14 ms·
The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There
- iN7h33nD 12y agoSomething I have never understood. Why do employees have to give two weeks notice to an employer when the employer could fir you today with no notice at all? I understand that keeping you around for two weeks could be bad for them, but why isn't it bad when your quitting as well? I guess this could all be solved by forcing severance packages by law for a minimum of two weeks or something like that.
- fredleblanc 12y agoI see a two-week notice as a reverse-layoff situation. In many jobs, you're hired with the ability to leave whenever you want, which becomes more like a reverse-firing. But, of course, when you do that, you risk tainting your reputation within the industry, perhaps not being able to give references or worse. Depends on the industry I'd say.
- Delmania 12y agoUnless it's specified in your contract, there is no obligation to give your employer 2 weeks notice. It's nothing more than courtesy.
- lostcolony 12y agoAnd it's a -professional- courtesy, whereby you are maintaining a better relationship with the company you're leaving (because you never know if you might some day want/need to come back). The converse, a company letting you go effective immediately, no severance, is sufficiently discourteous that it will likely prevent anyone from -wanting- to come back, as well as will build a reputation for them that will likely prevent a lot of talent from even looking at them as a possibility. It behooves both employees and employers to keep their professional impressions positive.
- danielweber 12y agoYes, a company that lays off part of the staff without severance is telling all the remaining staff "get the fuck out now."
- pekk 12y agoThe real reason for the asymmetry between the conventional obligations of employee and employer is the underlying power asymmetry. A typical employee's life has a single point of failure in his employer, while a typical company doesn't any comparable dependency; it is one-to-one vs. many-to-one. Employees can't afford to get informally blacklisted, they'll have trouble paying bills. Companies can always hire another guy who needs to make rent. Employees stand to lose everything, but when companies go away, capital finds a way. When a typical employee's BATNA against informal blacklisting on the employer grapevine is minimum wage, homelessness or gun in mouth they have no expectation of control over the situation, even if they do nothing wrong. Whereas a company does expect to have control; all they have to do is not write down any discriminatory reasons, and just claim underperformance. So if they want you to dance like a bear, you'll either dance like a bear or start scrambling to fund your early retirement. That's why we have nothing to say any time someone raises the question of how it's fair for things to be so asymmetrical: because it isn't fair, it's just what you have to do to make your monthly payments.
- merijnv 12y agoFWIW, in the Netherlands many collective bargaining agreements DO stipulate a minimum notice for firings (barring special circumstances like gross neglect, committing felonies, etc.). For example, my first system admin job had a contract mandating 1 month's notice in both directions. Usually the notice given by the employer is longer than the notice given by the employee and the notice duration for the employer increases with seniority (so after several years I'd be owed 2 or 3 months notice). I think the main reason there's no notice by employers in the US is the lack of unions/organised labour to fight for rights like these.
- rhino369 12y agoIt's considered a professional courtesy, as is providing adequate severance. If you work at a place that doesn't give severance, I wouldn't necessarily give two weeks notice. But there is some law about notice. The WARN Act covers large employers who are conducting large layoffs. They have to give 60 days notice of large layoffs 50-500 depending on work site size and other factors.
- jarsin 12y agoIts because you should never burn a bridge no matter how bad you want to. Unfortunately something that is rarely talked about in our society is how companies burn bridges all the time in layoffs etc. So its a double standard. Nobody ever talks about this side of the coin when it comes to layoffs and how companies behave. Everyone thinks oh its legal for them to just throw you out with no severance so its fine that they did that. Then sadly anyone complaining about being laid off in that way is labeled a "bitter former employee", and quitting without giving 2 weeks notice is considered you slapping them in face.
- j2kun 12y agoThe author doesn't describe much of the aftermath of that firing, except to say that basically everyone lost their jobs anyway. I would have liked to hear about the remaining 10% of (the last group of) employees who were not fired. Did they perceive this incident as poisoning the well? I would guess so, but maybe everyone was just happy with their severance packages and got on with their lives. The effect was what I wanted to read in an inside story like this one, but it just wasn't there.
- jliechti1 12y ago“Abel, put that camera down right now!” Armstrong screamed on the call. “Abel, you’re fired. Out!” You can listen to the actual clip here (I wouldn't say he screamed at him, but it was forceful): http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_slatest/2013/08/11/audio_recording_aol_ceo_fires_employee_during_conference_call.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_slatest/2013/08/11/audio_reco... And the HN discussion on this article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6197081 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6197081
- shockzzz 12y agoThat was definitely not a scream. Maybe it felt like it, but it wasn't.
- jaytaylor 12y agoScream or not, it's still not a defensible way to behave.
- code_duck 12y agoTrue. But based on the situation and the accounts of his behavior, clearly the manager was under a lot of stress.
- DubiousPusher 12y agoAnd nothing says leadership like cracking under stress.
- code_duck 12y agoYeah, I feel sympathetic for the guy but I wouldn't want to hire him.
- DubiousPusher 12y agoThat's downright decent. Don't necessarily condone but always seek to understand. I'm picking up what you're putting down.
- tdicola 12y agoIMHO having everyone call in to listen to a pre-recorded message telling them they're fired is just as bad as the public firing Armstrong gave. At least have the decency to have a face to face conversation or meeting.
- gtaylor 12y agoIs this commonly done? I'd feel like a terrible person doing this. At the very least, have an actual human on the phone doing the mass firing.
- dsacco 12y agoYes, this is common. It's not just tech companies. As an example, a number of years ago Best Buy had a huge round of layoffs amidst a revolving door of unsuccessful CEOs. Stores that were closing did not know until a specific date, when they'd go into work as usual and open a securely delivered packet. If the packet delivered was packet A, it informed them that they were laid off, effective immediately - all employees of that location. Packet B informed them that they were not closing. They had no idea what the case would be until the morning they opened the packet, and the packet was delivered the previous night.
- vetler 12y agoWow. I've never heard of layoffs being done this way before. I guess it's a scalable way of doing mass layoffs, but still ... that is really cold-hearted.
- jonnathanson 12y agoIt's cold-hearted, but if scale is an issue, then some of the alternatives can seem equally horrifying. Is it really more humane to send a couple of axe-wielding Bobs to the office, set them up in one or two rooms, and then steadily parade people in and out over the course of a day, the rest of the team trembling and gossiping and worrying about when and whether their turns will come up, their eyes locked on every colleague and friend to slink back to his desk from the abattoir? Think about that at 1,000-person-layoff scale. If we apply some basic Little's Law math to the process here, we quickly see how "by-hand" firings would drag on for quite some time, perhaps needlessly prolonging the inevitable, and almost certainly disrupting work at the entire office for days on end. There is no "good" way to do this. I've never had to do it myself, and I can only hope I never have to. The thought of how "best" to do it would keep me up for weeks. At the very least, I suppose in-person messengers are better than automated voicemail recordings, or sealed envelopes. But even if using a human messenger, a mass layoff is not going to go down well for the people being laid off. There is something to be said for ripping off the band-aid (though perhaps in timed batches, so you're not just dumping N people out into the cold, to fight over the same jobs on the market all at once).
- pmorici 12y agoIs he saying that it's ok to fire someone publicly if it is for a good reason? Or is his point that it's inappropriate to fire someone in that fashion period?
- tempestn 12y agoI think he's arguing against both the method and the (lack of) reason.
- choppaface 12y agoIs there a good way to fire people? A nice severance package and some decency are desirable. The fired employee will likely never receive what's most valuable: a thorough and actionable analysis about what went wrong. In this case the company failed, and the laid off employees will probably never thoroughly understand why. In my own experience, I've seen several engineers fired because they were mis-hired into roles that were obviously bad matches (often intentionally to meet the VP's head count goals). Those engineers weren't really given enough info to reconstruct what happened to them. I guess the message of the article here is that Tim Armstrong dumped the full weight of failure on his team-- undesirable in the view of almost any philosophy of management. Furthermore, in light of Armstrong's experience, his acts were reckless as well.
- Terr_ 12y agoVery true, alas, the ways which are good for people are, regrettably, not the ways that are good for the company lawyers. In addition to the emotional/honesty difficulty of a good postmortem, there's the fear that somebody will say something to trigger a lawsuit, spurious or otherwise.
- cookiecaper 12y agoIt's not just about lawyers. The lawyers don't get involved until someone comes along and suggests that there may be a complaint; i.e., the people involved get alienated and offended before the lawyers enter the picture. Most people do not take criticism well at all and in all honesty, most people don't want a big, honest list of their infractions, even if they claim they do. Consider also that many times employment decisions are entirely petty and done just because someone in the chain of command doesn't like the "laid off" individual. There are various terms that are corpo-speak for this. Employment in an organization is really professional likeability management, which is a tricky, fickle field.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y ago>The lawyers don't get involved until someone comes along and suggests that there may be a complaint Lawyers are involved from the very beginning of a layoff. They make the template. >most people don't want a big, honest list of their infractions, even if they claim they do. If one's immediate supervisor is doing their job, the employee will already know what would be on the list.
- peter_l_downs 12y agoCan't read it (no LinkedIn account), is there a publicly-available copy somewhere?
- myhf 12y agohttp://pastebin.com/GtprNCXK http://pastebin.com/GtprNCXK
- houseofshards 12y agoit is available for reading even without the account. At least works for me.
- pdkl95 12y agoWow. They took the javascript-only, broken page stupidity even further than current fad frameworks that only serve up an empty <body> tag. This linkedin page doesn't even include a body at all: <html><head> <script type="text/javascript">...</script> </head></html>
- toothbrush 12y agoPeople who design such brazenly idiotic things should be promptly keelhauled.
- ryan-allen 12y agoThe web embraces random hacks like this, it wouldn't be what it is without people doing stuff like this!
- emp_zealoth 12y agoOh no! It wouldn't be a mess of glitching, flickering, sliding about "dynamic" content slots that would actually work better as a plain static website... There are webpages that cause firefox to need more RAM than AAA games Sarcasm for (I hope) sarcasm
- outericky 12y agoThose of use that worked through the first dot-com bubble can surely tell better stories than that. There is no graceful way to do it. One company I worked for, there were probably 200 people, and the CEO gathered everyone into a big room and started talking layoffs, kind of beating around the bush. But essentially saying a core team will stay on, while everyone else is gone. A person asked, when will we know if we are on the core team? And he just blankly answered, "Oh, we spoke to those individuals this morning" - Yeah, the collective gasp was something I will never forget. I had only been there a week but made the core team. 4 months later the company was out of business.
- masklinn 12y agoI'm reasonably certain you missed it. The "worst way to fire someone" wasn't the public way it was announced or the pre-recorded layoff messages, it was the firing of "Abel" in front of all his colleagues for — as far as they knew — doing what he was supposed to do: > I guess my point to CEOs and managers alike is this – don’t fire people in front of 1,000 colleagues for no real reason. To put it mildly, it doesn’t help morale. > If you are ever considering doing it, take a deep breath, and at least wait until you can meet with the person in private. Or, even better yet, perhaps you shouldn’t fire someone for no good reason at all
- cookiecaper 12y agoReally the article is not interesting. I think everyone knows that it's terrible practice to fire someone in front of thousands of their peers. I'm sure even the guy that fired Abel knew that, but didn't care since he was in the process of firing everyone else anyway. The discussion this article generates about how to fire people is much better than the article itself.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoSomebody should make "Nominations to Biggest Douchebag of the Year Award" and people making such decisions should be listed there by name.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- therealidiot 12y agoGrrr. Can't view on mobile because I don't have a LinkedIn account.
- leovander 12y agohttp://pastebin.com/raw.php?i=98g0MVGG http://pastebin.com/raw.php?i=98g0MVGG
- negamax 12y agoI was fired yesterday. To be truthful there's no right way of doing it. As someone who had been on both sides of the table, this is scarring moment for everyone.
- throwthisdude 12y agoI've fired folks and been fired and there is absolutely a difference between good firings and bad firings. A good firing is one where the manager has laid out the problem long in advance and given the employee the opportunity to fix it. (Some will argue that being put on a "plan" is just HR cover and that the firing is imminent, but that certainly wasn't the case with me. I wanted them to improve.) In general, my philosophy is that any true firing (non layoff) should be easy for the employee to see coming a mile away. If not, then you're not communicating well. If you've told a guy "look, you're a salesperson and you need to make X calls per day" and then they don't make those calls, well then you've given them a chance and they blew it. They knew they blew it and so the subsequent firing is both understandable and foreseeable. My own firing came out of nowhere and made no sense. 6 weeks prior I'd been given a raise. It was so egregious and personal, the manager himself was fired a few months later. Possibly the most flabbergasting part is that the company was scared to hire me back due to fears id harbor a grusge, gather evidence and sue them for something else later (which wasn't true). The whole thing was shocking and confusing to the point that I went through the stages of grief. It also shattered my faith that the world works in predictable ways: if you're a loyal, hard worker with a great performance record, you have nothing to worry about. Suddenly that safety was just gone. In subsequent jobs, no matter how well they say I'm doing, I feel I could be axed at any moment. It's a horrible feeling. I have very real scars from it. (Obviously.) So in other words, these are human beings. They deserve an explanation. They deserve a chance to do better (if it's performance related) and maybe they deserve a sincere apology for bringing them into a position that isn't working put like both parties had hoped. So yes, and this is very personal to me, there are good and bad ways to do it. Anyone who says otherwise shouldn't be employing or managing anyone.
- negamax 12y agoI agree with you. My comment was on the lines of 'whichever way you do this (the act of firing i.e.) it's going to leave bad impact on all involved'.
- hackerboos 12y agoI suppose only in the US it's this easy to fire someone. Here in the UK this would, more likely than not, be taken to an employment tribunal.
- slgeorge 12y agoYou are probably right, but the law has changed a lot in the UK in the last two years or so as I understand it. It's moved much closer to the US system for employees during the first 2 years of employment. The situations under which a Tribunal can be called, and the amount of support available to an individual has decreased. And, the total amount of money that an employer can be hit with is at a fixed level.
- aragot 12y agoHow is it legal to talk about it? Surely they've brickwalled them in the employment contracts saying "The employee agrees not to publicize events happening inside the company, with no limit of time, or the employee agrees to compensate the company for the loss of image"? How come the OP doesn't mind talking negatively in public about his former company? I've already signed a simple software EULA which specified: "You (the Customer) will not comment about the performance of the product in public".
- nitrogen 12y agoContracts are not laws, and one would have to be very crazy or very well compensated for a non-disparagement agreement to make sense. I'll take my rights to free speech and coordination with my peers any day.
- pluma 12y agoBTW, in some jurisdictions, a lot of clauses commonly found in contracts are invalid. Most EULAs don't hold any water in the EU, for example, especially when they contain "surprising" clauses (i.e. something a consumer would not reasonably expect to find in an EULA).
- facepalm 12y agoI am amazed by the idea to let people call a number and have them be fired by a prerecorded message.
- jacquesm 12y agoTotal cowardice.
- facepalm 12y agoSure - I'm not saying I am impressed in a positive way. It just amazes me that people even thought of such a thing. Although I wouldn't judge prematurely. I've never had to fire people. Perhaps an unemotional way works better.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoCould be worse. I'm now imagining individual calls all greeted with the same prerecorded message: "Hello SUBJECT NAME HERE. As of this moment you're no longer employed at SUBJECT HOMETOWN HERE branch of the company. Thank you for helping us help you help us all. <click>". (of course without substituting values for the template variables)
- facepalm 12y agoSounds like a Twilio project for an afternoon :-/
- lightbritefight 12y agoYC summer 15 is looking for start ups, so....
- lordnacho 12y agoI've been involved in letting people go. Sometimes it's surprisingly pleasant, sometimes it's predictably unpleasant. - Somewhat predictable. One of my devs just didn't want to do the work. You could tell he just wanted to be something other than a dev (which he admitted to afterwards). I mean he knew how to do it, it wasn't a complex task (read a file, compare it to a DB, show the differences). But after many weeks of zero progress, I decided enough was enough. I think he was relieved. - Pleasant: I call my remaining dev into the office. Me: "So, you know what's going on in the company, right?" Dev: Smiling, almost laughing his head off: "Yeah haha, I can't believe the boss blew that much money in a few weeks. It would take me ten thousand years to make that amount. Of course I know what's up." Me: "Glad you understand. You're right, I just worked out the loss comes to far over the total of everything everyone in my family (parents, grandparents, ...) has ever made in all of history. Times ten. Well at least you have the experience in finance now. More than happy to provide a reference. Anyway, gotta can everyone else now..." We even did the old Alan Sugar "You're Fired!" routine from the Apprentice on one guy, causing much laughter. - Absolutely shocking. So, the boss has hired a new trader, and he's coming towards the end of his probation period (3 months typically in the UK). Boss goes on holiday, and runs into a guy who says he knows this person, and comes up with some hearsay that is totally not checkable. Calls his junior managers (I was away), makes us can him right before the deadline. Lawyer tells us not to say anything at all about why he's being canned. Obviously, the guy wants to know why, but it's not like the reason makes any sense, and the lawyer of course doesn't want us sued. Dude goes red, appeals to common decency, starts shouting, but no. Just silence. I'm still annoyed about this thing. I never even got to say goodbye or any chance to tell him after the firm went down the toilet. Come to think of it, the boss had everyone fired through his juniors (me and a couple of others.)
- aaron695 12y ago> Quick side note. Obviously, this conference call was different than every other one we’ve had. But still, Abel was doing what he always did, and as far as I know, was given no instruction to do something different. This is not true. The employee had been specifically been warned about his behaviour before and told not to do it. [1] Don't go on about how it doesn't change anything, if it didn't then people would mention it in the story. But they don't because readers need that snide, they are better than others feeling to be clear cut. An employee going against his boss, while his boss is super stressed and then getting fired adds to much humanity. The original OP's story is interesting from a company facing layoffs side of view though. [1] http://www.businessinsider.com.au/aol-ceo-apology-2013-8 http://www.businessinsider.com.au/aol-ceo-apology-2013-8
- eropple 12y agoI'm curious when "photographs" (which, as described, were part of this dude's job) became "recording a private meeting" in the sense that any actual human being would mean it. Or when a meeting with a thousand people was somehow "private". So I won't go on about how it doesn't change anything--though it doesn't--but I will inquire as to why you'd cape for one of the most universally acknowledged jerks in the industry.
- runewell 12y agoI remember the good ole' dot-com days where the writing was on the wall once Webvan stopped coming to the office.
- caboteria 12y agoI worked for a company that was constantly hiring and laying off, often at the same time. The "tell" was if you showed up to work on Friday and there were Pinkertons at the front door then you knew it was going to be a rough day.
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoI worked with a startup a few years back where the CEO would get upset and talk about firing people. The first couple of times, I'm sure, he got great results. And he actually pulled the trigger and fired some people. But this went on for months. Once you start threatening to fire people? You've got nowhere to escalate past that. You're done. People just throw away any sense of civility and hang in as long as they think they can get a check out of you. Talk about ways to destroy your company morale. You should always fire quickly, gently, privately, and with kindness. You should never fire publicly and harshly. And you should never drag out firing somebody because you're too chicken to get the job done. You want to play the role of hard-as-nails company leader? Fine. People remember that stuff. You want to be a billionaire prick, good for you. But I'll never work for you. Life's too short.
- rhino369 12y agoThis is true even for rolling layoffs that are purely financial. Better to rip the bandaid off than go through round after round of layoffs. Nobody feels safe and everyone is looking for a life raft.
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoSome of the worst morale I've ever seen is in companies after they've gone through multiple layoff rounds. And it's a bitter thing: survivors are hard-working, political, and very cagey; the kind of place where everybody is friendly and out to help everybody -- but not really. In reality nothing is going to get between them and their personal goal. And it's very rare that everybody's personal goals line up.
- asrfull 12y agoI Did find this article interesting.
- sago 12y agoFired by pre-recorded message? What kind of spineless asshat does that?
- kuni-toko-tachi 12y agoA company exists to make money. It is not a vehicle for comfort or compassion. It does not matter one bit how much effort you put into it, unless you have a material stake in it, it is simply a job. You always have a updated resume. You always reinvest in your skill set and network. And when there are rumblings in the press, you hit the payment ASAP to secure a new role elsewhere. Being naive to the nature of these things is foolish and immature. I'm not being harsh, just honest. Challenge every raise and every bonus you get to check your value. Leave on your terms, or make them pay to keep you. When you realize this, being laid off is a completely enjoyable experience. It means you can travel, work on your startup, and move on.
- marktangotango 12y ago>>Patch hacked salaries, to the point most editors hired after 2012 were making less than $30,000 a year. >>You could almost make that flipping burgers. And this job required a college degree and experience. So is 'flipping burgers' not "no skill, minimum wage, part time" now? Maybe a cook in casual dining restaurant can make $30k, but nobody 'flipping burgers' at the Burger King is.
- morganvachon 12y agoHe does have a point though: There are many jobs out there that require a Bachelor's degree and at least some experience, but pay less than $35k per year. Local government is notorious for this. I recently considered applying for a job as a criminal intelligence analyst at a local agency. I have 14 years' experience in a closely related field of law enforcement, I have all the certifications they are asking for plus some, and it's a job I would likely enjoy greatly. But the starting pay was barely more than I'm making now. Given all the variables, I'm better off staying here, at least for the time being. Another example: Our regional victim-witness program, run by the state, requires a Bachelor's degree in Psychology and/or Sociology, and previous experience with courtroom work or social services. However, it starts at less than most of those social services or court clerk positions pay, and those jobs have much lower barriers to entry (basically, high school diploma and no criminal background). It's purely a "do it for the love of the job, not the money" kind of thing, and that would be fine except it's barely a living wage around here. Given that you're expected to be on call 24/7/365 on salary (i.e. no overtime/holiday compensation and no way to have a second, part time job), it's simply not financially viable for most people.
- commandar 12y agoI recently got offered a sysadmin spot with a local agency by an acquaintance that had taken over their IT department. Fortunately, government jobs actually post their salary rates so I was able to decline before either of us wasted too much time. They wanted someone to run the back end for an 18 county area, including supporting local offices. Starting pay? Between 26k and a starting cap of just over $30k/year.
- gadders 12y agoOfftopic: Abel Lenz (Able Lens) must be the best name for a photographer ever.
- yitchelle 12y agoIt comes back to the old rule to keep some sort of civility. You praise someone publicly, but you reprimand someone privately. This is totally applicable for firing as well.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoEarlier HN story about the Tim Armstrong fires Abel meeting [ca 1.5 years ago]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6197081 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6197081
- bane 12y agoI've been through a few weird layoffs. At one company, the division director and a vice president started walking the halls and would stop at a person's office, go in for a private meeting and lay that person off. News spread faster than the layoffs and by the time they got about halfway down the halls, the office was vacant ("you can't fire me if you can't find me"). It "worked" because it took another week for the rest of the people to get laid off. I survived, but I remember it as being particularly traumatic, like slowly pulling a bandaid off. It would have just been better to get everybody together in an all-hands and do the deed, then follow up with personal meetings for severance payouts etc. It only affected about 1/4th of the staff, but it was enough to send me out job hunting. At another place, they felt they had overhired for a PM position. So they called up one of the PMs and let him go -- with 30 days notice. His job, for the rest of his time was to take the surviving PM around to his customers, tell them he had been fired and that this new PM would be inheriting the work. The PM that survived described it as "the roughest professional work he'd ever done, spending all day with a dead-man walking". The company felt they were being compassionate with the 30 days, but it was absolutely demoralizing for both employees. Based on that I decided to start looking for another place right after that. There's not a lot of right ways to fire people, but there are definitely wrong ways. One "right way", at a small startup I was with, we had struggled for a while and simply run out of money, the lead investor got everybody on the phone, and simply announced who was being let go and their severance packages, and who would be staying behind. I survived, but based on my previous experience, I immediately started looking for another job. Layoffs are a bad sign for everybody, and I've found that the people who get laid off are usually the "lucky" ones. In every case, the people that survived the culling had it miserable and usually ended up getting laid off anyways just a bit later. It signals "the company is in trouble, our business plan is not working" and it's almost always time to just move on.
- monk_e_boy 12y agoFrom my experience, whenever a manager is let go the team soon goes and gets repaced by all new faces. It think when you see someone more senior go it's a catalyst for someone in that team to think "Ooops, time for me to go" and once one or two team members leave, the others feel resentment (didn't get promoted into the managerial position) or fear of change (rightly so -- a new manager is going to make mistakes and half the team is gone)
- michaelochurch 12y agoTim Armstrong is a Category 5 fuckstain. He's one of the few people for whom I'd laugh if he got a serious, painful illness. He singled out two female employees and their "distressed babies" as reasons for cutting the 401k match, in front of the whole company. He did not volunteer to reduce his salary instead. http://www.businessinsider.com/what-aols-ceo-meant-blaming-a-pay-cut-on-sick-babies-2014-2 http://www.businessinsider.com/what-aols-ceo-meant-blaming-a...
- rayiner 12y agoI forgot about that. Class A-DB.
- Lagged2Death 12y agoI guess my point to CEOs and managers alike is this – don’t fire people in front of 1,000 colleagues for no real reason. To put it mildly, it doesn’t help morale. There's an assumption here that Armstrong wanted to boost morale, because that's what a good person would do, or because that's what other effective managers do. And really, one very simple explanation for what would otherwise be a howling blunder like this is that it was damn well intentional; that it was exactly intended to provoke stress and anxiety. That destroying morale was explicitly the point. Is that so unthinkable? Fear and domination are popular management strategies when times are tough, and times have been tough in the journalism business - as the author takes some time to point out - for quite a while.
- leroy_masochist 12y agoHaving worked both in tech and non-tech jobs, I think firing hits people harder in tech companies, for one simple reason: tech companies spend a lot of time and effort trying to create an environment where people are made to feel special and valued. When people get fired, this entire world is upended, often without warning. The "without warning" part is probably exacerbated in many cases by the fact that especially at tech companies, most people over 35 seem paranoid about giving negative feedback to Millenials, or holding them to firm day-to-day standards in general. No matter what the company is, when it reaches a certain size it's going to have HR people and lawyers, and they're going to put processes in place so even if you want to take the fired person out for a beer and an honest chat about what went wrong, you can't. This discussion is centered on examples of the shitty ways people have been fired, but the really shitty thing we should be focused on is the tendency not to give people firm, dispassionate, detailed guidance on the company's expectations for their performance and subsequently give them accurate feedback on how they have performed relative to that standard. "We want you to crush it and do epic shit; I'm here as a resource if you need anything" might feel good to say to a new employee; it's a lot more pleasant than saying, "I expect you to know how to do X by Y date, while keeping me advised of any changes in A and B", etc. But the latter will reduce both your and their stress over the long run.
- ci5er 12y ago> most people over 35 seem paranoid about giving negative feedback to Millenials, or holding them to firm day-to-day standards in general Can you speak to this? I'm part of the over-35 cohort, but I'm not sure that I understand what you mean.
- leroy_masochist 12y agoWith the caveat that this certainly doesn't apply to everyone: I think that a lot of millenials, especially those who went to selective colleges, have a hard time dealing with active supervision and negative feedback. I think this is because relative to previous generations, millenials were raised in a more coddling environment -- participation trophies, grade inflation, etc. I think that this coddling is especially pronounced with regard to high-achieving children/teenagers, who by the time they are in their early 20's have a track record of "success" (i.e., straight A's, high SATs, got into college of choice, got job of choice), and who have basically been set up to suffer major emotional trauma at their first encounter with anything that significantly diverges from "success" as they have come to understand it. On the non-millenial side, I think that people of a slightly older generation see themselves in a bit of a conundrum, in that they want to get top talent (technical or not) from the top schools, they perceive that "kids these days" are a bit more sensitive and less overtly competitive than they were when they were that age, and get a little bit scared about the possibility of fucking up and putting the hot new developer (who was a "big recruiting win") in tears. So, they treat the new kid with kid gloves and basically keep their fingers crossed that he/she will be able to do quality work just by figuring things out on his/her own. I actually don't think millenials themselves are responsible for any of the above. It's the fault of their parents, the general environment fostered by the elitist college-industrial complex that encourages everyone to aspire to a 4-year degree (and which idolizes those who go to the top schools), and subsequently managers who don't want to take the risk of actually helping the people under their charge develop professionally and personally.
- chrisbennet 12y agoThe last time I was laid off, I was given a couple months notice. I was working for a 3 person company, all of us engineers. It was handled very nicely. Boss/Owner: "Our investor is cutting our funding from enough for 3 engineers down to 2 engineers." Me: "Gee boss, we're really going to miss you..." ;-)
- brewdad 12y agoA professional services company I worked for once did a massive layoff by calling everyone in our office at home on Thursday night and telling us to stay home Friday and wait for an envelope to be delivered via FedEx. If you were fired, you got info on severance. If you still had a job, you got info on next year's health plan options. Of course, some employees missed the phone call and showed up at work only to be locked out. I was 2000 miles away visiting my in-laws. I called in multiple times Friday morning trying to find out if I had a job to return to on Monday. Each time, it became harder and harder to find a manager who was still "with the company". I ultimately survived but that was not the most relaxing of vacations.
- AnimalMuppet 12y agoI heard (second or third hand) of this layoff at Evans & Sutherland back in the day. They first laid off a bunch of managers. But then there was nobody to tell their subordinates whether they were laid off or not. So they mass disconnected everyone from the network. If you could log back on, you still had a job. Full disclosure: Over the years, someone may well have told me that this story was not accurate.