5 ms·
People who are hung up on ingredients being "natural" drive me nuts. I'm 100% for rigorous product testing to ensure safety, but if an ingredient is safe and a
by CuriouslyC 12y ago
People who are hung up on ingredients being "natural" drive me nuts. I'm 100% for rigorous product testing to ensure safety, but if an ingredient is safe and allows the creation of higher quality food, it shouldn't matter it is natural or not. Cars, the internet and modern medicine aren't "natural" either...
There are literally tons of people who will ridicule anti-vaccination nuts, then turn around and insist all food be "natural", completely oblivious to the hypocrisy.
- brandon73 12y agoNone of those are put into your body multiple times every day, a body which evolved in tandem with the natural world over eons. I'm not strictly a naturalist, though, but it makes sense to err on that side of caution, because evolutionary biology.
- venomsnake 12y agoIt didn't evolve in tandem, it adapted and began to modify "natural world" to suit it.
- Oletros 12y agoAlmost all of the vegetables and cereals we eat appeared after great modifications to the wild species less than 10 thousand years. How the body evolved to that? Were they natural?
- rayiner 12y agoThe desire for things that are "natural" arises from the wariness of ingesting something that hasn't been tested by time and human history. There's a long history of commercially-common chemicals that turned out to have tremendously bad impacts on human health (e.g. trans-fats, lead in gasoline). Vaccines raise the same concern, of course, but have dramatic and immediately obvious countervailing benefits that justify their use. In comparison, the only benefit from chemical food additives is usually saving a few bucks.
- bsder 12y ago> Vaccines raise the same concern, of course, but have dramatic and immediately obvious countervailing benefits that justify their use. Vaccines have an enormous amount of data logged, an actual trust fund dedicated to paying out if there is even a whiff of an issue, and regulators who oversee them. At no point has anyone shown a modern vaccine (last 20+ years) to be unsafe. Period. Quit spewing your uninformed opinions. This is in stark contrast to the food chain where quite a bit of it is uninspected.
- rayiner 12y agoAnd at no point in the last 2,000 years has anyone shown celery to be unsafe. Testing and historical use are both sources of confidence in the safety of something. Vaccines have the former, and I have quite a bit of confidence in their safety. Food additives don't really have either basis for confidence.
- ambrosio 12y agohttp://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8157392 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8157392
- ars 12y ago> At no point has anyone shown a modern vaccine (last 20+ years) to be unsafe. Period. That is simply not true. I am pro-vaccines, but your sentence is false. Simply google: rotavirus intussusception and you will see. His point about vaccines is 100% correct: Until the vaccine has been on the market for 10-30 years we do NOT know that it is safe. We might consider the risk worth it, but do not confuse that for "safe". This is equally true for all the non-natural food additives. The natural ones have the benefit of decades, centuries, or millennia of testing. (The only exception would be things like vanillin that are exact copies of known natural additives. I consider them just fine even if they are classed as artificial.)
- bsder 12y agoYes, let's (even though 1999 is almost 26 years ago, but okay, I consider anything after about 1990 to be "modern"): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotavirus_vaccine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotavirus_vaccine "In 1998, a rotavirus vaccine (RotaShield, by Wyeth) was licensed for use in the United States. Clinical trials in the United States, Finland, and Venezuela had found it to be 80 to 100% effective at preventing severe diarrhea caused by rotavirus A, and researchers had detected no statistically significant serious adverse effects. The manufacturer of the vaccine, however, withdrew it from the market in 1999, after it was discovered that the vaccine may have contributed to an increased risk for intussusception, or bowel obstruction, in one of every 12,000 vaccinated infants." Note the may. The number is so low as to make it difficult to correlate. That's 40-50 cases in a year. Aspirin kills that many in a year and we don't consider it unsafe and we take it for things which are lots less pressing. However, they pulled the vaccine because the perception in the United States is that we have adequate treatment for Rotavirus without the vaccine and it simply wasn't worth trying to correlate. "Meanwhile, other countries such as Brazil and Mexico undertook their own independent epidemiological studies which demonstrated that 4 deaths were attributable to vaccine, while it had prevented approximately 80,000 hospitalization and 1300 deaths from diarrhea each year in their countries." 4. You will get that many people dying of an allergic reaction to anything if you give it to several million people. More people die of peanuts in a year. Is that "unsafe"?
- bsder 12y agoAnd, oddly, a lot of this weird shelf-life ingredients dance could be sidestepped if we sealed and irradiated food. However, radiation isn't "natural".
- chris_va 12y ago"Extract of sunlight"
- xenophonf 12y agoMore like Cobalt-60 extract: http://www-naweb.iaea.org/napc/iachem/Brochure%20on%20gamma%20irradiators.pdf http://www-naweb.iaea.org/napc/iachem/Brochure%20on%20gamma%...
- bgvrofg 12y agoThat is an interesting idea, as far as I know you can radiate something and not have it become radioactive. I wonder what is the real reason it is not used, maybe it decomposes the food after a while? Apparently it is used in some cases ( very interesting [0] ), but looks like the fear is still big. [0]:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_irradiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_irradiation
- DanBC 12y agoThe real reason it's not used is because people do mot understand radiation and fear it in all its forms.
- bane 12y agoArsenic, Asbestos and Ricin are all natural.
- kefka 12y agoI use ricin my stir fry. It tastes great! (In all honesty, this proprietary and hidden labelling is what needs to go. Of course, that means people wouldn't buy these "foods", unless they had to or didn't care. I'd rather not be a guinea pig. In other words, I don't trust them to make sure what is safe or not.)
- rdtsc 12y ago> I'm 100% for rigorous product testing to ensure safety, but if an ingredient is safe a And how many long term tests have you personally performed or at least how many scientific studies have you persnally analized to know if an ingredient is 100% safe? "Natural" doesn't mean much these days. I presume here it means "it won't result in short or long term harm". > Cars, the internet and modern medicine aren't "natural" either... Yap not natural. And "new car smell" that so many people love and appreciety is pretty bad for you. > There are literally tons of people who will ridicule anti-vaccination nuts, then turn around and insist all food be "natural", completely oblivious to the hypocrisy. You mean real world is not 100% black and white? I think it is reasonable to assume vaccines are safe and result in a net benefit if taken yet to being skeptical of new and untested long term compounds. This has happened many times with known "safe" chemicals that let us down. BPA and plastics, DDT, medication that caused birth defects. The track record of vaccines letting us down doesn't come close to that.
- whytry 12y agoNatural used to be something but then the industry coopted that so now it means nothing. Just because some people still want actual natural food doesn't mean that they're wrong just because it's now a meaningless term in the food industry. It's getting to the point where language is breaking down because as soon as a customer knows how to ask for what they want, the industry wants to change the definition of that word to mean high profit margin.
- mrgriscom 12y agoIt actually might soon be considered an eating disorder: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orthorexia_nervosa http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orthorexia_nervosa
- odiroot 12y agoThis one linked from your article is actually more relevant to the original post: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemophobia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemophobia
- holri 12y agoCars for example do have a negative impact on hour health. They are unnatural prosthesis. We do not use our natural foot anymore. Therefore we are getting fat and immobile.