6 ms·
Why? It may be nice, but why should employers be forced to subsidize reproduction?
by wyager 12y ago
Why? It may be nice, but why should employers be forced to subsidize reproduction?
- jacquesm 12y agoBecause it is one of those things that help close the gender gap, and besides without reproduction where will those companies get the next generation of workers and who will help pay for the pensions of those that work today. Almost every developed country has done the math and has realized that having children is part of having a society and that paid leave for people that have children is on balance a good thing. Ditto anti-discriminatory hiring laws and laws that state that it is illegal to ask a woman directly or indirectly whether or not she plans to have children during the hiring process. Here is a nice map illustrating the various times available per country: http://worldpolicyforum.org/global-maps/is-paid-leave-available-for-mothers-of-infants/ http://worldpolicyforum.org/global-maps/is-paid-leave-availa...
- vonmoltke 12y agoI agree fully on the gender gap and non-discrimination issues. I'm going to disagree somewhat on the benefit of encouraging reproduction past a certain point. There is a limit to the number of people this planet can sustain. There is a limit to the size our societies can grow to before they start fundamentally changing, and not for the better. Those issues should be considered before making policy decisions that reduce the burdens of reproduction beyond the replacement rate. In my opinion, couples should have support in the form of parental leaves, daycare, and such for the first two children. After that, you are on your own.
- jacquesm 12y agoYes, that's a good point but I don't think it is 'encouraging reproduction' so much as that is is making sure that there is some balance. Society has entered a coffin corner where we need to increase the numbers to sustain the previous generation, obviously that isn't going to be a long term viable strategy and some very clear headed thinking will be required to see if we can still work our way out of that. But that's a different issue altogether than the one at heart of the debate here. Not entirely unrelated, but unrelated enough to be seen as a separate item.
- vonmoltke 12y agoYeah, I was wavering on whether to even make the point because it does start down a path that branches away from leave policies. I think it is useful to keep those concerns in mind when discussing them, though.
- jacquesm 12y agoPoint taken, it's a problem and a very serious one and one that we will likely have to face in the relatively near future.
- ssharp 12y agoWhat happens if you have one child, but your second pregnancy is a multiple?
- vidarh 12y agoUN population projections indicate that the population will peak later this century and fall back substantially before resuming a much more modest growth rate. Most developed countries are today only maintaining growth through immigration, if at all, and China is set to peak and start contracting in the next couple of decades. India is lagging, as is many African countries, but even that is unable to prevent the world population from peaking towards the end of the century. That is with encouraging reproduction this way in large parts of the developed world, and with substantial easing of restrictions in countries like China. Ironically, the US, with the worst maternity leave policies in the developed world, has one of the highest reproduction rates of the developed world, while most European countries today are below replacement rate. Policies to limit support beyond the first two children may sound sensible, but would likely have a negative effect: The countries which today have extensive maternity or paternity leave for the most part will run into substantial problems of aging populations unless they manage to push reproduction rates up and/or increase immigration numbers over the next few decades. Given the political resistance to high immigration rates most places, that's not likely to fly. The "payoff" of holding back of maternity leave to limit reproduction rates would also be minimal because the countries with good maternity leave for the most part have a low enough reproduction rate that budging it some small percentage rate further down would not really do much. More and more countries are making the transition to low reproduction rates, and if it continues we will eventually be in a situation where population decline will be the major problem.
- mahyarm 12y agoThe fast reproducing countries are developing countries. Most developed countries reproduce just a little bit over or under replacement rates. Make birth control cheap or free, have some sort of family planning education and humanity will reproduce below replacement rates very quickly. See Iran for an example.
- corysama 12y agoAre there any countries where employers are legally obligated to pay a significant amount (>=80% salary) for a significant time (>=3 months) for maternity leave? It's my (highly ignorant) understanding that European employers do not; European governments do.
- parennoob 12y agoNot going to happen any time this century, but relaxing the restrictions on immigration or adoption could also effectively achieve "getting the next generation of workers". It is somewhat naïve to imply that reproduction is a strict necessity for getting new workers in developed countries, when thousands of children are dying of malaria and dysentery elsewhere in the world. With the Earth's population way larger than it ever has been before, reproduction at the current rate is not particularly important or desirable. However, lots of parents will usually participate in it as a choice.
- sigzero 12y agoI don't believe they should. If a company decides that that option is part of their benefits package great. The Fed should not be reaching its hands into businesses for much more than they do right now.
- tinco 12y agoBecause someone will have to pay, and it is the governments task to decide who. Obviously it could be decided that the government will pay for it. Regardless of who pays for it, the employers will suffer discomfort. Do you think it is the employers right to not be forced to subsidize the reproduction of their employees?
- joshuaheard 12y agoYes, someone will have to pay: the person raising a child. If they can't afford to take time off to have the child, then they should seriously reconsider having a family. Having a family involves major expenses that only increase as the children age. The employer side is that some employers will not be able to afford this luxury and will be unable to hire a temporary replacement. The result is decreased productivity, which hurts the economy. It should be the employers' choice if they want to offer that benefit. If it is such a benefit to the employer, then all employers will do it. As we continue to pile mandates on employers, you raise the cost of hiring. Economics 101 says if you raise the cost of something, you get less of it. More mandates=less jobs.
- colmvp 12y ago> Yes, someone will have to pay: the person raising a child. If they can't afford to take time off to have the child, then they should seriously reconsider having a family. Having a family involves major expenses that only increase as the children age. Agreed. My parents didn't have me until they raised enough money to take time off. Likewise, I don't plan on having a child (if any) until I have that cushion. Quite frankly, I don't begrudge the government or corporations for not providing such benefits. I don't consider it their responsibility.
- jacquesm 12y agoI did the same, but at the same time I don't begrudge others less fortunate financially to not be able to do so. Otherwise you get into a 'children are for the wealthy' situation which is for obvious reasons also not desirable.
- untog 12y agoIt's not as if having a child is some selfish act that only benefits you - it is to the benefit of society. Simply put: we need a new generation of workers to be working when we retire, or we're screwed. Optimally, those workers will be well educated - and numerous studies have shown that the more involved a parent is in their childs life, the better (particularly when they are very young). So, perhaps it isn't fair that employers subsidise this - but what's the alternative?
- Someone1234 12y agoWhy should companies be forced to pay for roads, utilities, and public schools? Because they need all of these things to get their business done.
- pc86 12y agoThey don't pay for any of these things. They pay taxes. The argument is here is whether the company should directly fund parental leave or if it should come from tax revenue (or if it should happen at all, which I think is a different argument).
- Chinjut 12y agoBecause it would be a nicer world to live in (in my opinion and many others') if becoming a parent didn't practically require sacrificing one's career and thus future livelihood. Mind you, I'd be happy to see paternity leave paid from a general tax base rather than necessarily from a particular employer, but the general principle that sometimes entities should pay for things they might otherwise not want to pay for to help make society more pleasant to live in is just the same as for myriad other generally accepted expenditures.
- Chinjut 12y ago(Minor clarification: I wrote "paternity leave" thinking "That's the gender-neutral term, right? The one with 'parent' in it?". In retrospect, I realize my brainfart, but can no longer edit. Please pretend I had written "parental leave")
- digikata 12y agomaybe we should tie it to benefit of corporate personhood as a societal responsibility.
- vidarh 12y agoStrawman. It is not necessary for employers to "be forced to subsidize reproduction" in order to provide paid maternity leave. A lot of countries that have paid maternity leave covers it out of tax payment, or national insurance funds that are often predominantly or wholly paid by employees.