9 ms·
Komodia SSL certificates are in many products
- jrochkind1 12y agoUm, this is missing even a link to an explanation of what the issue actually is, seems to just assume the reader knows. I do not and googling isn't working out. Am I being dense?
- jlgaddis 12y agoClick on any of the number of links on the front page concerning "Lenovo" or "Superfish".
- quadrature 12y agoSomeone extracted the certificate from superfish and found that the key was protected with a password. The password turned out to be "komodia" which is a company that makes an ssl redirector. this has lead to people looking at komodia certificates. more information here http://blog.erratasec.com/2015/02/extracting-superfish-certificate.html#.VOZygi5O0ro http://blog.erratasec.com/2015/02/extracting-superfish-certi...
- x0x0 12y agotl;dr Komodia is a company that makes an SSL hijacking product, as described on their site: Our advanced SSL hijacker SDK is a brand new technology that allows you to access data that was encrypted using SSL and perform on the fly SSL decryption. The hijacker uses Komodia’s Redirector platform to allow you easy access to the data and the ability to modify, redirect, block, and record the data without triggering the target browser’s certification warning. [1] A necessary feature of such a product appears to be the inclusion of the private SSL key in any product using their hijacking tech and the installation of komodia as a valid certificate in the OS certificate store. Therefore, anyone who wants can buy a product using Komodia, extract the private SSL key, and MITM at will any computer infected with any product using Komodia software. Any website protected by SSL where that SSL authority isn't pinned by chrome (do other browsers have such tech?) is now trivially vulnerable to SSL hijacking by, eg, anyone in the same coffee shop or local network. And, of course, between that user and their destination site. The current kerfuffle is due to the fact that Lenovo was caught pre-installing Superfish, an adware/spyware product -- for the users benefit! -- that, in turn, installed the Komodia ssl hijacking toolkit and broke SSL on any such infected computer. The race is now on for every goddamn script kiddie in the entire world to the bank accounts of any suckers that trusted Lenovo. Go up to Seattle where windows laptops are more common, roll into a coffee shop, and I bet you can earn yourself some bank account logins. ps -- this is a reason people buy macs. You get a vanilla OS install; that's currently only really available for Windows afaik from the Microsoft store. [1] http://www.komodia.com/ http://www.komodia.com/
- mikeash 12y agoI've barely touched a Windows machine in many years, so I'm a bit out of touch. How difficult is it to do a clean, vanilla install on one of these computers these days? I imagine that's the first thing you'd want to do after pulling it out of the box.
- x0x0 12y agoFor people reading this, probably not hard, merely annoying. Though note that you may have to pay for the install media; the recovery disk / partition is infected with the same adware/spyware that came preinstalled. For most people, it's not going to happen without help.
- e12e 12y agoDon't you actually need to buy a new license? I don't think you can activate any 3rd party installer (say downloads via microsoft.com, making an usb key) with the oem serial? Not sure though, the only windows license I'm currently using isn't OEM, it's a full 8.1 pro license. This does sound like a good argument for wiping the OEM windows 7 pro partition on my laptop, and install a windows 10 trial or something (I currently just run Debian GNU/Linux on it -- but it's technically dual-boot).
- lurkinggrue 12y agoDell is about the only manufacturer that will let you get generic install DVDs. They use a bios based licensing system these days so you don't even have to deal with those issues so much. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/System_Locked_Pre-installation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/System_Locked_Pre-installation
- netheril96 12y agoDon't know why you are downvoted. Before I switched to Mac (now I know what a good choice I made!), I find that installing fresh Windows without piracy is incredibly hard. The so called OEM embedded serial key works only sometime; Other times, the fresh Windows will ask me to buy and activate it. Utterly confusing even for a techie like me. So I installed a pirated Windows.
- notsony 12y agoHowever distasteful Lenovo's business decision to bundle adware on their consumer laptops, the finger of blame should now rightly point to the third-party software provider, Komodia. Lenovo did not vet the software properly before bundling it and heads should roll, but I do not think they are deliberately evil or malicious. If Lenovo are to be condemned, then the entire open-source community must also condemn itself for allowing OpenSSL and Bash to have remained vulnerable for so long. Just like Lenovo, our eyes were wide shut, and it took a shock to open them.
- 0x0 12y agoOpenssl and bash serve useful purposes and don't try to sneakily alter the user experience without being upfront about it. Pretty big difference, there.
- Argorak 12y ago"Point to the supplier" is a standard tactic, but also wrong. They did put their customers up to harm, for no other reason then trying to squeeze another buck out of them. They provide no additional benefit to the customer. OpenSSL and Bash are free services providing benefit to their users.
- orblivion 12y agoOne counterpoint, if a minor one, is that Lenovo still maintains that this posed no security concern.
- crazychrome 12y agoLenovo customers pay $$, man. Lenovo is either incompetent or evil. you pick.
- takluyver 12y ago> Lenovo is either incompetent or evil. you pick. (S)he picked incompetent: > Lenovo did not vet the software properly before bundling it and heads should roll, but I do not think they are deliberately evil or malicious.
- 12y ago
- maaaats 12y agoHonestly, this adds nothing new to the discussion. "Everywhere" with no data to back it up.
- razster 12y agoI believe this is click bait. Seems that way to me anyway.
- tlrobinson 12y agoHere’s some that have been found so far: Komodia’s “Keep My Family Secure” parental control software. Qustodio’s parental control software Kurupira Webfilter
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- slipstream- 12y agoIn case you're wondering, the keys/certs are different for each product. https://gist.github.com/Wack0/17c56b77a90073be81d3 https://gist.github.com/Wack0/17c56b77a90073be81d3
- lurkinggrue 12y agoI'm sure it isn't that hard for somebody to get their hands on the private keys for those products and I bet they used the same password. Edit: LOL, ok so the keys are right there on that link. Nice!
- crazychrome 12y agoI bet it's going to be linked to NSA, GCHQ and IDF in tomorrow's news paper.
- jgrahamc 12y agoWell, if you want to go down that path just visit the Komodia about page: http://www.komodia.com/about/ http://www.komodia.com/about/ Barak Weichselbaum founded Komodia, Inc. in 2000, following his military service as a programmer in the IDF’s Intelligence Core. But you don't need to worry about provenance to see that technically this is a scary thing to do.
- woodman 12y agoConscription make the military service irrelevant.
- leesalminen 12y agoWhen you join the military, either through conscription or of your own free will, their first job is to train you psychologically so that your beliefs are aligned with theirs. It usually works.
- woodman 12y agoYup, and it is a temporary effect - that is why there is a graduated rank structure. As the mental conditioning (to put it charitably) wears off, you are further removed from danger and positions where immediate obedience to orders is necessary.
- rdtsc 12y ago> Conscription make the military service irrelevant. Consription in the IDF’s Intelligence Core doesn't
- woodman 12y agolol, first of all - it is corps, not core. Second, these are the same people that monitor cctv feeds of border fences - it isn't some elite unit of super hackers.
- StavrosK 12y agoI find it funny that "komodia" is Greek for "comedy".
- fmela 12y agoThe founder of Komodia talks about how their products work (2010): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hCuTRzFY9CQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hCuTRzFY9CQ