11 ms·
How the 'John Oliver Effect' Is Having a Real-Life Impact
- Amorymeltzer 12y agoThe article says so briefly, but what makes his show wonderful is the comedy mixed-in with in-depth news research and assessment. It's the kind of thing you'd want or expect on a constant basis from massive, 24-hour news networks, but is either largely absent or lost in the noise. I personally gave to the Society of Women Engineers (http://societyofwomenengineers.swe.org/ http://societyofwomenengineers.swe.org/) after his show because he did such an effective job of conveying his message. More news programs could learn from him.
- mc32 12y agoWhat I don't get is why it's necessary to have comedy to get people engaged? What is it that news requires the 'chaser' of comedy? I don't think we can attribute it to people being base/vulgar. Why can't a serious, well researched news program do well? Why does there have to be a chaser to make it successful?
- sbov 12y ago60 minutes seems to do fairly well. I'd classify it as John Oliver-esque without the comedy.
- flycaliguy 12y agoI think it's because finding the funny in even the worst news is an important part of being human. It's an important feature in our ability to cope and deal with things. Maybe it's evolutionary? The people who when presented with a problem were able to keep their spirits up while tackling it perhaps had a better success rate then those who lost perspective on their responsibilities to their own emotional wellbeing.
- Retra 12y agoMost people don't like sitting in front of a TV and being lectured and/or read to. They need something to satiate their need for acceptance. Comedy is far safer than the popular alternatives: FUD, hate, and conspiracy. A great personality is another good one, but those are rare.
- navait 12y agoI think television is terrified that you would turn to another channel, etc; Telling a joke keeps you for a few seconds, enough time to tell another. And then you're engaged. But you have to make the case to watch your show in the span of 30 seconds. The advantage of comedy is that you're always telling a joke - users can enter at any point and will stay to hear the rest. And if in-depth news analysis was something people wanted, well, the Economist would have a much higher subscription base than it currently does.
- quadrangle 12y agoBecause comedy provides a veneer of safety around an issue. The hahaha part of human nature is largely about reacting to being uncomfortable. People avoid things that just make them seriously uncomfortable, and comedy provides a safer, lighter way to deal with it. It also makes it harder for opponents to attack. It's really complex. It's nothing to do with vulgarity, vulgarity is just common in comedy because it's another thing that makes people uncomfortable.
- oscilloscope 12y agoCognitive dissonance puts viewers in tension. Laughter resolves that tension.
- mc32 12y agoHmmm, sort of like they are finding the jocular humor, the ironies, the satire _for_ you, so you don't have to. They are doing all the work for you and you get to sit down and _not_ think. So you get to eat your cake and have it, as it were.
- yazaddaruvala 12y agoSo I'll put it to you this way, through highschool and university the best teachers or professors I ever had were comedians. Maybe "entertainers" is a better word. One of them even specifically told us about his strategy before he started his series of lectures. Basically, when people get bored they stop absorbing. Once in a while he will "trick your mind" (i.e. confuse it), and you will pay attention again. To be honest, its why I know as much about operating systems, locks and threads, as I do. To make this story relevant. Humor is just that, a trick someone plays on your mind.
- mc32 12y agoI think you might have a point there. For an instructor I can attribute it to personality or style. They know you a bit and try to engage but broadcast is simplex so i think its something else. I think they're trying to reproduce a type of gossipy jocular delivery of news. Maybe a bit like a town crier but still different. My feeling is they're trying to seem like they're your friends, so you feel more engaged and listen and don't mind the bias because, you 'know them, and you accept that trait'. The unattached news delivery was not engaging us psychologically (for whatever reason we may need that) so they came up with this new recipe. Never the less in other countries I've had news delivered pretty matter of factly --with built in biases of course but the news wasn't chased with comedy satire etc. There might have been irony but anyhow there's something about the need for comedy to make it digestible for us
- germinalphrase 12y agoThis speaks very closely to my own development as an educator. Being a 'fonte of knowledge' is only engaging to student who're already intrinsically motivated to learn. With the expectation that every student be engaged and successful in their learning (regardless of the baggage or apathy they carry with them into the room) I've found myself actively attempting to improve the performance aspect of my job. It helps that my partner is an improv comedianne, but when I began this work (as as natural introvert) I didn't imagine that a daily self-review of my "performance" would consider timing and delivery as significantly. In any case, it works and because it works I try to improve this skill.
- 88e282102ae2e5b 12y agoI would speculate that the audience for TV news these days might not be looking for well-researched news.
- gohrt 12y agoJohn Oliver's show is (relatively) well-researched. That's half of its value and appeal.
- cbd1984 12y agoIn addition to what everyone else has said, even the most serious of the serious hard news reporters have never read the news in a completely dry monotone. Humans actively filter such boring stimuli; it isn't immoral to do so, it's inevitable.
- burnte 12y agoThe comedy makes it more engaging. Simple as that.
- gohrt 12y agoThe word "vulgar" originally meant, "in the common language people understand", instead of "the elite formal language of the elites". That's precisely the point here, to meet people where they are and communicate in a way that feels natural, not arcane and ritualized. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vulgar_Latin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vulgar_Latin
- briandear 12y agoIt's because many millennials demand to be entertained and have the attention span of a gnat. There are younger folks that can tell you everything about Kardashian's new ass but can't name the Vice President.
- masklinn 12y ago> What I don't get is why it's necessary to have comedy to get people engaged? It's not, but entertaining people is a good way to keep them engaged and comedy is a relatively easy way to entertain while telling. When the content is dry and the delivery is dry and completely unengaging people just tune out, even if the subject is interesting in the abstract. Comedy is not the only way, Attenborough is entertaining without being comedic, but it's a good way nonetheless. And comedians are observers of human nature by trade, so they might have an easier time couching down and expressing more "serious" topics than some other entertainers.
- scotty79 12y agoContent is absurd so comedy as vessel is totally fitting. Same stuff was said seriously but when you hear someone describing with serious tone how reality is absurd you don't believe him.
- Toenex 12y agoI'm English and my first exposure to John Oliver was the segment he did on Civil Forfeiture which I found both interesting and entertaining. What struck me was how more like a British satire the show was. Do others think it matters that John is British and thus gets a little extra leeway (we do like our swearing) and can play the outsider role somewhat?
- kozhevnikov 12y agoJohn was also a panellist on literally the first Mock the Week and few others during its 1st/2nd seasons and available on YouTube. Although I think he was still finding his style back then. http://mocktheweek.wikia.com/wiki/John_Oliver#List_of_appearances http://mocktheweek.wikia.com/wiki/John_Oliver#List_of_appear...
- coldpie 12y agoSlightly OT, if you like John Oliver, you may enjoy The Bugle, a podcast which features Oliver and his friend Andy Zaltzmann discussing world news, often focusing on America and the UK.
- tn13 12y agoWe have always known that peddling feel-good bull that validates our own beliefs and biases gets many takers. I don appreciated JO's efforts to talk about things like Net neutrality but his arguemnts are mostly plain wrong.
- taeric 12y agoI would be interested in seeing more on which of his arguments are plain wrong. The net neutrality one, I honestly don't remember. Pretty much every other show, though. Bloody amazing. The lottery and the wealth gap ones were particularly fun. The Miss America one, brilliant.
- mynameishere 12y agoThe Miss America one, brilliant. Haven't see the "Miss America" one personally (and I won't) but I can tell you that that particular institution has been a laughingstock for decades. If he has something new to ridicule about it, kudos, but I doubt it changed any already fully-formed opinions from his viewers.
- pbh101 12y agoI suggest you watch it. I enjoy his show but most of his stances are decently predictable (and I generally disagree with). This is one that surprised me.
- oliverthrowaway 12y agoThat was kind of what made it brilliant. The Miss America pageant makes some grandiose claims about how they're the world's largest source of scholarships for woman -- 45 million in a particular year. They showed that (a) They were using some sleight of hand, and the real number was something like 100 times less than that (b) That still made them the largest source of scholarships for women
- gohrt 12y agoThat's actually a huge misconception, and LWT got it wrong: Miss America's paltry scholarship program is the largest provider of women-only scholarships. Many many non-women-only programs give more scholarship money to women than Miss America.
- rattray 12y agoSo _Last Week Tonight_ does longer-form, more in-depth comedy reporting? That actually seems like a terrific mix, and definitely a hole in the market. People want to be entertained and informed, and while _Colbert_ / _Daily Show_ provide good breadth, we need good depth as well.
- pbh101 12y agoI've watched a good number on YouTube. They are generally longer-form, and get into some more detail. I find them quite enjoyable, but I think you may be disappointed if you go in expecting a lot more depth. I don't think you want your sister telling you that's how she keeps in touch with American news (hypothetically speaking :)
- ottertown 12y agoI grew up watching Jon Stewart and occasionally Colbert. I always thought it was interesting how Jon Stewart would defend against his critics by saying something along the lines of "my show is preceded by puppet prank callers (crank yankers), this is a comedy show first and foremost." That was his defense against people saying he was contributing to news imbalance or accusing him of not doing anything useful to alleviate the problems of biased journalism. He took a hard line (and still does I think) that he was a comic and was not responsible for anything beyond that. I remember once he had a segment about a 9/11 first responders bill (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FM6cvbjZmQE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FM6cvbjZmQE), which may have reversed the course of that bill for the better (http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/27/business/media/27stewart.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/27/business/media/27stewart.h...). John Oliver seems to have grasped the power of that particular segment and has, in my opinion, drastically improved the form of the political satire. It will be interesting to see how his perceived influence will affect next season.
- cjubb39 12y agoThat's part of the reason I never really liked Jon Stewart. He knew he was the primary, if not only, news source for a large demographic; yet, he would consistently hide behind the Comedy Central logo in the bottom corner when he was criticized. It's like he felt he---and only he---was allowed to turn on and off his "real" journalist at whim.
- dmschulman 12y agoI'd compare it to Kronkite talking about the Vietnam War, if I had to pull out a quick example in relating it to network news. Kronkite was candid and honest and his manner might not have always been what the network wanted (they'd prefer some kind of ra ra America attitude), but it was his breaking character that made people pay attention. I don't think anyone feels the same about any other anchor on TV right now, CNN, FOX, MSNBC, NBC, ABC, etc. I'm not saying Stewart is a journalist, him being able to sit on the fence like he does upsets guys on the networks, but he is effective with his hosting and I don't think he's doing anyone a disservice.
- 12y ago
- quadrangle 12y agoJohn Oliver's show has honestly taken things to a far better level, dealing with real issues in approachable ways. The Daily Show is just cluttered with inside gossip about crappy news TV which I don't give a shit about either. Basically, the Daily Show has had a handful of great segments but is mostly straw-man stuff that's kinda nice, kinda meh. Colbert is fantastic but rarely really took on real issues — although his Super PAC thing was superb. Fact is, John Oliver's show is totally amazingly great. The best of its kind, hands down (says me, someone who basically avoids TV shows and actually has only a modest sense of what's out there).
- cbd1984 12y ago> The Daily Show is just cluttered with inside gossip about crappy news TV which I don't give a shit about either. Believe it or not, parodying that crap 24-hour cable TV news was the original premise. Actually telling the news was a side-effect, at best. Who knew the old Will Rogers gag of reading the paper would go over so big with a new generation, eh?
- myth_buster 12y agoI believe 'The Daily Show' has evolved over couple of years as it has become the news source for a large subset of millennials. Hence now they mock relevant topics just to bring awareness as opposed to birth a movement which Oliver does best.
- dmschulman 12y agoIt's hard to cover much substance in 23 minutes or however long The Daily Show gets. I think they understand this and treat the show as a time to make jokes, but use the interview segment to really dig into current events. The extended interviews especially are fantastic because they're so candid, sometimes tense. If you're just watching Jon Stewart for 12 minutes of news jokes, you're only getting a small taste of what the show has to offer.
- maxerickson 12y agoJon Stewart is often a terrible interviewer. Especially when he either hasn't found any respect for the guest or when he likes the guest so much they can't take the promotional point of the interview seriously. In one case he fails to address the perspective of the guest (which means he emotes a lot and asks questions they don't answer) and in the other they more or less just smile knowingly at each other for 5 minutes. I suppose another way to say it is that much of the problem is that he tends to make the interview about himself.
- Sir_Substance 12y agoI'd like to express my hatred of websites that deliver content via javascript, requiring me to turf through 20 different scrips to figure out which one I have to enable to scroll the page. HTML is fine people.
- jobposter1234 12y agoJust because you make choices that complicate otherwise-simple things in your life does not mean you should criticize decisions made by people who give you information you do not have to pay for.
- gohrt 12y agoIt's the JavaScript that complicates otherwise simple things.
- Sir_Substance 12y agoNoscript is used far more widely then crazy over-engineered javascript based text delivery systems. I run into a new website with this problem less frequently than once every few months. It's always the same few, like Time, still using their stupid hand-rolled content engines. It's not my job to cater to special snowflake syndrome.
- veidr 12y agoYou kind of remind me of the guy who rails against the design stupidity of cylindrical bottles every time he gets a drink. Rectangular bottles won't roll away, stack more efficiently, and are easier to use. WTF is wrong with beverage vendors. (That guy is me. But neither of us is going to win.)
- marknutter 12y agoYour bottles keep rolling away?
- 12y ago
- ch215 12y agoAnyone who likes Last Week Tonight should also check out the Bugle podcast Oliver hosts with Andy Zaltzman. Satire at its best: http://www.thebuglepodcast.com/ http://www.thebuglepodcast.com/
- r00fus 12y agoThe bugle podcast once made me laugh during my entire commute home (45m) - episode 205 [1]. Andy and John are comedic geniuses. [1] http://thebuglepodcast.com/bugle-209-the-bugles-5th-birthday/ http://thebuglepodcast.com/bugle-209-the-bugles-5th-birthday...
- ch215 12y agoAgreed. My favourite's got to be episode 152. The world is indebted to John Oliver for the term "fuckeulogy": http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AVb84n-FFx4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AVb84n-FFx4
- coldpie 12y agoI host an archive of old Bugle episodes, if you want to relive the late 00s: http://gamesplusone.com/thebugle/ http://gamesplusone.com/thebugle/
- popeshoe 12y agoI owe you my thanks, I used your site years ago when I first discovered the Bugle and was religiously listening to all the older episodes that had fallen off the Times feed.
- coldpie 12y agoIt was fun to put together, since the old Times Online website lost a few episodes and I had to scrounge them up where I could. I couldn't find episode 54A for months, and in the end, one guy just emailed it to me.
- 12y ago
- mhomde 12y agoAnother key to Last week tonight, besides its length, is also that its not on cable and doesn't have advertisers. I can hurl as much vitrol on specific companies as they possible can without getting sued... The GM ad was so great: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j6IZ2TroruU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j6IZ2TroruU
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Another key to Last week tonight, besides its length, is also that its not on cable and doesn't have advertisers. It is, in fact, on cable. Do you mean not on basic cable?
- mhomde 12y agoAh, yes, Thanks :) I'm not too familiar with the finer points of American tv-distribution
- DanBC 12y agoBefore Stewart, Colbert, or Oliver the UK had Chris Morris. Morris created the radio show "On The Hour", which transfered to tv as "The Day Today", and followed that with "Brass Eye". You really should seek these out if you're interested in news and current affairs satire. (Morris then went on to co-write "Nathan Barley" with charlie Brooker.)
- verytrivial 12y agoNote to anyone who considers themselves fans of 'news' parody and social commentary: The above comment is EXCELLENT ADVICE!
- jahnu 12y agoEspecially brilliant was the Brass Eye Paedophile Special which satirised the media's obsession with paedophilia at the time so perfectly it did actually change things for the better. After the initial, predictable storm of protest that followed of course. I'd be interested how a US audience would react to that special. I'm sure you can find it easily enough on Youtube.
- duncans 12y ago> it did actually change things for the better {{Citation needed}}
- jahnu 12y agoJust a personal opinion. I feel that after the broadcast the hysteria dropped off dramatically. Well at least until the whole Jimmy Savile thing.
- dspillett 12y agoThe real shit-storm about the paedophile episode was actually after it was repeated. The initial showing got complaints, but nothing like the attention the later showing was subject to.
- carlio 12y ago
- soneca 12y agoHis show about World Cup in Brazil was a real eye-opening for a lot of brazilians. It was shared a lot around here and it was the best way available to explain what was wrong with Wordl Cup and FIFA. I don't know about any "real impact" other than making people more informed about what was happening, which is a great deal, as the local media wasn't able to accomplish it.
- dspillett 12y agoInforming people is the first step to causing any impact on this sort of thing, so that alone is pretty significant.
- icantthinkofone 12y ago"the Miss America Organization is the largest provider of scholarships for women in the world, he directed viewers to donate to other groups he deemed more worthy" Personally I find John Oliver to be a dick. Things like the above quote and other stories he's covered, where I have some knowledge, shows he's playing up to the internet scream and not the realities of life. It's show business and that alone.
- Paul_S 12y agoMaybe you should research whether or not "the Miss America Organization is the largest provider of scholarships for women in the world". You might be surprised.
- icantthinkofone 12y agoI quoted the article which stated that fact so if you wish to disagree with the article, and John Oliver apparently, please show what you know.
- Shivetya 12y agoWhile he went after the Miss America foundation for its scholarships, there are many cancer and related charities who are just as bad and could do with exposure. However like how government works, people prefer to not to know and that is very dangerous.
- anindyabd 12y agoI think one reason why Oliver enjoys so much success is the fact that HBO posts the main news story section on Youtube after every show. The ready availability of these digestible segments helps extend the show's reach. For Comedy Central shows, if you don't watch the episodes on TV you have to use the Comedy Central website or Hulu, neither of which have the appeal of Youtube. I like Oliver, but Colbert is (was?) still my favorite. I didn't watch him for the news, I watched him for the comedy. I don't think either Stewart or Oliver can match Colbert when it comes to being really really funny.