6 ms·
The problem with the article is that it calls the finding of the server "blatantly illegal", when that hasn't come to trial. The government says https://ia6006
by ikeboy 12y ago
The problem with the article is that it calls the finding of the server "blatantly illegal", when that hasn't come to trial.
The government says https://ia600603.us.archive.org/21/items/gov.uscourts.nysd.422824/gov.uscourts.nysd.422824.75.0.pdf https://ia600603.us.archive.org/21/items/gov.uscourts.nysd.4...
>In any event, even if the FBI had somehow “hacked” into the SR Server in order to identify its IP address, such an investigative measure would not have run afoul of the Fourth Amendment. Because the SR Server was located outside the United States, the Fourth Amendment would not have required a warrant to search the server, whether for its IP address or otherwise. See United States v. Vilar, 729 F.3d 62, 86 (2d Cir. 2013) (Fourth Amendment warrant requirement does not apply extraterritorially); In re Terrorist Bombings of U.S. Embassies in East Africa, 552 F.3d 157, 167 (2d Cir. 2008) (same). At most, any search of the SR Server needed only to be “reasonable” – that is, justified by “legitimate governmental interests.” Vilar, 729 F.3d at 86. Given that the SR Server was hosting a blatantly criminal website, it would have been reasonable for the FBI to “hack” into it in order to search it, as any such “hack” would simply have constituted a search of foreign property known to contain criminal evidence, for which a warrant was not necessary.
which seems reasonable.
- tptacek 12y agoIt probably wouldn't have mattered, because the overwhelming majority of the evidence in the trial came from Ulbricht's laptop, which the USG searched both under a warrant and incident to Ulbricht's arrest --- an arrest for which they had some probable cause prior to the SR server search. There's also a doctrine of "inevitable discovery" with implications here as well. The prevailing wisdom about this case seems correct: what shattered Ulbricht's legal defense was his utterly slipshod OPSEC.
- ikeboy 12y agoBut they only found Ulbricht because of the server AFAIK. What was their probable cause before the server search?
- tptacek 12y agoUlbricht was a suspect prior to the search.
- ikeboy 12y agoCould you source that? Not saying it's wrong, but I don't remember it.
- gojock 12y agoThere is no source on that because it isn't true[1]. Ulbricht was found via the server - all evidence that came as a result of that (including the laptop) would have been dismissed if a 4th amendment appeal was successful. The only evidence found outside of the server chain was the posts to the Shroomery and Bitcointalk - and as the link in grandparent comment points out, this is not sufficient probable cause for a search warrant (and a search warrant on the Gmail in any case would still not have linked Ulbricht to DPR sufficiently) [1] right in the second paragraph of article linked in grandparent comment: > The arrest of Ross Ulbricht got its start when the FBI somehow discovered the real location of the Silk Road server in Iceland. and > Every shred of evidence except for two “hey, I found this site” posts derives solely from the server seizure.
- rosenjon 12y agoFor some reason I can't reply to ikeboy directly. Is there a nesting limit for comments on HN? Anywho, you can do the search that got him caught yourself. https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3A+bitcointalk.org+rossulbricht%40gmail.com&biw=1023&bih=580&source=lnt&tbs=cdr%3A1%2Ccd_min%3A%2Ccd_max%3A1%2F31%2F2011&tbm=#tbs=cdr:1%2Ccd_max:1%2F31%2F2011&q=%22silk+road%22+.onion https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3A+bitcointalk.org+ross... The relevant result is now #2, but used to be #1 (http://motherboard.vice.com/read/the-google-search-that-took-down-ross-ulbricht http://motherboard.vice.com/read/the-google-search-that-took...) He had deleted the original comment, but someone had replied and copied the text. He subsequently posted an ad for job postings with the same username and his personal email address (I think rossulbricht@gmail.com). Basically, he was about as sloppy as it gets if you're running a criminal drug enterprise. Also, his confidant, Variety Jones/Cimon, hinted that he had done some research on Ulbricht and found some stuff. He was absurdly cocky about evading law enforcement. Makes you wonder if he has some kind of psychological disorder.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoI'd like to refer this back to a response I gave before - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8441139 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8441139. Basically USA claimed to be using the CoE Convention on Cybercrime in order to have the server raid performed. But that convention requires that USA's government bodies extend the same legal protections to those in other countries as if they were USA citizens within their own jurisdiction (and the other country has to provide the safeguards of their own law too). That is, if the Fourth protects Ulbricht if he was in USA then the same protections must be applied. This is very sensible. It means that parties can't go off on hunting expeditions and treat the citizens/subjects of other countries in the [convention's] union worse than they treat their own citizens. Now the testimony I linked to in that prior post at once claimed that the CoE Convention was being used and claimed they weren't certain. To me that strongly suggests the USA government agent(s) was attempting to deceive whilst under oath, perhaps not strictly lying but certainly not being helpfully informative - perhaps they realised after the fact that they'd failed to abide by the convention and so claimed it was maybe "comity" in order to have a get out clause when the issue of safeguards was raised? > ">In any event, even if the FBI had somehow “hacked” into the SR Server" // So, such an unauthorised intrusion may not have run afoul of the Fourth, perhaps, but it would either have broken the domestic law or breached obligations under international conventions depending on if they sort permissions from Sweden first or not. [and possibly neither if they established a protocol that bypassed international agreement]. From where I'm viewing it seems USA don't really care about the application of the rule of law neither in USA nor in other countries when it comes to USA government agents.
- maxerickson 12y agoIceland. I think you may be reading too much into the treaty. It isn't clear to me that it demands countries extend all domestic protections (but I have not read it terribly closely). I see where it says the laws they pass to comply with the treaty should provide protections. Beyond that, I don't think it obligates the US and Iceland to cooperate solely under that framework, what it does is create a situation where if the US comes to Iceland with a proper warrant, Iceland is obligated to comply with that warrant. If the FBI just wants to send the police in Iceland a tip and Iceland does something based on that tip, well, that's that.
- Scruff_Face 12y agoThere was at least one entry in Ulbricht's diary file with an entry like 'leaked real IP again'. If you believe Ulbricht actually wrote the diary file.
- rtpg 12y agocan someone explain the non-warrant requirements of the 4th amendment abroad? I don't seem to be grokking how that's reasoned out
- mikecb 12y agoRead starting on page 3[1], where it explains the case law. [1] http://biotech.law.lsu.edu/Courses/nat-sec/2009s/InreTerroristBombingsNov242008.pdf http://biotech.law.lsu.edu/Courses/nat-sec/2009s/InreTerrori...