2 ms·
No, physician supply is a fundamental issue. The price of medicine is high in part because of scarcity: there are (doctor's working hours) x (number of doctors)
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
No, physician supply is a fundamental issue. The price of medicine is high in part because of scarcity: there are (doctor's working hours) x (number of doctors) doctor hours available for consumption.
People desire more doctor-hours than exist, hence some rationing mechanism is needed. By increasing the number of doctor-hours (either increase number of doctors or doctor working hours) you can reduce the scarcity.
You can't eliminate scarcity simply by making a moral choice.
- nradov 17y agoSure you can reduce the price of physician time by increasing the supply, but that isn't practical for several reasons. 1. The high price is largely due to the need to pay off education loans. Physicians commonly finish training $200K+ in debt. Even if there were more physicians, they would have to charge almost as much just to make ends meet. To solve that you first need to find a way to cut the price of education. 2. Very few people want to be physicians, and fewer still have the intelligence and talent to do it well. Treatment by a quack is often worse than no treatment at all. 3. The only way to get a lot more physicians in to industrialized countries is through immigration from developing countries. However the political climate has turned against immigration (I think that's a bad change, but it's unlikely to reverse any time soon). And importing physicians leaves those developing countries bereft of medical care they desperately need. 4. Most physicians already work long hours. You can't squeeze much more out of them. Or if they do work longer, quality of care suffers.
- frig 17y ago(1) is easily solvable given enough political will; a federal program funding medical loans in exchange for N years of post-education service in particular hospital systems. There are successful models for this in use in the army (both at the level of things like ROTC and also at the level of becoming a doctor-for-the-army); if the federal government's role in healthcare expands a program like this producing physicians for "general service" is entirely reasonable. (2) is correct in principle but without firmer #s it is hard to say if it's materially limiting. A look at an actual chart is revealing: http://www.aamc.org/data/facts/charts1982to2007.pdf http://www.aamc.org/data/facts/charts1982to2007.pdf ...page #3 (as printed on the page) has a matriculation chart: - in the 1982-3 period 16,597 students matriculated - in the 2006-7 period 17,759 students matriculated ...which is ~7% increase of 20 years. The last page has a graduation chart which is similarly flat. By comparison, the # of full-time fall enrollees at degree-granting institutions: - in 1982: 7,220,618 - in 2007: 11,269,892 ...which is a ~50% increase over 20 years ( cf http://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d08/tables/dt08_188.asp http://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d08/tables/dt08_188.asp ). I've omitted part-timers as largely irrelevant wrt the # of future medical school students. Now it's possible that: - there's been a nearly-constant supply of students enrolled in college each year who are interested in and capable of becoming physicians - ...almost the entire 50% increase in student enrollment has been in students uninterested in medicine and/or incapable of becoming competent physicians ...but that extreme of a shift seems rather unlikely. What seems more likely is that medical schools have decided to hold class sizes mostly constant over the years, with a slight upward trend (which I'd wager is mostly accounted for by the opening of new medical schools over those decades, not by increased class size at existing institutions). If that scenario pans out -- that the pool of qualified candidates is larger than the current matriculants -- than while your point (2) is a limit on how far the supply of physicians can be increased it wouldn't be the case that we're necessarily close to that limit..
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThe question of whether training more doctors is feasible is tangential to the point that making a moral choice won't make medical services less scarce. It may not be feasible, and in that case there is no solution to the problem of scarcity of medical services. Regarding increasing the number of doctors: plenty of people want to be physicians. In 2007, 42,315 people applied to medical school, but only 17,759 were accepted. http://www.aamc.org/data/facts/2007/mcatgparaceeth07.htm http://www.aamc.org/data/facts/2007/mcatgparaceeth07.htm The people who are rejected are fairly close in scores (GPA, MCAT) to those who were accepted and there is plenty of overlap between the accepted/rejected distributions. Let me do a little normal-distribution-fu. Assume that MCAT VR of 8.3 is the cutoff for "intelligence and talent to do it well". If we accepted every white person above that cutoff, we could train about 10,728 more white doctors per year and a few thousand more asian doctors. (I picked 8.3 so I can call you a racist if you say you want a higher cutoff. ;) ) Regarding point 4), I agree. In any case, while increasing the supply of physicians may not be feasible, this doesn't mean it is the case that making a moral choice can cure issues of scarcity.
- frig 17y agoThank you for making my case more succinctly. I'm intimately familiar with the specifics of medical education as a family member of mine is a high-up muckety-muck at one of the world's better academic hospitals (won't be more precise than that). There's a perception amongst outsiders that medicine is unbelievably difficult that only a handful of people qualify for medical training on their merits; a more accurate assessment is that the # of slots is fixed and the admissions are as selective as they need to be to filter down the applicant pool to the # of available slots. It'd take time to ramp up to being able to handle that many students -- medicine is mainly taught by working under the supervision of existing experts, and there's a finite supply of expert-hours at the moment -- but the present rate of doctor-production is far from what it could be without a material drop in applicant quality.