5 ms·
> This is a business plan. It is, but not because they have a plan beyond it, though. Cox/Time-Warner/etc. basically shook down Google for money a couple of y
by bsder 12y ago
> This is a business plan.
It is, but not because they have a plan beyond it, though.
Cox/Time-Warner/etc. basically shook down Google for money a couple of years ago. Google backed down and the last-mile ISPs thought they won.
Google, of course, was extremely unhappy to painfully discover that there was insufficient competition if the ISP's decided to play dirty and block their ads. So, Google now looks at the ISP's as a pure, existential threat that they must neutralize.
So, even if the ISP's upgrade or get really cheap, Google doesn't care. This is about making sure that no company ever has the ability to cut off Google's flow of ads to the consumer ever again.
Google will roll out fiber even if it's somewhat unprofitable just to slowly squeeze the ISP's into obeisance.
- mkr-hn 12y agoI learned a new word today.
- bsder 12y agoGlad to provide a valuable public service. :)
- daniel-cussen 12y agoYeah me too. obeisance: noun: deferential respect.
- sushirain 12y agoVertical integration is a powerful business strategy.
- rayiner 12y ago> Google will roll out fiber even if it's somewhat unprofitable just to slowly squeeze the ISP's into obeisance. Anti-competitive conduct is good when Google does it?
- enjo 12y agoSeems like the opposite of anti-competitive from my perspective.
- rayiner 12y agoDumping a product on the market at below-cost in order to force your competitors out of business is classic anti-competitive conduct.
- Dylan16807 12y agoBut those companies do the same thing to competition. If all sides are below-cost then it goes back to being fair competition, and it weakens monopoly power.
- Gimpei 12y agoNot really... Anticompetitive would be if: 1) The entrenched players were selling at "zero profit" or price equal to marginal cost. (I find this dubious, they are monopolies after all. internet services are a fraction of the US price in many European countries) 2) Google were doing this with the intention of raising prices once all of its competitors go out of business. Since they are behemoths in their own rights, I just don't see Google having the desire to push a price war to this point. In general "dumping" is hard to establish since no one is going to reveal their cost structure. In my experience it is normally an accusation flung by incumbents because that other guys stuff is too cheap. If it breaks the back of the ISP monopolies and forces them into the role of unprofitable utility, all the better. That's the whole point of market forces, right?
- kar2014 12y agoOkay that is anti-competitive, than what shall we call dumping a useless service onto consumers that they have to overpay for? Also these ISP's keep their competitors at bay, so consumers do not have a choice but to pay them high fees for useless service.
- aquadrop 12y agoIf that's the case, it would be more effective to settle on something cheaper, let's say program '100mbit/s to every home' and cover larger area faster. I also think that it has something to do with making major ISPs less aggressive, but there's probably something else, why Google needs 1 Gb/s
- mahyarm 12y agoI think as far as last mile costs goes, 100mbit or 1gbit, it isn't much different in price. It's running the wire in the first place. And 1gbit is impressive like gmail was. It blows everyone out of the water because their competitors stagnated.
- hkmurakami 12y agoThink about this in terms of a startup vs incumbent problem. The newcomer often needs to be 10x better than the incumbent in order to change the customer's habits. Fiber is just that.
- diminoten 12y agoBut it is profitable, isn't it? Google keeps telling everyone that they're not going into the fiber business to lose money. I think what's more important is that they're willing to spend money on fiber that they could spend elsewhere to get better returns. Returns on being an ISP probably aren't as good as returns on other kinds of infrastructure, at least up front.