2 ms·
What about all the evidence saying that when you pay teachers for students performance, students learn less?
by Alex3917 17y ago
What about all the evidence saying that when you pay teachers for students performance, students learn less?
- tokenadult 17y agoCitations, please?
- Alex3917 17y agoAlfie Kohn cites a bunch of studies in Punished by Rewards.
- tptacek 17y agoHere's a good starting place: http://www.alfiekohn.org/teaching/edweek/meritpay.htm http://www.alfiekohn.org/teaching/edweek/meritpay.htm Also note that Kohn's ideas on extrinsic versus intrinsic motivation are hardly original. Most people who work at startups should find them collegial, since they're one of the key ideas in books like _Peopleware_.
- tokenadult 17y agoI hope there is somebody besides Alfie Kohn writing about this. http://www.britannica.com/blogs/2009/02/alfie-kohn-is-bad-for-you-and-dangerous-for-your-children/ http://www.britannica.com/blogs/2009/02/alfie-kohn-is-bad-fo... But what about the point in the originally submitted link that in most states NOTHING in particular is done to evaluate teachers?
- tptacek 17y agoThat's what you have to contribute here? A blog post taking Kohn to task for his tone? It's definitely true: Kohn is an archetypical bleeding heart liberal. I'm pretty liberal, and he makes my eyes roll. But that doesn't make him wrong. What he's saying about incentive pay harmonizes with what we as technology entrepreneuers already know about incentive comp, and with what we're already observing in school districts around the country. The teachers in Oak Park don't even get a pizza party for jacking up ISAT scores, but those scores are still a top-of-mind issue for them year round. A reasonable person could argue that it's better not to do formal evaluations at all, rather than smothering the whole school system with meaningless standardized tests.
- tokenadult 17y agoA reasonable person could argue as well that pupils (or their parents, their legal representatives) may just as well be empowered to shop for schools strictly on the basis of their own preference, just as customers shop for technology products on the basis of whether they like the products or not. Today, pupils are assigned to schools, and have very limited choice of teachers within the schools to which they are assigned. Just as I agree with you that workplaces are more pleasant when workers are honored and valued for their capacity to make decisions, so I hope the school system begins valuing learners for their capacity to notice when a particular teacher isn't a good fit for a particular learner.
- tptacek 17y agoIt always seems to me like private school advocates are weirdly unable to look more than a few moves ahead into this game. Maybe it's because they haven't had trouble with their school's management before, or because they've never worked for a private K-12 before. Subsidizing private schools hurts public schools in a vicious cycle. Private schools do not, as a rule, outperform public schools with students of similar backgrounds (even on bogus standardized tests). On balance, it's pure adverse selection: state-subsidized private schools that accept only students who are likely to maintain their artificially inflated performance metrics.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agojust as customers shop for technology products on the basis of whether they like the products or not. That might be a simplification on your part, if not it's naive. Customers don't have to like a product - they see an advert for it that tells them it's right for them, or their friend has one, or the guy in the shop sells it them because it's got the highest markup. * I hope the school system begins valuing learners for their capacity to notice when a particular teacher isn't a good fit for a particular learner.* So, a teacher is a poor performer - do you sack them and have no teacher or do you realise that poor education is better than no education? In order to get better teachers better candidate teachers need to come forward. Finally, parents have a large part in education - parents that teach respect for teachers will make the job easier and make the classes learning benefit. Parents that help with learning outside of school will help their children learn better.
- Alex3917 17y agoThe author of that post is wrong with respect to the quote he pulled out from p. 104 of PbR. If he had read the rest of the book, he'd see that Kohn makes all the same points that he makes in the rest of that paragraph. And with respect to the Education Week article, why the hell is he taking issue with a magazine article about the book instead of the book itself? While I agree that some of Alfie Kohn's arguments are questionable, this article is pretty bad; although it's largely irrelevant since the research behind PbR is pretty solid regardless.