10 ms·
Is San Francisco losing its soul? (2014)
- steven2012 12y agoDon't worry. When VC funding dries up and 90% of these startups die, then rents will fall, buildings will vacate, and the whole cycle will start over again. People forget that these things go in cycles and that nothing lasts forever.
- FrankenPC 12y agoA buddy of mine (who happens to be gay) left SF to move to Chicago. His parting words: "SF is the Calcutta of the West. F'k this place"
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- defen 12y agoCan you unpack that comment a bit, for people who aren't terribly familiar with the demographics/culture of India?
- refurb 12y agoI was going to say, i have no idea what that means.
- spikels 12y agoHow's he enjoying the weather? I was just back there last week -20F then came back to SF sunny and 70F. Reminded me why I made the opposite move years ago.
- antidaily 12y ago-14ºF last week in Chicago though.
- nomore94103 12y agoMade this account just to respond to this, because it hit very close to home. My partner and I also moved to Chicago after living in SF for a decade. In short: it was no longer the city that we loved when we moved there. Now I've lived in cities all my life, so I've no illusions: cities change, neighborhoods evolve, and that's okay. You just find a corner of the city that fits your style, because there always is one. But this time it's the mood of the entire area that has changed. There's an obsession with money and wealth, and an influx of wealthy individuals that's changing local businesses, prices, and focus. Its becoming like Manhattan of the west - only without the culture or institutions. Chicago is a much more cultural and cosmopolitan city. But more importantly, also more livable.
- qq66 12y agoIn what way? I've spent a considerable amount of time in Calcutta -- it has its extreme positives and extreme negatives like many cities. The analogy needs some clarification.
- skj 12y ago"Facebook, Google, Apple and other companies lay on shiny luxury buses to ferry their employees on the approximately 90-minute trip. San Francisco's Municipal Transportation Authority estimates about 35,000 ride the air-conditioned, Wi-Fi-provisioned buses each day." Facebook has only a couple thousand employees, and Google has maybe 15,000? in Mountainview, and certainly not that many who live in SF. Not sure about Apple. Are there more companies with shuttles, or is this number made up?
- quest88 12y agoLinkedIn, Yahoo, Genentech and EA also have buses. Other smaller companies also contract out Bauer's (http://www.bauersit.com/ http://www.bauersit.com/) to provide shuttle services as well. I'm not saying this adds up, but there are other companies participating.
- uiberto 12y agoCounting one employee riding twice per day may make the difference.
- clsec 12y agoConsidering the number of buses I see every day, I would agree. Companies like Genentech & Yahoo transport emplyees as well. It's also an SF MTA estimate and I'm pretty sure they have a good idea of the traffic & transit conditions in the City.
- mseebach 12y agoSince these busses are direct competitors, the MTA also has probably the strongest incentives of any actor to overstate the severity of the problem.
- Decade 12y agoSFMTA routes end at the borders of the city. They are not direct competitors to buses going down the peninsula. If anything, SFMTA lines are feeders, because the corporate buses don't wander all over the city.
- vasilipupkin 12y agoThe problem is, the restrictions on development, which make housing in such short supply are also the very thing that makes San Fran a beautiful city. Remove those restrictions and both of the following will happen a) artists will have an easier time staying b) it will look like Midwest or LA.
- clsec 12y agoEd Lee is developing the City faster than any previous mayor in my 43 years of living here. In the past few years I've seen no less than 30 cranes up in the City at any given time.
- vasilipupkin 12y agoright. That's probably true, but I thought it was the case that Bay Area has restrictive development rules relative to the rest of the country. Is that not the case?
- wavefunction 12y ago"Relative" is a good description, as one might find the development rules of the rest of the country quite "permissive."
- clsec 12y agoI can't speak for the Bay Area, but SF Mayor Lee used to work in the planning department and has eased restrictions quite a bit from previous times. He's also got connections to bring in developers and money to work within the restrictions that currently exist.
- jseliger 12y agohas eased restrictions quite a bit That's great news—SF has been the least affordable city in the country for a couple years: http://www.citylab.com/housing/2013/10/san-francisco-exodus/7205/ http://www.citylab.com/housing/2013/10/san-francisco-exodus/... , and for years I've been reading articles from people who say they a) hate high housing costs but b) also hate any new buildings. Which is amazing, because it's like saying, "I hate that supply and demand function!" The solution to rising prices in the face of rising demand and constant supply is simple: build more, per Yglesias in The Rent is Too Damn High (http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0078XGJXO http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0078XGJXO). That Lee is now doing so, on at least some level, is great!
- rchiniquy 12y agoThanks for chiming in, media from London. Is it possible to write about this issue from a far-away or recently-arrived perspective? Worrying about this a decade or two sooner would've been more timely. The city changed dramatically from the late 90s to early 00s. We had a lull in change during the macroeconomic recession, but now the machine is getting back up to speed. I've been increasingly sad over the years as my friends who are artists, librarians, dancers, therapists, social workers, statisticians, teachers, writers, musicians, accountants, anything other than software engineers, have been falling away from the Bay because it is just so expensive. Rapid growth can apparently kill anything. IMO it's likely too late to do anything for San Francisco. There's still time to worry about Oakland though.
- rchiniquy 12y agobtw, since this Guardian article uses the "Compare Oakland to Brooklyn" trope, here's a great article putting change in Oakland into a historical context: http://nextcity.org/features/view/oakland-gentrification-libby-schaaf-tech-industry-inequality-foreclosures http://nextcity.org/features/view/oakland-gentrification-lib...
- BashiBazouk 12y agoSo, San Francisco only gained it's soul in the fifties? What about the previous 100 years? You know, the years that all the beautiful architecture was built? The Haight was once great but now it's a hollow shell of it's brief glory and the shell emptied long before the tech millionaires showed up. Do we really need to save it as a museum piece? Has anyone seen a real beatnik in a generation? I don't think a city should freeze it's self in time so the aging can relive their youth. A truly thriving city is in a consent state of change. So the city goes through a gentrification cycle. After the next crash or long decline, neighborhoods will open up for a future wave of bohemians. In the mean time, a lot of buildings in decline will get fixed and modernized...
- agumonkey 12y agoGood question, same goes for Nations, what makes a nation ? Waves are naturel, but how fast change is felt as breaking or losing its 'soul' ?
- Cyclone_ 12y ago'He complains of a "soulless group of people", a "new breed" of men and women too busy with iPhones to "be here" in the moment, and shiny new Mercedes-Benzs on his street.' So he can't tolerate people different than him? Tough luck I say.
- kordless 12y agoSomeone isn't 'different' because they have their noses stuck in a device 24/7. They are simply not considering others around them. I see no reason why I should have to tolerate people going around not being present with others. We all have a right to our feelings, so saying "tough luck" is equivalent to saying "I don't care what you feel", which is actually the point of all of this.
- Wintamute 12y agoAren't you saying "I don't care how you feel" to everyone choosing to engage with the world less directly/personally and more removed/technologically?
- kordless 12y agoI'm saying the inverse, I think. The person in the article has a good point, and we shouldn't tolerate 'tough luck' as the response. Someone in their phone clearly doesn't have the bandwidth to care how I feel about their engagement with our reality. I've watched teenagers literally shake their friends to try to get them out of their phones to answer a question on which Jamba Juice they wanted. That behavior is irritating because it mutes my ability to state my feelings to that individual. Obviously I don't talk to everyone I see in the world, but given a significant amount of people run around with their nose in their phone all the time, it can affect how someone who isn't in their phone views the world. Less people engage in conversation, less people 'see' you on the street, less people are 'aware' you exist, etc. It's a real problem and SF is the epicenter of it because a) this is where it all gets built and b) it's part of the tech culture.
- 12y ago
- kens 12y agoHere's almost the same article from 1999: "How the Internet ruined San Francisco" http://www.salon.com/1999/10/28/internet_2/ http://www.salon.com/1999/10/28/internet_2/ "The dot-com invasion -- call them twerps with 'tude -- is destroying everything that made San Francisco weird and wonderful." Buildings getting converted to condos, soaring real estate prices, evictions, artists unable to afford SF, traffic, class struggles against yuppies, gentrification. The only thing missing from this 1999 article is Google buses. Edit: with more comments than upvotes (45 vs 30 currently), the parent article is going to get penalized off the front page. So you might want to slow down the commenting... http://www.righto.com/2013/11/how-hacker-news-ranking-really-works.html http://www.righto.com/2013/11/how-hacker-news-ranking-really...
- VonGuard 12y agoI was here the first time. I'm here now. This is so totally different than 1999. In 1999, the boom included a lot of counter-culture people. Hackerspaces were still hidden underground things, and the technology was so new, a lot of pie-in-the-sky dreamers were here trying to make their way in the world. This time around, there is an established norm for how the startup scene works, and that scene requires MBAs and business suits. The people who have come around to take advantage this time are not nerds, they're not tech people, they're people of all sorts. I think the best way to so describe them is to say that these are normal people. That's fine anywhere else, but not in SF, home of the weirdos. SF has NEVER been a town of normal people. This gentrification process is basically turning SF into the Valley. The old days where burning man types held parties in their warehouses are long gone now. The first dot com boom made millionaires out of some of these weirdos, like JWZ. But this boom is not doing that. The people getting rich now came to SF just to get rich, and they have no interest in being weird, burning man, or any of the SF-style weirdness. Yes, in 1999 artists had to leave SF. But at that time, it was just some artists and weirdos leaving. This time, it's ALL of them leaving. There are no more blue collar people in SF. No more weirdos in SF. No more poets in SF. It's a real shame, and while it could have happened in 1999, it didn't quite get going enough to really do the damage that's being done this time around.
- BashiBazouk 12y ago
- dannyr 12y agoI'm pretty sure that same question was asked decades ago. Here's a story of urban development in SF during the 50s. http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/nation/2008-11-09-2450995649_x.htm http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/nation/2008-11-09-245099...
- big_astrocyte 12y agoImagine every startup in the world moving to SF! The startup world will get trapped in a cycle of exorbitant rents/salaries and exceptionally high burn rates. This would mean that 'real' innovations would more or less die down and any company which is in an 'attractive space' and can raise money would be free to spend it on even more rent/salaries. Spending on ever higher rent/salaries so that they can 'compete' for limited resources. The situation has come down to '10 year lease deals' being the last option. The cycle will continue until we realize how we got caught in this trap in the first place!! I would've had no motivation to move if people didn't keep telling me that I wouldn't be able to raise money because VCs didn't like to invest 'outside the bay area'!! I tried to reason with a partner at one such VC firm and he said 'that is how the world works'. Seriously?!! This is a guy trying to invest in innovation and yet is so oblivious to bringing innovation into their own sector. Sorry for the rant.
- soggypopsicle 12y agoI would like to see the same article written from the point of view of bay residents who are being displaced by the art folk.
- TACIXAT 12y agoOr one from 50 years ago complaining about all the bohemians moving in. Change happens.
- scythe 12y ago>Emerging in its place is the mostly white, male-dominated, monied monoculture of the tech industry and there appears no end in sight. It's weird to flinch at reading this. What am I, a racist? But this sentence just isn't true for me. I mean, sure, as the demographic majority there are a lot of white people in tech, but my experience just hasn't been "mostly white". At some meetings I've been the only white guy in the room: how much more diverse do we need to get, exactly? What is the case where I work is that white people are far more likely to live in San Francisco, whereas the nonwhite immigrants seem to be a little more responsible and live in places like Fremont, Dublin, and Sunnyvale, and tolerate 90 minute commutes to do so. Which is not an aspect of the tech boom that a publication like The Guardian would ever emphasize, because a story about entrenched old hipsters making life difficult for people from Bombay who worked themselves to the bone just to get into the country -- that just doesn't fit the prevailing narrative -- nor does the fact that they're doing so to preserve a culture famous mostly for its reputation among America's majority demographic. I mean, I'm not gonna deny that being white gives some tech workers (like me) an unfair advantage in life, which also happens to be true in roughly every single other American industry, but I've been exasperated by this enough to point out that the people opposing expansion are generally shortsighted hypocrites -- bring on the evictions, so that the nonwhites who comprise 75% of my scrum team can live in the city where they work, maybe. And I'd like to apologize apostrophically for stealing my coworkers' right to represent themselves.
- swatow 12y agoIn this context, Indians and Asians count as White. Why? Because in the narrative of the author, Whiteness is not a race, but rather a social construct designed to reinforce the privilege of Whites, and to enforce a uniform way of thinking and acting. Whiteness also serves to create and justify economic disparity. In this narrative, anyone who accepts this system, reinforces its values, and receives the benefits of Whiteness, is effectively White.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoThe tech industry is disproportionately asian relative to the population of the nation. So the whole thing is especially goofy.
- sandworm 12y agoSan Francisco has a soul? It's a port city. Like New York, Vancouver or any other city connected to the outside world San Francisco gets waves of different immigrants with each generation. Today's wealth is just another gold rush, of which SF has seen many. It's a boom-and-bust city.
- swatow 12y agoI'm commenting because I don't want this on the front page. Not that I am writing more comments that I would otherwise just to get it off the front page, but rather that I think that the reasons that this algorithm is used, apply to this article. As a tech worker I am sick of being degraded and dehumanized in the media, with terms like "twerp" and "soulless". What was our crime? Being awkward, White (or Asian or Indian) and male? Not living the lifestyle or having the attitudes that the Left require of SF residents? The left dehumanizes people that it wants to attack (often physically, as has happened in SF [0]). We should recognize that the dehumanization and degradation of tech workers is not only hateful and unjustified, but also likely to result in violent acts. [0] http://www.cnn.com/2014/04/14/tech/mobile/google-glass-attack/ http://www.cnn.com/2014/04/14/tech/mobile/google-glass-attac...
- ild 12y agoTechies are hated because, compared to old money, they seem to be (being young, probably why) self-centered, give no investments in community, are willfully agreeing to live in illegal condo conversion etc. And also, the type of techies who move to SF are more towards libertarian startupniks; humble Indian H1B workers all live in Santa Clara, Milpitas, Campbell etc.
- swatow 12y agoHow is this characterization of techies different to the reasons someone might give for hating Blacks, Jews or Mexicans? Because it's true? Are you going to require the same standard of evidence for these claims you make about techies, as you would if someone made similar claims about Blacks, Jews or Mexicans?
- ild 12y ago> someone might give for hating Blacks, Jews or Mexicans? Because: 1) The groups you mentioned above are too heterogeneous to pass any blanket judgment. 2) The conversation is not about techies in general (say a system admin in Shaker Heights, OH, a programmer in Tacoma, WA etc.) but narrow subset of IT people who is well aware of social tensions in city, caused by rapid influx of money, too busy/lazy to participate in improving social ills of the place _insist_ in moving in here, for variety of reasons, although they work in Mountain View. Keep in mind I do not hate them; I myself despise hatred.
- whybroke 12y agoIf there had been any doubt about the Guardian's accuracy, the responses in this thread have dispelled it. Not a single post stating there's a vibrant, interesting culture emerging but instead a flood of neo-liberal "screw you"s interspersed with a few "you're a racist" and a "being absorbed in your iphone is diversity" along with a "good riddance to the gays" for bonus points. Dear god I'm glad I got out when I did.
- swatow 12y agoThe problem with comments like yours is that you've chosen to shame the top level posters instead of replying to a single one of them. Shaming works well to enforce uniform beliefs in a tight knit social circle, such as you may have enjoyed in SF before the tech influx. It doesn't work so well online.
- whybroke 12y agoI am in fact a software engineer. When I lived in the city I had fiends who were social anthologists, post docs from over seas, drag performers, dance studio mangers, red cross workers even a poet. Not single one still lives in the city (even though one of them had a building named after him). I only make software so that I can have a rich life outside of a cubical among a diverse set of people who can teach me things. In today's San Francisco that sentiment is no only unobtainable but would render a person un-hire-able.
- brianmcconnell 12y ago21 year SF resident and tech worker here. A lot of the people who are complaining about the boom are using the late 1980s and early 1990s as their baseline, the time in SF's history when it was actually cheap. That was shortly after Loma Prieta, and at the height of the AIDS epidemic, before anti-retrovirals came out. People were literally dropping like flies back then. There was quite a lot of underground culture then too. A friend referred to it as the "dancing in the ovens" period. Since then, SF has reverted to its mean. People are moving here again, building new housing is systematically blocked by NIMBYism, and predictably it has gotten expensive again. This is really a failure of long-term policy. The tech industry doesn't help itself in many cases, but if housing had been in balance with demand, things wouldn't be so out of control. These things always go in cycles. The get rich quick period will end. The people who are only here for money will leave. The people who are here for the city will stay or come back.
- jcnnghm 12y agoSan Franciscans have no one to blame other than San Franciscans for the housing policies that are pricing people out of the market. Well meaning but ultimately deeply misguided liberals are still insisting that housing supply doesn't affect pricing (http://truth-out.org/news/item/26656-developers-aren-t-going-to-solve-the-housing-crisis-in-san-francisco-the-definitive-response-to-supply-side-solutionists http://truth-out.org/news/item/26656-developers-aren-t-going...), while others are are calling for a moratorium on building (http://www.bizjournals.com/sanfrancisco/blog/real-estate/2015/02/mission-district-moratorium-david-campos-calle-24.html?ana=twt http://www.bizjournals.com/sanfrancisco/blog/real-estate/201...). Meanwhile, in Washington DC, rents are falling because of the increase in supply, while both the population and number of jobs in increasing. DC also has a unique character that they've been able to preserve despite growth; San Francisco needs to do the same, and fast. San Franciscans need to start pushing the city for a lot of new housing units, probably 100,000, with expedited planning, approvals, and building if they don't want to get completely priced out of the market. More on DC: * http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/01/11/dc-rents-are-falling-are-house-prices-next.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/01/11/dc-rents-ar... * http://bigthink.com/ideafeed/falling-rents-in-dc-a-product-of-satiated-demand http://bigthink.com/ideafeed/falling-rents-in-dc-a-product-o... * http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-04-23/washington-faces-apartment-glut-after-boom-real-estate http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-04-23/washington... * http://dcinno.streetwise.co/2014/08/01/did-you-know-d-c-s-rent-is-actually-getting-lower/ http://dcinno.streetwise.co/2014/08/01/did-you-know-d-c-s-re... * http://dc.urbanturf.com/articles/blog/dc_area_rents_drop_3_as_new_apartment_supply_rises/7979 http://dc.urbanturf.com/articles/blog/dc_area_rents_drop_3_a...
- astrocyte 12y agoTech worker here who lived in the valley and frequented SF often. I ventured elsewhere about 3 years ago and recently visited friends for a week to decided if I want to come back. The city has definitely changed.. The valley has definitely changed. Cultured has definitely fled. Egos have definitely gone through the roof. People have definitely become more impatient and unfriendly (esp in SF). If I come back, I would live in either Oakland or Berkeley. The city looks a lot more worn (aside from the newly minted millionares who have refurbished the Victorian homes in SF). Things have become a lot more homogeneous (not in a good way) and scaled up to meet the expectations of the monied. I have several friends who have lived in the valley for about 10 years who are currently looking to go up to either Seattle/Portland or move out to Austin. Female friends who comment about the nature of attitudes of males in the valley and how they don't feel they can find a level headed husband... And this all has to do w/ tech. New Money .. Egos .. and ever escalating rent/property values putting even more pressure on expression, culture, art, and the 'chill' atmosphere that was hallmark of SF. The new types I could imagine enjoy it very much and the bay still has much to offer everyone. It is what it is. However, this time around (2015), individuals thankfully have more choices around America and the world to pursue a tech minded career. If the bay area doesn't excite you anymore, I highly suggest getting out of there and seeing other parts of the world and not just for vacation. I am constantly shocked at how much more I have begun to enjoy art/culture/music venues/socialization/biking/nature after having left the bay. People tend to drink the kool-aid while in the bay and believe it is the only and best place on earth. Maybe that is a good thing as it keeps the hidden gems from getting flooding w/ money. I've gotten a chance to live in a city that was on the rise and have carefully observed the way in which money has influenced the way it is shaped... Stuffy SOHO mixed use development condos priced at $300k+ .. art that i paid $70 for now goes for $600 ... Tinderfication of dating (everyone becomes a transaction). Drowning out of culture/expression. I guess it seems wise to me, from my experience, to simply move around and enjoy cities in their prime. Life is too short to sit around playing bidding wars for culture/housing and endure the snotty attitudes/foolishness therein. There is no reason to get hostile in objection to these truths. The SF/bay area of today is not the SF of yesteryear. Culture is absent. People are more tense. The goal is to cram people in like sardines (much to the ignorance of what the Nimbies wanted to preserve). Money talks is the new motto ... I don't even want to get into the race (doesn't apply if you're white/Asian) and gender issues that have become even more pronounced. I will be quite thankful if the next revolution in tech is not spawned from the bay area. Maybe it will focus more on actually improving society vs the current trajectory of monetizing people w/o compensation.