3 ms·
>Lately I've been leaning toward the view that "market fundamentalism" is partly responsible for the collapse of deep revolutionary invention after around 1970
by eli_gottlieb 12y ago
>Lately I've been leaning toward the view that "market fundamentalism" is partly responsible for the collapse of deep revolutionary invention after around 1970 or so. The timing is certainly right and the causal mechanism seems to be there. The symbolic point would be the cancellation of the Apollo program.
One of the most elegant critiques of neoliberalism I've ever heard is but a few words: "the cancellation of the long term".
Markets are great aggregators of localized information, localized in space, social networks, and time. The downside is that this means they get stuck in local optima and don't really use long-term information very well. They're really just massively parallel, distributed hill-climbing algorithms for economic production and allocation.
So when you're looking to move from one hill to an entirely different hill, you need something less like a combinatorial hill-climber and more like an intelligent agent that enacts coherent long-term plans. That's where the state comes in, and in fact, where it never left, since states enforce the property, debt, and contract laws that keep markets functioning in the first place.
The counterpoint is that companies like Google (Google X and the like) or individuals like Thiel and Musk have managed to show that once you get sufficiently rich mega-rich people, who are completely secure in their wealth, they can afford to make long-term plans that might temporarily spite the market (like starting Calico instead of buying an Instagram competitor). The problem is both that the public then has no control over the process, and that there's no particular reason for the mega-rich to make these long-term plans other than as personal hobby-horses: these guys are techno-futurist nerds, nobody made them pour their money into radical life extension, space exploration, or artificial intelligence.
- api 12y agoI'd agree with 100% of that. Thiel, Musk, Brin, etc. are oddballs. I have a good friend who works as an interior designer out in The Hamptons(tm). She's told me stories -- basically the mega-rich out there act like petulant toddlers but with lawyers and millions of dollars. They're constantly enlarging homes they never use, buying even bigger yachts, and suing each other over the most inane things you can imagine (dog poop, etc.). The vast majority of the mega-rich just use their money to masturbate in increasingly sophisticated ways. The few mega-rich visionaries we have look so super-humanly exceptional because they are indeed exceptions. I also like to say that the aristocratic elitism you sometimes hear in Silicon Valley circles is a bias from living in ValleyBubble -- your rich people are better than most other rich people. This is more typical for what you get when you give a hairless monkey this much power and wealth: http://www.thesmokinggun.com/documents/crime/jeffrey-epstein-brief-history-of-slime-786903 http://www.thesmokinggun.com/documents/crime/jeffrey-epstein... Mindless short-term dopamine chasing... all too human, and in no way exceptional.
- aswanson 12y agoRight. The beautiful thing about these days, if anything, is that we have a group of people in their 40s with access to incredible amounts of capital and are still able to dream big. I don't think this has ever happened before in history; most resource controllers in the past were dead-set in what made them rich (financial engineering, railroads, industry) and simply stayed there until they died. We finally have a combination of wealth and radical transformative vision in several individuals. Good times.
- jacquesm 12y ago> if anything, is that we have a group of people in their 40s with access to incredible amounts of capital and are still able to dream big. I don't think this has ever happened before in history Howard Hughes.
- aswanson 12y agoHe came to mind as I was typing that comment. But the man himself didn't constitute a group. He was an iconoclast.
- gaadd33 12y agoMost of the early automobile pioneers? Westinghouse? Alfred Lee Loomis? Henry Flagler? I think it's easy to assume that people who are known for massive success in a single industry were only involved in that. If you dig into a lot of their lives you see that they had many other ventures, some which were successful (Miami) others were not (Fordlandia). However their primary/initial success is what gets all the historical coverage. Also as time goes on and the engineering achievements are seen as more routine, they become less and less notable when not put into the context of the times. At one point the transcontinental railroad was seen just as crazy as the Hyperloop.
- jacquesm 12y agoOk, How about Walt Disney? Edison? How many will it take to satisfy your 'group' requirement? (Which I think is a technicality anyway.)
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoVery elegantly stated.
- swatow 12y agoBut the market funded companies like Google and Tesla, and continues to have faith in the profitability of both companies. Google's price earnings ratio is 25, Tesla's is 1207. You are trying to force a round into a square hole, by trying to make Google and Tesla fit your narrative of visionary individuals with the resources to ignore the market.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoExcept that if you notice which ventures I'm praising, it's their unprofitable, no-expected-time-to-market radical R&D initiatives. Calico and SpaceX are what I'm praising far more than just Google and Tesla.