan 12y agoCoinBase does far more than just look at the blockchain. They go beyond know your customer (KYC) requirements and actively 1. Ask users about income sources and Bitcoin usage, even for low volumes far below legal requirements. 2. Monitor and analyze blockchain transactions for activity they disagree with and close accounts with BTC in these chains, with no prior notice and no evidence of wrongdoing. When a company is more aggressive at removing users than Chase bank you know there is a problem.
- deitcher 12y agoEh. Investors invest in lots of companies, some of which make pretty bad mistakes. I think Superfish should be forced to wither on the vine because of this - and especially because it pawned off responsibility by saying, "hey, it was those guys, not us!" as should Lenovo ("it is just theoretical!"), but I doubt the investors explicitly backed something with the intent to break security. Few do.
- mobiplayer 12y agoFew do, I can probably agree with that. But it's not like investors through money out of the window unknowingly of where it ends. They either knew about it and didn't care about it or they just didn't care about it in any case, because following due diligence would've raised some red lights.
- ptaipale 12y agoMost likely someone showed them some Powerpoint slides, and the hapless investors just did not understand that there could be serious privacy and security implications. That doesn't mean they aren't responsible and shouldn't burn their fingers; investors actually should look into these things when they decide where to invest.
- deitcher 12y agoDepends who the investors are. I know some really first-class ones... then again, I know some dumb ones...
- ronreiter 12y agoAs an Israeli, all I can say is that I am ashamed.
- rabbyte 12y agoAs a human, you needn't be culpable for offenses perpetrated by others regardless of their relation to you. If you belong to principles and help the people to foster them, your only shame will be from your own failures; a shame you can actually do something about. I'm a proud American but it doesn't mean what people think it means.
- Tepix 12y agoShouldn't it work both ways then? If you're not culpable for offenses, why are you proud of achievments that you have nothing to do with?
- madaxe_again 12y agoJingoism.
- rayiner 12y agoHardly. Countries inculcate values, educate people on the public dime, support R&D, etc. People should be proud when those policies bear fruit. E.g. Sergei Brin's family emigrated to the U.S. when he was six, because of Soviet discrimination against Jews. E.g. they were graded harder on university entrance exams, or given tougher exams altogether. He went to public high school and college, and went to graduate school at Stanford on a National Science Foundation fellowship. And Stanford, as an institution, heavily benefits from public spending on research. So why shouldn't Americans take a little credit for Brin's success?
- murbard2 12y agoBecause they overwhelmingly had nothing to do with it.
- the100rabh 12y agoWait, is it the same company as its website says something totally different about the company. This website says its a visual search company. I wonder why would they be installing spyware ?? Or is that they are doing something different as well ?
- guenther1977 12y agoSee superfish advisors who are prof. from MIT, Yale... http://www.home.superfish.com/#!board-members/c1whv http://www.home.superfish.com/#!board-members/c1whv Professor Tomaso Poggio, PH.D – MIT Prof Lior Wolf – MIT/Tel Aviv Professor Yosi Keller – Yale/Bar-Ilan Olga Russakovsky, PH.D – Stanford (Fei-Fei) Ron Bekkerman, PH.D - University of Massachusetts
- anon012012 12y agoThey're all in computer vision, machine learning, ect... I doubt they helped for more than the visual search engine.
- nailer 12y agoI doubt the investors really knew about the MITM attacks with the universal private key either. I think Superfish and Komodia did something bad, but the buck should stop with them.
- glesica 12y agoWhy? It was probably pressure from the investors that drove them to do it. You can't say to someone "get this done no matter the cost" and then expect to be held blameless when they do something shady. It's kind of like a mob boss who says to his lieutenant, "Boy, it sure would be helpful to us if that grocery store burned down". How else were they supposed to monetize their tech? They did exactly what everyone else does and found a way to use it for advertising.
- eCa 12y agoUnless they want to be connected to superfish forever, now is the time to publicly distance themselves from it.
- skj 12y agoYou overestimate how much people care outside of the tech community (which is not the same as the academic computing community).
- madaxe_again 12y agoSurely Mossad are somewhere in there too? I can't imagine an intelligence agency not having an interest in this.
- mobiplayer 12y agoIt is a clumsy implementation at best and not ideal for any covert operation, why would a serious intelligence agency have any interest in this?
- madaxe_again 12y agoFree and easy intercepts with a straightforward "it wasn't us!".
- mobiplayer 12y agoHaha fair enough! I guess blaming private companies and investors is a good way to move attention from yourself.
- shrektoo 12y agoIt may be immature but this Adi Pinhas guy sounds like he's a bit of a dick: http://www.home.superfish.com/#!about-us/c1eqi http://www.home.superfish.com/#!about-us/c1eqi
- 1ris 12y agoWhat about criminal prosecution? In plenty jurisdictions this is illegal. Wiretaping, unauthorised access, unauthorised decryption, "Hacking", breach of privacy (manybe even copyright infringement; they edited other peoples content without their permission) or something like that is usually prosecuted harshly if it's done by a individual. I hope a company does not get away with it.
- rpedroso 12y agoI hope that there will be legal ramifications to discourage this kind of behavior, but ultimately, the vendor that packaged Superfish with the computers is a Chinese company who will probably claim that this kind of thing is permitted by their EULA.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoWhat does it matter that Lenovo is chinese and Superfish Israeli?
- diyorgasms 12y agoDamn right. A grand jury can indict without the defendant present (in fact that's how it usually works). Then the US can work to extradite, or just arrest if any of the defendants ever try to enter the US.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoWell, you know, we don't even arrest employees of American companies, like anyone on Wall Street.
- rpedroso 12y agoAlthough Superfish was founded in Israel, they're headquartered in Palo Alto now. The nationality of Lenovo is relevant insofar as it affects the applicability of US law. IANAL so I can't say how relevant that fact is, but I suspect it complicates litigation..
- tek-cyb-org 12y agoeven thgough im Palestinian and these guys are Israeli, should we really be blaming superfish? this company makes software, seams like a bunch of hackers to me. Lenovo is the real culprit here.
- nothrabannosir 12y agoBoth. Superfish is profiting, they're being held accountable for their actions. Lenovo is responsible, they are being shamed duly. The same happens with, for example, gun manufacturers and other war profiteers. I'm not trying to pick a side here, just pointing out: blame doesn't need to fall on just one party. They are partners in crime.
- matthewmacleod 12y agoYes, we should be blaming them. The product serves a bad purpose, and doesn't even have the redeeming quality of being well-implemented.
- rpedroso 12y agoNot to mention how reluctant they were to even admit the security issues presented by Superfish installations. They (and Lenovo) repeatedly denied that the injection of a trusted root certificate posed a security threat. Spin your mistakes however you want in a press release, but don't lie about security vulnerabilities that put users at risk.
- mercurial 12y agoThey deserve their part of the blame. They make a subcategory of software known as "malware". And they're perfectly aware of it (companies making "software" usually don't have to hide from antiviruses).
- serf 12y ago>even thgough im Palestinian and these guys are Israeli that has nothing to do with anything. >should we really be blaming superfish? this company makes software, seams like a bunch of hackers to me. More like a bunch of crackers. They produced a nefarious piece of software (which couldn't be used responsibly or in a just way), and it got used in a way that harmed users. Both parties profitted from hostile actions, which then hindered the defense of their userbase. "Should be we really be blaming Cult of the Dead Cow? This company makes software, seems like a bunch of hackers to me. The users of BackOrifice are the real culprit here." (yes, I know, my cyber-threat definition list is frightfully out of date. Maybe I just like cDc)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hoodoof 12y agoDraper Fisher Jurvetson = SuperFish? Classy. Ultimately its worth remembering this is Windows..... Microsoft has to be responsible for the crapware installed when people buy a Windows computer. The reasonable conclusion is that if you buy Windows you risk stuff like this because Windows resellers install crapware on top of clean Windows builds.
- snlacks 12y agoI agree, I like Windows, and I think Microsoft agrees too... But they also have agreements that come from times that were very different. The official Microsoft store, their own hardware, special new editions are some of the ways they seem to try to get around it. Sucks for users, either they don't know better, they have to build their own/clean their own, or buy from a limited selection.
- moomin 12y agoIt's way funnier than that. They can't interfere with crapware because of anti-trust decisions.
- yitchelle 12y agoNot so sure that you can pile all the responsibility onto Microsoft for this debacle. If your favorite Linux distro is to include some adware crap on it, should Linus take the blame? Ultimately, Lenovo should take the full blame for this. edit: grammar
- freshyill 12y agoLinux is free and there's no stopping anybody from doing whatever they want to it. Windows is not free. When an OEM licenses Windows for resale in their PCs, that comes with certain terms and conditions about what the OEM can install. If this falls within the terms of the agreement of what the OEM can do, then Microsoft needs to take at least some of the heat.
- serf 12y agoFalse analogy, for a few reasons. Linus is the maintainer of the Linux kernel. Linux is a product of the work of many people. Linux is free, and can be redistributed without securing licensing or rights to do so. Microsoft Windows is a proprietary product, which many people are only exposed to from the initial install on their bought hardware. The company who supplies the hardware, along with the company that supplies the software engage in contractual deals to allow this to happen. Microsoft's image benefits when it is known that they do due-dilligence in checking out the suppliers who they allow to represent their product through licensing. How are you okay with companies who create malware for corporations for pay? They deserve no responsibility themselves for simply existing with nefarious motivations? Microsoft requires licensing their product to use it, and goes an extra step by providing evaluation of the products which use their licensed software, and are vocally against the addition of crapware; but they take no blame when they allow their product to be continually licensed by a vendor that does harm to the image? To answer your question: The distribution that is responsible for spreading the adware should be held responsible, as should the developers of that adware. That's likely why Mint became so popular (numbers wise) after all the Ubuntu fiascos in semi-recent history. I don't think it's as simple as a one-party fault. Sorry.
- Fede_V 12y agoOne of the most effective ways we can shut down companies that make this kind of crapware is public shaming. Publicly naming companies and executives associated with this horrendous breach of privacy and security should hopefully serve as a deterrent for VCs who are considering making a quick buck by funding companies that are fucking over non-tech literate consumers.
- keslag 12y agoPublicly shaming Comcast doesn't seem to be working, at all. I think it's good in theory, but doesn't work so well in practice.
- Fede_V 12y agoI actually think that part of the reason why Comcast has had such a horrific time getting their proposed merger approved is because they suffer from such a horrific reputation. Obviously, shaming only goes so far... but realistically speaking, besides boycotts and shaming, there really aren't many effective ways to register your disapproval towards privately owned companies.
- e40 12y agoComcast has a monopoly in most of the markets in which it operates. This makes a huge difference.
- TheCraiggers 12y agoYou and the parent are both right. The problem with Comcast is that many people (I being one of them) have no choice in the matter. It doesn't matter how much I despise my ISP, for they are literally the only game in town. My vocation dictates I have high-speed internet, thus I'm forced to work with Comcast. Shaming Lenovo or its partners can make a difference because people do have a choice here. There are many laptop vendors out there. And if "Vintage Investment Partners" becomes well enough known as something the public finds distasteful, it could conceivably cause other companies to shun them as well. You know, at least until they change their name. Still, I'd argue that if people cared enough, this approach would work in non-monopolistic cases.
- comboy 12y agoApart from discouraging future VCs, legit question - do you think those listed ones had any idea about how does it exactly works? I mean, you need to be careful what you support, so I think that list is great anyway, just wondering how it usually looks like.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hnnewguy 12y agoIt's their obligation as owners to know what their portfolio companies are up to. When the big investors who supply capital to these funds ask questions, "We don't know what they are up to" is not a reasonable answer.
- murbard2 12y agoWhy is Superfish getting all of the heat, while Komodia gets comparatively very little? A product that injects ads in your web traffic is crapware, but the scandal here isn't that superfish was crapware, the scandal is the security hole it introduced, which compromised Lenovo users. Yes, we all hate crapware, but there's a big difference between bothering people with sneaky, unwanted, ads, and opening the doors for malicious parties to intercept their online banking credentials. However, a SSL intercepting software does not need to expose such a security flaw. It was only Komodia's moronic implementation which did so. If instead of using a fixed private CA key, they had generated one on the fly when the software is run for the first time, users wouldn't have been exposed. Regarding the VCs, I would give them the benefit of the doubt as well. What where they pitched? SuperFish was about shopping using image recognition. For all I know, they raised money on a pitch about offering a search service, and then ended up pivoting. I don't know for sure if that's the case, but it's possible, and the VCs should get a chance to tell their side of the story before being dragged in the mud.
- ffumarola 12y agoIt's not just that Komodia used the same root cert. It goes a bit deeper than that: https://blog.filippo.io/komodia-superfish-ssl-validation-is-broken/ https://blog.filippo.io/komodia-superfish-ssl-validation-is-...
- murbard2 12y agoI was wondering if they even did the validation properly on the Internet facing side. Turns out they don't, wow.
- patcheudor 12y agoAlso covered on HN first: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9078536 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9078536
- elcct 12y agoInjecting ads into traffic is basically stealing advertising space from websites. They should sue the living shit out of Lenovo.
- Pxtl 12y agoSo what the hell do we buy now? HP's quality has hit rock bottom and is starting to dig, Lenovo is doing their best to destroy the Thinkpad brand, Asus is incapable of making a device without at least one fatal flaw... is Apple the only one making laptops that aren't garbage anymroe?
- devy 12y ago2015 Silicon Valley Startup Hall of Shames award goes to .... Superfish!