4 ms·
Reexamining what makes health care so expensive.
- tokenadult 17y ago"The rise of HMOs was enabled by an earlier federal government attempt to rein in health care costs, the Health Maintenance Organization Act of 1973. The idea behind HMOs was that these insurers would control costs by offering a wide array of preventive care to their subscribers. That sounds like a plausible idea until one realizes that people, on average, change insurers every four years or so. An insurer that invested in preventive care was unlikely to reap the cost-saving benefits." That's an interesting response to the HMO phenomenon, which I remember was touted as a solution to ballooning health care costs. The cost containment didn't happen, which is an important lesson for today's predictions about efforts to contain health care costs.
- duncanj 17y agoThe HMO trend was based on the assumption that people were usually going to work for the same company for a long time. It made tons of sense, and still does in a union-provided health plan context, for example. Perhaps the trend will be for employers to pay the tax, drop their company-based health plans, and then their employees will purchase their own plans that follow them around. Then, these plans will keep individuals in longer, making it more worthwhile to focus on prevention and overall health.
- furyg3 17y agoI also read this as one of the most important points in the article. I wonder if requiring insurance companies to accept all customers, regardless of risk or pre-existing conditions, would create incentives for insurers to promote more preventative care. Since customers could still switch providers, insurers wouldn't know whether or not they'd be holding the short straw when the customer gets sick in 10 years, but that wouldn't matter since they'd have the same chance as any other insurer of 'reap[ing] the cost-saving benefits' of their own preventative care.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoUnless the insurance company holds 50% market share, the odds are pretty high that they won't reap the purported benefits of preventative care. If a companies market share is 10%, their odds of reaping the benefits of P(customer switches) x 10%. Regardless, I'm not sure how an insurance company will manage to get people to eat less and exercise more.
- fnid 17y agoSeems then that a public option would be good for health because the insurer of the public would want to reduce costs over the life of the member. If a lot of the costs are due to diseases that could have been prevented cheaply earlier in life, then total health care bill would be lower and thus the public option could operate much more cheaply than a private insurer with a 4 year outlook. Again, this is another data point on the short sightedness of our nation. We continue to look less and less far into the future and the human race is suffering. We are paying more for less quality. The environment is suffering. We need a vision. we need to look into the future. we need a more longterm outlook with perhaps some short term sacrifice so that we don't end up some day not existing.
- anamax 17y ago> The idea behind HMOs was that these insurers would control costs by offering a wide array of preventive care to their subscribers. Nice theory, but preventative healthcare doesn't reduce costs. (Good plumbing and sanitation does.) See http://prescriptions.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/08/18/the-problem-with-prevention/ http://prescriptions.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/08/18/the-proble... http://prescriptions.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/09/03/when-preventive-care-costs-more/ http://prescriptions.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/09/03/when-preve... and so on. Preventative healthcare doesn't (and can't) address many of the things that drive healthcare costs.
- nradov 17y agoYou're only correct if you ignore patients' longevity and quality of life. Those may not show up as line items on a budget, but they represent real costs to society. When setting public policy it's a mistake to ignore those factors or treat them as externalities.
- anamax 17y agoI'm not ignoring those things. I'm pointing out that the claims that preventative healthcare will save money are wrong. We can argue about whether specific preventative measures are worth what they cost. My point is that it is dishonest or ignorant to say that they'll save money.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoOne unavoidable reason why health care costs go up is simply Baumol's Cost Disease. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baumol%27s_cost_disease http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baumol%27s_cost_disease In short, health care hasn't experienced the same productivity gains as manufacturing, agriculture or many other areas. The cost of medical services is proportional to income, while the cost of cars, computers and groceries have gone down relative to income. Therefore, the opportunity cost of visiting the doctor has gone up. There is little we can do to fix this without mass producing medicine.
- tomjen2 17y agoYou seem to be right, that would be what is happening. So, how do we mass produce medicine?
- nostrademons 17y agoOne-size-fits-all cures. You can buy a treatment, but whether or not that treatment works for your disease is your own responsibility. Let the buyer beware - if you die, it's your own damn fault. Medicine's not the only industry that faces this problem. Education also requires that the product be tailored to the customer. Except in the public education system, the government did try to mass produce it, having standard curricula that all students must learn, and if it's not appropriate for your brain, that's your own damn fault. Go drop out of school or something. Those of us who went through the public school system know how that turned out...
- gaius 17y agoMass producing medicine is easy. Mass discovering and FDA-approving new medicines is the hard part.
- rsheridan6 17y agoThat wouldn't help with costs anyway. You'd be paying about as much for a bunch of new patented drugs - actually more if they were good enough to get you to switch from generics. You might get better treatment, but not cheaper treatment.