8 ms·
It seems to me that, if you have one of these, you live in a two-party consent state (e.g. California), and you invite a guest who hasn't clicked the EULA over,
by amluto 12y ago
It seems to me that, if you have one of these, you live in a two-party consent state (e.g. California), and you invite a guest who hasn't clicked the EULA over, then someone is committing felony wiretapping.
I would love to see a TV vendor prosecuted for this.
- amelius 12y agoSo how about if somebody in California replies to an e-mail which was sent from gmail.com?
- jneal 12y agoIMO there is no expectation of privacy with email. Maybe only false expectation. If you go into someone's home and take part in private discussions, you probably don't anticipate being recording in any manner.
- threatofrain 12y agoI actually think there is a reasonable expectation to privacy, and that most people, from senators to elementary school teachers, believe that email is technically secure, meaning that "normal people" could not read their email even if they wanted to, at least not without resorting to "hacking" or "spying". In fact, one might say that email is more secure than normal mail, because normal mail doesn't have a password and is default delivered to a publicly accessible mailbox. If a neighbor wishes to invade your privacy via your email, how do they do so? Probably by entering your password somehow. If that person wants to steal your physical mail, how do they do so? By walking up to your mailbox when nobody is looking. Also, email at least has a very plausible chance of being encrypted; even if you don't know what that means, your workplace may be doing it for you. But companies, including financial or accountancy firms, don't encrypt physical email to their customers. I think most reasonable people have the belief that email is safer than mail, and in 2015 I think they might be right.
- Spooky23 12y agoMany people believe that the world is flat. Doesn't mean that it is. There has never, ever been any expectation set that internet email is private. There have been many examples in the broader media that show how one might compromise email. Also, you have no way to assess the quality of the email service provider, network provider, or client environment. Postal mail is more secure for 99% of the public for several reasons, including: - A paper envelope is tamper-evident. My dad used to correspond with radio operators in the Warsaw Pact... envelope tampering was trivial for me to detect as a 5-year old. - Stolen mail is stolen. You don't get the message. Detecting a pattern of missing mail is pretty easy. - If you're not a police organization, tracking postal mail metadata is risky. Bystanders will notice somebody rifling through a mailbox every day. There really isn't a way to surveil outbound letters. - It's a serious felony to tamper with mail. Linking physical mail theft to a perpetrator is pretty straightforward. Also, Postal Inspectors take mail integrity very seriously, sometimes too seriously. With electronic crimes, you probably have a 1/100 chance of finding a cop who understands your complaint AND has the means to do anything about it. - It's much easier to implement physical security practices/procedures that keep secrets transmitted by mail secret than via digital means.
- waitwaitwhay 12y ago> There has never, ever been any expectation set that internet email is private. Of course there has.
- res0nat0r 12y agoOnly if your expectation is that mailing your thoughts on what amounts to a digital postcard that passes through dozens of hands before it arrives to the destination is private.
- waitwaitwhay 12y agoWhat I meant was that most people assume it is secure. I mean only a few % at most has any clue how email works. I suspect most of my colleagues who has been working as developers for decades don't know that email may pass through dozens of hands. Of course if you know how it works you know its not secure, but very few people knows how it works.
- rgbrenner 12y agothere is no expectation of privacy with email. Maybe only false expectation. I'm not sure why this was voted down... not only has the Supreme Court said repeatedly that there's no expectation of privacy since you're trusting the information to a third party... but email isn't even transmitted securely. If anyone expects their email to be private (and isn't using PGP or something), they have a false expectation of privacy. It's unfortunate that's the case, but that is reality.
- sukilot 12y agoVoice communications among common people have never been encrypted, yet have been the major class of privacy-protected communications for the 20th century.
- cbr 12y agoIn MA you need two-party consent for audio recordings, but not for text or audioless video. CA may be similar.
- amluto 12y agoIANAL, but I'm pretty sure that wiretapping applies specifically to sound recordings.
- patcheudor 12y agoThese things are going to be purchased by hotels. If the hotel does turn off the feature, it won't likely be protected by a password and if it is, there are likely going to be too many hotel staff who will know what it is to make it an effective security control. Given other features, aka., vulnerabilities within the TV environment, things could get interesting. I posted a longer reply to this main thread which covers that a bit more in detail.