3 ms·
The use of the term "Manhattan Project" is a bit unfortunate. If there was such a program, most would not know about it -- those that did would be forbidden to
by e12e 12y ago
The use of the term "Manhattan Project" is a bit unfortunate. If there was such a program, most would not know about it -- those that did would be forbidden to talk about it. In other words, if there were a "Manhattan Project for Cybersecurity" -- it would look like NSAs Bluffdale facility, and would have as much publicity and official comment on what it was, who was working there and on what.
Security is different from offensive capability -- I don't think the best way to secure infrastructure is through threat of mutual assured destruction -- if anything, being the worlds prime nuclear power (and conventional weapons power) -- the USA already have "assured destruction" covered. Sure, a country wide blackout would be devastating, but so would dropping a few terra-tons worth of nukes on the offender.
I think what's needed in terms of "cybersecurity" is more openness, better education and perhaps most important: better and more correct incentives. There's a huge gap between what is available (secure coding, secure systems, best practices (or even half-decent practices)) -- and what we see companies, governments and organizations do. I also think it is absurd to promote the Sony hack as a threat to national security -- talk about hyperbole. Some personal data and a little intellectual property was leaked. It pales in comparison to the allegations of commercial secrets stolen by the NSA on behalf of US industry, for example.
- danielweber 12y agoEveryone wants a "Manhattan Project" for their own pet technology. The real MP was building technology that they theoretically knew was possible. Most modern calls for an MP are "just throw a lot of money at this thing," which is how it works in games like "Civilization" but doesn't actually in the real world. From TFA: A real Manhattan Project for cyber would draw together some of the greatest minds of our time, from government, academia, the private sector, and civil society . . . who would proceed to bitch at each other endlessly. I firsthand saw what should have been a nice cordial introductory meeting turn into an hour-long shitstorm about which person at the table invented the term "firewall" (since more than one of them had claimed credit).
- mattybrennan 12y agoExactly. The manhattan project was throwing money and brains at a specific idea, knowing it was theoretically possible and a game-changer if it worked. What's the Cyber Security equivalent?
- ams6110 12y agoI don't think there is one. Cybersecurity requires pefection. The old saying that to keep systems secure you have to win every battle with your attackers, but the attackers only need to win one. I think we're fundamentally doing it wrong. We work to try to make things more secure, but perfection is not possible for humans. We need to accept that complex computer systems and networks cannot be secure. And find ways to make them useful dispite that.
- Pxtl 12y agoA fully audited LAMP-equivalent stack and and a similarly-audited computer to run it?
- trhway 12y ago>"Manhattan Project for Cybersecurity" -- it would look like NSAs Bluffdale facility i think that facility and all these fiber-splits secretly installed across the world has been the "Manhattan Project for Cybersecurity" :) Like with the original MP, sometime ago there was theoretical idea that it is possible to listen to and record the "whole Internet" and that would open new possibilities, incl. ones like "total awareness" and Tor traffic correlation... So the government has thrown best brains and money and "voila!"
- obastani 12y agoI see this sentiment a lot ("security is a matter of best practices"), but I'm an outsider, and I've never seen a description of what this entails (at a high level). What are the kinds of best practices that you think would help solve the problem? Thanks!
- e12e 12y agoThat is a very good question, and one that isn't easy to answer succinctly! Just by asking that question, you are on your way to better security. One key thing to understand is that security is a process -- it cannot be added on. Similar in that way to how "high quality" cannot be added (and high quality is often a prerequisite for security -- bugs (in sub-systems) are almost always bad for system security). Another key is to see security as a trade-off between real threats and risks, and convenience[1]. For example, I don't currently encrypt my email (with gpg, my smtp server speaks SSL/TLS to those that are willing) -- I use webmail from time to time -- which IMNHO cannot mix meaningfully with gpg and/or end-to-end encrypted email. I have a bootstrap issue with both gpg and OTR -- very few of those I communicate with use either. So I cannot use either. This is another aspect, which I've seen little discussed: secure communication is all about the network effect (I'm sure it's been discussed, but I have not seen it discussed much). Facebook is actually a positive point here: Facebook chat supports[2] xmpp, which supports OTR (but not in the browser, messages that are encrypted are unreadable to Facebook, and via the web client). By having chatsecure on my phone, and many friends on FB -- I actually have a few I can communicate securely with, via XMPP+OTR. That google killed/are killing XMPP access to their IM, is devastating with regards to the security of IM going through Hangouts. Another important point, is that security is all about looking at the system, and realizing that the system, like the original MVC -- when it was MVCU: Model-View-Controller-User[3] -- includes people. People, unlike hw/sw tends to forget passwords, type passwords into the wrong input window[4] etc. I remember reading one of the "Rainbow books"[R], I believe it was NSA Orange Book[5], or maybe[6] a long while back, and found it to have a lot of good points on making a secure system. Maybe someone else have some newer recommendations? Again, it's a complex question. You can't be confident you're communicating securely if you can't be confident you're using a secure system. Hence, Snowden, as seen in Citizienfour, tells the journalists to use an air-gapped (off-line) system for encryption and de-decryption. This is good advice, against most "normal" adversaries. But it is really hard to be paranoid "enough". It is easy to back-door a modern device via it's BIOS/boot-code/kernel, to install various key-loggers (in hardware or software) -- and most people don't realize how absurdly easy it is to break into most houses undetected (see: bumpkeys, lockpicks). I've come to the conclusion that one small aspect that needs work is helping people choose and use better passwords/pass-phrases -- as that is often the weakest part of a system. Sometimes that can be mitigated by using hardware tokens to store keys and delegate encryption to. I'm afraid there are no easy answers. [1] Should be a link here to a sign posted outside a secure facility, I think a prison or jail, stating simply: "Security is not a convenience" -- but I couldn't find it on-line. I believe someone used it in a talk on security a good while back... [2] https://www.facebook.com/sitetour/chat.php https://www.facebook.com/sitetour/chat.php [3] https://heim.ifi.uio.no/~trygver/themes/mvc/mvc-index.html https://heim.ifi.uio.no/~trygver/themes/mvc/mvc-index.html [4] http://bash.org/?244321 http://bash.org/?244321 [R] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rainbow_Series http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rainbow_Series [5] http://www.fas.org/irp/nsa/rainbow/std001.htm http://www.fas.org/irp/nsa/rainbow/std001.htm [6] http://www.fas.org/irp/nsa/rainbow/tg017.htm http://www.fas.org/irp/nsa/rainbow/tg017.htm