8 ms·
Is 'SimCity' Homelessness a Bug or a Feature?
- davidw 12y ago> "To me video games are the so-called 'real America,'" he said. "The real America operates according to a video game logic, and that game logic is neo-liberalism Homelessness is a real problem, but, uh... yeah. I'm going to flag this as essentially a political article (most everything vice.com publishes is). Maybe for his next book he can chronicle how Quake is the real America too, with the mutant monsters representing ... well... whatever the hell you want since you're willing to make such huge non-sequiturs.
- johnloeber 12y agoI don't think this is essentially a political article. I think the article is interesting in its subject matter alone, regardless of the author's blatant political shoe-horning.
- chicofarm 12y agohow does that make it political?
- davidw 12y agoLet's rewrite it. Say it's some conservative commentator like Bill O'Reilly: "To me video games are the so-called 'real France,'" he said. "The real France operates according to a video game logic, and that game logic is socialism" That doesn't strike you as overtly and primarily political in nature? Beyond that, it's simply inane.
- Malarkey73 12y agoI don't think it is inane at all. Lots of games since Monopoly, Elite and running through Civilisation and SimCity have model economics, free trade, and free thinking ideas in-built into the game mechanics. And a lot of economics and free trade ideas seem to be justified by game theory and the naturalistic fallacy. And a lot of chasing GDP or national wealth or Educational policy sometimes seem to be maximising some goal - like a game- rather than just running countries for the benefit of people. I think its actually a very telling analogy if you think a little more deeply about it.
- davidw 12y agoIt's a totally made-up analogy with no supporting facts. What does it even mean that "the real America operates according to a video game logic"? Does France operate that way? How about Morocco or Mongolia? It's nonsense.
- popeshoe 12y agoIn America if you collect 100 coins you get an extra life. In America if you get seriously hurt you get taken to hospital and lose some money In America you can only carry 2 guns In America if you try and run forward and sideways at once the two velocities are combined and you run twice as fast I guess some of them work
- iopq 12y agoyou run sqrt(2) as fast
- TeMPOraL 12y agoWhat does "gamification" means? I say answers to those two questions are very relevant to each other.
- palmer_eldritch 12y agoExcept current France doesn't operate according to socialist logic. It's much closer to neo-liberalism too (as most of today's world). Just because the current president has the label "socialist" for historical reasons it doesn't make it socialism.
- davidw 12y ago"Socialist!" is one of those meaningless code words, like "neoliberal!" that just means "bad!" for the intended audience.
- rat87 12y agoneo-libreral means pro free trade neo-conservate means pro war especially against non-democratic regimes they don't like seeking to remake them into democracies.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoTotally. Those labels are instant mind-killers and in my book they are tools of the Dark Arts. When someone calls you a "socialist" or "neoliberal" or whatever, they imply you believe everything some ideology has to say, so they can go ahead, point any random weak point (every political ideology has some) and call you a moron. This is so totally dumb behaviour, that I can't even begin to describe it. What's equally dumb is assuming that if you agree with some group on one thing, then you should also agree on everything else. Basically - for me, giving yourself a political label is a sign of subpar thinking. Giving others political labels is disingenuous.
- djur 12y ago"mind-killers" and "Dark Arts" are self-describing labels, though. They don't avoid being political rhetoric just because they were coined by a guy who purports to be opposed to political rhetoric.
- brazzy 12y agoUm, yes. It is indeed overtly and primarily political once you have rewritten it to be.
- davidw 12y ago> Um, yes. It is indeed overtly and primarily political once you have rewritten it to be. I changed two words - I replaced America with France and "neo-liberalism" with "socialism".
- anon1385 12y agoActually at first you used the word "communism", which is why I downvoted you and flagged your comment. You are just using inaccurate emotive language to rage wildly against a line in the article that offended your zealous patriotic/conservative sensibilities. You loudly complain about pretty much any article that contains a hint of politics you dislike. It just fills the comments with useless noise (I know I'm adding to it, but after seeing you do the same thing dozens of times it's getting pretty tiresome). If you don't like a submission, move on, don't post dozens of whining comments about how it hurt your feelings and how such submissions need to be banned from the site.
- davidw 12y agoI actually flag all politics here, even the articles that agree with my political views, which are not at all what you seem to think they are, either. It helps to get rid of these articles and keep the site a good one for startups/hacking/interesting articles, so for me it's worthwhile. The article doesn't hurt my feelings: I think it's genuinely silly and low-quality.
- DanBC 12y agoAn important part of flagging - and it is mentioned in the guidelines - is to avoid commenting that you've flagged the article. Look at the low quality sub-thread that your comment spawned.
- 7952 12y agoThere is a tendancy to treat real world problems in an overly abstract way. That you pursue an argument because of a particular dogma rather than actual empathy for the victims of a problem. For example people love to debate funding of healthcare (which we can all disagree on) whilst loosing site of its actual purpose (which we mostly agree about). The same is true of homelessness where it is easy to discuss it in broad economic terms that can be dogmatic. But actually it is a social problem which means that it is caused by people breaking the agreed rules of the game. If a family member has no home you are supposed to let them sleep on the couch until they get back on their feet. When these basic societal rules break down we are only left with the state which is not a good replacment for family and friends.
- Spooky23 12y agoYou got it. I have relatives who work with the homeless, and one of the striking things is the population that is growing now: veterans. Politicians love waving flags and "supporting the troops". But when some if these men come home and can't adjust, the flags get out away. Many turn to alcohol and start a spiral the ends on a street somewhere.
- happyscrappy 12y agoIn Boston goes around to pick up the homeless and bring them to Pine Street or another shelter but you cannot force them to get into the van and they still die on the street. I don't know what the solution is but you will never be able to pass a law forcing them into the van.
- cturner 12y ago[Getting this in early - I'm not an American.] > healthcare .. which we mostly agree about Reading this brought to mind a Reagan speech. Found it (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YUKC9E04Sck https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YUKC9E04Sck), complete with propaganda slides. The final example he gives goes right to it. Social democracy is the mainstream worldview at the moment in educated debate. Even the US moves in that direction. A social democrat will look at opposition to public healthcare with disbelief, "can anyone really be so mean?" Or disbelieve it altogether as you do. Well-funded public healthcare is central to the socal democrat worldview. It's easy to argue towards at the moment, because it aligns with the momentum of public policy. For freedom-centric people, it's uncomfortable. The person opposing it will often be inarticulate, to the point of appearing to be crazy. Their task is hard: they are not merely opposing one policy, but the whole momentum of worldview that's driving it. That's hard to do well. But beneath the rambling, there's probably a legitimate philosophical position that's not understood properly even by the speaker.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- matthewmacleod 12y ago1. It's not a political article. It's an article which includes some content from someone possibly making a political point. 2. Even if it is political, that's not a problem. It's about an interesting intersection between video game technology and politics, and with some focus on an area with a heavy tech presence (the bay). That's relevant.
- V-2 12y ago"Including some content" and making a political point based on it pretty much fullfils the definition of "political" to me ;) Even candidate speeches do exactly that. They're hardly ever "purely political". While I don't downvote nor dismiss the article, you seem to be hairsplitting to me (as for point 1).
- V-2 12y agoWell, I haven't played SimCity (or any games, for that matter) for a while now, but if I recall, this type of games was always more akin to central planning model than laissez-faire; or else they wouldn't be that playable.
- ginko 12y agoFrom my European perspective SimCity actually misses several city planning tools to reduce homelessness. The most important being the ability to build public housing and set up social services.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rsynnott 12y agoSimcity 2000 used to have subsidised housing and homeless shelter ordinances, which reduced crime, though you never actually _saw_ anything. It is weird that they've never tried adding a public housing mechanic; it could be quite interesting.
- hueving 12y agoYeah, building a new housing complex would take years to attempt and would likely be shot down by some lobbying group either because it didn't have enough low income housing or neighbors were concerned about the bad energy it would give off.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoIt is amusing what happens when you make games that are "realistic" in a way which isn't fun for players but is like real life, and get to see how the player base reacts. Depression Quest springs to mind. Or way the book the protagonist of The Fault In Our Stars loves cuts off abruptly once the main character dies, which upsets her to no end.
- cLeEOGPw 12y agoSeems this isn't intended "realism", but rather game engine's emergent behavior that just happens to mimic real life. Only very small percent of such unintended effects happen to make sense, so don't overestimate it's significance.
- hueving 12y agoI'm not sure it's amusing to make a game that is unfun because it reflects an unappealing part of life. In this case it was just amusing because reading the comments made it seem like they were talking about real homeless people, especially when the article slaps you in the face with the relationship to real homelessness over and over and over and over.
- iopq 12y agoDepression Quest is built on having sex with people in the industry and making a half-assed excuse for a non-game.
- V-2 12y agoIn the original Civilization, if your political system was Democracy, there was no Corruption :))
- RobertKerans 12y agoMy main strategy for quite a while was to race toward Statue of Liberty, then use it to immediately switch to communism; I'm pretty heavily on the side of 'be careful about using games as a metaphor for life' re the OP.
- popeshoe 12y agoIt's an amusing thought, but I imagine that most of these people realise homelessness isn't really a problem you can simply fix by following some set of procedures. Ultimately it's a game to be played for entertainment, and if you can get some people to think about social issues as they play it that's wonderful, but it's still supposed to be enjoyable. Clearly homeless people in the game are impeding some peoples enjoyment and it's a problem that is not obvious to solve. Some games that offer more freedom let you solve problems like these in more interesting ways, for example when I played Dwarf Fortress (years ago now), a common strategy was to make the nobledwarfs accommodation floodable with lava, so if they got too uppity with their demands (sometimes nobles would insist that you make certain items or not sell a certain items or they'd get furious and make everybody else unhappy) they could be dispatched. I think it'd be funny if Sim City offered a similar option.
- hueving 12y agoHomelessness punishable by death should clear it up.
- simonh 12y agoThe 'final solution' option? It's been done in real life of course many times in many countries, but I don't think adding an option to Sim City to round them all up and shoot/gas/incinerate them, or build a 'killing fields' facility is really what people are looking for in that game. In DF we can get some distance from it because it's explicitly a fantasy world, but Sim City is a bit too close to emulating real life for something like that to be a reasonable option.
- hueving 12y agoIt would be more interesting if they had that option just too see how often players would resort to something like that.
- Danieru 12y agoAll of them. It is a common accepted reality in game design that players will take any shortcut offered. Players will go so far as skipping content just to "solve" a challenge with the fastest method. Players would jump at genocide if it solved their problem. It would be an interesting result if it was not so predictable.
- ttty 12y ago>How to get rid of homeless reproduces dozens of threads concerning "homelessness" that appeared in Electronic Arts' online forum between 2012 and 2013. This is the $ 150 book?! with 438 pages? This is easy money!
- teddyh 12y agoI wonder how they cleared all those copyrighted posts.
- dagw 12y agoHardly. Would you know how to go about convincing a large number of people to buy 438 pages worth of forum posts for $150? If so, how much time and effort do you think it would take? What do you think your hourly wage would work out to be once you combine that time with the time taken to collect and the data and actually make the book.
- tsotha 12y agoOnly if people actually buy it.
- WBrentWilliams 12y agoI'm going to earn my downvotes today. It was more interesting reading the comments than the article, especially when one of the threads devolved into saying the article is political. The other entertaining point is the offense at the notion that America is it's entertainment. The fact that some took offense at that is interesting from both a technology standpoint and a startup standpoint. It is an imperfect mirror, reflecting why we do things and why some businesses fail and others succeed, from a certain point of view. In other words, perhaps part of why a given venture gains customers in not just need, but need coupled with entertainment used to market and sell.
- unimportant 12y agoCopy stuff people post on forums - sell it in form of a book - pitch it in a way that makes it sound profound - ??? - profit
- SixSigma 12y agoNot the first time. See: Voices from the Hellmouth http://everything2.com/title/Voices+from+the+Hellmouth http://everything2.com/title/Voices+from+the+Hellmouth One of the posts http://slashdot.org/story/5415 http://slashdot.org/story/5415
- ceeK 12y agoReminds me of the Mitchell and Webb sketch 'Kill all the poor', where they statistically decide whether it would solve their problems. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=owI7DOeO_yg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=owI7DOeO_yg
- yourad_io 12y ago> By removing the aesthetic markers of online forums—author’s signatures, side banners, avatar pictures, and so on—Bittanti's book recontextualizes the discussion to reveal what players and the game are saying about homelessness. Except the players were talking about beating the game, not the homeless/real-life homelessness. Not amused.
- wmil 12y agoMy favorite part of this article (and in general discussions about SF) is that asking the homeless to move to Oakland is considered so inhumane it's unmentionable.