6 ms·
Twitter Cuts Off Employee Access to Its Metrics
- Lur 12y agoI don't understand - can't one calculate MAU from firehose data? If so then all companies who bought that data can access this elusive MAU metric.
- minimaxir 12y agoMAU includes users who passively consume content and do not post content. Deriving MAU from tweet data alone will vastly underestimate it.
- bhouston 12y agoYou can likely calibrate past firehose data with past MAU data and then you can use firehose as a predictor. I am sure there are strong correlations between the two.
- patio11 12y agoIn addition to this, the firehose license almost certainly includes 96 pt font printed in blood-on-asbestos specifically enumerating "publishing aggregate statistics" as one of the things you're not allowed to do with the data, on pain of a breach of contract suit with damages measured in percentage points of Google's market cap.
- MichaelGG 12y agoSo why publish it, when you can just calculate and trade on the info? Though the costs of getting all the data might hurt the profitability of this plan. (The resellers charge per tweet, so you'd need to fall back to a sampling scheme, though that might be his enough.)
- joosters 12y agoAn 'active' user doesn't have to be tweeting, so they won't all show up in the firehose. MAU figures are pretty dubious anyway - see the other recode story about how 4 million 'active' users vanished because iOS no longer automatically fetches tweets: http://recode.net/2015/02/05/how-twitter-lost-4-million-users-because-of-apples-ios-8/ http://recode.net/2015/02/05/how-twitter-lost-4-million-user...
- MichaelGG 12y agoSo, in that sense, going by unique tweeters is an even better metric. Also, since Twitter offers limited (1% or 5%) of the firehouse to anyone via the streaming API, wouldn't that be a fairly decent way to estimate things?
- dredmorbius 12y agoThe data can still be correlated. Given a history of known actives and corresponding tweets, the average tweets-per-active can be determined. That may change over time but it's unlikely to do so in a capricious fashion without good cause. Say, onboarding a large class of users for whom Twitter and/or Tweets are of secondary interest. Not that, say, Google might have done that with Google+ or anything. Just because you cannot _directly_ see the number you're interested in doesn't mean you cannot infer it by other means.
- AznHisoka 12y agoTrue, if only stock prices were based solely on quantitative metrics. But it's also based on human emotions and expectations.
- mathattack 12y agoI'm amazed that it took this long, given that the # is material to how the stock trades. (Look at their volatility on earnings day) Why give thousands of people access to information whose inadvertent release could cause public disclosure problems? (As a public company, material information needs to be released to all investors at the same time) Even an accidental mistake could cause big problems, let alone insider trading.
- oddevan 12y agoSeconded. The company I used to work for had stories of a gong on the sales floor that would sound when someone made a sale. Once they were publicly listed, though, the gong went away, since anyone on the floor would have an idea of sales for that month and therefore be subject to insider trading. I immediately concluded that being in a publicly traded company is boring. I work for a school now. :)
- mathattack 12y agoThere's tradeoffs. Public companies are more boring, but having permanent capital does bring a little more stability. Different things for different people. To borrow from Peter T, it's much easier for private firms to get from 0 to 1. Public companies seem to be better on globalizing, where standards and process are important. Neither is universally better. (I've moved to steadily smaller companies in my career)
- GrinningFool 12y agoI'm not sure what you mean about being publicly traded gets you permanent capital? THe only capital you receive is from the stocks your company sells. All the subsequent trading doesn't benefit the company - after the IPO proceeds (and subsequent offerings that may be issued), the stocks are only a liability to the issuing company.
- eldavido 12y agoTechnical nit: stock is equity, which is absolutely NOT a liability in the technical sense of the term. Generally liabilities are something that has to be paid back on a more-or-less predefined schedule; equity is more "permanent" (but it's really a spectrum with points in between like "convertible debt" and "preferred debt" and such, which have some features of both.) The point about "permanence" refers to the lack of any obligation by the issuer to pay it back on any schedule. That changes of ownership can happen without the company really knowing/caring is a huge feature of public equity markets, compared to say, a private partnership where, if an individual wants to exit, it might lead to business closure because the partnership needs to liquidate in order to cash out the partner, or the partner needs to find someone else to buy their partnership stake, which may be difficult as partnerships aren't as standardized as NYSE-traded equity with regard to reporting, control, and legal precedent. tl;dr share capitalism has some really nice benefits that too often go overlooked.
- t0mbstone 12y agoI don't understand how/why a publicly traded company like Twitter should be allowed to hide such an important piece of data from the public and from shareholders?
- oddevan 12y agoIt's less to do with hiding data from the public and more along the lines of controlling the data so that no one in the company gets it before the public (and thus allowing said person inside the company to trade company stock on insider information).
- mjmahone17 12y agoIsn't this solved with trading windows, which you only open up right after earnings calls? Or am I missing something?
- eldavido 12y agoThose don't apply to the general public. The problem is insider gets info -> calls his brother-in-law -> brother-in-law trades on early info. Illegal, but lucrative.
- kingryan 12y agoIf you're classified as an "insider" then you can't even trade in the trading windows without a 10b5-1 plan. So at TWTR (I'm a former employee) knowing things like the MAU would probably make you an insider, which means you can only sell on a plan. Not knowing the MAU is a blessing in this case.
- pc86 12y agoAs mathattack said, public companies are required to disclose this type of information to the public all at once. If I work at Twitter and tell you that our MAU dropped 5% this week, and earnings is in two weeks, you could short the stock and make a lot of money. It's to prevent this type of scenario. The data is private until it's released to everyone simultaneously.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kenrikm 12y agoI understand the reason they did it, though I think they should have done this way earlier. This seems to send a negative signal that you're not growing as fast and want to keep your cards close.
- badusername 12y agoDoes Facebook have similar policies? What's the level of transparency there?
- fishnchips 12y agoThat sort of information is readily available to Facebook employees as well as widely distributed. But for example engineering levels are secret.
- jchendy 12y agoWhat does "engineering levels" mean?
- lacker 12y agoWhen someone gets promoted at Facebook, that fact is generally not shared. There isn't a big list of "who just got promoted".
- badusername 12y agoI was more interested in knowing the level of transparency on a day-to-day basis on metrics such as usercount, revenue, etc. you know, stuff that could get you in a bind for insider trading.
- fishnchips 12y agoUser count - yes; revenue - I honestly don't know. There are quiet periods for restricted stock units for when you might know more than the market. When then quarterly numbers are out the blackout period ends and you can trade your stock. It's been like that in every publicly traded US company I've ever worked at.
- dredmorbius 12y agoFB have published their daily actives as recently as September, 2014.