18 ms·
Extracting the SuperFish certificate
- passfree 12y agoWell done :)
- jessaustin 12y agoIs it good or bad that they made no attempt at all to obfuscate the cert and password? I mean, obviously this whole stupid MitM attempt is stupid, but by leaving this stuff totally in the clear, can they claim to have done all this out of stupidity rather than out of a callous disregard for the security of their customers?
- xnyhps 12y agoThey added a password to the private key which they didn't have to, so it's not true that they didn't attempt to obfuscate it at all. In practice that only bought them a couple of hours at most, but why add a password unless you're trying to stop people from using it?
- spacefight 12y agoThey didn't "buy hours" - they didn't really have a defense line there. They cashed in the day they signed the contract with Lenovo. Someone should sue to see these contracts open in the public.
- mikeash 12y agoIf you subscribe to the idea that you shouldn't assume malice when stupidity suffices, maybe the programmer in question just saw somewhere that it's good practice to use a password on private keys, and didn't understand why you do it or how it helps.
- jessaustin 12y agoYeah that's another point for the "don't blame us because we're stupid" argument. They're actually so stupid that they use a password, that's stored in the same place as the cert. If they used any of the standard anti-reversing techniques, that would have implied enough sophistication to be expected to know how TLS certs work, thus enough sophistication to know to just generate new certs on first use. One would have expected Commodea to make this automatic for their poor stupid customers, however.
- xnyhps 12y agoLooks like the software they were using indeed requires a password on the private key: http://www.komodia.com/wiki/index.php/Komodia%27s_Redirector_API_Guide#Flags http://www.komodia.com/wiki/index.php/Komodia%27s_Redirector... (Down near the bottom, "sslpsd - To the password of the root CA (it's mandatory).")
- qzw 12y agoThe implementation may be mostly stupidity/laziness as they probably just used Komodia's ad injection SDK: http://www.komodia.com/ad-injection-sdk/ http://www.komodia.com/ad-injection-sdk/ But if you look at what Komodia says on that page regarding anti-virus: "The SDK has anti virus capabilities and each compiled version generates a totally new version." it's pretty clear they know this is something that most people would consider to be malware rather than just run of the mill adware. So the blatant disregard for users appears pretty malicious.
- murbard2 12y agoUseless. What would have been valuable would have been to generate a random private key at installation time. As it stands, it seems like the private key extracted can be used to mitm all Lenovo users.
- danielweber 12y agoYes. There are a bunch of legit proxies that do this already, and they know that when they mess with SSL they need to be careful.
- chinathrow 12y agoLegit? Care to elaborate? I am really interested.
- guscost 12y agoDebugging proxies like Fiddler (Windows) or Charles (Mac) generate a certificate if you want to inspect HTTPS.
- userbinator 12y agoSome ad-removing proxies (basically the exact opposite of Superfish?) and antivirus need to do MITM on SSL as otherwise they would be completely ineffective against ads or malware served via SSL.
- sillysaurus3 12y agoIs it true that an antivirus program like Microsoft Security Essentials installs a cert into the system cert store in order to MITM all network traffic?
- barrkel 12y agoNo. Some != all.
- 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- brohee 12y agoIt was obfuscated. The "product" uses an obfuscating executable packer. It was extracted from a memory dump not from reversing the program.
- im2w1l 12y ago>[strings] is an ancient (mid-1980s) program that simple extracts human readable strings out of a binary file, discarding the rest. It's really a stupid simple program. No it isn't. http://lcamtuf.blogspot.se/2014/10/psa-dont-run-strings-on-untrusted-files.html http://lcamtuf.blogspot.se/2014/10/psa-dont-run-strings-on-u...
- lucb1e 12y agoThen again, he did let the 'malware' infect himself. (Ghetto reversing as he calls it.) I'm pretty sure it wouldn't be a big deal if strings failed... but you still have a good point!
- tomjen3 12y agoMy guess is that he ran in a vm, at least that is what I would do.
- Someone1234 12y agoNo it isn't, what? Nothing he said discounts what you added. You should have just said "be careful with strings" and linked your link, rather than making some vague hand waving correction which wasn't...
- im2w1l 12y agoIt isn't a dumb and simple program. It does a lot of complicated stuff under the hood, and it is good to be aware of that.
- mynameisvlad 12y agoIt's simple in what it does, which is what the OP was going for. He never really made any claims of it being simple in how it does it.
- geofft 12y agoIt's not a complicated thing it does at all: it uses the standard system facilities for opening an object file to scan through the data section instead of the entire file. In the '80s, it used a.out format, which was dead simple. Today, GNU strings uses the GNU libbfd library, which is quite a bit more complicated, although the fundamental process of parsing an ELF file is also not that complicated. The actual problem here is that such a dumb simple task as parsing an ELF file isn't something you'll do without vulnerabilities, if you're not paying attention to vulnerabilities. Run `man elf` on your favorite Linux system, and you'll see docs of <elf.h>, which you can use to read ELF files. Write something to just dump the text section -- it shouldn't take you more than like 30 lines of C. Then tell me how many integer overflows you managed to squeeze in those 30 lines. :)
- jere 12y agoThis is incredibly interesting. I was like cheering at this point: >I could just use the file super.txt as my dictionary!
- NanoWar 12y agoFunny how I just bought a Lenovo yesterday, then read about this MitM issue and today it's cracked :-/
- robin_reala 12y agoTime to wipe and install a fresh OS then.
- jbigelow76 12y agoThat is normal protocol for any new PC I buy. The crapware that PC manufacturers don't even bother trying to hide like antivirus, photo management, browser helpers etc... always warrants an OS wipe after unboxing. If my next laptop isn't from Apple it will be one I can buy from Microsoft directly where they don't install any of that garbage.
- Symmetry 12y agoANother reason to install your own OS is that SSDs are much cheaper from Newegg than as laptop upgrades.
- Someone1234 12y agoTo be honest if you purchased a consumer grade Lenovo machine then malware is the least of your concerns. That thing will be a paper weight within a year. They're like the "Gateway" laptops of yesteryear. Thinkpad is still "fine" but Lenovo's consumer stuff is utter junk of the highest order. Source: Worked at a startup which purchased consumer laptops (shudder). Asus were "fine," Acer/Dell was "ok," Lenovo were horrifying, only being beaten by an unbranded laptop we had. So I'd highly recommend avoiding Lenovo's stuff unless it is a Thinkpad.
- seansm 12y agoWhat about Toshiba's
- snsr 12y agoLooks like Superfish (and Lenovo) are using this malware - http://www.komodia.com/products/komodia-redirector/ http://www.komodia.com/products/komodia-redirector/
- qzw 12y agoYeah, they even have a page specifically geared toward people who want to use it for ad injection: http://www.komodia.com/ad-injection-sdk/ http://www.komodia.com/ad-injection-sdk/ Edit: spelling
- robin_reala 12y agoThat page is scary reading. They’re actively selling their product as resistant to AV software and warning that it might be targeted by Google/Microsoft in the future.
- tempestn 12y agoTechnically they're saying that their competitors might be targeted by Google/Microsoft. But yes, it's messed up that a company is openly advertising their malware product like this.
- markbnj 12y agoYep, I was just thinking the same thing. Pretty horrifying to read "The SDK has anti virus capabilities and each compiled version generates a totally new version" and realize that a major PC OEM knowingly installed this on new systems. It's malware in every sense of the word.
- PhantomGremlin 12y agoNo honor among criminals. They also: Actively remove global proxy injected JS by either removing the JS from HTML or blocking the requests to the ad server. So if someone else injects JS, they remove it before injecting their own.
- 12y ago
- weld 12y agoLooks like the technology used by Superfish is SSL Digestor by Komodia.com
- omnibrain 12y agoIt will be interesting to see where (and in which applications) this particular cert shows up now people start looking for it.
- Kronopath 12y agoQuestion for the more legally-minded among us: Can Lenovo face consequences over this? I mean, they deliberately crippled the security systems of their consumer goods, presumably without properly notifying their customers. That sounds like the kind of thing a company could, or should, get sued for.
- compbio 12y agoDutch IT lawyers [1] say that Lenovo could be breaching European and Dutch Law. More specifically the "cookie law" which says that explicit permission is needed to change and read data from a user's computer (Lenovo never asked explicit permission). I also hear mentions of breaching the "computer intrusion" law (classifying this as a hack) and even the "communications tapping" law (Lenovo is not licensed to MitM your connections). I do not think a EU class-action or private citizen lawsuit will follow, but perhaps the official institutions can hand out a big fine. However, if Lenovo MitM'ed your connections and you can prove that, that would in principle be enough to get this case in front of a tort judge. [1] http://tweakers.net/nieuws/101472/lenovo-overtreedt-wet-met-voorgeinstalleerde-malware.html http://tweakers.net/nieuws/101472/lenovo-overtreedt-wet-met-... (lang:nl)
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoI don't know Dutch law but I'm interested you say "tort judge" - unauthorised access to computing systems is made a crime in EU. It should be a criminal prosecution.
- jfoutz 12y agoDidn't they come that way? It's not like they secretly snuck into your house and changed your computer. They sold something broken. It's the difference between going to your house and breaking the latch on your window, vs selling you a window that won't latch.
- DennisP 12y agoIf I sell you a window that only appears to latch, and then come by later and rob your house, I might face criminal charges. Lenovo didn't just sell something with broken security. It purposely broke the security, and profited from it.
- SixSigma 12y ago| sort | uniq > super.dict why not | sort -u > super.dict
- bdb 12y agoMuscle memory.
- Gravityloss 12y agoEasier to remember? You have to remember switches for every command, while commands like sort only need to be remembered once.
- robertgraham 12y ago'cause I'm a Windows user who don't know the advanced flags of Unix command-line tools
- dpritchett 12y agoCode is not the only sort of thing with an optimal chunk size. Languages and APIs (such as sets of library or system calls) run up against the same sorts of human cognitive constraints that produce Hatton's U-curve. Accordingly, Unix programmers have learned to think very hard about two other properties when designing APIs, command sets, protocols, and other ways to make computers do tricks: compactness and orthogonality. http://www.catb.org/esr/writings/taoup/html/ch04s02.html http://www.catb.org/esr/writings/taoup/html/ch04s02.html
- sbi 12y agoWhat charming casual racism. "It's pretty ghetto" ... "The ghetto way is just to run this on a machine" ... "The ghetto reversing is to run strings."
- twosheep 12y agoIs that racist? I thought ghetto just meant poor/inelegant, across all colors and nationalities.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jessaustin 12y agoWhen sbi sees the word "ghetto", she thinks of a particular race. So this is a case of the pot calling the kettle... Whoops! Never mind...
- antsar 12y agoRacism? Webster's definition[0] of ghetto (and that of any other respectable dictionary) makes no reference to any particular race. Would the phrase "the poor man's solution is to run strings" also be racist, by your logic? [0] a part of a city in which members of a particular group or race live usually in poor conditions; the poorest part of a city
- mbrubeck 12y agoThat's only one of the definitions in Webster. It also includes: > 1: a quarter of a city in which Jews were formerly required to live http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/ghetto http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/ghetto (Note: I'm not calling the article's author racist, just noting that the above claim about Webster is factually mistaken.)
- integraton 12y agoIn the US for the past many decades the word "ghetto" has referred to qualities associated with poor urban american neighborhoods, specifically black neighborhoods, and only has a historical connection to jewish ghettos. http://www.npr.org/blogs/codeswitch/2014/04/27/306829915/segregated-from-its-history-how-ghetto-lost-its-meaning http://www.npr.org/blogs/codeswitch/2014/04/27/306829915/seg...
- nailer 12y agoWhy would they voluntarily distribute their own private key?
- nothrabannosir 12y agoIt's a local proxy, meaning the certificate needs to be deployed locally.
- nailer 12y agoAh - I'd assumed they had a box in China somewhere that was MITMing and injecting the ads. Thanks.
- chinathrow 12y agoWell, if you look at what the SDK could do - that isn't too far out of reach: http://www.komodia.com/products/komodia-redirector/ http://www.komodia.com/products/komodia-redirector/
- mahouse 12y agoTaking away the legal aspect, that would be incredibly slow and easily noticeable.
- sillysaurus3 12y agoIt wouldn't delay the page load time, so it doesn't seem like it would be slow or very noticeable. As a user, at most you'd notice ads popping up a few seconds after the page loaded. But users without adblock are used to such things. And as long as the adware reserves a blank space on the page to display ads, the ads won't mess with the layout of the page when they load. EDIT: Why has this been downvoted twice? It's absolutely correct. It's a strange day when you post something unambiguously true to HN and it gets summarily downvoted. The only part that isn't unambiguously true is that "most users without adblock are used to such behavior already." But I stand by that phrase, because "most users" are people who understand almost nothing about about computers. Remember, downvotes are reserved for trolls and people you disagree with, not something which you think is "maybe untrue but I don't know whether it's true." I've complained in the past about having to write epic edits because people don't follow this so I have to explain myself further. Maybe you want more explanation about how precisely the above MITM would work? Here's how: The page loads. This completes normally, and the user doesn't see anything differently. In the meantime, Superfish reads the network traffic that has loaded. It also has injected some javascript in order to reserve a spot on the page to display ads. This would be a big blank space where the ads go after they load. Now the network traffic is sent off to China or wherever. It's analyzed on a server, then the server sends back commands to Superfish about what to do, like "Display ad 91234128 at X,Y spot on the webpage." The total roundtrip time would be no more than a few seconds. China isn't the moon. Half the speed of light is fast.
- samsk 12y agoThere is a way how to identify MITM on HTTPS connection. If you are using SSL cert authentication via HTTPS, than it stops working, because browser (at least my FF) will not know that it should send a client cert to server and you can not 'login' (not analyzed it deeply)... I discovered it when I'be bought Lenovo Yoga2 Pro in December, and I could not login to my site that is using SSL cert authentication. Google than recommended me to remove SuperFish...
- captn3m0 12y agoI think what you are referring to is Cert Pinning. [1]: http://security.stackexchange.com/questions/29988/what-is-certificate-pinning http://security.stackexchange.com/questions/29988/what-is-ce...
- rchowe 12y agoI believe the intent of the parent poster was actually correct. SSL client certificates [1] are a way to securely authenticate (i.e. login) by using a certificate which you control the key to in addition to the normal SSL certificate for the website. An over-simplified example: if Alice (A), a client with web browser on a compromised computer, wants to access the BigCorp website (B) she sends a challenge, such as a random string, to B, and B sends back the challenge encrypted with the BigCorp SSL certificate. Alice's browser verifies that the signature corresponds to a valid certificate, which it does because BigCorp's certificate is legitimate and signed by a legitimate CA, and then Alice's web browser and the web server negotiate a session key to use for SSL. If we introduce an attacker, Eve (E), to this, who has the key to a trusted certificate on Alice's machine, Eve can intercept Alice's original challenge and send back an answer to that using the trusted certificate, which Alice thinks is genuine because the certificate is valid in her browser. This is where certificate pinning helps, since if Alice has visited the site before, the certificate does not match and she gets an error. After the negotiation, Eve then has a session key to both A and B, and any data that A sends, Eve decrypts and re-encrypts with the session key for B, passing it seamlessly onto B, and vice versa for traffic going the other way. SSL client certificates break for a MITM attack for a different reason. When Alice is using an SSL client certificate to authenticate herself, she has her own certificate on her machine which she knows the private key to (it can even be self-signed). The web server knows Alice's public key (stored like a password hash in a database), and can therefore perform a similar challenge for Alice. When Eve intercepts this challenge, she cannot send a valid response back to the server, as the only valid key for Alice's account is stored on Alice's computer. Therefore, sites that let you sign in with an SSL client certificate often just stop working when you are being MITM'd. [1] http://www.symantec.com/connect/blogs/client-certificates-vs-server-certificates-what-s-difference http://www.symantec.com/connect/blogs/client-certificates-vs...
- soheil 12y agoInteresting, from komodia's website: "Barak Weichselbaum founded Komodia, Inc. in 2000, following his military service as a programmer in the IDF’s Intelligence Core." https://twitter.com/idfspokesperson https://twitter.com/idfspokesperson
- rjaco31 12y agoThis shouldn't be a surprise. As military service is mandatory, virtually every single Israeli company has been founded by someone who did some times, and the most tech savvy people usually end up in the intelligence stuff.
- danielweber 12y agoJoel Spolsky on his time in the army: http://www.inc.com/magazine/20080301/how-hard-could-it-be-lessons-i-learned-in-the-army.html http://www.inc.com/magazine/20080301/how-hard-could-it-be-le...
- madaxe_again 12y agoSurely, Intelligence Corps. "Intelligence Core" is rather self-refuting. As another poster says, this likely means nothing as all Israelis are forced to go through a military brainwashing program.
- rdsnsca 12y agoThe only way to get out of being drafted in Israel is to be pregnant. No way out for a male.
- rmc 12y agoPedantically some (trans) men can get pregnant. Downvotes for pointing out something that has happened: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Beatie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Beatie
- fny 12y agoNot true. Certain cultural groups (e.g. orthodox, Arabs, Druze) and others are exempted: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exemption_from_military_service_in_Israel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exemption_from_military_service...
- annnnd 12y agoQuestion: how does it work if user goes to the page which has invalid / self-signed certificate? Does proxy sign the altered page with the same certificate as others, thus making the warning go away? This would leave you open to other parties' MITM attacks too (because warnings are silently ignored). Or do they leave the page intact if the page certificate is not legit?
- xnyhps 12y agoAssuming, from the password, that it uses "SSL Digestor" by Komodia, then yes, it should generate an invalid cert: http://www.komodia.com/wiki/index.php?title=SSL_Digestor#Cert_creation http://www.komodia.com/wiki/index.php?title=SSL_Digestor#Cer...
- sergiotapia 12y agoAnd people scoff at the idea of buying an Apple laptop. Lenovo used to be championed around as the best competitor because of it's hardware, but this comes to light: What do you say to that? For the past 5 years Apple has had the best laptops in the world hands down.
- reitanqild 12y agoExcept quite a few of us can't stand them for various reasons: * the os does not feel practical (menu bar on only one screen? No universal home/end? No universal way to jump/select words like (ctrl + ->, ctrl + shift + -> on Windows and Linux) * non-standard keyboard layout, no way to adjust it (specifically fn/end) Mind you, I am a fan of Macs and recommend friends trying them but I don't want one as long as I cannot afford one laptop for work and another for photos and stuff. (btw: I didn't downvote you)
- exogen 12y agoFWIW, OS X has a menu bar on every screen since 10.9, and you can indeed jump/select words, just substitute Option in place of Control (always been that way AFAIK). What's "the standard" keyboard layout? Looking forward to that one. :)
- reitanqild 12y ago> FWIW, OS X has a menu bar on every screen since 10.9, Good. About time should we say? I left Apple three years ago. > and you can indeed jump/select words, just substitute Option in place of Control (always been that way AFAIK). Except if you use another application, then you have to use CMD or fn. But careful, cause in a third application that is a substitute for home/end. > What's "the standard" keyboard layout? Looking forward to that one. :) It's easier to tell when someone breaks it: * Adding shortcut keys on the sides of the keyboard so that I end up starting 5 calculators. (my wifes hp compaq) * Not putting ctrl in the lower left corner, nor letting me remap it, causing frustration every time I move from the full size Apple keyboard to the laptop or between almost any other machine and an Macbook. (Some thinkpads fails here but at least then you can change it in bios.) * not having home and end keys nor any consistent way of replacing them. Again I'm an Apple fan and I am happy that they saved us from older Windows phones but it is not for everyone.
- Shank 12y agoThere's an ongoing discussion with some members of the Chrome team on Twitter involving whether or not they should revoke the cert: https://twitter.com/matthew_d_green/status/568437037906444288 https://twitter.com/matthew_d_green/status/56843703790644428...
- higherpurpose 12y agohttps://twitter.com/agl__/status/568443835841261569 https://twitter.com/agl__/status/568443835841261569 Thanks for making HTTPS non-mandatory in HTTP/2, IETF!!
- JonnieCache 12y ago>Thanks for making HTTPS non-mandatory in HTTP/2, IETF!! You're shitting me!?! Who, specifically, do we have to blame for that?
- nickysielicki 12y agoThat is fucking infuriating. What was their reasoning for removing it? http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/ietf-http-wg/2013OctDec/0625.html http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/ietf-http-wg/2013OctDec/... >To be clear - we will still define how to use HTTP/2.0 with http:// http:// URIs, because in some use cases, an implementer may make an informed choice to use the protocol without encryption. However, for the common case -- browsing the open Web -- you'll need to use https:// https:// URIs and if you want to use the newest version of HTTP. Someone explain to me when "an informed choice" would ever come to the conclusion of, "Encryption? Not Necessary!"
- warkdarrior 12y ago> Someone explain to me when "an informed choice" would ever come to the conclusion of, "Encryption? Not Necessary!" I've been informed that encrypted web traffic costs money for the certificate and for additional server hardware. Thus I made the informed choice to use HTTP/2.0 without encryption.
- jkot 12y agoMove along, nothing to see here. Lenovo said there are no security concerns.
- joelthelion 12y agoI hope the people in IT departments who like to pretend things like Websense or Cisco Web Security are good things are reading this.
- jjarmoc 12y agoI've been hoping for years people would wake up to the risks of these things. I presented on the topic at Blackhat Europe a few years back, where I disclosed several certificate validation flaws in Cisco Ironport. I understand there's legitimate reasons for enterprises to want to decrypt and inspect TLS connections, but it's not without it's risks and downsides. If you're curious about my past work, see: http://www.secureworks.com/cyber-threat-intelligence/threats/transitive-trust/ http://www.secureworks.com/cyber-threat-intelligence/threats... http://media.blackhat.com/bh-eu-12/Jarmoc/bh-eu-12-Jarmoc-SSL_TLS_Interception-Slides.pdf http://media.blackhat.com/bh-eu-12/Jarmoc/bh-eu-12-Jarmoc-SS...
- userbinator 12y agoGood set of slides. Companies are more likely to be afraid of the other risk, which is why SSL interception is used - when malware makes use of it to avoid detection. Security cuts both ways. I think the most important point is that the user should be in control of the traffic, which means knowing whether or not interception is being used.
- jjarmoc 12y agoYeah, it's a balancing act, and there's certainly a desire (and probably even a legitimate need) to monitor encrypted comms for malware C&C channels, data exfiltration, etc. Your view seems to reflect a similar nuance as my own. Administrators need to weigh the risks and benefits as it relates to their own environment, and users should at least be aware that such monitoring is taking place. Beyond that, there's some technical challenges, but I see the bigger issues as political and expectation vs. reality alignment. There's also a video of my talk online, which I'd honestly forgotten about. Maybe someone will find it interesting; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7TNdHzwTNdM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7TNdHzwTNdM
- mmastrac 12y agoThe key is on Github now: https://gist.github.com/mathiasbynens/7a13a467b22c42505490 https://gist.github.com/mathiasbynens/7a13a467b22c42505490
- bigiain 12y agoAnd, you'd have to assume, in at least private versions of metasploit and wifi pineapple already...
- driverdan 12y agoI'm surprised hashcat doesn't support PEM files and there doesn't seem to be any public GPU based cracker.
- geococcyxc 12y agoIf the private key/certificate really is the same for every installation of superfish, it would be interesting to investigate whether the the key is shared by all the other customers of the SSL interceptor as well. Their references mention Barracuda Networks and Astrill, for example.
- danielweber 12y agoAs someone who used to work for a Barracuda competitor and would love to spill some hot soup on them, I'm very confident in saying: no way. Even if they were dumb and incompetent enough for this (they aren't), enough of their customers are savvy enough to demand they change it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- plorg 12y agoI was just browsing some pages on the Lenovo forums where users were complaining about SuperFish (some from January, one updated complaint from today). I refreshed a page and received a message stating that the forums are down for maintenance. Either this is damage control or the forum provider (Lithium?) was ill-provisioned for the current level of traffic.
- gaia 12y agoAnyone up for decoding the cert used by GoGo Inflight WiFi Service? https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150105/09344429597/gogo-inflight-wifi-service-goes-man-in-the-middle-issues-fake-google-ssl-certificates.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150105/09344429597/gogo-...
- moyix 12y agoThis is not likely to be possible. Rob Graham was able to do it for Superfish because the SSL interceptor resides on the same machine as the browser, meaning that the private key is accessible to anyone who installs Superfish. By contrast, the GoGo interceptor is going to be a computer somewhere either on the plane or possibly on the ground (at some GoGo data center), meaning that its private key isn't accessible unless you can somehow gain access to the interceptor system.
- namesty 12y agoIf you are a developer and want to disable superfish on your site, follow the instructions here: http://glipdev.github.io/ http://glipdev.github.io/ We discovered this a few months ago after customers with lenovo laptops were complaining that our site wasn't working for them.
- michaf 12y agoSo you could MitM between superfish and the internet, insert <meta name="superfish" content="nofish"> and everything is all right ;-)
- namesty 12y agoHah exactly!
- chinathrow 12y agoYou could have rung the bell a bit earlier ;)
- opinali 12y agoI hope tons of other computers, not just Lenovo's, that have Superfish will also be using the same certificate that's now compromised. Need more shit in the fan toward these guys.
- hurin 12y agoSo while individuals have been charged with numerous hacking charges and potentially decades in jail time for mundane things, such as obtaining plain text info and port scans. Lenovo which actually facilitated breaking ssl security on all of their customer computers is going to get away scot-free?
- crisnoble 12y agoIt is more likely that Robert Graham will be charged for "Unlawfully guessing a password and talking about it"
- kevin_thibedeau 12y ago"Ladies and gentlemen of the jury. We will show you how the defendant used the notorious hacker tool known as 'strings' to facilitate his vendetta against Lenovo."
- hipaathrowaway 12y agoThis. I've recently begun anonymously reporting HIPAA violations in FLEX pager systems. Unfortunately the act of demodulating these unencrypted signals easily obtained with a $5 SDR potentially constitutes a felony. This absolutely terrifies me.
- apsec112 12y agoLenovo is a Chinese company. If you move to China and get backing from the Chinese government, then yes, you can hack into US computers and get away with it scot-free. (Alternatively, if you stay in the US and join the NSA, you can get away with hacking into Chinese computers scot-free.)
- hurin 12y agoThat's not how the law works for multinational corporations - they are accountable to the laws in the nation in which they conduct business (which isn't to say they will be persecuted).
- benmmurphy 12y agoAre google or other browser vendors looking at ways of combatting this in the future. Would it be a massive privacy invasion to send back root cert details to the browser vendor so they can identify suspicious root certificates. It might be nice for browsers to flag locally installed root certificates and give some kind of visual indication to users but I'm not even sure how easy this is to do because a lot of browsers use the system roots and don't control the roots directly. its easy to identify the extra certs when you control the original roots. also apparently this doesn't go down too well with corporate users who want to install extra private roots for internal services or for MITM.
- nugget 12y agoIf Chrome implemented better cert checks, Lenovo (or anyone else) could just install their own version of ''Chromium, enhanced by Superfish'' for users and push them there instead. Who do we turn to then, Microsoft? (No thanks.) The party at fault here is Lenovo; I would be cautious to blame the tools they used. Also keep in mind there are many white hat uses for MITM SSL packet manipulation. If you lock down all the tools, pretty soon you end up with a walled garden controlled by very few parties (who then pull crap like this in the end anyway, with slightly better spin/PR).
- cheesedoodles 12y agoKeller Rohrback L.L.P is taking the opportunity to get in the spotlight by investigating possible claims [0][1]. Would be interesting to see the how it evolves. Looking at Komodias webpage, Lenovo could have a hard time defending that they did not know about its possible SSL interception. Failing to understand the impact is Negligence, at least. I would argue that decrypting the traffic is as intended by Lenovo. [0] http://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20150219006362/en/Keller-Rohrback-L.L.P.-Investigating-Superfish-Adware-Lenovo http://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20150219006362/en/Kell... [1] http://www.krcomplexlit.com/index.asp?N=attorneys-Seattle-WA-Lenovo%27s-Superfish-Malware&C=517&P=12472 http://www.krcomplexlit.com/index.asp?N=attorneys-Seattle-WA... edit: added original source
- tn13 12y agoI think there is one more party involved here that no one talks about. Microsoft! Sooner or later Microsoft will have to reconsider their partnership with hardware manufactures such as Lenovo for consumer products. Too much of choice and too much of competition has made consumer PC laptops shopping an unpleasant experience. Windows Surface Pro 3 however is an amazing device. In my opinion Microsoft should now come with their own laptops made by MS well integrated with Windows Phones, Xbox and Band.
- kazuho 12y agoWhile the blogpost is interesting, I am skeptical of the author's claim that the recovered private key may be used for decrypting user data transmitted over the wire, since private keys cannot be used for encrypting data sent to somebody else. What it can all do by itself is to decrypt data sent from others, or to digitally sign some data. I would suspect that the bundled private key was used for digitally signing data to show that it was actually generated by the software. The approach is not perfect (since the private key may get decrypted as the author did), but in general it would work effectively for kicking out third party software. If the developer's intention was to encrypt the data transferred through the public network, then he/she should have used TLS with server-side authentication, with optionally using clear-text credentials transmitted over the encrypted channel to authenticate the software (e.g. basic authentication over HTTPS). If it gets proved that private information could be decrypted from data transmitted over the public network by using the recovered private key, then this would be an interesting case of misusing public-key cryptography.
- kazuho 12y agowhy minus votes?
- maxerickson 12y agoBecause you've misunderstood the situation. There's no doubt that this key can be used to man in the middle user connections, that's what the software it was extracted from is using it for.
- kazuho 12y agoThank you for the comment. I think you did not understand my comment. It is true that the software is used for MITM. It is true that _Superfish_ is in the middle, decrypting the communication. OTOH the author claimed that it might be likely for _others_ as well to possibly MITM the communication, by using the recovered key. My comment is that such a situation is unlikely under the premise that the public-key encryption technology was used correctly (from technical standpoint, not ethical). EDIT: Even if it was the case that the recovered private key was used by the MITM server running locally for communicating with the web browsers, it wouldn't mean that others could use the key to decrypt data transmitted over the wire by using the key, since all the communication encrypted by the key would terminate within the local machine. EDIT2: Ah sorry, now I understand. The root certificate installed by the adware was using the recovered private key. That would mean that others can MITM the communication by DNS spoofing, etc. together with a server certificate signed with the recoverd key.
- halayli 12y agoUnless I am missing something, the only traffic you can decrypt is between the browser and the proxy which is localhost, not the proxy and the website(traffic you see on the wire).
- soheil 12y agoCan anyone verify if this is also on Chromebook? I just noticed today after I did a google search on my girlfriend's laptop, a few seconds later a section appeared called "Visual Results" she has the Chromebook Toshiba 1080p. This would be insane if in fact it is the same MiTM.