7 ms·
The USA is automatically photographing millions of cars and putting the data in a giant database used by all law-enforcement. It reads like the premise of a dy
by javajosh 12y ago
The USA is automatically photographing millions of cars and putting the data in a giant database used by all law-enforcement.
It reads like the premise of a dystopian science fiction novel.
I can't help but guess that the reaction is going to be a big shoulder shrug, because, to but it bluntly, things aren't that bad for most people. If you are white, have a good job, follow the law, and make sure to richly kiss ass if and when you come in contact with the police, life in the USA is rich, full; it's like heaven.
If I have heaven, am I going to risk it just because of some law enforcement techniques which are only questionable in the abstract?
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoYou may be on to something there. I wonder, however, how people are going to reconcile what the government is doing now with all of those previous works of fiction? It's going to have to add up to something -- a narrative must be formed. Were those just the halcyon days of yore? And now we've somehow "grown up" to face the realities of a scary world? Even more troubling, people are people, and when this is seriously abused -- and my money says it'll happen within the next 20 years -- how are people going to explain it all away? I am left with the troubling thought that we are creating for ourselves a dystopian society never dreamed of even by sci-fi writers. Rome had nothing on this, nor does North Korea. The attention a known dissident would receive in former East Germany is a cakewalk compared to the kind of surveillance we're giving each citizen who's guilty of nothing. The only thing we're waiting for is the logical and natural corruption of large systems of people to take place.
- jkaunisv1 12y agoUm, I really don't think it's at East German Stasi-levels. Known dissidents were gaslighted, had objects in their homes moved around, and had informants reporting on them in their apartment buildings/family/workplace. It's bad, it's dystopian, but it doesn't seem to be THAT bad yet.
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoMy comment was limited to data collection only. Apologies if I appear to have one overstated my case. My hair caught on fire for a minute there.
- harry8 12y agoSerious question, do you think it's that bad for wikileaks employees or volunteers? Jacob Appelbaum claims it is and has moved to Germany where such things are living memory along with their overthrow. I'm inclined to believe him. I haven't seen evidence of his track record for telling lies is worse than government spokespeople and apologists on the general topic.
- jkaunisv1 12y agoI know basically nothing about wikileaks. Given what the CIA/other agencies have done in the past, I guess it seems plausible.
- honestcoyote 12y agoThe operative word is 'yet'. You're right. Things aren't that bad now, compared to the Stasi. But the problem lies in the tools and information available. All it takes is for one of the parties in power to decide they want to use it for their own unscrupulous purposes. And suddenly, they have more information than the Stasi could have dreamed of. There's no guarantee there will ever be anyone in power who wants to abuse this. But it's a dangerous situation we've put ourselves in. If we're starting a betting pool, my bet would be on the system limping along as it is for the forseeable future. Average citizens won't even really notice the growing surveillance. Criminals will, but no one will care about them. Certain protest groups, like whatever form the future Occupy takes, will see the system used to their detriment, but ordinary people will still not care. Always safe to bet on apathy, and relatively safe to bet on the politicians / powers-that-be realizing they can already have most of what they want without creating a repressive hellhole--which would cause more economic and social problems than it would be worth.
- FeeTinesAMady 12y agoThe FBI does that. They've done it since J. Edgar Hoover. They did it to Martin Luther King.
- javajosh 12y ago>how people are going to reconcile what the government is doing now with all of those previous works of fiction? I don't think we should over-estimate how widely read those works of fiction actually are, so there may not be a reconciliation. This, reality, is literally the first time some people have thought about the implications of mass surveillance with modern technology. SF geeks are, once again, ahead of the curve. :) Movies like Minority Report are good primers for the concept of a panopticon. But I must have read 10's of stories involving panopticons in Analog and F&SF on all sides of the issue, in all variants. I remember a particularly good one involving how to get away with murder in a panopticon society. Iain Banks' The Culture with it's benevolent, quite desirable panopticons (the Minds). Oddly, I don't remember any stories that remind me of what's going on now, which is a battle between those who want to protect security at any cost, and those who simply don't trust the government, any government, with the kind of power necessary to even come close to the level of protection they seem to be aiming for, which is total.
- sliverstorm 12y agoTo put it even more bluntly, automatic license plate scanning doesn't really seem to have been bad for anybody, aside from people on the lam. Though I am open to examples to the contrary.
- angersock 12y agoThis is the sort of apparatus that, once installed, lies dormant until one day it is called into action and springs shut, clamping down on freedom. Just because they're building the gallows slowly and using such wonderful rope doesn't make the eventual hanging any less troublesome. EDIT: You know, 70 years ago today the Red Army found out what could be done with good record keeping and decent surveillance, and at what scale. Imagine, just imagine, if you could type your favorite demographic into a terminal, get a list of everyone fitting that and some other criteria, and then a list of addresses and doors to knock on. Mankind and government has never done well with such power.
- a3n 12y agoThis would seem to be a great database for the police to watch for juicy civil forfeiture targets to stumble through their jurisdiction, to seize a car or its possible contents. How would they know that you have good stuff inside the car? Other databases.
- r00fus 12y ago> If you are white, have a good job, follow the law, and make sure to richly kiss ass if and when you come in contact with the police, life in the USA is rich, full; it's like heaven. Sure, until any of the above changes. Or you piss off the wrong person with connections. Some of which you may have little control over. And to be honest - to not be raked over the coals simply to exercise my right to freedom of movement is not exactly "heaven" to me, it's the basics of a free society based on laws.
- javajosh 12y agoDon't mistake my description for advocacy - heaven should not be for so few, nor should it be so judgmental and so brittle. As for your comments about movement - try to keep some perspective! While the TSA is an icon of everything wrong with our security climate (security theater, irrational assessment of risk, irrational assignment of resources, and a banal humiliation meted out to those who can't afford to skip the lines) it is, at least theoretically, under our control. The next President could dismantle the whole thing (although I'm not sure what statutory restrictions there are - certainly the President and Congress could change things if they wanted). No one wants to be the one to dismantle the TSA, because when the next attack happens (not if, when) they'll get the blame.
- ulfw 12y ago> If you are white, have a good job, follow the law, and make sure to richly kiss ass if and when you come in contact with the police, life in the USA is rich, full; it's like heaven. How exactly does this sound like heaven? Sounds incredibly restrictive and authoritarian to me. Always make sure you're not saying or doing the wrong thing. What happened to 'land of the free; home of the brave'?