4 ms·
> Here’s why you should pay close attention to this experiment. After just a single year in Chicago’s intensive tutoring and mentoring program, known as Match,
by gwern 12y ago
> Here’s why you should pay close attention to this experiment. After just a single year in Chicago’s intensive tutoring and mentoring program, known as Match, participants ended up as much as two years ahead of students in a control group who didn’t get this help. A report that is being released Sunday by the University of Chicago Crime Lab also finds that they performed substantially better on the Chicago school system’s math test; their scores on the N.A.E.P. math exam reduced the usual black-white test score gap by a third. This success carried over to nonmath classes, where these students were less likely to fail. Greater success in math also helped get them on track to graduate. It also led them to become more engaged in school, and they were 60 percent less likely than members of the control group to be arrested for a violent crime.
> I know of no initiative for disadvantaged young men of color that comes close.
Neither do I. I look forward to the post-mortem explaining why this program will turn out to be a failure like all the others.
- ccvannorman 12y agoPrograms that seek to better explain math will not last, I agree. What is needed is to change the kids' MINDSET about math. How do we make them WANT it? They've already decided it's boring and difficult.
- chii 12y agothey didn't 'decide' it was boring, it was taught without any context, and the average kid did not have the imagination to be able to know how useful math is going to be. Basically, instead of teaching, i think the school ciriculunm should try to pique the interest of the students, and make them intrinsically motivated to find out more. How to do this depends on how good their teachers are, and atm, not many teachers can do this even if they want to, because they are required to teach a certain amount of 'standard' stuff, and leaves not much room for the teacher's own brand/style.
- sukilot 12y agoWhy would you--what?
- ggreer 12y agoGwern's comments rarely take the time to lay out every step in his reasoning. Mix in his typical snark and you've got a recipe for misunderstanding. I'll spell it out. When it comes to disadvantaged and struggling students, tutoring has been tried countless times. As the article points out, it typically fails. What is Chicago's Match program doing differently? If the answer is, "not much", we should expect it to fail. In that case, the initial indications of success could be a statistical fluke, an uncorrected selection effect, or even biased researchers "juking" the stats. It took some digging, but I found a paper on the pilot study.[1] This preceded the one mentioned by the NYT, and had just 106 students. I don't see any glaring errors, but I don't spend a ton of time reading academic papers. They at least admit potential issues with scaling (the program relies on volunteers to keep costs low) and the poor statistical power of their study. Figures 5 through 8 are particularly damning. I'd love it if this program worked, but I'm not optimistic. 1. http://www.matcheducation.org/s/Crime-Lab-pilot-study-paper_Match-Tutors-Chicago.pdf http://www.matcheducation.org/s/Crime-Lab-pilot-study-paper_...
- jacinda 12y agoThey mention in the article that the tutors are typically recent college graduates, which would means they would be closer in age to the students they are tutoring. This could lead to more of a sense of camaraderie between the tutor and pupil, which could be more motivating for students of this demographic than the academic assistance (especially if the students don't have someone they could consider a true "friend" in other areas of their life). It would be interesting to see a similar study where you divided students into 3 groups - those who would receive no tutoring, those who would receive tutoring from recent college graduates and those who would receive tutoring from someone at least twenty years older than the student.
- slowmovintarget 12y agoIt isn't really about friendship. The article says so, but then you keep reading and get to the actual mechanics. From the article: “It’s friendship and pushing — they nag them to success,” Barbara Algarin, the executive director of Match Education, which runs the tutoring program, told me. “These students can make remarkable progress when they appreciate that their tutor is in their corner. The math connection leads to better study skills and a love of learning. Grades improve across the board.” That's essentially parenting, not friendship.