4 ms·
It's bizarre. Pretty much everyone understands that better information can be extracted by gentle methods than by harsh techniques. That's not why the harsh t
by nl 12y ago
It's bizarre.
Pretty much everyone understands that better information can be extracted by gentle methods than by harsh techniques.
That's not why the harsh techniques are used. In the second paragraph of this article it give away the real problem:
Sometimes I got to the point where I had to literally order them to stop. Even then there was surprising blowback. People thought I was coddling terrorists.
The priority of those harsh integration techniques isn't to get information. It's a form of punishment, and a threat to stop others acting against US forces.
One needs to understand that frame of thought before one can stop the techniques.
- digi_owl 12y agoSeems to sum up the whole mentality of the US system. And i find myself wondering if it can be traced to the background of the original colonies.
- nl 12y agoNo, that's not it! The bizarre thing is the reaction on HN, not the US system. The US system functions exactly as intended, assuming you realise that it is designed to punish suspects.
- TsiCClawOfLight 12y agoBut how could anyone think that punishing in itself is helpful in any way whatsoever? This is an honest question, I really don't get how the American system could have been designed the way it is.