3 ms·
Joking about what is, or isn't treasonous, is to my way of thinking in just as much poor taste as joking about sexual orientation or race. I "get" the freedom
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
Joking about what is, or isn't treasonous, is to my way of thinking in just as much poor taste as joking about sexual orientation or race.
I "get" the freedom of speech thing, there isn't any law against it, but I dislike it because the topic of encryption and privacy are things I consider important. Neil could have just as easily joked that Turing would still be around if he had been a bit more discreet about his "tastes." And I would be equally offended.
So when you have people who have put their liberty and their life on the line for something they believe in, I think it is important for us to treat what they did with respect and not make jokes about it.
- vonklaus 12y agoIt seems like you agree that you support free speech, but were still offended. This is a totally fair point. > things I consider important I am glad to see that you realize that virtually everything falls under the category of "important" to one person or another. Jokes are jokes and frankly I think nothing should be off limits. Freedom, ironically, is the absolute core of this argument and what Edward Snowden fought for personallly.
- acjohnson55 12y agoI personally thought the joke was funny, even if it made light of my deeply held political sensibilities. But what do you mean by "nothing should be off limits"? Are you saying that no joke or form of speech should be beyond criticism, no matter the venue? I don't think anyone has a right to someone else's platform to make any sort of speech they like. Even though I found the treason joke within my limits of taste for an Oscar's broadcast, I respect the prerogative of the original poster to voice criticism. That's part of free speech too, although interestingly some are trying to silence that person with downvotes.
- sroerick 12y agoIt's a funny joke. I didn't see the broadcast, but laughed at just the description. However, in the context of the Oscars, its humor will be lost on a large performance of the Audience. In the context of the narrative of the evening, the result of the joke is that a lot of viewers will be able to dismiss CITIZENFOUR without watching. But it was a good joke.
- acjohnson55 12y agoIn the context of the broadcast the joke was so quick, and it came after an impassioned speech by Laura Poitras. I can't even imagine someone being inspired to see the movie by either its Oscar win or the acceptance speech and being thrown of course by the quick little one-liner that followed it.
- vonklaus 12y agoI didn't downvote you, I appreciated your commentand it underscores my larger point. Freedom of speech isn't freedom from consequences, and there very well could be public backlash for this, or any other comment. Private organizations can enforce consequences on employees or stakeholders for falling outside their prescribed internal policies. Also, saying generally offensive things can certainly alienate somebody in society or professionally. I don't think this particular case the joke went too far and was certainly written by the oscar comedy writers and probably not by Harris himself. To your other point, on a private platform people certainly have the right to deem what is acceptable communication. I agree with that, certainly. In really no case is a form of speech 'beyond criticism'.
- slavik81 12y agoHe started the awards with "Tonight we celebrate Hollywood’s best and whitest". Clearly, you're going to find a lot of his humour to be in poor taste.
- joezydeco 12y agoAll the jokes on award shows like the Oscars telecast are written by a room full of comedy writers. That opening joke was actually "Tonight we celebrate Hollywood's best and whitest OOPS I MEAN brightest". Actually kind of a funny and relevant joke given the current state of race in Hollywood. Chris Rock's recent interview is a good read along those lines: http://www.vulture.com/2014/11/chris-rock-frank-rich-in-conversation.html http://www.vulture.com/2014/11/chris-rock-frank-rich-in-conv...
- smtddr 12y ago>> Joking about what is, or isn't treasonous, is to my way of thinking in just as much poor taste as joking about sexual orientation or race. Honestly, I use to feel the same way as you but.... I've begun to realize that jokes about serious matters is actually one form of communication to spread awareness about an issue, relief some social-stresses and it also serves as social-indicator. Like, if someone were to ask me "When could we consider the problem of racism mostly solved?" My answer would be, "When you stop seeing racist jokes/comments in youtube comments of any vid with minorities in it and when Louis CK's racist jokes don't make the audience laugh anymore." The jokes are not the cause of the problem, they're the indicator that the problem still exists. btw, same thing for gangsta-rap music. People say it causes problems in the African american community; I say gangsta-rap music is so popular because a lot of African americans can relate to it. Every black person in USA, including myself, can talk about instances of racism endured and/or the struggles in low-income areas of America. When that's no longer the case, they'll stop buying it then it'll stop being made. That said, there's definitely a time & a place for those kinds of jokes and it requires some tact to understand where & when it's appropriate.
- arrrg 12y agoMy first impression of this would be that it’s an alright joke, mostly because I think “treason” is a ridiculous and non-sensical concept in the first place and in general.
- Mimu 12y agoList me 5 jokes that does not offend anyone.