4 ms·
I saw a really good paper showing how myths about UFOs almost exactly mirror the "old world" myths about "the little people" and the Faie. The form of the myth
by nl 12y ago
I saw a really good paper showing how myths about UFOs almost exactly mirror the "old world" myths about "the little people" and the Faie.
The form of the myths mirrored each other almost exactly - strange night visitations, kidnappings and often sexual violations.
From memory the paper argued that they represented "the unknown" in the human psyche , and the rise of science had forced the myths to take a more scientific form.
I wish I could find the paper.
(I guess some will argue that this is actually evidence that UFOs have been visiting since prehistoric time. Enjoy, I guess: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chariots_of_the_Gods%3F http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chariots_of_the_Gods%3F )
- sroerick 12y agoCarl Jung's flying saucers is a good read. He discusses the idea that of technological society automatically assuming that visitors have a "far more advanced technology", and the idea of the saucer being a completion the incomplete mandala of the industrial age. Very interesting stuff.
- msh 12y agoCarl Sagan makes that comparison in his book "the demon haunted world".
- makmanalp 12y agoThis would be very interesting to read about. Slight tangent: I also remember seeing some stuff about how the brain is influenced by sociocultural things - like how people from christian-majority nations see heaven / hell / god imagery during psychosis but people from other, dissimilar cultures see different things. Or: how come people ingesting hallucinogens consistently report being one with god or being god? What's so special about the concept of god that triggers that kind of hallucination? Why isn't it as common to think that you're any other object, like a toaster?
- sogen 12y agoThere's an old 1900's illustration of UFOs, saw it in a Ripley's Magazine way back in the late 90's - early 2000's. They looked like stuff from that era: Cigars, Hats, Zeppelins, etc.
- joshontheweb 12y agoIt isn't uncommon to hear modern sighting described using these words as well. That doesn't really mean much since these are still common objects today.
- blackbagboys 12y agoAdditionally, manifestations of paranoid schizophrenia and other psychiatric disorders change with culture; during the Cold War, it was a common delusion that one was being monitored by the CIA or the KGB; nowadays many sufferers report that they're on a 24/7 reality TV show they can't escape from
- lefthandrev 12y agoChariots has some interesting points in it, but there are heaps and heaps of parts that are either simply untrue or have been disproved. I do love his stance on pharmaceutical drugs.
- api 12y agoJacques Valee has a number of books on this subject. He's a bit on the spooky rather than skeptic side of the fence though, and argues for some sort of common underlying phenomenon. I think he might be right to some extent -- even if it's a psychological phenomenon, that fits the bill for a common underling cause.
- bunderbunder 12y agoJoe Nickell is an author who's written extensively on this subject. He's a paranormal investigator who happens to also be a Ph.D. folklorist, and his folkloric interpretations of many modern phenomena can be extremely compelling.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoI think Terry Bisson (or perhaps another author, can't quite remember who) wrote a story with this premise - that UFOs do exist, but they are actual factual faeries.
- jacquesm 12y agoChariots of the Gods is a load of bull. It has been extensively debunked but it still sells (for what reason I have no idea).
- nl 12y agoCouldn't have said it better myself.
- LordKano 12y agoDon't forget the non-verbal (Telepathic) communications and sleep paralysis. I have heard it theorized by, let's call them enthusiastic evangelicals, that this indicates that what people now experience as UFOs are the same phenomena, caused by the same entities and done for the same purposes as the phenomena that people used to experience as Demonic visitations. Me, I'm an open-minded skeptic. Absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence and a lot of unanswered questions doesn't imply a particular answer.