4 ms·
>and mentioning someone else's trademark in that context always creates some possibility of confusing people // It's not 'possibility' it's 'likelihood' of con
by pbhjpbhj 12y ago
>and mentioning someone else's trademark in that context always creates some possibility of confusing people //
It's not 'possibility' it's 'likelihood' of confusion that is considered, amongst other factors - eg http://www3.ce9.uscourts.gov/jury-instructions/node/244 http://www3.ce9.uscourts.gov/jury-instructions/node/244.
The NFL own the RTM (eg serial number 78688906, 77182909, 76572704) and they use it to sell merchandise, TV broadcasts, and clothing respectively. The problem they face is that bowl is a generic term for a [sports] competition (cf http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/bowl http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/bowl), and super is also standard language. You can't use trademarks to prevent a person describing something. Moreover when I say "buy my beer to drink whilst you watch the Super Bowl" I'm not using the trademark, I'm using a description of a sports event. If I said "buy my beer to drink whilst you wear your Super Bowl t-shirt" [assuming the owners have registered the mark for clothing] then I'm using the trademark, but I'm still using it to describe the TM owners goods, quite clearly, and so there's no confusion.
Clearly one could create confusion: "drink our Super Bowl beer" uses the term as if it were a trademark, and moreover as if it were the advertisers trademark.
Isn't "super bowl" just a description of a large sports event ; that would seems to lack the distinctiveness normally required of a trademark for anything that's normally related to sports events. The 2 live marks incorporating "super bowl" would make it appear the the USPTO consider use of the term separate to the NFL's mark as allowable [but I'm not sure they've been properly examined as yet].
- gonzo 12y agothe other issue here is nominative use. Using trademarks as nouns can lead to dilution. This plays some into your "descriptive" complaint: Isn't "super bowl" just a description of a large sports event ; that would seems to lack the distinctiveness normally required of a trademark for anything that's normally related to sports events. But registration is prima facie evidence of validity. Quoting 15 USC 1507(b): A certificate of registration of a mark upon the principal register provided by this Act shall be prima facie evidence of the validity of the registered mark and of the registration of the mark, of the registrant's ownership of the mark, and of the registrant's exclusive right to use the registered mark in commerce on or in connection with the goods or services specified in the certificate, subject to any conditions or limitations stated in the certificate.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoSurely that prima facie just means that courts should proceed with cases [that don't challenge the validity] assuming the mark to be valid once registered rather than that once registered the mark can not be challenged. For example genericisation causes a mark to become invalid despite that mark being registered - surely other objections work the same way. What I was trying to intimate was that someone with big enough cajones could challenge the validity of the mark as being merely descriptive of some goods (TV broadcasts, say) rather than being a proper indicator of origin of goods/services. ref: http://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=0882283 http://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=0882283, http://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=0846056 http://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=0846056 are some of the early registrations - NFL do appear to have seen off several other registrations and uses to the term "super bowl" (superbol, soul bowl, superbowlz, ...) in court however.
- rayiner 12y ago> It's not 'possibility' it's 'likelihood' of confusion that is considered, amongst other factors I used "possibility" deliberately. "Likelihood of confusion" is a factor in the legal test for trademark infringement (and generally the most important one). But the mere possibility of confusion might be enough to get a retailer to steer clear of a trademark as a practical rather than legal matter.
- rtpg 12y ago> Moreover when I say "buy my beer to drink whilst you watch the Super Bowl" I'm not using the trademark, I'm using a description of a sports event I think you would also have a difficult time convincing a judge you were not talking about the NFL championship. Application of the law is rarely a "check the dictionary, guys, he's technically correct" thing. Especially when it comes to things like trademark violations (where it's about confusion to the general public)
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago>convincing a judge you were not talking about the NFL championship // You don't need to. Trademark law doesn't prevent you from referring to people's products, nor their origin, it prevents you from selling your own products as if they were someone else's. The judge doesn't care [shouldn't!] that you're referring to the NFL Super Bowl TM - their concern is whether you're suggesting your product comes from the company that own the Super Bowl trademark (for a limited set of products). Not even an imbecile would think that "buy X to use whilst you do Y" means that the people selling X own Y. "Buy our gloves for your skiing trip to France" - oh clearly that company owns France /s. It's not about confusion of the general public, it's removed from that. Even if you can show that there is no actual confusion (surveys or whatnot) the judge can still decide there is a likelihood of it (and vice versa).