8 ms·
So let me get this straight... SpaceX is worth half of WhatsApp? Does anyone else feel like they're living in Bizarro-world?
by gaius 12y ago
So let me get this straight... SpaceX is worth half of WhatsApp? Does anyone else feel like they're living in Bizarro-world?
- wuliwong 12y agoThis is what I wondered too. I think there must be something we are missing. SpaceX has 3,000 employees and tons of capital equipment. They have contracts worth billions of dollars and loads of proprietary technology? I thought they were already profitable? But is that incorrect? It would seem disingenuous to claim that they lowered the price of space travel by 90% if they actually weren't even breaking even? hahahha.
- robotresearcher 12y agoThe investors also believe that their 10% stake is worth more than $1B. That's why they invested. Maybe SpaceX could have got more. But at this valuation they closed the deal and now have $1B to play with. Both parties happy.
- _pferreir_ 12y agoYeah. That seems to be the case.
- stdbrouw 12y agoSame reason diamonds are worth more than water.
- Tossrock 12y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted, that was my first thought as well. Sure, I understand the concept of defensive acquisitions, valuation as what people are willing to pay, per-user value, developing world markets, etc. But rockets are still rockets, and a messaging app is still a messaging app. I think it's the incredible disparity in total embodied energy for WhatsApp vs SpaceX that makes this intuitively hard to accept.
- 3pt14159 12y agoTo be fair whatsapp is not just a single messaging app, it's hundreds that work on all sorts of shitty phones in all sorts of languages.
- tsotha 12y ago>But rockets are still rockets, and a messaging app is still a messaging app. I think it's the incredible disparity in total embodied energy for WhatsApp vs SpaceX that makes this intuitively hard to accept. The hardest thing I ever did as an investor was let go of thinking there's some correlation between the things I like and market value.
- tsotha 12y agoStock valuations are based on what investors think the earning potential of a company is. While rocket companies are beyond cool it's a pretty difficult business in which to actually make money.
- wuliwong 12y agoI think messaging apps are even more difficult, right? SpaceX has made around $4 billion on contracts so far which I would guess is more than whatsapp.
- nandemo 12y agoYes, but they haven't made $4 billion in profits. That's "just" their revenue from the contracts. Compared to a software company, they have huge capex and huge operating costs.
- wuliwong 12y agoSuper-late reply but yes, agreed. I am wondering how much value they have in capital goods and land? Like if whatsapp goes bust, it's worth zero but SpaceX has some assets it could sell. And again, they have 3,000 employees, I would think buying heavily considers the size of the workforce they are acquiring.
- aetherson 12y agoFacebook's acquisition of WhatsApp was probably primarily defensive. By that, I specifically mean, "They were worried that WhatsApp would cause them to lose revenue from their core business, and their valuation of WhatsApp was heavily based on avoiding that potential loss."
- tsotha 12y agoWhenever you have huge fixed capital costs and high per-unit costs your upside is limited. A 10x increase in the whatsapp user base doesn't increase costs much, while SpaceX probably couldn't deliver on a 2x increase in volume for a few years. That's just the handicap of a business that makes real things. What investors are looking at is potential. The upside for heavy-industry SpaceX is far more constrained than that of a social media company.
- krschultz 12y agoNo. WhatsApp is used by billions of people daily. SpaceX is a really good government contractor. What % of AT&T's market cap ($175B) is its SMS business? What % of Lockheed Martin's market cap ($65B) is its space business? Think about the incumbents WhatsApp & SpaceX are trying to dislodge. Generally speaking the ones WhatsApp (now Facebook) are larger by market cap than the ones SpaceX is targeting. That reflects the fact that something everyone uses a little bit every day is generally worth more than something used by very few people, intensely.
- teraflop 12y ago> WhatsApp is used by billions of people daily To be pedantic, more like hundreds of millions of people monthly.
- clamprecht 12y agoWhat's an order of magnitude between friends?
- samstave 12y agofresh out of magnitudes... got plenty of attitudes though ready to ship!
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI think maybe Musk should consider releasing a social app and then selling it to bankroll the future of humanity.
- TeMPOraL 12y agogaius, we've been through this discussion today :). https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8915524 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8915524 EDIT: but to answer your question - yes, I very much feel like that.
- rcchen 12y agoOne thing that needs to be considered is that SpaceX is operating in a space that has far higher risk for a (relatively) indeterminate reward right now. A single accident could severely damage the company's reputation and revenue stream, and I think their valuation might reflect this cautious approach to their business model.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI agree; though as a side point - after 3 failures in 2008 and that famous "optimism, pessimism, fuck that" quote, I want to believe it will take more than just a single accident to damage SpaceX's reputation.
- robbiep 12y agoYou could replace spacex with whatsapp in that paragraph and it would still be true- more so even- the barrier to change with messaging apps is almost zero however everyone knows rockets are hard and no one expects a failure on the pad to destroy what is looking like a good launch track record. If whatsapp start charging or introduce ads I can't see why people would stick around, considering the Huge number of whatsapp users who also have viber/snapchat/basis sms also installed
- api 12y agoIt is. The fact is that we really don't spend much on space.
- ProAm 12y agoThe ROI is debatable.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoOnly if you look at quarterly return.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 12y agoAnd that right there is the crux of the issue. Short term thinking at its best.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoOur society would be unrecognisable without it. Most of the things we complain we could be doing instead of the space industry, we have good information on to complain about them due largely to the space industry.
- ProAm 12y agoI think that is true for our space industry in the 50's and 60's, but we've had a space station up there for years and what has come out of that? Im playing a bit of the devils advocate, but honestly all I hear is 'we are preparing for deeper space missions..."
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> but we've had a space station up there for years and what has come out of that? Nothing at all... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_research_on_the_International_Space_Station http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_research_on_the_Inte... ISS scientific value coverage in media sucks, I'll grant you that.
- mliker 12y agoTaking a basic economics course would answer your question.
- tsunamifury 12y agoDon't confuse market value with intrinsic value. Money is not the arbiter of all things.
- Florin_Andrei 12y agoFinally, a comment that makes sense. Thank you.
- SilasX 12y agoHad a similar realization when I caught up with my old boss at a big aerospace/engineering conglomerate. I looked it up and it had an $11 billion market cap. He (being in a smaller town) hadn't heard of Uber, which has ~$16 billion market cap.
- eitally 12y agoAnd the company I work for, which employees about 45,000 people in 25 countries, mostly in factories building complex electronics, only has a $2b market cap.
- jccooper 12y agoSpaceX has tremendous potential, but most of what will make them lots of money has yet to be proven--both technical and economic. It's possible they'll never figure out launcher re-use, or get it working well enough to matter. It's possible they will and no one will care that space launch is now 10% what it was, and flight rates will stay the same, and they'll just end up dominating a relatively small and stable niche. It's possible the incumbents will quickly copy their techniques and push them aside. It's possible they'll fail in enough launches to drive off every customer and bankrupt the company. I don't believe any of that, but it's possible and you have to take the uncertainty into consideration of value. Whatsapp has users and works and will continue to work. You know what you're getting there.
- wuliwong 12y agoYea but you could make arguments that whatsapp could suffer any number of ill-fated results. There's no business without risk. Technical risks are difficult but whatsapp has only shown that it can charge $1/year. $19 billion is a bet (and a risky one) that they will be able to squeeze more money out of those 700 million users.
- vidarh 12y agoWhatsapp was not bought only for its revenues or revenue potential, but also to protect against them turning around and using that userbase in a way that could turn into a threat to Facebook (whether themselves, or by selling to someone else).
- gaius 12y agoWhatsApp could go MySpace overnight. Or I guess more accurately, go BBM. If they had a multi-day outage, how many users would they have on the other side?
- nandemo 12y agoThe real answer was given by simonh elsewhere in this thread: the comparison is moot since they aren't publicly traded companies. The market is not saying that Whatsapp is worth double of Spacex.
- threeseed 12y agoThat we are having this exact same discussion AGAIN. Yes I believe we are living in Bizarro-world.
- danielha 12y agoLet me borrow your valuation calculator for a sec... Oh it says here that my dream to solve world hunger is worth north of a gazillion dollars.
- elberto34 12y agoI would much rather be an investor in whats app than spacex. It may be decades before spacex develops anything beyond the prototype level, whereas whats app can quickly scale and become the next Facebook or Google with a few years.
- jacquesm 12y ago> whats app can quickly scale and become the next Facebook or Google with a few years. Whatsapp got bought by Facebook, they will definitely not become the next Facebook and I sincerely doubt they'll ever become the next google. Try as I might, living without Google is hard, living without Facebook is stupidly easy.
- ekianjo 12y agoYeah, and most quality watches are worth more than computers which are infinitely more complex. Do you have other questions about Value ?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 12y agoYep: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8914756 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8914756
- onewaystreet 12y agoThe WhatsApp acquisition was an aberration. Zuckerberg was desperate and the WhatsApp founders knew it. Trying to rationally justify it is a bad idea that just leads to wrong conclusions. Nothing should be compared to it.
- jgreen10 12y agoI guess this is an old discussion, but WhatsApp seriously threatened the dominion of Facebook, a company that is valued at $209B simply for owning a significant amount of the daily attention span of consumers world-wide. Essentially, the value of WhatsApp is based more on what it could have destroyed than on what it could have created. Advertising is kind of funny like that, since it's not a product that consumers actually want. No value is lost to consumers by switching to a platform without advertising, even though the economic damage to advertisers can be huge.
- shenoyroopesh 12y agoThe difference is straight forward - Facebook "owns" Whatsapp, and the deal was paid majorly through stock, if I remember correctly, vested over a period of time. SpaceX still has it's independence and fresh infusion of $1billion in cash. It would probably fetch much more than $10 billion if it sold out now, but I doubt Musk would want to do that.