2 ms·
Even if the US was given the information in violation of Iceland law, which I'm not convinced of, it wouldn't have any bearing on what happens in a US court. My
by ikeboy 12y ago
Even if the US was given the information in violation of Iceland law, which I'm not convinced of, it wouldn't have any bearing on what happens in a US court. My point stands completely.
And if Iceland gave over the info in error, that's their problem, not the US's.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoThe law they claimed to use to require Iceland to do the search also requires that USA provide the same protections as if the suspect and search had been made in the USA. USA of course can renege on their agreement to abide by the Convention but under rule of law it should have an effect on the US court. If Iceland did the USA's bidding and in doing so contravened the USA's Convention agreement then it certainly looks like that should be the USA's problem - in practice USA don't seem to care about that sort of thing. The international community shouldn't allow USA to act unlawfully to parties just because they're not on USA soil. What I'm saying is that it looks like the USA's request required them to provide certain legal protections that they didn't extend. It seems like they were prepared to flout the rule of law in order to apprehend DPR. The ends are right but I don't think they entirely justify the means.