4 ms·
Jesus, besides the merit of CB Insights' claim, this whole thing reeks of incompetence. You're a YC-funded startup and you can't do your own visual design? I'll
by danso 12y ago
Jesus, besides the merit of CB Insights' claim, this whole thing reeks of incompetence. You're a YC-funded startup and you can't do your own visual design? I'll admit that when I need ideas/designs, I'll often head over to the D3 gallery page, copy the relevant parts of the code, but at least modify it so that it looks different, and actually meets my needs. What's comical is not only did they purportedly rip off a design, but they ripped off a pretty prosaic one. And I don't know what's the worser sign of their operational capacity, that they signed into a competitor's product to take code/get inspiration, or that they couldn't even be bothered to come up with fake email addresses, or that it required 12 employees to go in and successfully make off with the designs.
Edit: Also, as a data-handling-person, the startup's defense that their inspiration is "only the way data is displayed" is annoying...data display is very important...but also, data display is the first thing people see, and I imagine is the thing that makes it into slidedecks in lieu of actual proof of quality of data analysis and data research...if you have the resources to be great and different at the "backend" part of data work, you most definitely have the ability to not just borrow someone's design...as good data display often follows a bespoke understanding of the data itself.
Also, I must credit HighCharts and its well-documented API as getting me through various crunch-time oh-shit-I-need-a-web-graph-right-now situations http://www.highcharts.com/demo http://www.highcharts.com/demo
- minimaxir 12y ago> if you have the resources to be great and different at the "backend" part of data work, you most definitely have the ability to not just borrow someone's design...as good data display often follows a bespoke understanding of the data itself. Given the incredible popularity of "big data" startups, this assumption I believe is incorrect. There are many data-oriented startups who have put out questionable data visualizations in the name of "content marketing." (e.g. Mattermark, another YC company, has been fond of doing this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8090617 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8090617 )
- samsnelling 12y agoI grew up playing a huge amount of basketball, and therefore have a completely different frame of reference here. In sports, you watch a lot of film and study your competition. You then take the best parts of your competition, and prepare to compete with them. Sometimes you take their best plays. Sometimes you you design new plays to actively exploit the other team. The point that I'm trying to make is: this is a competition. The fact that CB would even validate this YC company by writing this post - to me - is a defensive move rather than an offensive one.
- aasarava 12y agoI imagine that sports plays are not copyrightable. Web design and code are.
- api 12y agoThe thing that irritates me is that naive users would assume CB Insights were the ones who copied, as they don't have the YC brand. Not YC's fault per se... just how people generally use brands as a shorthand for merit. At this point YC is almost more like a meta-corporation with its individual startups as departments.
- avn2109 12y ago>> "At this point YC is almost more like a meta-corporation with its individual startups as departments." Yup, that's the idea. It was designed that way from square one. Deconstruction and postmodernism are the spirit of the age, after all.
- api 12y agoIt's quite interesting. There's one attribute of capitalism that I think is largely responsible for its success, and is likely the single largest factor that contributed to the USA's victory over the USSR: Capitalism allows permission-free innovation. In my opinion, markets get too much credit and are actually secondary to this. A market is just a way of performing goal-directed gradient descent and aggregating decision making. Markets are not by any means "efficient," and are highly vulnerable to getting stuck at local maxima like any other gradient descent algorithm. I think the ability to engage in permission free innovation is actually a much more significant advantage than markets. You could nix the market and implement some kind of socialism and I think you'd still have a fast, innovative economy if you allowed people to negate the bureaucracy. I'm not saying markets don't have advantages, just that they're not a panacea. I saw this when I worked as a government contractor. There was an incident within the org where I worked that had the effect of temporarily suspending the bureaucracy, and for that brief period of time it innovated like a small agile private company! Everything felt like it went vertical. Then the bureaucracy came back and all innovation halted. Now you had to ask permission, so nothing could happen. Thing is: as the size of a corporation approaches "big," its internal procedures and politics start to resemble government. Microsoft, IBM, and yes even the venerable Google start to look a lot like government agencies internally. As they grow they take on a lot of government's problems, like sclerotic bureaucracy. The meta-corp model avoids this by allowing individual "departments" to function with an extreme level of independence. It uses mechanisms like equity finance to capture upside while creating enough autonomy to allow permission-free innovation.