4 ms·
Sylvania Factory Tour – Vintage Tube Services
- slashnull 12y agoconvervativeguitarists.com fuckblindteststubesjustsoundbetter.com iliketoseemyaudiohardwareglowinginthedark.com ... wait now that I think about it I need the loudest EL84 they have in stock ASAP
- TylerE 12y agoLet's not turn HN into Tumblr.
- KeytarHero 12y agoSure, just ignore the technical reasons why tubes are better for some applications. From IEEE: http://spectrum.ieee.org/images/archive/images/tubet1.gif http://spectrum.ieee.org/images/archive/images/tubet1.gif (source: http://spectrum.ieee.org/consumer-electronics/audiovideo/the-cool-sound-of-tubes http://spectrum.ieee.org/consumer-electronics/audiovideo/the...)
- Gravityloss 12y agoI find sound creation to be quite interesting, compared to sound reproduction. In a way buying an amplifier is easy. You plug in your guitar and try to find sounds that you like, that fit your vision of what your music sounds or are just plain cool. Just bought a tube amp. Second hand, they are not expensive. There are so many amateur musicians who don't just have the time to use their gear so much that it would start wearing a lot. New features are rare. So 20 year old equipment is often perfectly usable.
- kazinator 12y agoBuying guitar amplifiers is hard. Because, anything that sounds different from what you currently use day-in and day-out initially sounds very cool. Then spend a week with it, and you gradually start hearing into it stuff you dislike. Finally, you hate it all together. :) This is part of the reason for the conservatism. The problem is avoided when people stick to circuit topologies and components from 1940-1960. (Plus extra gain stages for metal: that's what "modern" means).
- kazinator 12y agoTubes do in fact do something particular when they are used as signal processing elements to create distortion. This is the "tube sound" and is so important in guitar that it's faithfully simulated in guitar-oriented digital equipment. Also, when the combination of a tube power amplifier, output transistor and speaker is subject to overload, it produces artifacts that cannot be obtained in any other way in an equally compact form factor. Simulating the actual live sound of a little 50W tube combo cranked to the point that it is crapping out is theoretically possible with some non-tube equipment. In addition to the digital processing to model the total physical system (crapping-out tube output stage, saturated output transformer, and clipping speaker), a powerful back end is required to deliver the results of the calculation to reproduce the actual moving air molecules: a hi-fi system rated well into the thousands of watts.
- dghughes 12y agoI think it's the odd transharmonic (or total harmonic?) distortion that sounds pleasing if I recall my sound engineering from a zillion years ago, an even THD doesn't sound good.
- TylerE 12y agoNom pe. Opposite.
- kazinator 12y agoThere is a hypothesis that asymmetric clipping in single-ended tube stages produces even harmonics that sound good. However, asymmetric non-tube circuits (e.g. diodes or whatever) do not have the tube sound (merely on account of doing asymmetric clipping and nothing else). Furthermore, tube power amp sections are often push-pull: symmetric clipping when overloaded. The saturation of output transformer cores is also symmetric. "THD" is just a summary of all nonlinear distortion of a signal.
- TylerE 12y agoIt get's even more interesting... The (these days) extremely rare germanium semiconductors sound better than modern silicon semiconducters....so the guys building fuzz and other similar effects are using the dwindling supply of NOS germanium transistors and diodes. Germanium conducts at a lower voltage, sometimes as low as 0.15V vs 0.6-0.7V for silicon.
- kazinator 12y ago> "This tube crushing machine prevented any seconds from falling into dishonest hands!" How ironic! Little did they suspect that people would be trading completely fake Sylvania (and other) "new old stock" tubes decades later.
- joezydeco 12y agoThis machine was more about preventing defective or slightly out-of-spec tubes from being smuggled out of the plant and sold on the black market as new units. These things were somewhat expensive in their day. If you had the means to build counterfeit Sylvania tubes back in those times, you might as well have gone into legitimate business for yourself.
- kw71 12y agoI have come across lots of jerks selling bad old tubes ("but my tester featuring unknown principles of operation pointed the needle at the GOOD sector, not the BAD or "?" sectors!" (What kind of instrument has a "?" on the meter face?)) I wonder how the counterfeits would be done today, since the phenolic bases on the old octal tubes probably can't be matched by any material around now.
- kazinator 12y ago>What kind of instrument has a "?" on the meter face? Why, a dashboard designed by Dennis Ritchie. You will have to google that one.
- dietrichepp 12y ago> You will have to google that one. It's from The Unix Hater's Handbook, which is worth reading if you like Unix.
- dietrichepp 12y ago> What kind of instrument has a "?" on the meter face? I've seen a few equipment testers with a "?" between "Bad" and "Good". I have a battery tester with this, and tube testers like this are not uncommon. They are typically emission testers, which wire up the tube like a diode, with the grid wired to the cathode. As the tube ages, the cathode coating will wear out and emission will drop. The cathode coating wears out through normal use the same way an incandescent lamp wears out: at normal temperatures, it will evaporate and get deposited somewhere else in the tube. Emission testing is far from perfect, but it's a good first test to figure out e.g. which tube is a dud. I have a hard time caring because I never buy NOS tubes (same reason I don't buy CA3280s).
- Aloha 12y agoWhile this is cool, the rest of the website is made of snake oil.
- kw71 12y agoThermionic tubes are works of art. It's amazing that most of the work to build these was done by hand, and yet they perform very well and are highly durable. Now the article has me wondering what a DC Millimeter is. :) I think I need to get one for my metrology stack.
- dietrichepp 12y ago"Most of the work was done by hand..." Well, the machines and jigs to make them were quite sophisticated. From the video: "You'll notice that at no time are they touched by hand." Start at about 12:05: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GDvF89Bh27Y&t=12m05s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GDvF89Bh27Y&t=12m05s
- nitrogen 12y agoDoes that video cover blowing the glass?