4 ms·
Does anyone know of any studies that show that pornography harms children more than anything else, like seeing bomb victims on nightly news or ISIS beheadings o
by peterwwillis 12y ago
Does anyone know of any studies that show that pornography harms children more than anything else, like seeing bomb victims on nightly news or ISIS beheadings on Facebook? I seem to recall seeing porn when I was a child, and i'm not intellectually or emotionally damaged, as far as I know.
- devindotcom 12y agoWell, you're not exactly an unbiased source on yourself ;) To be honest, I would expect many studies to have rather a moralistic bent, since it's getting into issues of right and wrong, cultural issues rather than strictly behavioral ones. That said, I do think there is something to the idea that early exposure to porn does change one's expectations when it comes to sex. Sure, you could view like a "action movie" version of the act, but all the same it could taint somewhat one's ideas of how it's done, what the opposite (or same for that matter) sex is like in or out of bed, etc. Banning it is, of course, ridiculous and impossible, so I wouldn't support it even if I thought it was morally justified (precious little is).
- sarciszewski 12y agoThis was a well written and insightful comment. I couldn't have said it better myself. :D From the grandparent: > like seeing bomb victims on nightly news or ISIS beheadings on Facebook That's an interesting point to bring up. Maybe if you raise hell to the members of Parliament, they'll act to ban that stuff too?
- pyre 12y agoThey won't ban that violence. How else can use terrorism to scare people into supporting whatever it is you want them to support?
- jacquesm 12y ago> That's an interesting point to bring up. Maybe if you raise hell to the members of Parliament, they'll act to ban that stuff too? Of course they won't, wide dissemination of that stuff suits them just fine. Think of it like a partnership.
- rimantas 12y agoStill baffling, that violence and murder you see on TV almost non-stop is not considered a big problem. Probably because it is not. Everyone is going to deal with sex. Only a few will have to deal with murder. Go figure.
- sliverstorm 12y ago... harms children more than anything else This is not a strong line of argument. We don't have to fix things only in order of harm. IF it is considerably harmful, we should do something about it. It doesn't really matter if it is the most harmful.
- kazinator 12y agoYes it does matter! It matters if we could easily spend fewer resources to fix a much greater harm, but we are focusing on some scapegoat due to moralistic reasons not having anything to do with the scale of (or even existence of) harm.
- sliverstorm 12y agoIt matters, sure, especially if there are great alternatives handy that really do spend much less resources for much more benefit AND working on the example at hand rules out alternatives. But without those qualifiers, it is a weak line of reasoning. It's pretty rare that we can attack a social problem only one way at a time. Is it a reasonable argument to say that the USA's carbon emissions do not need to be worried about, because the USA does not emit more carbon than anyone else? China produces about 40% more carbon than the USA.
- ANTSANTS 12y agoThat's assuming it's actually harmful, which we have absolutely no proof of, just "think uh duh childrens" gut feelings. Society hasn't collapsed just because kids have had access to internet porn for a few generations. A more libertarian perspective would be "unless you can prove something is causing demonstrable, serious harm, the government should not be involved in it at all, because at best you're wasting resources on something insignificant, or at worst you're unintentionally causing actual, demonstrable damage to society in pursuit of a misguided goal." Not that it really matters in this case, it's obvious that Cameron doesn't give a shit about porn and is just using this as an excuse to curb civil liberties and justify surveillance.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 12y ago