8 ms·
3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint SE Plus
- nkvoll 12y agoIt certainly raises some good questions, and the Printrbot is a great machine at the price point (I have a Printrbot Simple RepRap clone myself). His looks pretty well calibrated as I've seen a lot of Z-wobbling artefacts on the prints from several Printrbot (Simple Makers, not necessarily the metal one). Worth nothing is that things like the Z-scar being on the side of the cup instead of under the handle is something that's decided by the slicer (the software that translates the 3d model into printer commands). Different open source slicers that are regularly used produce different locations for these scars -- and I'm not sure if it's actually possible to position/hint this Z-scar manually in any of them. They often do try to be "smart" about it, but the end result may vary.
- shanselman 12y agoDo you think I just got lucky with the Z-scar and Cura?
- nkvoll 12y agoSo I just took the coffee cup STL and loaded into the latest Cura myself, rotated in 90 degrees so it was standing upright. Without changing anything else, I ended up getting the layer changes on a few difference places over the print (I'm seeing this just by analyzing the G-Code using http://gcode.ws http://gcode.ws), depending on the layer height. It starts to the right of the handle and after a while seems to sort-of stabilize almost on the opposite side of the handle and on the right side of the actual handle, before the handle separates from the cup body. All in all, it will likely have come out decent, but certainly not under the handle as you have. This I guess is because Cura will start the new layer close to where it finishes it's previous layer by default. In other words: it depends on infill percent/pattern and model location on the build platform. I figure this is because you've added support. This causes the print head to get a "closest" start of the new layer exactly under the handle (because that's where the support material are). So going as far as calling it "lucky", no. The support placement actually helps Cura put the Z-scars in a good place on this model. On another model, it might be the exact opposite. (PS: I use Cura for all my slicing and I like it a lot -- but I don't feel like the software actually gives me much control about the Z-scar placement)
- shanselman 12y agoFascinating. Thanks for this. I was thinking it was either the support or running it through NetFabb first.
- Vendan 12y agoyou might try Slic3r, I did some tuning with the retract on layer change settings and managed to eliminate the z-scar stuff on my prints
- chokolad 12y ago> Printrbot (Simple Makers, not necessarily the metal one). I've heard from the couple of owners that Metal ones are much better than Simple Makers. here is the quote "but Printrbot Simple Metal is very reliable, I had one I’ve been carrying around in my car unpacked (I just dump it behind the seat, same with the tablet) and I just put it on the desk and it prints. Every time. Auto-bed leveling does wonders." And another one from the same guy "Just to be clear, I’m talking about Printrbot Simple Metal (not the previous wood version – that one is realty bad: it de-calibrates from day to day simply because of humidity "
- ghshephard 12y agoWhat this suggests to me, is that if you are making a lot of smaller 3d-prints, that don't leverage whatever special capability the UPrint has (size?), then it makes a lot more sense to have a large cluster of a couple dozen Printrbots than a single UPrint.
- im3w1l 12y agoBlack color makes it hard to see the shape.
- TomGullen 12y agoDon't know much about 3D printing but seems it's got a long way to go yet if it's taking 7 hours to make a mug with some ugly scaring which costs between $2 and $30 in materials. If I want to print a mug I'd want it done in 5 minutes and cost $1, otherwise what's the point of owning one from the point of view that one of these will be in every household. Does anyone know if the current materials have any hard limits on them as to how fast they can be manipulated for example?
- engendered 12y agoYou are, of course, exactly right. Right now 3D printing is mostly in the "neato" stage, and is being oversold by a lot of actors. The materials are limited, costly, and prohibitive, and the process is extremely slow and of moderate accuracy. It is getting better, of course, but there are some hard, sober limits on the sorts of materials that can be extruded and modeled like this.
- mseidl 12y agoCheap consumer 3d printing sucks. Keep in mind that if there is something cheap now like 3d printing, it's been around for 20+ years. And it has. Königsegg (The car company) 3d prints their turbos and doesn't do any machining to finish the impeller. Think of how accurate it has to be to spin to 100-150k rpm or more. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DNedUZxP8NU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DNedUZxP8NU
- tudorw 12y agoYou're right of course, it's hard to imagine it as a household item, although having said that, I know a lot of people who invested a lot of money into 2d printers and ink even though it cost way more than having better quality prints produced commercially. Maybe the appeal will outweigh the impracticality, if you had a uniquely shaped hand and regular mugs and utensils just didn't work, I imagine you'd be looking to get one in the next 12 months :)
- notahacker 12y ago
- thisjepisje 12y agoWhat's up with the abundance of cheap extrusion printers, while (almost) no consumer-grade SLS (selective laser sintering) machines are available? The latter technology seems vastly superior to me, in terms of freedom to actually print anything you want. Is the technology that much harder?
- jacquesm 12y agoHarder, much more expensive and much more dangerous to operate. So that's why they're not more common. The last thing you want is for a machine like that to be run in a regular home without proper fume extraction. At the back of those machines you usually see a thing like a very thick vacuum hose connected to remove the (toxic!) vapors. They also consume a lot of power, usually requiring industrial power hookups. edit: here is a nice picture of such a setup https://www.solidconcepts.com/content/images/repeatable-process-control-001.jpg https://www.solidconcepts.com/content/images/repeatable-proc... Those white tubes going up out of the machine are the extraction channels.
- thisjepisje 12y agoThe fumes especially are a good point, hadn't thought of that. SLS is also possible with plastic, though, in which case I guess the fumes are comparable to those produced by an extrusion printer.
- jacquesm 12y agoWell, almost. The SLS uses very fine grains as a base material, an extrusion printer uses a filament. The grains will vaporize much easier than filament but there is definitely a concentration of unhealthy particles in the air around an extrusion printer and I would not operate one without at least basic precautions (fume hood or something similar).
- yourapostasy 12y agoIf only it was possible to hook up on single-phase house mains an arc torch-based plasma gasifier to direct those toxic fumes into. I specifically looked for access to three-phase power when choosing a residence because I don't see power consumption requirements for the metal sintering gear coming down anytime soon.
- esw 12y ago3D printing reminds me so much of the early days of personal computing - it was an expensive hobby for techies, the equipment was hard to configure, and the everyday (practical) uses of the technology weren't immediately clear. But like personal computing, I have no doubt that 3D printing will become an essential part of our daily lives in the decades to come.
- bsenftner 12y agoJust like today's printer cartridges, the 'print material' used by 3D printers is insanely expensive. That's gotta change for any essential daily lives application.
- talkingquickly 12y agoReally? My impression has been that filament is pretty cheap e.g. < $30 per kg. For printing small objects, enclosures, small replacement parts etc, the filament cost has been pretty much negligible. That's why a lot of 3D print shops end up telling people just to buy their own printer if their doing any reasonable volume, because once the capital cost is out of the way, the consumables are fairly inexpensive.
- imaginenore 12y ago$30 is ridiculous. ABS plastic is around $1,000 per ton (or cheaper if you buy 10 tons). Does it really cost so much to make a wire out of the granules?
- talkingquickly 12y agoThat means there's approximately a 30x markup from raw ABS to a spool of 3D printing filament being sold over the counter in a shop to a consumer. I don't know how much filament costs if you buy industrial quantities rather than consumer ones. To be honest I don't know enough about industrial pricing to understand if it's ridiculous or not, 30x from raw material to something being retailed at a consumer level doesn't seem unbelievable to me. Markup on a black ink cartridge (the original comparison) is something in the region of 200x, so nearly an order of magnitude higher.
- huuu 12y agoThe problem here is patents and the cost of R&D. The only reason why 3D printing became main stream is because some patents expired and printers are being sold as kit instead of a product.
- bluedino 12y agoWe bought a Makerbot Replicator for $6,000 and it's been a huge disaster. I'm not sure if the people who bought it didn't read the Amazon reviews or what. We were having the local college print things for us for $150/pop. For double what we paid we could have gotten a lightly used Stratasys which is the same printer the college uses.
- wlesieutre 12y agoRecent version? My local makerspace has a pair of Makerbot Replicator 2s and they've been great. But I've heard not-so-great things about their newer products. https://www.3dhubs.com/best-3d-printer-guide https://www.3dhubs.com/best-3d-printer-guide is a pretty up to date guide on what the good printers are today.
- decktech 12y agoTry updating your firmware and desktop software. New versions were released today which should significantly improve print quality.
- bluedino 12y agoBleeding edge, daily updates to make the product work at a somewhat reasonable level. It's like the users are guinea pigs.
- EC1 12y agoThe users are guinea pigs. That's how it's always been.
- willtheperson 12y agoHow many products are there in the world that cannot be refined? Just because a new version or refinement exists, does not invalidate the usefulness of the original, nor does it mean the original users were guinea pigs. Now when a product has zero utility in it's first version, that's different. But I would argue you should demand your money back at that point.
- brudgers 12y agoOk, I am compelled to point out that the $22,000 printer works ~8 times as fast or does 8 times as much work...depending on how you look at it. Droplets versus mugs. Maths (0.2mm/0.1mm)^3 There is not much of a premium for performance in supply costs. The premium in hardware costs is ~4.5x. A lot for a consumer. Cheap if you're racing. What I was reminded of is commodity servers. You run the models through a cluster of three or four cheap rigs (maybe with different slicing software) to increase the odds of getting a good artifact in 8 hours and to allow taking a machine offline for tuning. Of course eight 0.2mm resolution printers will no more create a 0.1mms artifact than 9 fertile ladies will gestate an infant in one month.
- failed_ideas 12y agoFair enough, but it's still a valid comparison for most of us looking. Is the $600 machine 'good enough' for my usage, and it looks like it will be.
- brudgers 12y agoI wasn't being critical, I was being compelled. Hanselman's analysis is reasonable and not misleading. The $600 product easily solves the 95% case. And for a consumer oriented product probably the 99.9% case since most will sit on the shelf because it's still printing and how much stuff do people download off the internet and print with their color printers these days? The idea that we will all be making our personalized LPS (Little Plastic Shit)[1] to our snowflake's content is true. But only because most snowflakes are content without doing it as a hobby. It's Buck Rodgers cool when it's on the screen, but the reality of waiting 8 hours for maybe getting a widget only appeals to some people. It's like raytracing silver balls above a red and yellow checkerboard. Amazing to see it come out line by line over four hours at 320x200 in 1989. Not worth setting up a Blender scene to do it in the blink of an eye today. For most people, there are better options than doing it themselves. For a few use cases doing it yourself is the best option. And doing it yourself is a great option for people who want to do it themselves. That's the same class of people who put their recipes on floppy disks in C64 days. Done ranting. Get off my lawn anyway. [1] or plastic crap : https://encyclopediadramatica.se/Plastic_crap https://encyclopediadramatica.se/Plastic_crap
- mcmancini 12y agoIt's pretty amazing how the difference in object quality between the enthusiast and professional systems has evaporated. I would be interested to hear how frequently the Printrbot gets a clogged extruder vs. the Stratasys, what print quality on ABS looks like between the two units, what happens when you have a more complex shape with a lot of overhangs, etc. Aside from warranty service, what are the advantages of the professional system?
- ascorbic 12y agoThey reason they both have the "pile of spaghetti" look is that they're both FDM printers. The fact that even the most expensive FDM machines still give that crappy-looking result is because that's all the technology can handle. If he'd compared it with the results from even a consumer-grade SLA machine like the Form 1, let alone professional SLA, SLS or inkjet such as Objet then it would be completely different results.
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoI'm completly bewildered by the current 3D printing fandom. Every FDM print I've see just looks... off. I certainly am impressed people can make these things casually, but from an aesthetic and even practical point of view, it just looks terrible. I can't imagine using it for some of the more interesting use cases I hear about like replacing a cosmetic part in your car or house. I spent a bit of time on 3d printing forums and from what I can tell its just figurine printing and hobbyist screwing around. These photos are very telling: http://maukcc.blogspot.com/2013/03/comparison-between-sla-and-fdm.html http://maukcc.blogspot.com/2013/03/comparison-between-sla-an... A low price SLA would be a serious game changer. The Kudo3D project will be interesting to watch. I'd much rather spend $2000 on something that prints beautifully than $600 on something that will print "piled spaghetti." Interesting comment from the Kudo3D person on reddit with some details: http://www.reddit.com/r/3Dprinting/comments/25teeg/kudo3d_celebratory_tshirt_contest/chmt25g http://www.reddit.com/r/3Dprinting/comments/25teeg/kudo3d_ce...
- lmg643 12y agoStratasys has a $3bn market cap, and this post basically says their flagship product isn't much better than something that costs about 3% of the price. Probably not good for Stratasys long term outlook - SSYS. https://www.google.com/finance?cid=61380041562207 https://www.google.com/finance?cid=61380041562207
- steejk 12y agoThat printer is definitely not the flagship from Stratasys. It's actually their 'entry level' product and seems to be aimed at companies who want a printer comparable to consumer ones but with perhaps more durability and better support. A better comparison would be with the Fortus line which is used in commercial applications for functional products.
- gerbal 12y agogiven how shit the MakerBot product line got after the Stratasys acquisition, I'm not in the least surprised. (Cleaning a clogged print-head on a MakerBot Mini voids the warranty).
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI enjoyed reading this, as the author stated it is a rather contrived test, there are things the Stratasys printer can print that the Printrbot cannot (anything with complex overhangs and undercuts) but that really wasn't the point I think. There is also the entire 'tools' thing where the tool is often less important than the operator. I know people who can carve a bust out of ice with a chainsaw, but I'd be lucky to make a square block with the very same chainsaw and equivalent ice. The point being that tools are only as good as the training of the operator so tool comparison really does need to expert operators if it wants to be diagnostic. But what it does say, and I believe it is incontrovertible, is that the "personal 3d printer" market is evolving at least as fast as the "professional" 3d printer market and the overlap of capabilities is growing. For any manufacturing technology its going to be speed, cost, finish, and capability and while personal 3d printers have nailed it on cost, and they are now competitive on speed, they are working on finish and capability. And that suggests to me its a time thing, not a 'new science' thing between when 3D printers start delivering on their potential. I've got a Makerbot Replicator 1/Dual (the last of the 'opensource' Makerbots and currently replicated by the Flashforge Creator 3D for half the price I paid :-) which was much better than the original Makerbot 'cupcake' or the early reprap machines. There are print heads (a combination of an extruder and a hot end) now available which both improve the finish significantly and the speed. So its really a fun place to be. And my personal favorite is that its a way to exploit robotics hacking in a much more practical way than running around a room avoiding walls :-).
- grandalf 12y agoThis is a lower cost "prosumer" model and I believe has the best Amazon ratings: http://www.makergear.com/products/m-series-3d-printers http://www.makergear.com/products/m-series-3d-printers