16 ms·
A Designer's War on Misleading Parking Signs
- ape4 12y agoThe article says "looked a lot like a Google Calendar". In other words: any calendar program / app.
- allending 12y agoComplex rules are easy fodder for code. Would be awesome to have an app that simply answers: "Can I park on this street right now? (and until when)"
- Vexs 12y agoThat sounds incredibly brilliant- issue being accurate GPS locating, and actually finding out what rules are there. I really wish there was some sort of public works API where you could pull sign data, traffic lights data, etc. Seems like there could be some very interesting applications developed from that.
- rmxt 12y agoHere's a baby step in that direction for NYC: http://a841-dotvweb01.nyc.gov/ParkingRegs/ViewController/LocationValidation.aspx http://a841-dotvweb01.nyc.gov/ParkingRegs/ViewController/Loc... CSV and shapefiles can be found here: http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/about/datafeeds.shtml#parking http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/about/datafeeds.shtml#parki...
- maxerickson 12y agoThere are various efforts to put that sort of data into OpenStreetMap. Using OSM brings all the problems of redundant effort and crowd sourcing in, but it solves the 'in one place' part of the problem. There's also the issue that OSM focuses on the geo side of the data, so it is usually pretty awkward to encode complex data (like multiple parking regulations or traffic signal plans)
- gambiter 12y agoOr an electronic sign that simply shows red/green as a GO/NOGO indicator. We already have them for crosswalks, school zones, etc., why not extend it to parking zones? They might be slightly more expensive, but you could just install them on the curbs where there is more than one rule.
- goatforce5 12y agoGO/NOGO isn't good enough. I need to know how much it will cost to park there, and how long I can stay in that spot. Do the rules change if I have a resident parking permit? etc.
- emeidi 12y agoYou're onto something ... Sounds like the AirBnB or Uber for street parking. Disruption is in the making.</sarcasm> Why should people require a smartphone to figure out whether they can park on a street or not? My solution: KISS! European countries show that it's totally feasible to make easy-to-understand parking signs, in 2015, without any Silicon Valley tech at all.
- allending 12y agoWasn't really suggesting disruption or a revolutionary business model. Not everything needs to be about the Uberization of X or Y. Just something small and useful that would be convenient for users from my perspective. I received a ticket in San Diego a couple month's ago because I didn't walk down half a block to see a sign that mentioned street cleaning on certain days.
- sbierwagen 12y agoYep, been done: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/22/nyregion/iphone-app-tells-if-you-can-park-here-there-and-anywhere.html?_r=1& http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/22/nyregion/iphone-app-tells-...
- rmxt 12y agoA couple of thoughts: 1. The current NYC signs have arrows indicating directionality of the applicable rules. There are three kinds ( <--, -->, and <-->). Only one of their design example shows this information and it's implementation seems awkward. 2. The current NYC signs are theoretically reproducible and modular. Stacking them one on top of one another makes the driver feel like they are divining tea leaves, but the city might see it as minimizing costs. They can cut a couple hundred "Alternate Side Street Parking" signs for Mon./Wed. 9:30a-10:30a, and put them where they need to. With these signs, you are more likely to have a unique sign for every block. 3. I'm not colorblind, but are the green and red bars they've used colorblind safe? The red stripes are hard for me to see on my monitor, but maybe that is the intention. EDIT: Ah, I see in the infographic, that they've considered colorblindness. Still, the difference in the reds seems pretty subtle. 4. The text size gets increasingly small the more detailed the scheduled is. EDIT: The relevant section for parking signs from the MUTCD (Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices), the USA DOT publication on signs, says this: Parking signs should display the following information from top to bottom of the sign, in the order listed: A. The restriction or prohibition; B. The times of the day that it is applicable, if not at all hours; and C. The days of the week that it is applicable, if not every day. If the parking restriction applies to a limited area or zone, the limits of the restriction should be shown by arrows or supplemental plaques. If arrows are used and if the sign is at the end of a parking zone, there should be a single-headed arrow pointing in the direction that the regulation is in effect. If the sign is at an intermediate point in a zone, there should be a double-headed arrow pointing both ways. When a single sign is used at the transition point between two parking zones, it should display a right and left arrow pointing in the direction that the respective restrictions apply. So overall, it seems that these would be rubbing against the established grain, but perhaps a change like this is needed.
- wernercd 12y ago"3." There is a picture about 2/3 of the way through the article that shows the iterations she's went through and some of the changes for color-deficient people. http://pix-media.s3.amazonaws.com/blog/883/process.png http://pix-media.s3.amazonaws.com/blog/883/process.png Edit: I see you saw what I see. Without being colorblind myself, I'm not sure... but I would think the different textures (Solid vs striped) should stand out. I can only assume that she's received valid feedback on "Red with white background" vs "Red with red background" in choosing what she chose.
- byjess 12y agoParking signs are the worst. This designers improvements are clearer though the type size is much smaller. Sometimes you can only see the parking signs as you are driving by looking for a space. Its not much help if you have to park your car, then read the sign. I attempted a similar solution using a "universal language for time and date" that I created. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3o_n4XBKZUI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3o_n4XBKZUI Never really went anywhere beyond the video though.
- sanderjd 12y agoThanks for the link. This is a great idea and I'd love to see it get some traction so that I can use it for things.
- morsch 12y agoThat was much cooler than the actual article. I'm not sure I'm convinced of the concept, but it's certainly thought provoking and the video is very well done.
- math0ne 12y agoThis is really cool, I can think of some other systems that could benefit from this type of abstraction, like programming languages.
- Carrok 12y agoThe months section is actually how I've always viewed a year in my mind, except IMHO you have it upside down. Winter should be at the bottom, summer at the top.
- reikonomusha 12y agoSummer and winter according to whom?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- joshuaheard 12y agoParking tickets are primarily given to generate revenue for the city, so they have no incentive to make it easier for the user to park.
- greggyb 12y agoOr maybe to enforce parking rules that make sense, e.g. keeping all lanes of a busy thoroughfare clear for moving traffic during rush hour; alternate side parking in snowy states to keep the streets drive-able. Edited out snark.
- wtbob 12y ago> Or maybe to enforce parking rules that make sense, Denver recently decided that, since the fine for parking in a tow-away zone is twice that of parking in a street-sweeping zone, and since one can be towed in order to enable street sweeping, then parking in a street-sweeping zone is really parking in a tow-away zone, and doubled the fine. I'm pretty sure that while the parking rules are there to make sense and regulate the commons, their implementation is based on revenue maximisation.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- maxxxxx 12y agoAfter parking in DC I always thought there should be a "parking lawyer" service. You take a picture of the signs (sometimes 6 on top of each other), you upload it to the service and they tell you whether it's OK to park.
- daxelrod 12y agoThere's an app for NYC called Can I Park Here[1]. It does location queries against the NYC DOT parking regulations database[2]. Perhaps something similar exists for DC? [1]: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/22/nyregion/iphone-app-tells-if-you-can-park-here-there-and-anywhere.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/22/nyregion/iphone-app-tells-... [2]: http://a841-dotvweb01.nyc.gov/ParkingRegs/ViewController/LocationValidation.aspx http://a841-dotvweb01.nyc.gov/ParkingRegs/ViewController/Loc...
- juriansluiman 12y agoAlthough I completely agree the designed signs are much, much better than the existing ones, there is another problem. Why should you have so many rules for parking? Why can't you make the rules more simple? I want to show you a few signs in comparison, which are Dutch and notify drivers about free or paid parking. Those are (imho) very clear and only show when you need to pay. If you're outside that time frame, it's free: 1. [1] Paid parking all days between 18:00 and 24:00 2. [2] Paid parking from Mondays to Saturdays between 9:00 and 18:00, you're only allowed to stay for two hours max 3. [3] Paid parking from Mondays to Saturdays between 9:00 and 24:00 and on Sundays from 13:00 to 24:00 Am I just crazy, or are those signs way more easier to understand than the graphical green/red bars (especially from a greater distance)? I truly like the designers take to the problem, but isn't it just crazy you have to redesign individual rules to make the time slots understandable? [1] http://denhaagfm.nl/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/Betaald-Parkeren.jpg http://denhaagfm.nl/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/Betaald-Parke... [2] http://www.verkeerskunde.nl/Uploads/Cache/2013/2/130205105025.betaald-parkeren-ANWBAVD.resized.200x0.jpg http://www.verkeerskunde.nl/Uploads/Cache/2013/2/13020510502... [3] http://www.anwb.nl/bestanden/w280/content/gallery/anwb/nieuws/verkeer/nederland/2014/april/parkeren-bord-300-180.jpg http://www.anwb.nl/bestanden/w280/content/gallery/anwb/nieuw...
- jmilloy 12y ago> Why should you have so many rules for parking? There are three options: - You can park here for free - You must pay to park here - You cannot park here You're examples only relate to the first two, where you can always park, but sometimes you have to pay and sometimes you don't. It's easy in those cases to only specify when you have to pay, even when the schedule is different on Sunday (like your third example). When you have to add in additional information about when you cannot park (for cleaning, snow removal, altered traffic patterns during heavy commute times, etc), now you need two signs. Well, or two notices on the same sign. You can park for free if it's not a time on either notice. This is in the example at the top of the article.
- wlesieutre 12y ago- You can park here for free for one hour - You can park here for free for two hours - You can park here for free for as long as you want - You must pay to park here and can park for up an hour - You must pay to park here and can park for up to two hours - You must pay to park here and can park as long as you want to pay for - You cannot park here
- rayiner 12y agoParking signs in DC remind me of logic games: http://www.griffonprep.com/logicgame.html http://www.griffonprep.com/logicgame.html. You'll see four signs on a pole, made with no contemplation of each other, and try to figure out whether you can park. Worse are the complicated signs for roads that are one-way only part of the day, or where left turns are prohibited only part of the day. And in Wilmington, DE, you can park for free on holidays, but the city celebrates Vetrans' day in October instead of November.
- eli 12y agoThey should really just add a little note on all of them explaining that the most restrictive sign always wins. A surprising number of people seem not to know that.
- scottnyc 12y agoAs someone who is neurotic about parking (I will walk up and down the street 3 times making sure I didn't miss anything), I think this is wonderful. I don't care if it's hard to read or if I have to re-park at times. Simply being 100% confident that my parking is ok is a big relief. Revenue shortfall? Raise our taxes or fix your budget, just stop profiting from misleading confusion.
- secabeen 12y agoThe proposed solutions come from a misunderstanding of local government. Many cities don't have a central office of parking that is responsible for all parking rules. Different city departments have the right to restrict parking. That creates different signs. In both of her examples, the additional sign on the bottom is a add-on restriction. It may or may not have been coordinated with the above signs. (In California, there are lots of parking restrictions for street sweeping) The author also attacks the little sign at the top. People like to know why things are the way they are. That little sign (I can't read it exactly) helps citizens understand why the parking restrictions are present, and helps. She also seems not to understand the difference between "No Stopping" and "No Parking", which is pretty clear to me. I don't see any system in her solution for handling permit parking. Finally, her proposed solution would require a much more detailed (and expensive) master parking system. Cities don't have the resources to maintain those, and they would incur huge costs if a city-wide parking rule was necessitated. (For example, if street sweeping is changed with the current system, they only need to replace one or two signs per block. Under her system, every parking sign in the city would need to be changed)
- jameshart 12y agoThe designer had performed research and learned that no, people DON'T care why they can't park, they just don't want a ticket; and that they don't care about fine distinctions, they want clear unambiguous information. As for complaining that this misunderstands local government: that's the point, it's user-centric design. Parking signs should not be a catalog of the internal departmental divisions in city hall, they should clearly communicate to street users the way in which the street is permitted to be used. It's like complaining about the design of the iPhone on the basis that it completely failed to reflect the reality of how cellphone carriers operate. Yes, yes it did. That was the point.
- thrownaway2424 12y agoThat research is incorrect in my experience. People _do_ care why they can't park, because if the restriction is for street cleaning, and the street has already been cleaned, you can park (in my city). If the restriction is for construction, and work hasn't begun by 10am, you can park. So you do need to know _why_ you can't park, if you want to park in certain cases.
- jbob2000 12y agoThis is all well and great, but it will lead to a reduction in revenue for the city, as well as an increased expense in having all of the signs reprinted. As long as someone somewhere is making money, it's never going to change.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- himeag 12y agoYou dare rob the municipalities of this important income with your good communication?
- jrub 12y agoThe poor design of these parking signs is actually "a feature, not a bug." Parking tickets in the cities which have these sorts of sign issues (DC, NYC, Chicago, ATL, etc) make up a significant amount of income for the city. Paid parking certainly adds up but if a single space nets the city $10-$20 per day, a single parking ticket could cover a weeks worth of revenue for that single spot while still allowing the space to earn $10-$20 a day for the rest of the week. I agree it sucks, and I was burned by this exact problem when I traveled to DC with my family last winter. However it's unlikely to change, because not only would the change actually cost money to implement, it would (significantly) reduce the income to the city from parking tickets.
- eli 12y agoDo you have any evidence to support this theory other than the fact that there's motive?
- eyeareque 12y agoExactly. Why would a city change something that would make them bring in less profit?
- sambeau 12y agoIn October 2014, she got an email from Los Angeles city council person Paul Krekorkian. He wasn’t writing to ask her to stop producing LA signs. On the contrary: he wanted her permission to propose her design at the next council meeting. I don't know. But it seems they want to.
- thrownaway2424 12y agoThe idea that parking fines are a source of significant revenue is pretty bogus. NYC for example collects around $500m in fines while spending about $200m for the NYPD division of traffic control and another $270m for the Department of Finance (which collects the fines) and while these costs are not entirely dedicated to the purpose of issuing tickets, it gives you a sense of the scale of net revenues from parking tickets (low hundreds of millions at most) compared to a city budget of over $75 billion. Parking tickets exist because public property in urban areas is extremely valuable and the opportunity cost of letting some scofflaw waste the space is enormous.
- codereflection 12y agoI have become so tired of sensationalism in headlines, in this case use of "War", that I refuse to read the articles.
- DigitalJack 12y agoAnother red/green debacle for the 15 million color blind men in America.
- ferongr 12y agoI was about to make the same comment. It's really hard to distinguish between those two colors as implemented on the sign. Green and red colors by themselves are okay but there should be another clear identifying characteristic like shape, outlining etc.
- aw3c2 12y agoYeah, completely ignorant design: http://i.imgur.com/QWGUw31.png http://i.imgur.com/QWGUw31.png It's actually more than that unless you meant just the USA, not both north and south america.
- Amezarak 12y agoIn English, "America" is nearly always synonymous with "USA". If GP meant "North and South America", he would have said "the Americas" instead. I understand this is different in other languages which I imagine must be confusing and arrogant-seeming for those with English as a second language.
- frederickf 12y agoTowards the bottom of the article is a picture titled "The road to a better, better parking sign" that shows various iterations of the design. It isn't very clear, but if you look closely at the two iterations on the right there are stripes added to the red specifically for color blind. It's more clear on the designers blog: http://toparkornottopark.com/tagged/evolution http://toparkornottopark.com/tagged/evolution
- eli 12y agoI'm not actually a huge fan of the redesigned signs. It seems like it would be really hard to make work for even slightly complex cases -- alternate side on Mondays during the Fall for example, or 2-hour parking during the day except for residents. Also, like most unsolicited unofficial redesigns, it ignores real-world constraints. How much does it cost to produce these very specific signs vs combining modular and reusable generic signs?
- Patrick_Devine 12y ago> How much does it cost to produce these very specific signs vs combining modular and reusable generic signs? Probably less than the cost of a single parking ticket. As for your corner cases, there are some signs depicted with text at the bottom which can cover those scenarios. Not perfect, but I think it's a step up from what people have to deal with today.
- eli 12y ago> Probably less than the cost of a single parking ticket. I really doubt that, but my point is that none of us know. Design is a lot easier when you're ignorant of any cost or logistical constraints. > As for your corner cases, there are some signs depicted with text at the bottom... I guess it's better, but it seems like greatly more complexity in creating and managing signs for only a little benefit. At least around me those aren't corner cases: pretty much every sign would have one or more additional restrictions or exceptions. In front of my house it's two-hour parking Monday through Saturday except for residents, and no parking on Mondays during the Fall. I think that's pretty typical for DC.
- army 12y agoSome of those issues are just a lack of common sense. Of course no stopping implies no parking. Reminds me of an episode of Parking Wars where people were trying to argue that they didn't know what "No Standing" meant so it was ok to park there. I don't understand why you wouldn't apply the principle of caution she's invoking and not park somewhere if you're not sure that you understand the signs. That said, the signs are an improvement and are pretty nice. It's a bit harder to deal with issues like school days - maybe there needs to be a number or web site on the sign that you can use to check school days?
- andrewla 12y agoThis isn't the first place I've seen this -- back in December of 2009, in Manhattan (midtown somewhere, GPS says 53rd between Park and Lexington), I happened upon this sign [1] and snapped a photo. Uses green and blue instead of green and red, and is oriented horizontally instead of vertically, but appears to be official. [1] http://imgur.com/IXv0WqB http://imgur.com/IXv0WqB
- teye 12y agoGraphically representing all times wastes space, making the rules easier to understand for those who can read them, but decreasing legibility. This is a tradeoff, not an all-around win.
- Someone1234 12y agoConsistency is more key than minimalism. Plus producing identically sized signs has economies of scale that variable sized ones likely won't counteract.
- teye 12y agoNot minimalism. Information density. Visibility. Representing time with colored spaces decreases information density. Green & red blocks aren't enough -- the primary data, the numbers, are still required labels, and are made smaller to accommodate the new elements. Shrinking the primary data decreases visibility, so you, with decent eyesight, need to be closer. My grandmother will have an even harder time resolving it. Visibility hasn't been addressed, but deserves to be in any conversation about signage.
- larrydag 12y agoThis project looks like its begging to be built into a mobile app. Either a geolocation app or a Q scan code that tells you if you can park at any given location at any given time.
- Someone1234 12y agoI don't see it. Let's assume that the app exists and has a good database. Parking rules and regs change on a regular basis in the context of a city, typically both tickets and drivers utilise the same signage to determine if an offense has occurred. So for all intents and purposes the signs are the decider of if a ticket is issued. So when a driver arrives, they load the app, they'll still have to check the signs to make sure the rules haven't changed. And in the time it took to load the app and have it figure out your location (and you'll likely have to enter side of the street due to GPS limitations) you may have well just read the signs. And when the app is wrong (as it rarely will be) then the driver has no excuse. Saying "an app told me I could part!!!" will be laughed at, and the app creator will likely need legal protection as they will get sued even if the app is free. Lawsuits that you win are still expensive.
- dodders 12y agoThe DOT website in NYC already has a street parking function which displays the rules in effect for any specified street / intersection. I don't know if this is legally admissible, though - I believe the rules can only be enforced if the signage is in place.
- Strilanc 12y agoThis is an improvement. I think it needs more iterations. For example, the free sections look too much like the 1 hr sections (e.g. glance at the right-most sign in this blurry shot: http://pix-media.s3.amazonaws.com/blog/883/process.png http://pix-media.s3.amazonaws.com/blog/883/process.png ). How long did it take you to distinguish them?
- meej 12y agoNYC took steps to unclutter their parking signs a couple years ago. http://www.wnyc.org/story/283907-nyc-unclutters-parking-signs-with-redesign/ http://www.wnyc.org/story/283907-nyc-unclutters-parking-sign...
- petegrif 12y agoI live in LA. She's right. Thank God for her.
- petegrif 12y agoNow add a code so that you can scan with your phone and it will tell you if you can park there.
- bduerst 12y agoWhy not make a public API for the city so you can access it with an GPS-enabled app immediately? Come to think of it, many cities could stand to benefit from a public API with alerts and infrastructure notices. Too bad it's probably not in their budgets.
- ape4 12y agoThe QT code could encode JSON which describes the parking rules at that location.
- cjensen 12y agoGreat idea and format. I'm disturbed that some of the examples in the article appear to have errors. One sign has a column for "MWF" and a column for "T-Th". The latter I guess is meant to mean Tuesday and Thursday, but it sure looks like Tuesday through Thursday. Another example shows two traditional signs, one says "No Parking Nightly 10PM-6AM". The second says "1 hour parking 8AM-6PM except Sunday." The designer somehow interprets this as allowing parking from Midnight-6AM Sunday morning, but no parking 10PM-Midnight on Saturday night. Lastly, she uses "T" for Tuesday, "Th" for Thursday, "Sa" for Saturday, and "S" for Sunday. The "T" and "S" should be "Tu" and "Su" to be less ambiguous. Like I said, great ideas. But I also think I know why the designer gets parking tickets a lot...
- dddrh 12y agoMy personal system for Days is S M T W R F Y. (S)unday for the start of the week. Thu(R)sday since the R is pronounced with a strong "urr". Saturda(Y) since it's the last day of the week. It still a bit ambiguous, but it has helped me over the years.
- oxryly1 12y agoI'm surprised no one took you to task for ending the week on Saturday instead of Sunday.
- reportingsjr 12y agoThe week does end on Saturday though. Go look at any calendar and you'll see they all end on Saturday.
- avalaunch 12y agoI can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not. In case you're not, here's an example, from Germany, to disprove that all calendars start on Sunday and end on Saturday. http://www.timeanddate.com/calendar/?country=8 http://www.timeanddate.com/calendar/?country=8 Choose other countries from the dropdown and you'll see many, if not most, have the week starting on Monday and ending on Sunday.
- politician 12y agoThis parking sign example seems like a good way to communicate the problems with the practice of piling on new rules or features without resorting to using analogies to financial instruments -- technical debt or unhedged call options. The image of a totem pole containing a list of signs is a tangible day-to-day example that should evoke fear of unexpected fines ahead.
- intopieces 12y agoIf you're going to replace signs, how expensive would it be to just have one that changes from "Parking" to "No Parking" on a timer? My city already has similar signs for intersections that become no-left-turn when kids are around.
- apenguin 12y agoThat doesn't tell you how long you can stay parked. How useful is it to know that you're currently allowed to park, without also telling you it's going to change to "No Parking" as soon as you've left your vehicle? EDIT: If you could do a countdown timer to the next state, though, that'd be useful.
- oxryly1 12y agoAlso, what if you need a permit?
- peterwwillis 12y agoThere is a reason why parking restrictions & signs are maddening, and it's not to generate revenue as the cynical claim when they have no other explanation. The #1 reason is that parking laws change. Where there was no rule a year ago, there may be now, for all kinds of reasons. This means a sign needs to be added or changed. Some reasons for rule adds or changes: * new growth in the area causes increased demand for parking, requiring restrictions on non-resident parking. * a new area gets appropriated as part of a city/county and new enforcement follows. * residents are tired of their spaces getting yanked by people outside the neighborhood. * street traffic changes due to development, causing increased demand along a new street, creating the need for more restriction. * street cleaning is (finally) implemented, or schedules change. * a new commercial entity requires loading zones. * a new school pops up or is [re]moved The #2 reason for the current sign design is visibility. You have to be able to read a parking sign from your car, on the road, while moving, in inclement weather, and considering not everyone's sight is 'ideal'. Even if there was one sign, often there are multiple overlapping restrictions which can't simply be put into a single time slot. Even if this design incorporated every single day and different times depending on different criteria, it would have to be humongous to read all that detail without getting out and going up close. The #3 reason is ambiguity. Si no hablas ingles, 或者你住在一个历史的民族地区,તમે નિયમો કયા છે ઈન્ટરપ્રીટ થોડી મદદ જરૂર પડી શકે છે. The various colors, bolded words, and arrows help give insight as to what each sign is intending to tell you, without necessarily needing to be a native speaker. Other countries tend to use more pictograms on their signs which certainly help in these cases. I think the redesigned sign is very useful, but one single sign is just not going to replace the accessibility and functionality of several large simple signs. Less signs is definitely better, though.
- techiferous 12y agoThis design does not account for non-weekly parking rules, like "No parking during street cleaning on the third Tuesday of the month."
- vacri 12y agoThe signs are too small to read easily from a car trying to find a park. As the hours are not in standard positions, a small block of red high in the green bar would only mean 'sometime in the morning' when seen from a distance. Similarly, the allowed parking duration is far too small. Even if it's green all day, you still need to know if it's 30 minutes or 4 hours or whatever.
- halayli 12y agoNot sure if cases like "No Parking 7AM - 9 AM every 3rd Thursday of the month" are covered in her design.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- encoderer 12y agoOne issue I have is... if there is "no parking 1st monday" her sign will instead say "no parking any monday". That's wrong 3/4 of the time. Simplification or not, it's wrong.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- reedcat 12y agoThis is amazing! I have always been baffled by the ever more convoluted parking signs. This is especially useful since very often you have to figure out if you can park while driving by, so you don't have much time to analyse the signs.
- 725686 12y ago15 minute free parking to analize parking rules.
- pjlegato 12y agoThis article (and many comments here) grossly misunderstand the nature of city parking regulations. > Cities could make it easier for them, and improve parking compliance, just by making the parking signs clearer. The signs are confusing on purpose. Parking tickets are a huge source of revenue in most cities. Improving parking compliance is not the goal in most places. The goal is to maximize revenue from fines. Any assessment of the design merits of the signs must at least be aware of the actual context of the design they're evaluating. The signs are very well designed in the context of their actual goal -- to confuse people and generate more income for the city. Note that I am not endorsing this practice, just pointing it out. That's simply the way it actually is in most cities, irrespective of anyone's particular moral evaluation of whether it ought to be that way. If you think it's wrong that this happens, the first step towards fixing it is acknowledging that it's happening, rather than ascribing the confusing signs to simple ignorance of good graphic design practices.
- stegosaurus 12y agoI don't think the problem is that of signage. The issue is zero-tolerance. It expands beyond simply parking. The lack of discretion that computerised solutions seem to beget. The incentive structure that means parking wardens feel inclined to ticket for being 10cm over a bay.
- nnd 12y agoParking violations is a business. It's in their best interest to make the signs and the laws even more confusing so you'd pay the fee.
- snambi 12y agoThis is one of the best redesigns I have seen recently. Designers can have great impact on the world that we live. This is a great example.
- wkz 12y agoAllow me to present a standard swedish parking sign: http://i.imgur.com/e4KVoaC.jpg http://i.imgur.com/e4KVoaC.jpg Avgift means fee. The intervals specify when the fee applies. * White digits: Hours of weekdays. * White digits in parens: Hours of days before holidays (read: Saturdays, Christmas eve etc.). * Red digits: Hours of holidays (Sundays, Chistmas day etc.).
- pluma 12y agoI'm guessing in the case where parking is forbidden entirely at certain times there'd simply be a second (visually distinct) sign beside it as in most of Europe?
- wkz 12y agoYes. The [P] sign indicates that this area is intended for parking, and that outside of the hours specified in fee-sign, parking is free. In the case where the default is "no parking", the top sign will be a dashed or crossed red circle (the first meaning you can stop to let people off but not park, the other meaning that you can not stop there for any reason). There can then be a sign below it that specifies times when parking is allowed.