9 ms·
Yahoo to Spin Off Its Stake in Alibaba
- smackfu 12y agoSo current investors will get stock in Yahoo-Alibaba, a company that exists only to own Alibaba stock, and then they can sell their stock in that new company as if it they owned the Alibaba stock itself?
- PhoenixWright 12y agoYes which sounds stupid until you realize they didn't own "Alibaba stock itself," Yahoo did. Yahoo could've used that money as it wished but activist investors held Mayer's job as ransom, and she just payed in full.
- super_sloth 12y agoTo be fair, the market put such a small premium on the non-Alibaba value in Yahoo largely because they weren't confident that Yahoo wouldn't just squander it. Yahoo's purchase of Tumblr for nearly a billion dollars is a great example. That asset will likely never give Yahoo a return.
- pstuart 12y agoAre there any Yahoo acquisitions that haven't been complete disasters?
- scott_karana 12y agoFlickr and Tumblr haven't been disasters (yet) for users, at least... :)
- ceejayoz 12y agoFlickr stagnated for nearly a decade post-acquisition.
- dcole2929 12y agoit's ironic because technically Yahoo and their acquisitions are sound. Flickr is still one of the best looking photo sites around, and from what I hear from my Photography friends performs like a champ. Tumblr likewise is a good technological investment. I think the failure has been turning good technology into money, which is where a lot of companies fail. The beauty of Flickr and Tumblr are ruined as soon as you start heaping crap tons of banner ads on every page. But that said you still have to find a way to generate revenue from those investments.
- yuhong 12y agoTumblr was acquired after Marissa Mayer became CEO and one of her goals was to improve acquisitions.
- albertwang 12y agobrightroll
- rokhayakebe 12y agoWhat are the complete disasters and how did you come to the conclusion that they weren't worth the price they paid? Genuinely curious.
- nullrouted 12y agoBroadcast.com http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broadcast.com http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broadcast.com Made Mark Cuban some money but it never turned a profit for Yahoo and they don't have anything in that space anymore. You can look at the entire list here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mergers_and_acquisitions_by_Yahoo http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mergers_and_acquisition...! A couple of others that stand out: GeoCities, Zimbra (Yahoo bought it for $350 Mil, sold it to VMware for less who sold it down the road as well), etc.
- kenrikm 12y agoWell not all the acquisitions were bad.. ViaWeb ;-)
- shenoyroopesh 12y agoFlurry. Another acquisition that continues to lose money.
- rdl 12y agoOverture. Which was kind of like "PayPal buying eBay" in terms of Yahoo!'s core business, but didn't go far enough.
- gcb0 12y agooverture succeed in it made google buy much larger , i.e. more expensive when summed, competitors overseas to keep up :D
- vidoc 12y agoThe acquisition of broadcast.com for 5.7B. That's an expensive domain name but the redirect works :P
- coralreef 12y agoMostly paid in stock
- kansface 12y agoYahoo's stock is valued far less than the sum of its assets. That is quite a lack of confidence.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Yahoo's stock is valued far less than the sum of its assets. That is quite a lack of confidence. The value of any business entity with non-zero liabilities is less than the sum of its assets. That's just finance 101.
- seanflyon 12y agoMost companies have value that would not count as "assets"
- dragonwriter 12y agoMost company have intangible assets and/or liabilities whose valuation is less-than-concrete that aren't traditionally reflected on a balance sheet except when they are given a concrete valuation as "goodwill" in the event of acquisition of the company. These assets and liabilities exist all the time, though. In the case of a publicly traded company where the market cap is substantially less than the book value -- concrete assets less concrete liabilities -- there is a judgement that these fuzzy assets and liabilities aggregate to a net liability. That's a sign of perceived distress, but not really rare. Its even less rare for a company to be valued less than its (concrete) assets -- this is fairly normal. That just means that the net positive goodwill is less than concrete liabilities.
- yabatopia 12y agoThat's because investors look at Yahoo as a holding company, with 3 main components : Alibaba, Yahoo Japan and Yahoo (USA/Rest of World). It's quite normal that the value of the holding company is (far) below the sum of its parts. There are multiple reasons for this discount: assets are less liquid, overhead costs, management risks, taxes, etc.
- 12y ago
- PhoenixWright 12y agoThis demonstrates incredible weakness by Mayer. Giving away Yahoo's future in order to save her own skin. This should mark the end of Yahoo. I expect to see a merger or buyout soon after this closes.
- adwf 12y agoI've been waiting for either Alibaba or Softbank to step up and buy them out for months. Now that they're spinning off the Alibaba shares, and given that their core business is currently valued around $0 (by the market), I imagine that Softbank might pick them up for a steal.
- PhoenixWright 12y agoAn Aol merger or SoftBank buyout seem like the most likely scenarios. Microsoft might also be interested.
- charlesdm 12y agoIsn't she acting in best interests of shareholders in this case? Isn't that why she is there, to create shareholder value? Personally, I think that so far she has wasted a ton of money with little to show for it. Selling the stake and incurring 35% corporate tax on an amount that large just to fuel a war chest seems abysmal to do. That would be ~$13.5bn of destroyed shareholder value, and frankly, probably the end of her tenure as CEO. I can't believe for a second her job is to turn Yahoo around. With hedge funds on the board, I'd assume her job to be to deliver maximum short term shareholder value. They just need a friendly face to do it. Maybe she hasn't realised that yet.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y ago"Selling off the worthwhile parts of the company in order to make stacks of cash" is just how capitalists work.
- charlesdm 12y agoNot always a bad thing. In this case, I'd say it makes a lot of sense. Do Yahoo at this point still even own any interesting assets? Not counting passive investments, such as BABA or Yahoo Japan stock
- jackgavigan 12y agoDoes anyone know why Yahoo! can't simply distribute its Alibaba shares to the Yahoo! shareholders? I'm assuming it would incur a tax liability of some kind but I haven't seen any explanation or discussion as to why it's not as good an option as the spin-off plan.
- chuhnk 12y agoBecause it would be taxed at 40% vs the spin off which would mean absolutely no tax.
- jackgavigan 12y agoDo you have a source where I can read about the tax rules that apply?
- charlesdm 12y agoStock swaps and splits are generally tax exempt in most jurisdictions.
- esturk 12y ago>http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2015-01-28/yahoo-would-rather-not-pay-taxes-on-its-alibaba-shares http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2015-01-28/yahoo-would... This article is helpful in understanding this spinoff. Namely it explains some pretty interesting requirements for this spin-off to happen. The company have to have a function (however lame like Halloween costume rental), and that there can't be any pre-arrangement for Alibaba to buy back the stock before the spin-off, etc.
- jackgavigan 12y agoGood article. Thanks for the pointer.
- ucha 12y agoIt's the same thing. Distributing the shares or creating a spin-off that current Yahoo shareholders will own is the same. The other option would have been to sell the Alibaba shares and give the proceeds to shareholders but in that case, they'd have to pay 35% in taxes.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ucha 12y agoThis is the only outcome that made sense. - Yahoo already has 7B in after-tax cash from the sale of a 7% share in Alibaba. - Yahoo could not just sell more BABA shares, incur a 35% tax just to complete some large acquisition while they already have 10B in cash which is more than the value of their core business. - They still own 35% of Yahoo Japan and that share is worth another 7B in itself. Yahoo still has tons of assets. What's interesting is that the market values Yahoo at around 50B at the moment. The BABA spinoff is worth 40B. They have 10B in cash. Their share of Yahoo Japan is 7B. Even before accounting for Yahoo's core business, they should be worth 57B. We're probably looking at an adjustment in their market cap if no legal obstacles to the spinoff are met.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> What's interesting is that the market values Yahoo at around 50B at the moment. The BABA spinoff is worth 40B. They have 10B in cash. Their share of Yahoo Japan is 7B. Even before accounting for Yahoo's core business, they should be worth 57B. Which suggests (assuming all that is accurate) that the market values Yahoo's "core business" as a $7 billion liability.
- JOnAgain 12y agoMore like the market is expecting them to lose the $10 billion in the bank (spending on money losing core businesses) rather than return money to shareholders.
- spullara 12y agoI think that the core business has an EBITDA of $1,362 million according to their 2014 results. That may be declining but it is still very much a profitable business. http://finance.yahoo.com/news/yahoo-reports-fourth-quarter-full-210500209.html http://finance.yahoo.com/news/yahoo-reports-fourth-quarter-f...
- encoderer 12y agoOr simply that $40bn in volatile stock that can't be sold for a year is not worth full face value. Which makes a lot of sense if you think about it.
- manishsharan 12y agoSeems like Yahoo is the most successful VC in Silicon Valley!
- the_arun 12y agoHere is the official video from Yahoo on FY14 earnings : Marissa Mayer answering questions - http://finance.yahoo.com/topics/yahoo-q4-full-year-2014-earnings/ http://finance.yahoo.com/topics/yahoo-q4-full-year-2014-earn...
- alecco 12y agoThis is sad on so many levels. Multi-billion tax avoidance, opportunistic shareholders, an over-hyped CEO, and a good Internet company on its twilight.
- rokhayakebe 12y agoSeveral have been critical of Marissa's performance. Can you please briefly explain why? Bonus for sharing what you would have safely expected from a Yahoo CEO in two years.
- serve_yay 12y agoYou could ask her investors the same question.
- foobarqux 12y agoSome indication that the business will grow?
- StevePerkins 12y agoThis New York Times piece does a really nice job of cataloging all of the criticisms: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/21/magazine/what-happened-when-marissa-mayer-tried-to-be-steve-jobs.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/21/magazine/what-happened-whe...
- kolbe 12y agoI cannot for the life of me figure out how Yahoo! is making this spinoff tax-free. How can a non-Investment Company spin off an Investment Company? How can this new Investment Company be exempt from diversification rules? This is just my opinion, but if Yahoo has figured out and easy way for corporations to directly exempt themselves from capital gains taxes, this may be their most significant contribution to the world yet. And Warren Buffett should be very thankful!
- foobarqux 12y agoWhat diversification rules?
- charlesdm 12y agoI'm no tax lawyer and have no clue on the specifics of US tax law, but in many jurisdictions it is relatively easy to do a tax neutral demerger of a subsidiary company from a holding company. You essentially defer the capital gain, up until you liquidate that company/stock. Didn't Warren Buffet do something similar by trading P&G stock for Duracell stock a while back, thereby avoiding (deferring) capital gains taxes?
- kolbe 12y agoSo, you would refer to this action being tax-free, but that the owners of the new subsidiary will still owe cap gains from Yahoo's basis if the subsidiary ever sells the Alibaba stake? I don't really consider that to be a tax-free. Buffett does find creative ways to aviod taxes, but they usually involve the company he owns stock in buying that stock from him in a tax-free exchange. In that case, Buffett exchanged his $3bn worth of P&G stock for $3bn worth of a stake in Duracell. That had allowed him to re-establish his tax basis at the value of Duracel, and avoid cap gains on what he had made on buying P&G earlier.
- nandemo 12y agoSee the Bloomberg article linked elsewhere in the comments. In short: 0) the spinout will also run some (non-important) businness and so won't be a pure holding company 1) the spinout is less likely to sell the Alibaba shares and squander out the proceeds, 2) eventually Alibaba itself could buy out the spinout, and then it would have no need to sell its own shares. Surely shareholders would still have to pay capital gain taxes when the spinned-out company gets acquired at a premium, but presumably at a rate better than the 40% Yahoo would have to pay.
- ep103 12y ago... why?
- rocky1138 12y agoAside from the Alibaba news, which smarter and more capable people here are commenting on, I found this nugget to be really interesting: "The company’s net income was $166 million, or 17 cents a share, in the fourth quarter, compared with $348 million, or 33 cents a share, in the same quarter a year ago." How long is the current trend sustainable? Year-over-year losing half their net income! At this point it seems like a simple matter of time.
- downandout 12y agoIt is bad, and yet, it isn't. I would give just about anything to own a business throwing off net profits of ~$650 million per year, or half that, or even 10% of that. Many people feel the same way you do - the market currently assigns a negative value to this $650 million annual income - but I think it's not a terrible thing to have coming in.
- bane 12y agoYou can have a small net income in an otherwise hugely profitable year if you reinvest most/all of it back into the company for growth.
- guelo 12y agoThese tax loopholes are disgusting. All these greedy millionaires assholes.
- gojomo 12y agoThis is a much more detailed explanation of why the spin-out saves on taxes: http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2015-01-28/yahoo-would-rather-not-pay-taxes-on-its-alibaba-shares http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2015-01-28/yahoo-would... It also suggests that at some point, after some time has gone by, Alibaba will find it a no-brainer to buy the spin-out.
- skuhn 12y agoI can see how this benefits Yahoo's shareholders, and they are after all a publicly traded company. It still seems like an exceptionally poor way for Yahoo itself to reap the rewards of this long term investment, particularly when it needs to inject some life into its business by spending on talent acquisition or new ventures. Here's how I think the Alibaba investment breaks down for Yahoo: Yahoo paid $1bn to Alibaba in 2005. They sold a portion back to Alibaba in 2012 for $4.3bn (after tax), and returned $3.65bn of that to shareholders. Yahoo made $0.65bn after taxes. They sold more shares during the Alibaba IPO, and made $6.3bn (after tax), with a pledge to return $3.15bn. Yahoo made $3.15bn from the IPO. Yahoo's remaining stake is now valued at $40bn, which they intend to spin off into another company -- seemingly with no ownership interest for Yahoo (and therefore, no further financial stake). So over the course of ten years, Yahoo turned $1bn into $3.8bn. A 14.3% APY is nothing to sneeze at, but It sure is a far cry from the $103bn / 58.5% APY they could have had if they retained all of their Alibaba shares today. Even taking 40% off for taxes and a few billion for dividends, that is a lot of walking around town money. Besides shareholder goodwill and getting Alibaba off their back, I don't see what Yahoo gets of any real value. Yahoo's stock price will collapse when the Alibaba shares are spun off. A company worth $1-10bn has a lot more potential buyers than a $50bn company, and someone will acquire and consume Yahoo shortly thereafter. Unless they announce plans to spin off the Yahoo Japan shares, in which case a potential acquirer just needs to wait to pick them up for a few hundred million after that event.
- dcole2929 12y agoI agree with your thinking here but I don't think Marrissa had a choice either. Long term thinking if Yahoo wants to stick it out as an independently operating company this move is most likely short sighted, but at this point none of the investors want that. It's pretty clear that a large part of the board no longer believes in Yahoo's potential for success. They just want the money that is tied up in the Alibaba stock so they can move on with other ventures. Marissa's choices were either find a way to put a big chunk of cash in shareholder pockets ASAP or face a hostile board that was going to do it's best to take control of the company and divest the Alibaba stock anyway (you can see that certain characters on the board have been angling for this for a while now). Either way Yahoo probably loses but at least this way she has bought the company time to try and turn the corner and see if her vision can work.