4 ms·
I want to like Factor. I've tried to use it a couple of times, and found at least under OSX that the samples I tried to compile (tetris and one other) didn't ac
by samatman 12y ago
I want to like Factor. I've tried to use it a couple of times, and found at least under OSX that the samples I tried to compile (tetris and one other) didn't actually function.
More relevantly, I feel like Factor has lost the literal relationship between machine and software that is Forth's distinctive contribution. Our processors have drifted away from that mapping as well, though there are of course GreenArrays and a few other stack chips out there.
For a Forth that's pleasant to use and retains that feel, I suggest Retro. The Ngaro virtual machine is pure art, and the additions, particularly the [ and ] quotation words, are thoughtful contributions to the Forth lineage.
- desireco42 12y agoThank you for the pointer. I enjoyed Forth long time ago and wanted to rekindle that love with Factor, but honestly I ran into bumps. I am not giving up, but will definitely check Retro.
- e12e 12y agoThank you for the pointer to retro[1] and related[2] projects! I also sort of found Factor interesting -- but much of the point with Forth, is a high-ish level of abstraction on bare metal hardware. If you're going to be using a vm etc... why not program in something that is much more abstract, like Smalltalk, Lisp, Python -- whatever really? Retro I can get, apparently it is small and very portable -- that makes sense (perhaps not more sense than Smalltalk, though). [1] http://www.forthworks.com/retro/ http://www.forthworks.com/retro/ [2] http://www.forthworks.com/parable/ http://www.forthworks.com/parable/ http://retroforth.org/docs/The_Ngaro_Virtual_Machine.html http://retroforth.org/docs/The_Ngaro_Virtual_Machine.html